Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Mr. Prudent: Obama Preaches Deficit Sanity

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 2
oneyedman 1
JohnLynch 3
james osterberg 1
r2d2 1
allday 2
In AbsentiaW 2
Clovis 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

By Joe Klein Thursday, Apr. 14, 2011


President Barack Obama speaks about the budget

"This is one of the most important debates that we can have," President Obama said at the close of his much anticipated speech about the federal-budget deficit. He is absolutely right, although his speech didn't add much to the conversation in terms of specifics. Unlike Republican Congressman Paul Ryan's recent budget plan, Barack Obama's proposed no radical restructurings or curtailments of brontosaurus-size programs like Medicare or Medicaid. Unlike some of the other plans floating about, and there are scads of them, his didn't propose gimmicky new revenue-raising schemes like a national sales tax. Indeed, Obama didn't add much to the measures he had previously proposed — except for an increased desire to cut defense spending and a requirement that Congress enter into annual sudden-death negotiations if the deficit exceeds 2.8% of gross domestic product. But the President did add a crucial element to the debate: a sense of proportion and sanity.

Our latest episode of budget-deficit mania — a phenomenon previously witnessed in the 1980s and 1990s, after the last round of excessive tax cutting — has been the product, mostly, of brazen cynicism on the part of many Republicans and well-intentioned myopia on the part of some high-minded policy sorts. It is a phenomenon largely confined within the Beltway. A recent Gallup poll showed that only 11% of Americans considered deficits the most important issue facing the country.
(See the 2011 TIME 100 Poll.)

The strongest section of the President's speech was a history lesson. We didn't have a significant deficit problem 10 years ago. We had a budget surplus. We did have the long-term question of how to pay for the baby boomers' old-age benefits, but that was, and is, a manageable problem. The "crisis" we face was visited upon us by the very people now screaming loudest about the budget deficit. Republicans, colleagues of Paul Ryan's, voted for the Bush tax cuts — which, as Obama noted, added $500 billion per year to the deficit — and they also voted for the (unpaid for) wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and a massive (unpaid for) Medicare prescription-drug benefit. On top of these obligations, we suffered a severe recession starting in 2008, which reduced tax revenue by an estimated $500 billion per year — and which required nearly a trillion dollars in government spending to avert a total economic collapse. And voilá, this year's $1.6 trillion budget deficit.

Obama then proceeded to eviscerate Ryan's extremely radical proposal, which would replace the current Medicare system with a voucher designed to actually diminish in value over time. The Ryan plan would significantly increase the cost of Medicare for the poor and middle class. (Obama's scare figure was $6,400 per person per year.) It would also force the frail elderly to make complicated market decisions in the abstruse health-insurance sector at a time of diminished acuity in their lives. It is, without question, a terrible plan — and it is made worse by Ryan's stubborn insistence on a continuation of low tax rates for the wealthy.
(See where Obama falls on the 140 Best Twitter Feeds list.)

This enduring Republican low-tax fetishism has come to seem quite delusional: we've tried this scenario twice before, in the 1980s and 2000s, and both times the budget deficit exploded. There were those —most famously Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan — who saw it as a conservative ploy to reduce spending. But now, 30 years later, we have demonstrative evidence that the public has no wish to reduce spending on most government programs — and especially not on the big ones like Social Security (which is supported by 80% of the public) and Medicare. A recent Gallup poll showed that only 13% of Americans wanted a "complete overhaul" of Medicare; it also showed that a plurality of Republicans — 33% — wanted no cost controls on Medicare, with another 28% preferring only minor changes.

The least exciting section of the President's speech was his remedies, but no real drama was necessary. Obama proposed a return to the Bush-Clinton policies that put us on the path to budget surpluses in the 1990s — and he will be able to restore the Clinton tax rates simply, with his veto pen, if necessary, in 2013. On Medicare, he merely wants to bolster the powers of the cost-control panel that is already written into his health care reform act. He also proposed a tax-reform process that will eliminate loopholes. This last is normally a quixotic enterprise, but given the recent deficit hysteria, Obama may have a shot at real reform this time. Thanks to Ryan, everything — the ridiculous farm subsidies, the inefficient job-training programs, even the defense budget — is now on the table. Indeed, Ryan has bestowed a remarkable gift upon the President: his radicalism has framed the moderate, financially prudent profile for Obama's coming campaign. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Indeed, Ryan has bestowed a remarkable gift upon the President: his radicalism has framed the moderate, financially prudent profile for Obama's coming campaign.

Like I've been saying. This election is already over.

Sanity over vanity. 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

"Boehner&Cantor in a box"

to go,please

Thank you. pull up to the second window. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

"Boehner&Cantor in a box"

to go,please

Thank you. pull up to the second window.


LOL. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

his radicalism has framed the moderate, financially prudent profile for Obama's coming campaign.

You've got to be kidding me!!

Moderate? Financially prudent?

Is there another Obama we don't know about running in 2012? 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Obama’s Demagogy on the Deficit

Obama unveiled his deficit cutting proposal yesterday that was long on partisan demagoguery and short on specifics. In what details were given, there is serious doubt that such proposals genuinely put forth practical solutions to the deficit crisis. Elsewhere, the nebulousness of the president’s “plan” left many wondering whether the administration truly has a firm grasp of the complicated factors contributing to the national debt. At the very least, the president’s short-notice, ill-defined speech on the deficit — one that was filled with more political punches than proposals — shows that the White House is on the defensive, trying desperately to make the case that, contra the united Republican front that has co-opted deficit discourse in Washington, incisive budget cuts are not all they’re cracked up to be.

In unusually harsh language, the president began by railing against the GOP’s plan authored by Representative Paul Ryan (R-WI), saying there was “nothing serious or courageous” about cutting $6.2 trillion of government spending over the next decade. He accused Republicans generally of “paint[ing] a vision of our future that is deeply pessimistic.”

As for his own plan, the president proposed massive tax increases on the “rich,” cuts in defense spending, Medicare and Medicaid “reform,” and closing tax loopholes, while continuing to “invest” in clean energy, education, medical research, and transportation. He would leave Medicare and Medicaid relatively untouched, while claiming that his plan would cut $4 trillion over the next 12 years.

Yet, the president offered no specifics on the cuts he was advocating except broad, unrealistic dollar amounts. For example, the president believes we can realize budget savings by cutting $1 trillion from interest payments on the debt over the next 12 years. But interest rates are near zero now, and it is highly unlikely that they will remain that low for the next 12 years, especially given the fact that inflation is rearing its head. Some analysts are predicting debt service payments to rise from its current $196 billion to a whopping $800 billion by 2016 as a result of rising interest rates.

The president’s Medicare proposal is equally unclear. Obama proposed that the Independent Medicare Advisory Board can keep costs down. The president said he would do this by “chang[ing] the way we pay for health care -– not by the procedure or the number of days spent in a hospital, but with new incentives for doctors and hospitals to prevent injuries and improve results.” Obama clearly believes he can slow the growth of Medicare by strengthening the advisory board, which will recommend the best ways to reduce spending while still providing seniors with adequate care. The president claims that these measures will save an additional $500 billion by 2023. If this number is as real as his $1 trillion in Medicare “savings” to come out of Obamacare — savings that are dubious in the extreme — the result will be little or nothing done about an entitlement program that is going broke and could sink the US economy by itself eventually.

Obama offered no specific cuts in defense beyond savings that would occur in winding down the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and a promise to look into more cuts. He will do this by conducting a “fundamental review” of our “role in a changing world” and examine our mission and capabilities. Practically speaking, he will look to reducing our readiness, which is the easiest and least painful part of the military budget to cut, but the one which is the most dangerous to skimp on.

The president’s plan was claimed to have been based loosely on the report issued by his Deficit Reduction Commission, which recommended broad cuts in government programs and smaller tax increases. Both parties rejected the findings of the commission as unrealistic and unworkable.

Perhaps most disturbingly, the president seems to believe he is scarcely culpably for the deficit crisis himself. Obama’s long, misleading narrative on how the deficit was created at the beginning of his Wednesday speech, completely absolved him of any responsibility for the $4.5 trillion in debt his administration has piled on in just two years. At times, it was a surreal performance, as the president talked about problems with the deficit as if his administration’s increase of nearly 40% in federal spending never happened. He placed the entire blame for our fiscal woes on his predecessor — something he has been doing since he was sworn in.

Besides being dishonest, the president’s political demagoguery was not the way to start off bipartisan negotiations — a goal he claimed was his priority. Republicans reacted negatively to the display. Representative Ryan remarked that the speech was “excessively partisan, dramatically inaccurate and hopelessly inadequate to addressing our country’s fiscal challenges.”

Other Republicans took direct aim at the president’s plan to increase taxes. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell remarked, “[H]e may want to blame others for the problems” that his profligate borrowing and spending have caused, but the American people don’t believe the hype about Democrats being able to maintain entitlement spending at their current levels if only they are allowed to raise taxes. McConnell added, “Americans know that we face a fiscal crisis not because we tax too little, but because Washington spends too much.”

Representative Mike Pence gave the president credit for his “willingness to reconsider his earlier budget proposal,” but warned “[W]e cannot tax our way back to a balanced budget.” Pence also said that the American people are well aware that the way to a balanced budget is to get government spending under control while keeping taxes down.

Clive Crook, senior editor of The Atlantic, was unreservedly critical of the Wednesday speech, writing that it was “weak both politically and substantively.” He continued: “My instant unguarded reaction, in fact, was to find it not just weak but pitiful. I honestly wondered why he bothered.”

Crook’s question has an easy answer: the reason why President Obama gave the speech in the first place was because the Republicans had changed the conversation in Washington on deficit reduction to cutting government spending exclusively. Andrew Malcolm wrote, “Every word of Washington’s political discussion was about cuts in the budget, exactly and only what Republicans wanted to debate.” Malcolm thinks that Boehner’s “well mannered aplomb” in driving the debate on deficits forced Obama to make the speech he gave on Wednesday.

As Malcolm points out, every time the president talks about “cutting” the deficit, he gives a laundry list of spending priorities that promises more of the same. This speech was no different. After claiming to be proposing “tough cuts” in the budget, the president rattled off areas of government spending that would continue to see increased “investment,” promising “[he] will not sacrifice the core investments that we need to grow and create jobs.” Those “investments” include medical research, clean energy, new roads and airport, education, job training and even broadband access. In this way, says Obama, “we will win the future.”

Cato Institute economist Michael Tanner told Investors Business Daily that Obama’s plan “would allow government to continue to grow more or less on the same trajectory that it is now on, rising from 25% of GDP today to 42% of GDP by 2050.” In short, the president’s plan does nothing to curb government growth, pay down our massive national debt, address the ticking bomb of out of control entitlements, create jobs, spur business development, or assure that future generations will have the same opportunities that we have enjoyed in the past.

Mr. Crook was right. Why did he bother? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Mr. Crook was right. Why did he bother?

It's campaign time.

Time to pander to his base and put that mask on to once again lead the clueless to the ballot box to get the votes. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Republicans, colleagues of Paul Ryan's, voted for the Bush tax cuts — which, as Obama noted, added $500 billion per year to the deficit

LOL...tax cuts wouldn't add anything to the deficit...total liberal twisting of the truth

this country doesn't have a REVENUE problem...we have a SPENDING problem 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

0







0 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

0 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Oneeyedman

If you are going to post someone else's comments please post the source like I did. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

0 

r2d2 --- 15 years ago -

I just wish the Liar-in-Chief would shut up. He opens his foul mouth and makes us all sick.

He would do us all a great favor and just resign.

BHO go away! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground