Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

New Caney ISD Fails 4 year old CP student

who's talking here?

Jen 1
smartypants 11
QueenCassie 1
Sandyr9111 2
movedagain 1
Mygirl01 1
AFWife 3
proudmama1 1
ghostpost 1
ExLady In Blue 1
tennis 6
OH SNAP 1
TexasOma 11
moribundmaverick 5
Maglievaz Photography 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 6
thankfulformyfour 1
zerotocrazy 6
Tootiefrog 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

zerotocrazy --- 15 years ago -

My daughter is 4 years old, has cerebral palsy, and I am her voice. Please watch this short video that explains her story.
You Tube: LaKay's Voice
or copy and past this link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zhaJQY4lk9c 

Sandyr9111 --- 15 years ago -

Seen it a few months ago and shared it on my facebook.

I hope u are getting her what she needs. 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Perhaps the physical therapist was trying to say that she is not a specialist in the kind of physical therapy that your daughter needs and that's why it would be a waste of time for her to attempt to do that kind of work with her?

Also, there are tons of places in the Houston Metropolitan area that do pediatric OT. 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

I understand in regards to your situation & how it has been handled but I must say that I would never trust a government funded school to be dealing with my child's physical therapy...it's bad enough that you can't trust them with the education part. 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

Oh isn't she precious...LaKay is obviously well loved. I don't have answers nor am I qualified to offer advice...I will be praying for her. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

She is very adorable. She is also lucky to have a parent willing to advocate for her.

That being said, you are presenting only one side of the story. I am not disputing it, just stating the obvious.

I can not imagine any services being discontinued without your consent. Are her services to be provided spelled out on your paperwork? Is it stated that she will receive direct PT services?

Does your insurance cover private physical therapy? Not to dismiss your concerns, but I do know that the obligation of the school district to provide adequate services is not defined the same as what you will encounter in the private sector. I am not saying it is inferior, but there is a limit on what they are required to provide. I am surprised to hear of a therapist not familiar with botox injections for this purpose as it is not an uncommon method of treatment.

Is she a PT or a PT assistant?


I would assume that at this point you are familiar with the rights and procedural assurances provided to you each year as required. Have you contacted TEA regarding your concerns and allegations?

Good luck. It is a long journey and a huge undertaking to parent and advocate for a special needs child. 

Maglievaz Photography --- 15 years ago -

Last year I worked with a 17 year old boy with CP. When I started working with him I knew little about CP but quickly learned. I discovered he was very smart and wanted to learn very badly. Most of the people that had worked with him in the past did not put the effort in to help him improve. There were some people that did but it was far in-between. By the end of last year he was making all A’s and B’s. He had amazed himself with his grades but I knew he had it in him. It just took the effort to work with his teachers to present his assignments in a way he was able to do them himself. This person was not able to speak or communicate without the use of a tablet computer that was controlled by a joystick on his wheelchair. Don’t let anyone ever tell you your daughter is not capable of something because with determination anything is possible. I recommend you watch My Left Foot or read the book. This last summer with the help of the tennis coach we were able to get him walking on his gate trainer for as long as 2 hours. We called a meeting with the PT that had not seen him in over 3 years and she was amazed he was doing it. I asked why they quit PT on him and she replied “ he did not want to do it”. After futher investigation it had been the plastic boots he was required to wear. Instead of finding a fix to the problem they just gave up. It is going to take all the parents of CP kids to band together and lobby the state of Texas to fund the schools to hire better PT and OT personal. Right now the pay that schools pay a PT or OT is way below what the can make elsewhere so they tend to only have PT or OT assistants to do the job. 

QueenCassie --- 15 years ago -

I saw this on FB when "E" posted it. Praying for you and LaKay! 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

You seem to have an expectation that the school district's program is going to be the tipping point in your child's physical progress. This is definately NOT the case. School districts are strapped for money, are cutting services to the bone, and they never paid their therapists as much as those professionals can earn in private practice. I'm not saying that you don't get some very dedicated and compassionate people working for the district, but in general I have the impression that the BEST PTs are those who would work with you privately. (Even then you have to be careful.) Humble ISD is at the point where they bill the child's private insurer for the cost of PT. I imagine New Caney is either in the same boat or close to it.

If you expect the district to be the only one providing this important medical treatment for your child, I fear you will continue to be disappointed. That's not to say they shouldn't be helping, advising, and treating. But they shouldn't be the only resource. And also, that PT in the you tube video, was a b!tch. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

PLease tell me that this beautiful little girl receive the PT she needed and that the shots weren't for nothing?

I'll be damned if I would have let my child go without the therapy she needs just because the school district wouldn't do it.

I was unaware that the districts offered free PT for its students. Why in the world would they? The school is not a medical facility. If this is a need situation then Medicare would pay for the PT 100%. I don't get this. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

that the shots weren't for nothing?

The mom is not telling the whole story. I understand that her beef is with the school district and that is what she is upset about.

The shots are not for nothing even if the child doesn't get follow up PT. The Botox reduces muscle spasticity, which in itself can cause damage if untreated.

It is better if PT continues, of course. The parents need to pursue a course of treatment with a private therapist as they continue to seek services through the school district. 

proudmama1 --- 15 years ago -

I do agree that the PTs and OTs that work in the school system make less than those in other areas such as rehab, hospitals, etc. However, there are some reasons for that (shorter work days, shorter work years, benefits are better, etc). That does not mean they are not as qualified therapists.
With that being said: there are bad therapists out there, just like there are bad nurses, doctors, bank managers. If there is a problem with the therapist, I would go up the chain of command, even to the superintendant if you have to. If they have "lawyered up", perhaps time to look for a lawyer or perhaps a different school district or private therapy.
There are regulations to keep anyone on with PT/OT services: such as progress. If no progress has been shown, the patient cannot continue on skilled therapy services. This is something that many family members and patients have difficulty with.
I know about the benefits of Botox (I have seen positive results); if the PT or PTA did not know them, then that person definitely needs some training. I would be requesting a PT with experience with CP in children 

tennis --- 15 years ago -

I was unaware that the districts offered free PT for its students. Why in the world would they? The school is not a medical facility. If this is a need situation then Medicare would pay for the PT 100%. I don't get this.

Apparently you need to WAKE UP! NOTHING IS FREE..DUH! This is very depressing to me..esp. from NCISD! I have had several kids with CP and was determined as much as the kids/parents were to get them to walk first WITH asst., 2nd on their own with me closely watching them, then got my kids on the gait trainer and they were walking by themselves WITHOUT ME! I work with PT's VERY closely and have learned a hell of ALOT from them..so sorry you have a "not so caring PT or PTA". I would def. SUE the crap out of the district if that was my very own kid! If you have NOT contacted TEA in regards to this matter, I would do so like NOW! Please note that I am def. NOT a certified PT or PTA, but I am certified as a CAPE! ;) Unfortunately you can NOT request a PT or PTA(at least in my district). It is just "the luck of the draw" so they say! Have you taken your sweet lil one to Shriner's in H-town? They are awesome ppl. down there and def. know what they are talking about! I would highly suggest them to anyone and have done so in the past. Good luck in your journey and with her attitude she will be up and walking on her own sooner than ANYONE ever anticipated! 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

There are regulations to keep anyone on with PT/OT services: such as progress. If no progress has been shown, the patient cannot continue on skilled therapy services.

Not showing progress is rarely an issue with a 4 year old. She's already weight-bearing on a walker. That little girl has great potential.

That school district has a terrible PT.

If the district wants to bill private insurance for the therapy (not sure if that's the case), there is nothing to lose from getting the girl into private therapy. 

tennis --- 15 years ago -

Humble ISD is at the point where they bill the child's private insurer for the cost of PT. I imagine New Caney is either in the same boat or close to it.

So can you tell me this: What are parents suppose to do if they do NOT have private insurance? I have had several students in my past that their families can truly NOT afford it. I wish I were rich and could pay it for them...but also helps when you know a lot of ppl. aka PT's that work at TIRR downtown and Shriner's! ;) 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

So can you tell me this: What are parents suppose to do if they do NOT have private insurance?

I don't know if CHIP covers PT. Shriner's is another option.

It's really difficult if you don't have insurance of some kind. That is a fact. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

So can you tell me this: What are parents suppose to do if they do NOT have private insurance? I have had several students in my past that their families can truly NOT afford it. I wish I were rich and could pay it for them...but also helps when you know a lot of ppl. aka PT's that work at TIRR downtown and Shriner's! ;)


So - why is it the school district's responsibility to provide physical therapy or occupational therapy for any student?

Unless the federal government pays for these programs under some sort of rehabilitation grant, why should the taxpayers of the district pay for another child's therapy?

It's bad enough that the ISD's are short on money to teach the students in regular class - they should not be financing something that the insurance or Medicaid should be paying for. 

tennis --- 15 years ago -

It's really difficult if you don't have insurance of some kind. That is a fact.

Amen. glad someone out there understands! lol..
I honestly do NOT know if CHIP covers PT either..I will find out tomorrow and report back! 

tennis --- 15 years ago -

Texas Oma--WOW I hope you do NOT have any special needs kids/family members, etc. You need to take advantage of the TEA's website and learn some FEDERAL laws in Special Education like NOW! just saying..not trying to be rude honestly..this just hits a "certain nerve" for me I guess you could say. Hope you understand. ;) 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

So - why is it the school district's responsibility to provide physical therapy or occupational therapy for any student?


That is where I am confused. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

ou need to take advantage of the TEA's website and learn some FEDERAL laws in Special Education like NOW!


I worked in the Special Services department at DPISD and I KNOW there are programs available that are funded by the federal government. The school districts have to use those funds not the funds that educate our kids. ---- just saying.

But you, my dear, seem to expect these PT & OT services to be taken out of the funds in addition to the monies provided by the feds. There are insurance programs, such as medicaid and SSI, that pay for the physical health of special needs kids. 

moribundmaverick --- 15 years ago -

The problem is that federal and state governments require ISD's to provide certain services, but then give no funding. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

The problem is that federal and state governments require ISD's to provide certain services, but then give no funding.


The money is there but the SpEd department and the parents need to get the money.

Why should regular students be cheated of an education because someone needs PT and OT and doesn't want to use their insurance or Medicaid to pay for it.

Sorry -- but that's how I feel. Funds are short all the way around and PT & OT are not essential to educating a kid. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

why is it the school district's responsibility to provide physical therapy or occupational therapy for any student?

That is hard to explain. I probably won't do it well but I'll try. Some types of therapy are considered the responsibility of the schools because of the Americans with Disabilities Act. The child must be educated in the least restrictive environment, which means public schools. For example, if the school requires phys. ed, and you have a child with CP in the class, you need to get a PT in there to see if there are things that can helpful to the child so that he or she can participate as much as possible in that class. If the child can't hold a pencil, you might need an OT to advise on if an orthopedic support of some kind would help, and then teach the child to use it. With that extra help, hopefully the child will be included as much as possible in regular ed.

It's very difficult to look at a child who can benefit from help, and just turn your back. It is expensive though, and even though ADA is a federal law, the feds have never fully funded the program. That means these programs suck inappropriate amounts of money from individual districts.

On one hand, you have kids that can be helped in their communities. On the other, you have limited resources. It's a terrible choice. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

It might also be helpful to understand that NOT providing some services is a form of discrimination, the same as if you denied equal access to education on the basis of ethnicity. The child didn't ask to be born with a physical limitation. She has just as much right to fully participate, as much as possible, in her educational program as someone who is not disabled. That is the basic concept of ADA. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

smartypants....you explained it well, but I still say that the school district can AND SHOULD turn right around and bill the medical insurance company or Medicaid.

If I'm in a wreck or injured on the job and go to the ER, the ER will bill my medical insurance company who will, in turn, make me deal with the workman's comp or auto insurance company.

That's how it should work at the school districts - but they are chocked full of administrators that sit back and do nothing except drain the system with their high salaries and don't find ways to fund programs.

If a child needs OT and PT --- the parent can and should see those services from an independent provider. I would rather choose my PT or OT technician than leave it to some ARD counselor who is overwhelmed with meetings.

But - I guess I don't live in the real world. 

moribundmaverick --- 15 years ago -

even though ADA is a federal law, the feds have never fully funded the program.


Agreed.... same goes for IDEA and just about any other federal education act out there. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

the school district can AND SHOULD turn right around and bill the medical insurance company or Medicaid.

And many are doing that. On the other hand, it isn't appropriate to bill insurance to make a school wheelchair accessable, for example.


If a child needs OT and PT --- the parent can and should see those services from an independent provider

They can, and many do, but don't forget that the child's primary teacher also benefits when services are provided on site. The teacher receives help and input from a specialist who can tailor goals according to what is appropriate to the child's current classroom curriculum. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -


Agreed.... same goes for IDEA and just about any other federal education act out there.




And yet, every one of the libs and dems were hopping on board the Obamacare program?

Why?

Does anyone think that the health care program will be funded any better than what you are saying these education programs are? 

moribundmaverick --- 15 years ago -

I seriously doubt it- but that's how just about everything has been since the 50's. Everything sounds great in theory, but when put to practice, it's just a big mess. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

They can, and do, but don't forget that the child's primary teacher also benefits when services are provided on site. The teacher receives help and input from a specialist who can tailor goals according to what is appropriate to the child's current classroom curriculum.


And as a nurse, I benefit when I am on premise with the physical therapist........I get paid by insurance company or Medicare just as the PT does.

Why should every other student lose out because these students suck the til dry with PT and OT and botox injections and any other service that should not be a part of the regular curriculum.

I'm frustrated that kids are receiving less and less education and more and more people are demanding more of my tax dollars because they want this program or that program or this alteration or that alteration.

I'm not trying to be hateful to the handicapped, but there has to be a line drawn in the sand on what the districts can afford to payout.

And -- this leads to another comparison to ObamaCare.....death sqauds......who deserves what services. This would be a good example of having to make choices on who gets what.

Sorry, I'm on a roll tonight. I guess I better go to bed before I get my foot too firmly planted in my mouth.

Night all. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

every one of the libs and dems were hopping on board the Obamacare program?

Why?


Please don't say every. I do not support the health care reform we eventually got. I was in favor of single payer or the public option. This bill doesn't include those.

Does anyone think that the health care program will be funded any better than what you are saying these education programs are?

Well, the snarky response would be, not as long as GOP has a say in the matter. But besides that, I think it's better to TRY and help, even if it ends up that you can't help everyone, then to do nothing. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

I seriously doubt it- but that's how just about everything has been since the 50's. Everything sounds great in theory, but when put to practice, it's just a big mess.



As with everything with the government......look at the Post Office. They 'set it free' (sorta) --- it's one messed up mess. It can't pay for itself, it is top heavy in management, inefficient in how it performs, yet there is nothing we can do about it. Same with TSA ---- any time the government gets involved it's a mess. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

botox injections

btw, that is not provided by the school district. That is done by a medical provider. 

moribundmaverick --- 15 years ago -

any time the government gets involved it's a mess.


Well... you know what that means! Time to pack a survival bag, move to the middle of nowhere, and live off the land! And with all these darned birds and fish dying, and with only a year left until 2012, we'd all better do it sooner rather than later! :P 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -



Please don't say every. I do not support the health care reform we eventually got. I was in favor of single payer or the public option. This bill doesn't include those. OK - I take back the 'every'. What we got was a total boondoggle. It's not going to work and I hope and pray that it's overturned and we start from scratch with some common sense.

Well, the snarky response would be, not as long as GOP has a say in the matter. But besides that, I think it's better to TRY and help, even if it ends up that you can't help everyone, then to do nothing. It's not a GOP/DEM thing --- it's an idiots in Washington thing. No one thinks with their brain, they think with my pocketbook. And no, it's not better to TRY and help --- not with what they have done with this bill.



As a nurse, I see patients on Medicare having to struggle to make ends meet and pay for their meds. It's eat or pay for medications to live. The Medicare controls what is paid for and what is not.....one of my patients need Feosol (Iron) and it costs $12.00 for a month supply..........she's anemic - she needs the medicine, so she dips into her limited income (SS) to pay for the iron to keep her healthy. She needs colace to help her poop --- it costs $5.00 for a bottle - Medicare doesn't pay for that either. Same with baby aspirin. It use to be a bottle of baby aspirin was fifty cents.....now it's 3.50 - same quantity. Her eye solutions are OTC and she NEEDS them because she has such dry eyes....again not covered.

Another patient has to take Plavix --- he can't afford it, but fore gos needs so he can make the co-payment of 75.00/month.

So this health care bill is not going to help the people it needs to - yet all these people are hopping up and down that it's going to be soooooooo wonderful. BS - it's another drain on our pocketbooks and the government is going to manage it just like it manages Medicare and Medicaid. (I haven't mentioned anything about my Medicaid patients and what they have to do to get care.)
 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -



btw, that is not provided by the school district. That is done by a medical provider.


That's what I thought I read above. But the same thinking could apply --- Botox is needed to relax the muscles & tendons, therefore it should be covered in the best interest of the student.......see, it's one thing here and another thing there....doesn't make sense how things are done. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Now --- gotta get some sleep or I won't be any good to my patients tomorrow.

Night again. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

any time the government gets involved it's a mess.


Well... you know what that means! Time to pack a survival bag, move to the middle of nowhere, and live off the land!


lol good reply


Why should every other student lose out because these students suck the til dry with PT and OT and botox injections and any other service that should not be a part of the regular curriculum.

Okay, where would you like to draw the line? Our district provides special classes for pregnant teens, so they're not mixed in with the other students. Should that program be cut? How about the disciplinary program the really out of control kids attend? If they could just be in reg. ed., that would save money too. How about laying off the teachers who help the visually impaired? Special ed. teachers are paid more than regular ed. teachers...just put severely autistic kids in reg. ed without any support or early intervention? It would save money. How about cutting out bus service for those who live more than 2 miles away and let those kids walk or have their parents drive them? Or hire a taxi service. Transportation eats up a lot of money and people chose where they live don't they? Why should those who live closer have to support those who don't? How about we don't have any activities on school premises except actual school...no sports, no coaches, no away games, no stadiums. No fancy weight lifting equipment or gymnastic apparatus. Not necessary for physical health, totally optional. etc. etc.

Slippery slope. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

charity
children
connecting
health


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground