Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Housing crash is getting worse

who's talking here?

planemom 1
ladybeachbum 1
SoupIsGoodFood 10
justforfun 1
rEVOLution 2
oneyedman 6
Warren Peace 13
voice of reason 2
evolved 3
RedMulch 1
allday 7
SighFiGurl 1
Tipsyhic 1
DMBx6 1
In AbsentiaW 1
Dorothy Parker 1
crazypinetrees 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

New data just out from Zillow, the real-estate information company, show house prices are falling at their fastest rate since the Lehman collapse.

Average home prices are down 8% from a year ago, 3% over the quarter, and are falling at about 1% every month, according to Zillow.

And the percentage of homeowners in negative-equity positions — with a home worth less than its mortgage — has rocketed to 28%, a new crisis high.

Zillow now predicts prices will fall about 8% this year and says it no longer expects the market to bottom before 2012.

“There’s no way we can get to flat, from these depreciation levels, in the last nine months of the year,” says Zillow economist Stan Humphries. “Demand is a lot more anemic than we had previously thought.”

When in 2012 does Zillow see the market bottoming out? Humphries won’t say.

What a foolish boondoggle those tax breaks for home buyers have turned out to be. The government spent an estimated $22 billion between 2008 and 2010 on tax breaks to prop up the housing market. All it achieved was a brief suckers’ rally that ended last summer.


READ THE REST AT :Crash and Burn in the Housing Market 

ladybeachbum --- 15 years ago -

But yet, I have been looking all over this area for an investment house and they have been sold almost as soon as the listing shows up. Strange? 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I know, it's pretty bleak. I have a friend who lost a job and got behind on her mortgage payments. She has a job now and can make payments but can't catch up the back payments, the lender, bless their hearts, is breathing down her neck. She may lose the house to bankruptcy since her credit it totally shot. There are very little you can do in these situations. She's looking into MHAP, but it will be a long and painful process. Someone better figure out what is going to be done with all these troubled loans b/c it's going to have a huge impact on the economy. This is just the beginning of a process that has very few positive outcomes. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

But yet, I have been looking all over this area for an investment house and they have been sold almost as soon as the listing shows up. Strange?

Go with HUD listings, not bank.

Banks are criminals and it's inside dealing at almost market pricing. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Folks, this is also National numbers. We are doing much better in Texas than most states, but their housing woes WILL effect the overall economy..... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Who cares!!!

Obama got Osama!!!! 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

here's another way of looking at it.

For the young, there’s a silver lining in the housing bust
By Robert J. Samuelson, Published: May 8

If you’re a 20-something or even younger, your economic future is at best clouded. Your taxes will almost certainly be higher than today’s; your public services (schools, police, sanitation, defense, scientific research) will almost certainly be lower. Paying for old people, covering rising health-care costs, repairing dilapidated roads and servicing government pensions and the huge federal debt will squeeze take-home pay. Is there any hope for economic gains?

Well, yes — and from a surprising source. Housing. Say what?

Almost everyone considers the housing collapse a disaster, and it is. Since 2007, roughly 8 million homes have gone into foreclosure. Housing prices, according to the widely cited Case-Shiller index, are down about 33 percent from their 2006 peaks. They’re still falling, albeit at a slower pace. In some cities (Atlanta, Cleveland, Las Vegas, Detroit, Phoenix), they’re at or below 2000 levels. Home sales are stunted, and construction is a quarter of its previous peak. Housing’s implosion retards the economic recovery. Aside from unemployed carpenters and real estate agents, there’s much unsold lumber, carpet and appliances.

But housing’s troubles may have a silver lining. If you’re a homeowner, the steep fall in prices is calamitous. But if you’re a future buyer, it’s a godsend. What we’re seeing is a massive wealth transfer from today’s older homeowners to tomorrow’s younger homeowners. From year-end 2006 to 2010, housing values fell $6.3 trillion, reports the Federal Reserve. Assuming there’s no sharp rebound in prices — a good bet — that’s $6.3 trillion the young won’t pay.

Up to a point, the lower home prices merely deflate the artificial “bubble.” But there’s evidence that the declines transcend that. The National Association of Realtors routinely publishes a housing “affordability” index, which judges the ability of median families to buy the median-price home at prevailing interest rates. By this measure, existing homes are the most affordable since the index started in 1970.

Young buyers “will be able to enter the housing market at bargain prices,” argues NAR economist Lawrence Yun. When home prices again rise, increases will parallel income gains, meaning that the relative burden of housing costs will remain roughly stable, Yun says. He expects only modest increases in interest rates. (A rise of one percentage point — say, from 5 percent to 6 percent — on a $150,000 mortgage boosts the monthly payment about $95.)

Falling real estate prices have also affected new homes. They’re getting smaller and less embellished, as they must. New homes typically sell at a 10 to 20 percent premium over comparable existing homes. If prices don’t fall, buyers won’t buy. From 1973 to 2007, the size of the average new home grew by about 50 percent, from 1,660 square feet to 2,521 square feet. By 2009, that was 2,438 square feet, with more declines expected.

“People have become much more value oriented,” says Jeff Mezger, chief executive of KB Home, a major builder. At the height of the boom, with cheap mortgage credit widely available, over-confident buyers selected five-bedroom homes with Jacuzzis and granite-top kitchen counters, he says. Now, buyers favor practical amenities: more kitchen cabinets and bigger closets.

We are, perhaps, at a historic juncture. The relentless expansion of home size since World War II — encouraged by federal subsidies, including the mortgage-interest tax deduction — arguably resulted in many Americans being “over-housed.” Homes grew beyond what was “needed” or could even be enjoyed. The reason they kept expanding, Cornell economist Robert Frank has argued, was social competition. People want to be in the “best” neighborhoods with the “best” schools, and these neighborhoods have ever-larger homes. Somewhat smaller homes, Frank contends, won’t make people less happy.

If the housing collapse mutes this self-defeating syndrome, the main beneficiaries will be today’s young. Their homes will be somewhat cheaper and smaller; their operating costs (mainly utilities) will be somewhat lower. The sacrifices in living standards will be barely noticeable, and the savings — housing, after all, represents most families’ largest expense — will provide some relief from higher taxes and health costs.

Caveats apply. Housing markets are famously local; what’s true in one won’t be true in another. Moreover, the housing bust still looms large. The young are staying or returning home; new household formations are less than half of previous levels. Mortgage credit is constricted. Private lenders, once promiscuous with loans, are now prudish. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are in a state of transition — to what, no one knows. The price adjustment, especially for new homes, is incomplete. Unless these problems are overcome, housing construction will remain depressed. Eventually, the scarcity of homes would push prices up.

But crises pass and have unintended consequences. The young just might catch a much-needed break from this one. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The young just might catch a much-needed break from this one.

At the expense of the older homeowners? 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

At the expense of the older homeowners?

Yup... but let us be clear here, often the older homeowners were irresponsible and deserve their fate. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

but let us be clear here, often the older homeowners were irresponsible and deserve their fate.

Housing death panels? 

justforfun --- 15 years ago -

but let us be clear here, often the older homeowners were irresponsible and deserve their fate.

Housing death panels?



That is funny. lol 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

If my house value is dropping that fast I wish the country tax assessor would reevaluate my property for tax purposes. 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

If my house value is dropping that fast I wish the country tax assessor would reevaluate my property for tax purposes.


My thoughts exactly 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

At the expense of the older homeowners?


home prices around the country were very over inflated. their expense? for most it is a paper loss. deal. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

for most it is a paper loss. deal.

Just as long as it isn't your ox getting gored........... 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

If you can rent this movie, it explains it all. It describes how these greedy jerks not only robbed America blind but continue to do so with little or no resistance.

 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Nope, many idiots borrowed money against their equity to finance their lifestyle... Are those the greedy bastards to which you are refering? 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

Nope, many idiots borrowed money against their equity to finance their lifestyle... Are those the greedy bastards to which you are refering?

Those people are just dumb.

Banks are lawbreakers and thieves complicit with Wall Street in a scam that continues today, and this is one area Rev and I agree on. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

So evolved and Rev are giving the other transactors a free pass? Even though they falsely believed they were getting a better deal?

If you buy a $10,000 car for $30,000, it is not the bank's fault. It is a glaring symptom of an individual problem that needs to be corrected.

We need to stop giving politicians evidence that we're too stupid to run our own lives. We're driving ourselves down a more socialistic path...and we're blaming banks and politicians. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

By the time residential real estate hits bottom, we may not see much of an increase since baby boomers may begin transitioning to assisted living. But at least their houses are more likely to be paid for, so it'll be less stress on the banks. Younger generations should be looking to sweep in and get good deals on undervalued homes that won't appreciate when that time comes.

If you're just starting to enter the workforce for the first time, look to rent for the next 5-10 years, but start paying your house note now. Do a direct deposit from your paycheck that goes into an interest bearing account. Increase the payment by the same percentage that your wages increase. This way when you're ready to buy, you'll be better able to take advantage of more affordable loans.

Let your money for a house appreciate now....at the same time houses are depreciating. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

If you buy a $10,000 car for $30,000, it is not the bank's fault.

Really? That simple, huh?

Michael Phillips of the Wall Street Journal tells the story of a shack in Arizona owned by a woman that was valued at $130,000 four years ago by a crooked appraiser and mortgaged by a broker who was paid $10,000 in fees and took no loan risk.

Then he tracks the loan through Wells Fargo to HSBC, where it was packed into a mortgage-backed security, rated Triple-A by Moody's and S&P, and sold to, among others, the Oklahoma Teachers pension plan and PIMCO.

There were thousands of small mortgage companies that came out of the woodwork using loans from Big banks to generate mortgages to sell to financial institutions (wall street)
regular mortgage comnpanies make money off collecting the monthly payments, these guys made it off fees and commisssions. It's sold to wall street who bundles what they know is junk and hoists it on your pension or 401K (apparently you liked it in the tail) then wall street furthers the damage by betting against us all because they know the stuff is junk.

Gimme a break Warren. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Well of course I simplified it. The true value of an item is of course the limit of what someone is willing to pay for it. In your above narrative, you once again left out the part that someone was willing to pay that price for that shack without bothering to think how it came to be priced at that level. Most of the areas where housing prices skyrocketed were areas where you find the lofty notions of politicians who believe they can create open space laws, building restrictions, house to land ratios, and various other notions of the way things ought to be without ever seeing the unintended consequences occur. But they always do.

Buyers are looking to profit just as sellers and lenders are. You're still turning a blind eye to the greed of buyers who gobbled this stuff up.

Look again at what you just wrote. You know that every transaction takes at least two participants, yet you still limit blame to only one - the one that sells class warfare. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

Look again at what you just wrote. You know that every transaction takes at least two participants, yet you still limit blame to only one - the one that sells class warfare.

No. I blame both but you have to agree one has the upper hand and one created the junk that poisoned the system. The one I'm referring to was not the individuals. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

You're also describing accurately what occurred, but you're leaving out the why. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

I lay more blame on politicians who changed the incentives. Everyone else simply responded rationally to those incentives 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

I'll elaborate a bit more to fill in the blanks. Politicians targeted a sector of homebuyers. Actually, they targeted a group of renters with the intention of making them homebuyers. It turned out politicians did not know better than these individuals. Those folks should have stayed renters. But once the target population started responding to the change in incentives, the rules had to change for everyone else. If not for the pursuit of that vision, banks would not have stopped requiring a 20% down payment and a 33% debt to income ratio. If that alone had been preserved, we would not be in this mess. Well, we would be in another mess, just not this one.

There was no need for banks to create mortgage backed securities until politicians stepped in and created the incentives which led to an increase in bad loans. Once bad loans grew at the encouragement of the government, the bankers had to find a way to minimize their risk. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

They just re evaluated my property....got the notice a couple of weeks ago. My lots went from $1500 each in value to $6000 in value each. Not sure when the original eval was done but they went up. So did my house. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

I might as well turn the clock back even further, because there are several contributing factors which preceded, but led to mortgage backed securities. All were well intended, but had predictable results that politicians with election cycles in which to frame their decisions were less concerned with.

For the past several decades, the Federal Reserve has been publishing studies which showed racial disparities in mortgage approval rates. Many in politics and the media took this as virtual proof of racial discrimination. What got lost in those vague data points which used comparisons of approval rates based on income levels is that lenders do not look solely at income. As stated above, lenders also look at money available for downpayment, debt to income ratio, employment experience, and the consumer’s history of repaying debts. These areas also show differences by racial groupings, but again this does not mean it occurs due to any racial intent by an ethnic group “in power”. This is evident within these studies, but rarely reported because it doesn’t fit the agenda of the authors. The evidence in those studies is that Asian-Americans consistently outperformed whites in every category and end up with a much higher loan approval rate.

I point out the above background because if the government had pursued the noble vision of correcting this by treating the problem rather than the symptoms, we wouldn’t have this problem. Again, we would have another problem, but not this one. Treating the problem would have meant using government resources to assist renters become home owners by helping them save money for a down payment, helping them structure their debt to be 33% of their income or less, and so on.

But that didn’t happen did it? Political solutions often embrace dependence over assistance, so of course that didn't happen. It didn’t in part because the legal case for lending discrimination has been made much easier, due to the standards applied in civil rights law - where statistical disparities alone serve as a sufficient starting point for a case against someone accused who in some upside down world of twisted justice, must now carry the burden of proof to prove their innocence. So this makes it much easier to simply demand a statistical correction with the threat of adverse consequences if no correction occurs. When neither side can prove anything, but the accuser has a statistical disparity, the accused stands to lose. This can obviously be very costly for the accused - which makes it more likely that it will be resolved through a large financial settlement. Without even a single named victim, but armed with a statistical disparity, a corporation can spend over a decade and millions of dollars fighting this losing battle.

So rather than fight this battle, their distaste for risk erodes in favor of a less costly battle. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Let me ask a question and maybe it will seem ignorant or juvenile, but, I can live with that.

When my in-laws bought their home in 1972, they paid $22K for it. That same house, in 1998, was appraised at $395K, conservatively. Now, if you look at the income ratios for people buying similar homes in 1972 and then in 1998, there isn't a huge difference.

So, my question is, how did that happen? How do we end up with home values being incredibly overpriced and outrageous, while the average income has remained relatively stagnant in that same amount of time? 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Where was the house located? 

allday --- 15 years ago -

For the past several decades, the Federal Reserve has been publishing studies which showed racial disparities in mortgage approval rates. Many in politics and the media took this as virtual proof of racial discrimination. What got lost in those vague data points which used comparisons of approval rates based on income levels is that lenders do not look solely at income. As stated above, lenders also look at money available for downpayment, debt to income ratio, employment experience, and the consumer’s history of repaying debts. These areas also show differences by racial groupings, but again this does not mean it occurs due to any racial intent by an ethnic group “in power”. This is evident within these studies, but rarely reported because it doesn’t fit the agenda of the authors. The evidence in those studies is that Asian-Americans consistently outperformed whites in every category and end up with a much higher loan approval rate.

I point out the above background because if the government had pursued the noble vision of correcting this by treating the problem rather than the symptoms, we wouldn’t have this problem. Again, we would have another problem, but not this one. Treating the problem would have meant using government resources to assist renters become home owners by helping them save money for a down payment, helping them structure their debt to be 33% of their income or less, and so on.

But that didn’t happen did it? Political solutions often embrace dependence over assistance, so of course that didn't happen. It didn’t in part because the legal case for lending discrimination has been made much easier, due to the standards applied in civil rights law - where statistical disparities alone serve as a sufficient starting point for a case against someone accused who in some upside down world of twisted justice, must now carry the burden of proof to prove their innocence. So this makes it much easier to simply demand a statistical correction with the threat of adverse consequences if no correction occurs. When neither side can prove anything, but the accuser has a statistical disparity, the accused stands to lose. This can obviously be very costly for the accused - which makes it more likely that it will be resolved through a large financial settlement. Without even a single named victim, but armed with a statistical disparity, a corporation can spend over a decade and millions of dollars fighting this losing battle.

So rather than fight this battle, their distaste for risk erodes in favor of a less costly battle.


At least use quotations on that crapola from bankers_Warren's_heros.com 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Another excellent post, Warren.

This argument has been laid out to these people on here time and time again, but they only see what fits their narrative.

Banks are the evil doers that created this whole mess. Nevermind the politicians and their policies that actually created this whole mess. Barney Frank and Maxine Waters told all of us that Freddie and Fannie were in fine order. No problems whatsoever. Nevermind the homebuyer who knowingly bought a house the knew they really couldn't afford. The banks told them they could get the loan because the government told the banks to make the loans. Nevermind all of the facts, they don't fit the narrative. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Another excellent post, Warren.

You misspelled paste. You said "post." 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

You misspelled paste. You said "post."

Doesn't matter. Either way it's still the facts. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Crapola? I noticed your glaring failure to refute with any specifics.

But if you want specifics on my side, I'll gladly oblige:

For starters, ask Sears how this worked out for them in a sexual discrimination suit under these identical circumstances in the early 1990s. Even though Sears won in an appellate court, very few business could sustain the damage that Sears did - both financially and in the erosion of their good name.

But banks and lending institutions have a tougher road to travel because of the highly regulated playing field they work in which requires them to obtain government permission for some of the decisions that other businesses are free to make without interference. So even if a bank might be willing to spend that much time and money fighting an accusation, it is rarely in their best interest since federal regulatory agencies can hold up approval for bank mergers, acquisitions and other business decisions pending outcome of these cases.

The first prosecution of a bank for racial discrimination in mortgage lending was in 1992. The US Government used its Justice Dept resources to charge Decatur Savings and Loan Association with racial discrimination in mortgage lending based on an outcome difference between 2 selected racial groups. Decatur denied the charges, but chose to settle rather than begin years of litigation.

A year later, the Federal Reserve Board refused to approve an application by the Shawmut National Corporation to acquire New Dartmouth Bank, “because of the bank’s record on racial fairness.” This obviously didn’t sit well with the business’s decision makers because their business had not been convicted of anything, yet were experiencing adverse consequences. But because this was a government intervention, such legal standards were not required. The threat of legal action then began when the Federal Reserve Board referred the case to the Justice Dept. The mortgage subsidiary of Shawmut promptly settled out of court for a million dollars. It may be hard for anyone to believe, but in this case, there was no claim from any minority group that one single named person had been harmed - the statistical disparity alone was deemed sufficient to threaten legal action until a sum of money was extorted out of the bank to resolve the case.

Janet Reno, speaking as Attorney General, then warned other banks that those who “closely examine their lending practices and make necessary changes to eliminate discrimination” would “fare better in this department’s stepped-up enforcement effort than those who do not.” She then warned, “Do not wait for the Justice Department to come knocking.” Banks across the nation began settling out of court. Settling costs money, so obviously the cost of acquiring home mortgages would go incrementally up as well.

The definition of discrimination was further expanded under Reno when the Justice Dept brought a case against Chevy Chase Federal Savings Bank solely because it did not have branches in minority neighborhoods. Take a moment here and consider this change in philosophy from the 1930's era of unit banking laws - government edicts that prohibited banks from establishing more than one branch. This form of government regulation was a HUGE contribution to massive bank failure during the Great Depression because banks were prohibited from diversifying their investments and were made vulnerable when government imposed tariffs lessened the demand for American produce that played a role in widespread farm collapses, which in turn affected the less diversified banks in rural areas that served them.

But now, the new era of government control embraces the opposite vision. In the 1930's politicians believed they knew better than investors and bankers and chose to regulate them into failure because they believed it was wrong to diversify. Now, 60 years later, politicians still think they can achieve better results than the market by dictating that banks must now diversify into riskier locations of less financial solvency. In both cases, is it not obvious that the better approach was for the government to get the hell out of it and let the forces of risk and reward settle how banks locate their financial security? How much money has been wasted dictating economic failure? How much more will we continue to blow with this foolishness that results ONLY in lost productivity and lost retirement portfolios?

But back to Chevy Chase Bank. Surprise! They settled and agreed to open more branches in minority neighborhoods. At no point did anyone raise the question of how much this actually helped minority communities. Banks were not being forced to limit their loans to applicants that were financially solvent. That would have been far too wise and would not result in correcting a statistical pursuit. Instead, they were being bullied into the pursuit of statistical quotas. To do this, they had to lower lending standards. But they couldn’t limit the lowering of standards to only minorities. They had to lower standards for all mortgage seekers.

So in the late 1990s we had politicians using Fannie Mae to pursue this form of social justice. Take a look at this business article written in 1999 which documents this link title. Notice that the publically identified intention was to lower lending standards. Notice that even though the CRA is not named, the scope of government intervention in the market is saturated with the fingerprints of CRA’s mission statement. Note the warnings about what ended up happening as well.

Though I’ve pointed out the indirect effects that CRA triggered on the housing market, a causal influence can be seen with some direct effects of CRA. Even though loans with documented CRA criteria (which does not count the number of loans made with lower lending standards prompted by the pursuit of the CRA vision) appear small, their composition among losses were four times higher than the frequency that they occurred. For example, Bank of America showed in their October 2008 quarterly statement that only 7% of their loans were issued under the formal CRA program. It would appear to be a minor factor until you note that these loans constituted almost 30% of their losses on mortgage failures. In the financial world as you may know, that’s a big deal. Scales have been tipped for far less of an impact.

Lenders did not spontaneously and in unison suddenly begin lowering their lending standards. They responded rationally to the incentives and specific mandates created by politicians nobly pursuing well intentioned social justice. Since our founding fathers put together the framework for our economic systems, politicians have had a much worse track record of managing the private sector’s business. But we still can’t resists the impulse of bending over so that politicians can get busy doing something.


Yes, credit ratings played a role in this too. Once lenders began pursuing riskier loans in order to be able to lend to more solvent folks, they had to find a way to make the riskier loans appealing to other investors. So they bundled them along with more solvent loans to minimize the risk through mathematical averaging. These instruments were fairly new and debt rating agencies had little history to go by in order to accurately assess their risk. When lenders could then shop their securities around for the highest rating, it helped create the illusion of greater security that attracted investors.

So the bubble was absolutely in mortgage backed securities. But a very significant role in creating this bubble can be attributed to the choice of deviating from what had once been fairly secure lending standards in pursuit of “social justice”. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

The banks told them they could get the loan because the government told the banks to make the loans.

Many people are not sharp enough to understand that just because you can get a loan does not equate to being able to afford the loan..... 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Well that was quick.

You went racial with NO prodding.

Foolish. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

You went racial with NO prodding.

You're just pissed because he beat you to it.

Confederate....... there, I beat you to that one. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Many people are not sharp enough to understand that just because you can get a loan does not equate to being able to afford the loan.....

Even funnier is when you spell it out in perfectly plain English, they still can't understand it. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Confederate....... there, I beat you to that one.

Dammit. I bet you're in Grey slacks and coat too. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground