Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Call Our Troops Homophobes

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 4
randyjet 4
steinhoister 2
wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Sebastian 1
voice of reason 1
JohnLynch 1
allday 1
Gang Starr 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

by Ann Coulter

The Pentagon's poll on "don't ask, don't tell" is beyond idiotic. Instead of asking whether the troops support repeal of DADT, the Pentagon asked only if they can learn to play nice with the gays.

Even more absurdly, the Pentagon polled all military "personnel" -- and their spouses! Only a small portion of what is known as "the military" actually does the fighting. The rest is a vast bureaucracy along the lines of the DMV.

Today's military features "victim advocates" and sensitivity training facilitators, the Defense Advisory Committee on Women in the Services personnel and a million other goo-goo positions. How did we ever take the shores of Normandy without a phalanx of "sensitivity training" counselors?



No one has any need to be reassured that the military's "social action" staff will enjoy working with gays. Whatever a career in "social action" entails, it better be gay-friendly. Frankly, it's appalling the Pentagon's poll of all military personnel and their families didn't produce better numbers for the gays.

We're interested in what the men who fight think. As the Pentagon study itself reports: "A higher percentage of service members in war-fighting units predicted negative effects."

So gays openly serving in the military will harm the "war-fighting" part of the military, but the "social action" part will thrive!

Naturally, Marines are the most resistant to overturning "don't ask, don't tell," with 58 percent of those in combat opposed.

Who cares if the Pentagon's sexual harassment task force supports gays in the military? The combat units don't, and they're the ones who do the job. The rest of us shouldn't get to vote on gays in the military any more than we get to vote on the choreography of "Chicago."

Military combat is a very specialized field comparable to nothing in civilian life. There has to be a special bond among warriors -- and only one kind of bond. The soldierly bond gets confused if some guys think their comrades are hot or if they suspect their superior is having a relationship with a fellow soldier.

It's the same confusion that results from putting girls in the military. When an officer makes a decision, nothing should enter into it except his views on the best military strategy.

The military part of the military has valid reasons for wanting to separate the idea of martial ardor and sexual attraction. Combat units can't have anything that interferes with unit cohesion, such as, for example, platoon members who are dating one another. Racial prejudice is not the same thing as sexual attraction, so please stop telling us this is just like integrating blacks in the military.

A Military Times survey in 2005 found that nearly half of all women in the military claim to have been the victim of sexual harassment -- ludicrously more than women in civilian life. By contrast, two-thirds of minorities said they were treated better in the military than in society at large.

The Pentagon's report found that service members "repeatedly" said that allowing gays to serve openly would "lead to widespread and overt displays of effeminacy," as well as "harassment" and unwelcome advances. (To which I would add, "and the occasional leak of massive amounts of classified documents.")

Gays in the military understand this better than heterosexuals in civilian life. According to the Pentagon's survey, only 15 percent of gays currently serving said they would want their units to know they're gay. (Also, 2 percent of gays currently serving giggled when asked about their "unit," which is down from 5 percent from last year.)

There are far more discharges for pregnancy and "parenthood" than for homosexuality. In the past five years, less than 1 percent of all unplanned military discharges (i.e. not due to retirement or completion of service) were for homosexuality.

Here's a record of the discharges for 2008, according to the Defense Department:
-- Drugs: 5,627
-- Serious offenses: 3,817
-- Weight standards: 4,555
-- Pregnancy: 2,353
-- Parenthood: 2,574
-- Homosexuality: 634


The main lesson from these figures isn't that we should have gays openly serving in the military, but that we need to get girls out of the military, inasmuch as they are constantly being discharged for pregnancy, parenthood and weight issues.

According to a 1998 Department of Defense report, most discharges based on homosexuality involved "junior personnel with very little time in the military" and "the great majority of discharges for homosexual conduct are uncontested and processed administratively." More than 98 percent of discharges for homosexuality were honorable.

So gays and girls can join the military, get taxpayers to foot the bill for their education and then, when it comes time to serve, announce that they're gay or pregnant and receive an honorable discharge. Indeed, there's no proof that all the discharges for homosexuality involve actual homosexuals.

Why can't the Army and Marines have their own rules? Why does everything have to be the same? Whatever happened to "diversity"?

Maybe we could have an all-gay service! They'd be allowed to wear camouflage neckerchiefs (a la Paul Lynde) and camo capri pants. To avoid any sexual harassment claims, they'd have to have their own barrack, which we could outfit with a dance club, a cosmo bar and a counseling center called "The Awkward Place." Their band would mostly play show tunes, and soldiers captured by the enemy would be taught to reveal only their name, rank and seasonal color analysis ("I am Private First Class Jeffrey Smith and I'm a 'winter.'")

They wouldn't be allowed in combat, however, for the same reason women aren't –- it takes them too long to get ready.

Most people have no clue what military life is like, least of all the opinion makers in New York, Los Angeles and the nation's capital. The military is not representative of the country at large. It is disproportionately rural, small-town, Southern and Hispanic.

We ask our troops to do a lot for very little money. Sometimes they die for us. The least Democrats could do is not pass grandstanding bills while self-righteously denouncing our servicemen as homophobes. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

i think that it is amusing that coulter is your idol and you read her religiously. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

i think that it is amusing that coulter is your idol and you read her religiously.



And I find it amusing the you opened the thread with full knowledge of what it was gonna be! You must like her too! LOL 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

I have always admired gays serving quietly under don't ask, don't tell. What I can't stand are the homophobes who out them. And what I really can't stand at all is the solution. Once outed, they have to be fired. No more pay, no more benefits, no more being able to serve their country. Dishonorably discharged.
Every argument Anne has here is similar to the case for segregation in military barracks. Every one. Turns out, those fears were warrantless, baseless, ugly and just plain wrong. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

And I find it amusing the you opened the thread with full knowledge of what it was gonna be! You must like her too!

Hahahahaha, I was thinking the same thing! 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

I thought the title was being ironic. Boy was I wrong. If someone could have the courtesy, nay, decency to put Coulter's name in the headline, others might have been spared from opening it. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

I thought the title was being ironic. Boy was I wrong. If someone could have the courtesy, nay, decency to put Coulter's name in the headline, others might have been spared from opening it.



Her weekly article comes out EVERY Wednesday, so next Wednesday when you see me a post a thread title that disturbs you, just count on it being her column and don't open! There is your fair warning! ;) 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

What I can't stand are the homophobes who out them.

ridiculous...just because someone doesn't agree with that lifestyle, that doesn't make them "afraid" of that lifestyle 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

by Ann Coulter



This is a woman who believes America would be better off if women couldn't vote.... 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

This is a woman who believes America would be better off if women couldn't vote....

What she REALLY said/believes...

------
Coulter: "If we took away women's right to vote, we'd never have to worry about another Democrat president"
October 04, 2007 3:34 pm ET

An October 2 New York Observer blog post featuring excerpts of an interview with right-wing pundit Ann Coulter quoted her as saying: "If we took away women's right to vote, we'd never have to worry about another Democrat [sic] president. It's kind of a pipe dream, it's a personal fantasy of mine, but I don't think it's going to happen. And it is a good way of making the point that women are voting so stupidly, at least single women." Coulter went on: "It also makes the point, it is kind of embarrassing, the Democratic Party ought to be hanging its head in shame, that it has so much difficulty getting men to vote for it. I mean, you do see it's the party of women and 'We'll pay for health care and tuition and day care -- and here, what else can we give you, soccer moms?' "

Additionally, a separate October 2 Observer article printing excerpts of the interview quoted Coulter as saying during a discussion of terrorism: "Now this isn't the Cold War, these aren't sane but evil white men -- these are crazy Islamists. This country -- people are under the impression that it could never change, that this can be taken for granted, it can't be taken away, and this is a terrifying time. I mean, it's terrifying to think what could happen with a one-term Democrat, any of those Democrats." Coulter made her comment as part of her response to interviewer George Gurley's question, "How much blame does Bill Clinton deserve for 9/11?"

The New York Observer website states that Coulter's interview "was published in the October 8, 2007, edition of THE NEW YORK OBSERVER." 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Every argument Anne has here is similar to the case for segregation in military barracks. Every one. Turns out, those fears were warrantless, baseless, ugly and just plain wrong.

That is simply not true and most black American military members and vets do NOT agree with that. Just a few points are that blacks were integrated in the US military during the Revolution and 25% of the Army troops were black. Gays were NOT since it was illegal to be gay for ALL Americans. Segregation of the US miiitary was not law passed by Congress and thus was able to be undone by Truman with an executive order. Obama is not a dictator who can unilateraly dump DADT

The segregation in the military was by custom and tradition and was in many cases outright illegal. Jackie Robinson fought against the illegal segregation, was court martialed for defying it, but was granted an honorable discharge to get rid of him since he was a trouble maker. Segregation was illegal under the 14th Amendment, unlike gays who had no such amendment or case law supporting them.

There was no danger of blacks making advances to white folks to see if they were black. There was no disease prevelant mainly among black troops that could be passed on to white troops by exposure to blood. Unfortunately, being in the military means that you will get to share blood and spill it in rather extreme situations. If you think that pro athletes are a bit shy about HIV players being on the same team because of the slight risk of blood contact, just think how the military troops feel, especially the combat arms.

The Tuskeegee airmen showed the harm segregation caused to our military effectiveness when they out performed the average white pilots. They scored higher than the average white trainee, compiled a better record in many areas than white units, and after the war were the top unit in combat competition just before the Air Force wsa desegregated. I know of no contention that gays will constitute such an elite group that will outweigh the problems that they will cause. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

i think that it is amusing that coulter is your idol and you read her religiously

It is even more amusing that she never served and can be an authority on the military for some people. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I am opposed to repealing DADT and I think it should be retained, and judicial punishment handed out to those snoops who DO ASK and TELL. Gays who simply want to do their jobs and keep their commitments to the military should be allowed to stay. We need to use some common sense in this. If gays can and do conform to this policy, then any person who outs them should be punished. That is the only fault I find with current policy. 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

What she REALLY said/believes...

------
Coulter: "If we took away women's right to vote, we'd never have to worry about another Democrat president"
October 04, 2007 3:34 pm ET

An October 2 New York Observer blog post featuring excerpts of an interview with right-wing pundit Ann Coulter quoted her as saying: "If we took away women's right to vote, we'd never have to worry about another Democrat [sic] president. It's kind of a pipe dream, it's a personal fantasy of mine, but I don't think it's going to happen. And it is a good way of making the point that women are voting so stupidly, at least single women." Coulter went on: "It also makes the point, it is kind of embarrassing, the Democratic Party ought to be hanging its head in shame, that it has so much difficulty getting men to vote for it. I mean, you do see it's the party of women and 'We'll pay for health care and tuition and day care -- and here, what else can we give you, soccer moms?' "




She's repeated her "belief" many times in a few different ways. 

Gang Starr --- 15 years ago -

More drivel from DAnn Coulter!!!! 

Sebastian --- 15 years ago -

So against my better judgment I read the Coulter article even though i have seen her bigoted hate speech before. While the article wasn't as homophobic as i thought it would be for Miss Coutler, it was still classic ignorance. I didnt think anyone could top the great Coulter in the same topic but i was pleasantly surprised and humored by Randy's post.
First
Implying that blacks were treated as equals in the Revolution is absurd. Washington himself tried to get rid of African Americans (and succeeded) numerous times, he only finally let them in when he realized after Valley Forge that he would need them to win the war. If anything the British government was far more caring than the Continental army.

Also please look at the 14th amendment before claiming that is does not protect gays.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution
i believe most gay Americans are "persons born or naturalized in the United States"

And im not going to even begin to get into you Bigoted Coulter worthy talk about HIV being one of the prime cases against repealing DADT. (i find it amusing that you think someone with HIV could even continue serving in the Military regardless of their sexual preference.)

Just like Coulter, i wish more people would think before making such silly statements. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Thanks for the laugh and proof of my conviction that Coulter should be banged and left by the road. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Washington himself tried to get rid of African Americans (and succeeded) numerous times

When Washington took command at Boston, he did try and get rid of blacks, but after it was pointed out that they needed every man, he relented. I suggest you read some history before you make such statements. The high percentage of blacks in the Continental Army did not suddenly come about after Valley Forge. As for the Brits treating blacks better that is absurd, since most of the blacks who fought for them were sold back into slavery after the war ended.

As for the 14th amendment applying to gays that is beyond absurd since such conduct was ILLEGAL in ALL states. Thus gays were NOT any kind of a protected class. The conduct that defines a person as being gay was ILLEGAL, so they were NOT considered a protected class and the 14th amendment did NOT apply to them. AS a matter of fact, the Lawrence vs Texas case that struck down such laws was NOT decided on 14th amendment grounds. So you lose on that ground as well. If the SCOTUS did not think that the 14th amendment applied to them, I hardly think that your opinion has any weight at all.

Let me know when you have learned some history, law and logic. Try reading Washington, an Imperfect God which has a lot of info about Washington and slavery and his views and how he changed over the course of his life. You might learn something. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground