Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: New Abortion Bill on Perry's desk....

who's talking here?

smartypants 2
eterry2 11
steinhoister 4
Syrah1214 2
chilihead 1
ExLady In Blue 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
oneyedman 1
voice of reason 1
JohnLynch 20
OH SNAP 7
allday 1
Dr Aborto 1
Work in Progress 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 8
LiveFreeOrDie 2
Clock 13
Bornanraisedkw 12
Dorothy Parker 1
horseymomma 3
elliemae 1
dichotomy 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: New Abortion Bill on Perry's desk....

[i]Do you think this bill's intent is:[/i] [u]"The purpose of the bill is to traumatize women who are seeking an abortion," [/u] http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/7552437.html [b]Bill requiring abortion sonograms heads to Perry[/b] AUSTIN, Texas — The Texas Legislature passed a bill Thursday that would require doctors to perform a sonogram before conducting an abortion. Gov. Rick Perry had declared the bill to be emergency legislation, and it now awaits his signature. The proposed law requires doctors to conduct a sonogram at least 24 hours before an abortion and to provide the woman with the opportunity to see the results and hear the fetal heartbeat. The doctor is also required to describe what the sonogram shows, to include the existence of legs, arms and internal organs. Proponents said the law is necessary to make sure women understand what an abortion entails. Opponents say the measure would interfere in the doctor-patient relationship. "This will be one of the strongest pieces of sonogram legislation in the nation," said state Rep. Sid Miller, R-Stephenville, the bill's author. "House Bill 15 will protect human life, the lives of the unborn victims of abortion, as well as those facing life-changing decisions. ... This legislation will save numerous unborn lives." Only three other states require a sonogram for all women seeking an abortion. The Texas Medical Association opposed the bill because it dictates when a doctor must perform a procedure, and how the doctor must deal with his or her patient. While a pre-abortion sonogram is routine, it is not considered a medical necessity. An exception to the waiting period was made for medical emergencies, or for women who live more than 100 miles from the nearest abortion provider. In cases of incest, rape or fetal abnormality, the woman does not have to hear a description of the fetus. The bill passed both the House and the Senate with a two-thirds majority, meaning the law will go into effect immediately after the governor signs it. The vote on Thursday to concur with changes made in the Senate was 96-48, with three Democrats voting for the bill, and four Republicans voting against. State Sen. Dan Patrick, who sponsored the Senate bill, said he expected the bill to reduce the number of abortions in Texas. "We believe that if one out of five women after seeing the sonogram, hearing the explanation or hearing the heartbeat, change their mind, that's 15,000 lives that can be saved," said Patrick, a Houston Republican. In the final debate on the bill Monday, Sen. Wendy Davis, D-Fort Worth, said the bill was clearly designed to interfere with women exercising their legal rights. "The purpose of the bill is to traumatize women who are seeking an abortion," she said

yes Vote
 
 45.5% (20)
no Vote
 
 54.5% (24)
maybe Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

Do you think this bill's intent is:
"The purpose of the bill is to
traumatize women who are seeking an abortion,"

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/7552437.html

Bill requiring abortion sonograms heads to Perry

AUSTIN, Texas — The Texas Legislature passed a bill Thursday that would require doctors to perform a sonogram before conducting an abortion.

Gov. Rick Perry had declared the bill to be emergency legislation, and it now awaits his signature. The proposed law requires doctors to conduct a sonogram at least 24 hours before an abortion and to provide the woman with the opportunity to see the results and hear the fetal heartbeat. The doctor is also required to describe what the sonogram shows, to include the existence of legs, arms and internal organs.

Proponents said the law is necessary to make sure women understand what an abortion entails. Opponents say the measure would interfere in the doctor-patient relationship.

"This will be one of the strongest pieces of sonogram legislation in the nation," said state Rep. Sid Miller, R-Stephenville, the bill's author. "House Bill 15 will protect human life, the lives of the unborn victims of abortion, as well as those facing life-changing decisions. ... This legislation will save numerous unborn lives."

Only three other states require a sonogram for all women seeking an abortion.

The Texas Medical Association opposed the bill because it dictates when a doctor must perform a procedure, and how the doctor must deal with his or her patient. While a pre-abortion sonogram is routine, it is not considered a medical necessity.

An exception to the waiting period was made for medical emergencies, or for women who live more than 100 miles from the nearest abortion provider. In cases of incest, rape or fetal abnormality, the woman does not have to hear a description of the fetus.

The bill passed both the House and the Senate with a two-thirds majority, meaning the law will go into effect immediately after the governor signs it. The vote on Thursday to concur with changes made in the Senate was 96-48, with three Democrats voting for the bill, and four Republicans voting against.

State Sen. Dan Patrick, who sponsored the Senate bill, said he expected the bill to reduce the number of abortions in Texas.

"We believe that if one out of five women after seeing the sonogram, hearing the explanation or hearing the heartbeat, change their mind, that's 15,000 lives that can be saved," said Patrick, a Houston Republican.

In the final debate on the bill Monday, Sen. Wendy Davis, D-Fort Worth, said the bill was clearly designed to interfere with women exercising their legal rights.

"The purpose of the bill is to traumatize women who are seeking an abortion," she said 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

ok i am not the best poll maker.....sorry ya'll 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

some readers comments:

Hang on, who pays for the sonograms? I'm fairly sure that Texas isn't going to pick up the tab for the sonograms. So either the woman's insurance company (which might cover it since it's related to abortions, I dunno how Texas insurance companies work) or the woman herself has to pay for it.

If the woman herself pays for it and since this is now a mandatory, state-imposed cost, how is this, practically, any different from putting a tax on abortions?


This is completely asinine. The decision to get to the clinic is hard enough without having the doctor there showing this to you in an effort to change the woman's mind. Each woman has her own reasons for being there. While I may not support abortion, I will not be the person to tell another woman what she can and cannot do with her body. I do support this being a safe procedure and not revert back to the coathanger days when it was completely outlawed.


1) you don't have to pay for it.
2) it is NOT a medically invasive procedure
3) you don't have to look at the sonogram
4) if it could change your mind, you believe the fetus is a unique lifeform 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

Choosing to end the life of your own child should be traumatizing, IMO. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

more:

I think any woman who would still abort while awash in pregnancy hormones that are flooding her brain with gooiness over the fetus probably knows something these lawmakers don't. If you can go through with an abortion with your brain and body telling you to protect the pregnancy, with society clucking and tutting, and with every ad agency in the world touting babies and motherhood as nirvana, you should. There's obviously something really wrong with the situation you are in, and a baby is going to make it worse.


No, they've added a non-negligible COST to getting an abortion (state won't cover the sonogram), along with a waiting period.


The problem is forcing someone to pay for an unnecessary sonogram. It would be a bit like being forced to pay for an MRI just to have a dental cleaning. It does not make sense.

The underlying thought behind it is that many of the women getting abortions are low income and would not be able to afford the sonogram, thus not having the abortion.

Then the church will later gain one more member that adds to the collection plate and the state will later gain another tax payer. (but most likely another tax burden) 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

more:

s2s2s2: The Bill IN Question (aborts this window to pursue new window opportunities)

" (b) The form required by subdivision (a) must include a space to be signed by the pregnant woman and the following statements are to be certified by the woman undergoing the abortion by initials;
(1) "Before my abortion and at the clinic where my abortion was provided, a live, real-time obstetric ultrasound was performed, and the images of my ultrasound were displayed so that I could view them;"
(2) "A simultaneous verbal explanation of the results of the live ultrasound images, including a medical description of the dimensions of the embryo or fetus, the presence of cardiac
activity, and the presence of arms, legs, and external members and internal organs, was given me in an understandable manner;" and
(3) "A live, real-time heartbeat, when present, and a simultaneous verbal explanation of the live heart activity were provided for me to hear."

The woman must sign a form that says "I hear and understand my fetus's heartbeat". The ultrasound must occur no more than ONE HOUR before the procedure. REALLY?!

How is this different from saying "Before a licensed firearm may be sold, the customer must attend at least 1 (one) Anti-gun rally, and listen to no less than 4 (four) one-hour stories of gun violence told by members of the community. Then, the customer must sign a form declaring "Regarless (or because of) the risk, I want my gun NOW, neighborhood children be damned".



Nope. Casey v. Planned Parenthood says that the government can add impositions to getting an abortion, as long as they're not undue burdens. That was the case that says you can require a waiting period, for example. And yes, that is an undue burden for people who have to travel across the state or into a different state, but there is only and has only ever been a single person on the Supreme Court who has ever been pregnant. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

[i]Choosing to end the life of your own child should be traumatizing, IMO.[/i]

would not the actual procedure be enough? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

When I was getting my vasectomy. I really wished the doctor showed me a photo of my testicles before he severed my vasa deferentia. Where was Rick Perry then? :( 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

take your religion OUT OF MY LIFE.
simple concept. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Like all medical procedures the patient should be well informed of exactly what they are doing before making their decision. How can you know exactly what you are doing without all the facts? How about the women who decide not to do it after they see their child’s arms, legs, fingers toes and little face that didn't realize the baby was formed and was not some parasite as the liberals would have everyone believe? Not all women would make that choice if they are educated as to exactly what they are doing. Why would anyone have an issue with doctors informing their patients fully? 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

take your religion OUT OF MY LIFE.
simple concept.


preservation of life isn't a religious concept 

allday --- 15 years ago -

How about the women who decide not to do it after they see their child’s arms, legs, fingers toes and little face that didn't realize the baby was formed and was not some parasite as the liberals would have everyone believe?

Please show where anyone has ever said that... 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

I disagree with the bill. I think the woman should be forced to look at the images and listen to the heartbeat.

Getting an abortion is a life long decision that a woman must be able to live with. How can she live knowing she had an abortion if she's not even willing/able to look at an ultrasound image? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

What's everybody in a tizzy about?? It's just a mass of flesh!! .... RIGHT!?!? 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

I think the bill is OBVIOUSLY an attempt to traumatize women who are considering abortion. What we're really debating is whether or not that's ok. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

traumatize women


Traumatize over a mass of flesh!?!? Huh?? 0 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I think the bill is OBVIOUSLY an attempt to traumatize women who are considering abortion. What we're really debating is whether or not that's ok.


Thats not what I am debating. Who would like to have any medical procesure with only a small part of the facts? I think it is ridculous that women haven't been given this information sooner and I believe its been kept from them so that abortion doctors can keep making a killing off these procedures. How would you like to have a baby without help from medical advancements? We have made great medical strides that give us a wealth of knowledge why would anyone choose not to be informed?

If it is traumatizing maybe its because they know that it is a child and is already formed with fingers and toes and they want to kill it anyway. Thats disgusting.

If you were going to have an abortion and thought that you were only 6-8 weeks and that the fetus was a peanut a blob with no resemblance of a human would you feel differently if you saw the ultasound and saw your babies face or hand? Some women would be horrified I am sure if they knew what they had really done. Many I am sure are horrified and live with the guilt when they realize what that they did after the fact. Not all abortions are done a 6-8 weeks many are performed much later. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Anyone getting an abortion knows they're ending a pregnancy. Forcing them to have an unnecessary ultrasound to play mindgames because of others religious/personal beliefs, is wrong, imo.


Only three other states require a sonogram for all women seeking an abortion.

Which ones? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Anyone getting an abortion knows they're ending a pregnancy.


Of course they know that but they may not be aware of what exactly they are ending. Do you think every person that has one realizes exactly what the baby they are aborting looks like at their gestation? Do you think that if they have been informed would they have made the same decision? Do you think it is right for someone else to make that decision for them without their full knowledge and consent. Do you think it is right to make that decision for them without them being fully informed? What if you were in a situation with a pregnancy and a doctor told you that you needed to abort the baby and you followed his instruction only to find out he made a mistake?

Why are people so afraid of women having this medical knowledge and being fully informed of the situation?

Never have I seen so many people wishing to keep people in the dark.

Forcing them to have an unnecessary ultrasound to play mindgames because of others religious/personal beliefs, is wrong, imo.

If that was the only reason for the ultrasound I would agree. I believe that not all women or teenagers know how developed their child is and would not chose to do this if they had all the facts. Some still would sadly and that is why late term abortions were even an issue but not all would.

I think people don't want women to see because they are afraid it will change public opinion against abortion. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Abortion should be illegal and women who have them should be prosecuted as criminals....

We do this for every other life but a baby... what does that say about us? or you? 

Syrah1214 --- 15 years ago -

Frankly, I think it's a good idea. I've known plenty of women who were girls who had an abortion. They were told it's a "mass of cells" or lied to and told the baby feels no pain or lacked a heartbeat until much later on.

This was back before the day of internet and now the majority still struggle, knowing how far along they were and realizing they were lied to.

When we want plastic surgery, we go to a plastic surgeon and see on a screen what we would look like with a "new nose" or "new boobs" and see the current photograph of the "before" shot. I see nothing wrong with a woman being fully informed and seeing her child move and what's formed and developed up to that point.

And if a woman does change her mind based on an ultrasound, perhaps she will realize there are other options beside abortion, such as adoption. 

Syrah1214 --- 15 years ago -

What if you were in a situation with a pregnancy and a doctor told you that you needed to abort the baby and you followed his instruction only to find out he made a mistake?

My doctor thought (honestly) that the baby I'm carrying now (at 32 weeks) was not developing and suggested a D&C the following week.

I had a specialist take a peek with her ultrasound machine which was much more sensitive and showed much smaller "things" in the uterus and lo and behold, there was the littlest flicker of a heartbeat on her screen.

Needless to say, accidents can happen and it never hurts to have a second opinion or see that ultrasound. Not *all* abortions are because they just don't want to have a baby. Some are not considered abortions, but medically required D&C's that COULD essentially remove a viable baby from a womb in the case of true mistakes. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

I am on the fence about the ultrasound...... 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Docswife - If you Dr. suggested a D&C to terminate a pregnancy in this day and age......you need a new Dr. who is up to date on current protocols. I don't think I'd go back to that Dr. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

I think living with the abortion is the trauma. It is lifelong. Every woman I know of that has had one still thinks things like "oh, he/she would be 6 years old now". If forcing the woman to have an ultrasound can prevent even 1 woman from making a choice that she can't live with, it's worth it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it will necessarily stop abortions. For me it's more about having all the facts so that women can make the most informed decision.

Would you turn off life support on a lived one without knowing all the facts?

Information is good if we have the ability to know more we should always choose that option. 

chilihead --- 15 years ago -


Getting an abortion is a life long decision that a woman must be able to live with. How can she live knowing she had an abortion if she's not even willing/able to look at an ultrasound image?

It is impossible to make an educated decision five minutes before the procedure is scheduled. This will do nothing to educate the pregnant women! It is just inhuman punishment inflicted by selfriteous do-gooders. What the He!! is Perry thinking? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Maybe no one should be inform of any medical procedure. Lets just all go blindly into any and all procedures and accept what any doctor tells us.

That would be much better. 

eterry2 --- 15 years ago -

It's a sad day for Texas. 

eterry2 --- 15 years ago -

Maybe no one should be inform of any medical procedure. Lets just all go blindly into any and all procedures and accept what any doctor tells us.


So, why does the law of being informed apply only to abortions?????? 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

It is just inhuman punishment inflicted by selfriteous do-gooders.

I wonder if people said this about the people who opposed slavery, concentration camps, or any other type of genocide?

Nobody should have to SEE the person they about to murder. Heavens NO! That would be inhuman! 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

It's a sad day for Texas. 

nope...it's a sad day for Texas when a Texas resident CHOOSES to commit murder 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

So, why does the law of being informed apply only to abortions?????? 

Because currently no real info is being given to the patient. It goes something like this yep your pregnant come in next week and we will do the procedure.

More information should be given.

If it is just a mass of cells then why are the pro choice people so afraid? I would think it would be no big deal. What if people are being charged for abortions who are not even pregnant. People who have some type of medical issue. Having abortions can cause all kinds of future medical problems that can prevent a woman from ever being able to have a child. Why not be fully informed? 

eterry2 --- 15 years ago -

nope...it's a sad day for Texas when a Texas resident CHOOSES to commit murder 

We can argue about this forever without changing each other's mind. We have now communicated our positions. end of story. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

We have now communicated our positions. end of story.

nope, it's not the end of the story...life doesn't end on this earth...your perverted position will have further consequences...your position is that you are God...you AREN'T 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 15 years ago -

Ok so these women change their mind, now the baby is here and the woman can not take care of it. So she goes on welfare now what?.

What about in cases of incest or rape, should she change her mind then?

It is a woman's choice to do as she pleases with her body bottom line.


I know when I lived in Germany and wanted to have my tubes tied,, they told me I had to have my husband's permission. Talk about them being crazy, I said hell no this is what I want. I came back to the states and have a tubal. No one can tell me what to do with my body. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

It is a woman's choice to do as she pleases with her body bottom line.

the reality of the situation is...the baby IS NOT a part of the woman's body...your statement is LAME 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

your perverted position will have further consequences...your position is that you are God...you AREN'T





So hostile... 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

So hostile... 

nope...hostile defines the people who want to murder unborn babies 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

nope...hostile defines the people who want to murder unborn babies


Maybe but it also defines your responses to people...on ANY topic. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground