Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

HEB is the cheapest place to buy all the ingredients for your Thanksgiving meal

who's talking here?

Keystone 2
whatchamacallit 2
~grandma again~ 1
Lilteapot 1
qpc 1
Cajunmom 1
AFWife 1
Perfection 1
justcat 1
Meme2my5 2
quiettype 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
The Livable Forest Gump 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Channel 13 bought from Walmart, HEB and Target and HEB won.

HOUSTON (KTRK) -- If you haven't shopped for your thanksgiving dinner at the grocery store, wait until you hear from our frugal shopper. She went shopping to price compare traditional thanksgiving dinner ingredients at several stores.

Our frugal shopper compared prices at three stores. Her plan was to buy the same items at each store and find out which store is the best place to save money.

Amanda Grossman writes a blog called "Frugal Confessions," and this year she was inspired by a news article to go on a three-store shopping trip in her neighborhood to find out who had the cheapest prices.

"I saw this article where it says that this year people are spending 40 percent less in their Thanksgiving meal plans than previous years," Grossman said.

So she set out to find where families could spend the least amount of money on Thanksgiving dinner ingredients.

For her experiment, she shopped at Walmart, Target and HEB.

"We've compared apples to apples," Grossman said. "We bought the same amount of food, the same number of items, the same type of items and the same sized items for everything."

Grossman did use store brands where she could find them.

"We are going to cook green beans; we are going to have a pumpkin roll for dessert; we are going to roast a Turkey," she said.

Grossman found green beans the cheapest at Walmart for $1.42 a pound and at HEB, $1.68 a pound. Target was the most expensive at $1.99 a pound, which is 57 cents more expensive than Walmart's price.

A can of Libby's 100 percent pure pumpkin was the cheapest at Target for $1.29, and at Walmart and HEB the price was $1.50. But at HEB, right next to the can of pumpkin, was a store coupon for a free can of evaporated milk.

"I didn't use manufacturer coupons for this experiment; however, this HEB coupon, you get a free other product without messing with the experiment at all, so I did use this coupon," Grossman said.

But it was the price of an 11-pound turkey that made the biggest difference. Target's store brand turkey cost 68 cents a pound; Walmart's Butterball turkey was 98 cents a pound and HEB's Riverside brand turkey was 22 cents a pound with a $20 purchase, and that's what put HEB over the top when it came to saving money.

"This made a big difference because at Walmart, the cheapest turkey I could find was 98 cents a pound," Grossman said.

HEB was the winner with a total price of $26.89 for a complete Thanksgiving meal. Target came in second place with a total of $33.19 and Walmart was the most expensive at $35.43, something that surprised even Grossman.

"Honestly, I thought that Walmart was going to win," Grossman said.

The bottom line: the turkey is the key to shopping for a cheap Thanksgiving meal. If you are brand loyal, you are probably not going to find rock bottom prices like at HEB, where we found a turkey for 22 cents a pound. 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

probably not going to find rock bottom prices like at HEB, where we found a turkey for 22 cents a pound.

That is what I was looking for, I couldn't remember any stores posting their price of turkeys..I will get mine at H.E.B. Thank you ch.. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

Good to know b/c the budget is razor thin this year. Thanks for the post CH! 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

You will also wait in line for 40 minutes, where at Randall's, you will pay an additional $4 and get out of the store in under ten. 

justcat --- 16 years ago -

I guess it depends on what you buy..Neighbor got a Jenno at walmart for 29 cents pp 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

also wait in line for 40 minutes

My dh gets up early and he will go to the grocery for me. There is not a lot of people at the grocery that early. He loves shopping at heb, so I will let him..lol 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

I shop at HEB all the time including around the holidays and have never had more than a 10 minute wait. Now I don't go on the weekends or past 6pm most of the time. If I have no choice I would go after dinner time in the evening rather than at prime times. 

Cajunmom --- 16 years ago -

With all due resect, I don't think that is the case. Shopped at both for the 8 years I have been here and check out is about the same. 

whatchamacallit --- 16 years ago -

At Kroger, you can use coupons and beat the HEB price on everything, except the turkey. I got mine for .25 a pound with a $20 purchase. I think Kroger has HEB beat as long as you are a couponer. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

HEB has a meal deal right now where you get a turkey and a bunch of free items, stuffing mix see below.



H-E-B Fully Cooked Turkey
smoked, oven roasted or Cajun style, or H-E-B Fully Cooked Beef Brisket, whole or pre-sliced whole, flat or split, or H-E-B Fully Cooked Boneless Beef Prime Rib Roast - get 8 items free!

* H-E-B Pure Cane Sugar Soft Drinks 12 pk., 12 oz. cans, assorted varieties * H-E-B Asparagus Cuts & Tips 12 oz., frozen * H-E-B Creamy Creations® Churn Style Ice Cream 56 oz., assorted varieties * H-E-B Salad Dressing 16 oz., assorted varieties * H-E-B Broth, 32 oz., assorted varieties * H-E-B Hearts Blend, 8 oz., or Veggie Medley Salad, 12 oz. * Hill Country Fare Stuffing Mix, 6 oz. assorted varieties * Handi-Foil Giant Oval or Rectangular Rack Roaster
with in-store coupons save more than $14.45 in FREE items! 

Keystone --- 16 years ago -

At Kroger, you can use coupons and beat the HEB price on everything, except the turkey. I got mine for .25 a pound with a $20 purchase. I think Kroger has HEB beat as long as you are a couponer.

Amen to this! Kroger is always cheaper for me and I even did the HEB challenge. Didn't make a commercial out of my experience, since I didnt' save anything. 

Keystone --- 16 years ago -

And I HATE HATE HATE HEB's parking lot (Atasocita) and the noise level in the store, and the wait in the checkout line. 

AFWife --- 16 years ago -

You can get good deals at Target but you have to utilize both Target & manufacturer coupons.

I love HEB! They have the variety I'm looking for & all 3 of their own food brands (Hill Country Fare, H-E-B & Central Market) are pretty decent also. I can never find enough good food items at Kroger (even with coupons), it always seems to be toiletries & stuff. 

qpc --- 16 years ago -

Green beans are $1 a pound at Kroger. Turkey is .25 a pound. Pumpkin is .97 a can for Kroger brand, and the Libby's is a few cents more. For the items they mentioned, Kroger beats or is right there with HEB even without coupons. The last 2 weeks have had amazing deals on all sorts of Thanksgiving stuff. 

whatchamacallit --- 16 years ago -

The last 2 weeks have had amazing deals on all sorts of Thanksgiving stuff.



Yes, I've made too many trips over there lately, trying to build up my stockpile again. LOL 

~grandma again~ --- 16 years ago -

I went to Kroger and bought everything to make our dinner for 14 and spent less than $80. I was quite pleased with that because I had to get everything from salt to a 22/lb turkey and ham. I bought everything new because I will be cooking at my daughters and had no idea what she might have in her pantry. 

Lilteapot --- 16 years ago -

Well, now all the prices are here, I will read up and comparison shop before I decide which supermarket to go to!
Thanks :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground