Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Shocking: Agnostic Dad Loses Custody of Kids

who's talking here?

outermaga 1
Fallon 5
maverick 1
AFWife 1
Perfection 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
JohnLynch 2
SighFiGurl 1
Work in Progress 1
Puss In Boots 1
Storm Jane 5
Dorothy Parker 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Storm Jane --- 15 years ago -

A father is fighting back after losing custody of his children in Indiana. Craig Scarberry has shared 50/50 custody of his three kids with his ex-wife for 4 years. But when that time was just recently reduced to 4 hours per week, he started digging to find out why, and he had a shocker. The Judge wrote, "The father did not participate in the same religious training as the mother ... father was agnostic." The ruling also stated, "... when the father considered himself a Christian, the parties were able to communicate relatively effectively."

Saw this and just wants some other peoples views!! 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

According to what I'm reading the mother is a loser of a parent. I am a Christian but I see this as discrimination against him plain and simple. 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

Isn't the case where the mom is Jewish? Well she started practicing again after she had her son. or after the divorce? And the dad was not suppose to take the son to any other church? But he did anyway. He lost custody once because of this.

Not sure if it is the same case.

The dad broke custody agreements, whatever they were, and had custody taken away as a result.

The mom appeared to be a loon and the dad wasn't dealing with a full deck either. Any way you look at it, the kid is the one who gets the crap end of this deal. 

Storm Jane --- 15 years ago -

However, I never posed a situation for my children or ever forced my beliefs onto the kids. Matter of fact, they continue to go to a christian daycare. When I had joint legal I agreed to take them to Church functions such as the Mother's Day Choir. As well as allow them to go to church with my mother who attends on a regular basis, in addition to Church camp, those kinds of things. We were able to show that in no way, shape, or form do my personal beleifs and decisions reflect onto the children at all.
Craig Scarberry (father) 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

You know anytime a child has to be crapped on for the parents to feel like they are winning whatever it is they are winning, it isn't ever a good thing for the child.

Sometimes people can't live together. And when that happens and there are children involved, it would be nice to see folks take a grown up pill.

The children never ask for the parents to split up. The very least that can be done is for the parents to make it as easy on the child as possible.

Unless one parent is abusive, both parents should be reasonable. 

Storm Jane --- 15 years ago -

I agree, I think that this is a very sad day for the children... 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

You know you don't often hear of Hollywood doing much right. But Jada Picket Smith was on Oprah one day, and she said that Will Smiths son, and his mom spend Christmas with them. She said it isn't about the adults, it is about the children. Wow, not a lot of blended families can do this, but how great for the kids when they can. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Fallon also. If that is all there is to this story, it's a poor excuse to limit a fathers' time with his children. Sometimes dad's get the short end of the stick on custody issues. :( 

Storm Jane --- 15 years ago -

You know you don't often hear of Hollywood doing much right. But Jada Picket Smith was on Oprah one day, and she said that Will Smiths son, and his mom spend Christmas with them. She said it isn't about the adults, it is about the children. Wow, not a lot of blended families can do this, but how great for the kids when they can.

It's really easy to put your past silliness behind. My daughters father is awesome. Many of my divorced friend ask me how we can hang out. I just tell them that it takes a village and its not about me. My daughter is way more important then whatever drama we had when were young, she needs her dad and he is not a bad guy. He could never be anything less then a great friend, he helped make a very talented young lady. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I was under the impression that most custody laws unfairly favor the mothers anyway. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So what is the shocking part? 

Storm Jane --- 15 years ago -

So what is the shocking part?

I don't know, maybe its that a father was unjustly treated. Religion has no place in our courts.

The Judge wrote, "The father did not participate in the same religious training as the mother ... father was agnostic." The ruling also stated, "... when the father considered himself a Christian, the parties were able to communicate relatively effectively." 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I don't know, maybe its that a father was unjustly treated.

many fathers are unjustly treated in the court system where religion plays no part in the proceedings 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

many fathers are unjustly treated in the court system where religion plays no part in the proceedings


So when religion is the reason for the unjust treatment it should be ignored? 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Have to believe that there is something else going on here. After having 50/50 custody of the kid for four years, and the kid continued participating in church functions and daycare....and there is no change in that. Hmmmm. Something else going on here, me thinks. 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

If this is the same case I am thinking of, the dad broke custody agreements and was punished for doing so.

Not sure what the judge wrote or the context in which he wrote it. I'd have to see it fully before I could make a decision.

This is more of a case of both parents just sucking as parents. 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

But for sure the courts do not favor the dad's in custody agreements.

Some dads are dead beats, and those are the ones we hear about daily. But there are some darn good ones out there, and they do not get the same treatment in court as the moms do. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

So when religion is the reason for the unjust treatment it should be ignored?

where did you come up with this? trying to twist words again? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

where did you come up with this? trying to twist words again?


How is asking a question a twist of words?


You stated that people are unfairly treated even when religion isn't a factor. What is the point of this comment? Are you saying that since unfair treatment happens, that no one should care when it happens because of religion? If so I don't see the logic in that. 

maverick --- 15 years ago -

You stated that people are unfairly treated even when religion isn't a factor. What is the point of this comment? Are you saying that since unfair treatment happens, that no one should care when it happens because of religion? If so I don't see the logic in that.

It was unlikely the real reason, just one easily pointed to by the judge. Probably no real reason other than he is the father not the mother so he gets screwed. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Can you have religious limitations and/or standards put into custody agreements?

I've never heard of this before. 

outermaga --- 15 years ago -

Can you have religious limitations and/or standards put into custody agreements?

I've never heard of this before.


Yes, you can get an agreed order. You would be surprised at some of the stuff that some people put in their orders. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground