Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

water birth

who's talking here?

Carla 1
blessed 1
outermaga 1
GCan 3
My3LilJuels 1
planemom 3
karenact 1
Justwatching72 1
steinhoister 1
lizandmike 8
gumbeauxgirl 2
txdaddy 3
love my 3 kids 1
4boys 2
Meme2my5 1
JusticeForAll 3
jtcitrus 1
mommie21g1b 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
lawl 1
Gentle Presence 2
Work in Progress 4
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
ForestMama 1
CitrusWifey 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

Has anyone had a water birth? Wanna share your experience? I'm really thinking about it. 

Gentle Presence --- 16 years ago -

I had my fourth baby at home in the water. He was over 10 lbs and was one of my easiest deliveries! I went on to have two more babies. I was in the water for some of the labor but did not birth them in the water. When the time came to push, the water did not feel right so I moved. It is never a one size fits all.
I have been a doula since 2002 and one thing I learned is to go with the flow. The only thing you can expect is the unexpected!
The water is so relaxing. Combined with counter pressure on your back, it can really take the edge off of your contractions. It also helps your tissues to stretch so there is less chance of tearing. I did not tear at all with my water birth.
I just used my bath tub but you can rent large birthing tubs for a reasonable amount. They can be big enough for your birth partner to get on too. I think that would be nice. Are you going to one of the birthing centers or doing a home birth? 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

DH has lots of concerns about birthing anywhere except the hospital. He wants to meet with the ladies at Reunion to discuss his concerns and then we'll decide. We won't be doing a home birth. It'll be Reunion or the hospital.
We were at the hospital today and they said that once flu season starts, no one under 16 is allowed in the post partum area. Not crazy about that. It's just one more reason I don't want to deliver there. But dh has to be comfortable with where dd2 is born. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Liz,

I have to agree about delivering at the hospital. I know that home births have been the norm throughout history, but so has death in childbirth. . .

Too many things could happen to you or the baby during the birthing process. If you are in a hospital, they are able to take care of the situation immediately and save you or the baby.

It's definitely not as comfortable, but it is safer. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

I had my daughter in April. Everything routine and within a minute all that changed and I was taken for an emergency C-Section.My waters ruptured, the cord prolapse and was coming out before the baby. The nurse jumped on the bed with her hand inside holding the baby's head back. If I had continued to deliver her naturally, she would have compressed the cord and cut off her oxygen/blood supply. I had the most "boring" of pregnancies according to my obstetrician and probably would have been a good candidate for delivering at a birthing center.

Good luck as you weigh all of your options. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

i would not feel comfortable having my child born where there was not emergency medical care immediately available for the baby and mama. seconds count in a bad situation.

what exactly is the reason for your desire for the water birth? if something goes terribly wrong, are you comfortable enough with that reason to live with it for the rest of you and your child's life?

good luck to you.

gcan - that must have been terrifying. but, looks like everything worked out ok. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

gcan - that must have been terrifying. but, looks like everything worked out ok.

It was surreal because literally everything changed within seconds. DH likes to joke about how the nurse had me like sock puppet making sure baby didn't descend. However, I didn't realize how much he was impacted by the situation until a few days later when he described walking into the surgery room and seeing the docs pull the princess out. He was overjoyed with her, terrified for me and running between both of us. He finally looked at the doctor and asked him "This is all routine for you right?" Doc assured him that it was "routine" and that we were all doing well. 

Carla --- 16 years ago -

My cousin had several water births and loved them.

My3Juels has as well. She is someone you could talk to.

Reunion has awesome facilities. I haven't delivered there (I probably would have if they had been open when my youngest was born,) but I've been through it.

The one thing besides the water birth that is a huge plus to me about Reunion is that they let you labor naturally. I've noticed that the hospitals are really into intervention during delivery: inducing labor, trying to speed it up, etc. In my opinion, that is just asking for complications.

I'm still ticked off that the doctor broke the water with my second because he wanted to get home early.

There are always going to be situations like GCan's, but I think there are also many situations where trying to push Mother Nature causes problems as well. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

Here ya go...

0


;-)


Good luck :) 

4boys --- 16 years ago -

yes, for 2 of my kiddos including a 10 pound 13 ouncer. We went to nativiti in the woodlands, another birthing facility. My husband was very nervous about not being in the hospital too (not as nervous as my mom!) but he ended up being so much more comfortable. He was able to talk to the midwife and felt like she listened. At the hospital, he was afraid to speak up to the nurses because everything was so much more "routine."

Birthing centers and water births are not for everyone. But I would never have another baby at a hospital. LOVED the birthing facility! The only drawback, my dad insisted on announcing to everyone how I had a baby in a bath tub. He is a principal, and he said it over the school announcements. Nice! 

Gentle Presence --- 16 years ago -

Yes, my son likes to use the fact that he was born in a bath tub as his little known fact when getting to know new people!
Janet and Polly at Reunion or the midwives at Nativiti are very capable care providers. They are prepared for the unexpected events of birth. They do not offer water births yet at the local hospital but maybe one day they will. I hope your husband can go with you to Reunion to interview them. You will know what is right. Congratulations! Isn't it great to have so many options for your birth experience? 

karenact --- 16 years ago -

within a minute all that changed and I was taken for an emergency C-Section.My waters ruptured, the cord prolapse and was coming out before the baby. The nurse jumped on the bed with her hand inside holding the baby's head back.
The same thing happened to us with my third. I do believe they are able to handle a cord prolapse and transport you at least at reunion. Cord prolapses are rather uncommon. I have to ask, did they rupture your membranes or did you water break on it's own? 

love my 3 kids --- 16 years ago -

i had a friend using a midwife in kingwood she had a heart a tack and almost died shes now almost blind and trying to take care of a baby. if she would have been under a doctors care they would have diagnosed her earlier and she would not have had to be on life support the first few weeks of her babys birth. !! im not saying this is always the case i have wathed many people have homebirths and its wonderfull im just saying that bad things happen why take a chance. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

I have to ask, did they rupture your membranes or did you water break on it's own?

When the nurse was checking for dilation and the sac ruptured. Dr. Beckner who was my OB but not the delivering doc said that prolapse is very rare; however, when I went in for my two week checkup he said that he had three more instances of it. He mentioned that if a OB sees that once a year, it's a lot so the fact that there were four women with the same "rare" occurence was very odd. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

Too many things could happen to you or the baby during the birthing process. If you are in a hospital, they are able to take care of the situation immediately and save you or the baby.

... and unfortunately, even though there's a small chance of any of those many things happenning (we're not extinct afterall), they're the only thing hospitals are actually trained to do. They're not trained to deal with a normal natural birth. SOP is to have as many interventions as possible, and they will lobby you for that throughout the birth.

My wife is the real activist on this issue, she could give you a much more compelling argument. Janet and Poly are awesome, if there's a likelyhood of you needing hospital facilities, they'll tell you (and it's accross the street if complications arise).

As a Husband with a not-quite-crunchy wife and whose mother is a nurse, the birth center is the perfect compromise b/w home/hospital. As a father I can tell you my experience assiting my wife (in the tub massaging her back for hours and coaching/encouraging) was WAY cooler than any hospital birth I've ever seen depicted in either a movie or documentary.

just my two cents 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

i may be a little confused...someone enlighten me. here is my question:

is the 'birthing center' prepared to handle (diagnos/treat)a similiar situation that occured with katy Hayes? 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I'm glad I was in a hospital for my last two births...

You would think after having 3 babies, I'd be an expert! But, I started to hemorrhage horribly after #4 and needed a blood transfusion after #5...neither pregnancy was regarded as high risk or out of the ordinary.

I personally would rather err on the side of caution than worry about the type of "experience" I was going to have...not downplaying anyone's feelings on the birthing process, but as others have said, things can literally change in the blink of an eye...it's not worth the risk, imo.

The Katy Hays situation is tragic, would it have turned out differently had she been in the hospital? I don't know... 

gumbeauxgirl --- 16 years ago -

The same thing that happened to Katy Hayes has happened to women who have had hospital deliveries. I saw one story on Oprah several years ago and after hearing about Katy Hayes I googled to find it, but found another one instead. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

The Katy Hayes situation was horrible. That strep virus is probably MORE prevalent in a hospital, so she could have still contracted it. BUT, in a hospital, you are being constantly monitored for temperature, blood pressure, etc after birth. So it stands to reason that they would have caught the infection earlier and been able to start massive antibiotics and the like.

When I gave birth at Methodist in Willowbrook a couple of years ago, they did offer to let me get in a tub. I don't know if you are allowed to BIRTH in the tub, but they had one. Perhaps look into some of the hospitals with luxury birthing centers?

I have one friend who is about to deliver in Phoenix whose hospital offers mani-pedis in your room after birth!!! 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

I have been interested in water births for a long time.

Like others above I worry about emergency situations. My guilty conscience is very bad so if something happened to our baby it would haunt me. As great as it looks and sounds I can't do it. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

BUT, in a hospital, you are being constantly monitored for temperature, blood pressure, etc after birth. So it stands to reason that they would have caught the infection earlier and been able to start massive antibiotics and the like.

this is the point i believe. sure it CAN happen ANYWHERE, but at least the hospital setting gives you the impression that treament would come much quicker.

if something happened to our baby it would haunt me

see...this is another point. given the extreme situation that could happen, is it worth it?

i dunno...to each their own...but not to me. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 16 years ago -

BUT, in a hospital, you are being constantly monitored for temperature, blood pressure, etc after birth. So it stands to reason that they would have caught the infection earlier and been able to start massive antibiotics and the like.

this is the point i believe. sure it CAN happen ANYWHERE, but at least the hospital setting gives you the impression that treament would come much quicker.


From their blog...

We opted for a home birth, payed our money for it, and took a lot of precautions to avoid infections and other complications. For these reasons, and because a lot of people want to know, I am going to run everyone through the events that took place up to Katy’s hospitilization.

Katy went into labor around 10:45pm on Tuesday night, February 9th. I called the midwife, and started logging contractions at around 11pm. The midwife arrived around 11:45, and we kept track of Katy’s contractions for the next few hours. The midwife used only a gloved hand for all exams, and used a portable device to monitor the baby’s heartbeat. As a side note, the midwife used a fresh, sealed, glove each time she examined Katy. The hospitals all use gloves in a community box, therefore allowing multiple sets of gloves to be touched each time someone puts gloves on. Katy dialated, water broke, and pushed, and PUSHED, and PUUUSSHHHHED, and at 7:43am, we had a beautiful new baby girl. The video of the events immediately after the birth are posted on youtube.com, and there you will see a tired, but healthy mother with her new baby.

The next couple of days went as expected. Katy was very sore, but it was all muscle soreness. She was slow moving, but ate normally, breastfed, slept well, and had no fevers or abnormal bleeding. Saturday afternoon, Katy’s pain changed a little. I called the nurse’s line to Kingwood Medical Center, two different times, and they said that if she didn’t have a fever, or wasn’t bleeding, then it was normal post-pardom pains. The pain was in her stomach, but she did start to complain about a pain in her right shoulder. The pain was resolved with massage, and Katy slept most of the night. Sunday morning I called the nurse’s line again. They, again, said that all of her symptoms were normal, and that nothing sounded out of the ordinary. By noon, Katy decided to go to the hospital in spite of the nurses saying it was nothing to worry about. She was checked in at 12:30pm, and was in an ER room at 1pm. Most of you know the story from there.

I have asked several doctors, in many different specialties, what we could have done different. All of the doctors that we spoke to, including those that do not advise home birth, said that they would not have known to do anything different, and that if Katy had been in the hospital, they would have sent her home after the first 24 hours. It is not standard practice to test for strep A, and, though Katy was tested-and came up negative, there is nothing to indicate exactly where she got the infection. If the point of infection was our bathtub, the toilet seat, the couch, etc, then no test would have helped anyway. Also, it is completely possible, and happens very often with strep A, that no visible wound is needed for the infection to get in your body. As Dr Purdue said in the Houston chronicle story-”You can get it by scratching your head.”
 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

Thank you all for sharing your thoughts and concerns.

Let me clear up a few things that may be unclear.
1st, the birthing center is less than 3 minutes from the hospital. When I had dd1, the on call doc was busy so my ob had to come from his office to deliver. It took him as long, if not longet, than it would take for me to get from the bc to the hospital, should an emergency arise.
2nd, midwives are highly trained. It's not something you just decide to do. The ladies we are considering are both RNs and certified nurse midwives.
3rd, ds was born at a hospital with a midwife. During labor, I was encouraged to walk around, change position, et. He was induced because I had a health issue. He was delivered without any pain medication or intervention, other than the pitocin for induction.
Dd1 was born at Kingwood. Although the birth was relatively uneventful, I was told I needed to stay in the bed throughout my time there. They repeatedly "offered" (to the point of being very pushy" to do the epidural.

I do not want to be stuck in a bed for 6 hours of labor again. It's my body and my labor and I want to be able to do things that make it more tolerable.

In addition, I do not want to be stuck at the hospital for days after delivery like I was with dd1. I don't like my babies to spend hours in the nursery waiting for the pedi to round. I don't like the idea that dd1 will not be able to visit me at Kingwood (as flu season will have started and no one under 16 will be allowed in).

I understand that occasionally, complications in birth do arise. This is why we are considering the bc, which is staffed by medically licensed personnel who are highly trained in natural childbirth and is less than 3 minutes from the hospital. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

In addition, I do not want to be stuck at the hospital for days after delivery like I was with dd1.

Just a little FYI...the reason babies are kept at the hospital for at least 24 hours is to monitor their health and well being.

I don't know how old your first child is...my oldest is almost 15. Back then, the insurance company only covered 24 hours in the hospital so, most people were kicked out after 12 hours or so unless they wanted to pay out of pocket. There were so many babies and mothers with complications due to such an early release, that insurance companies were FORCED to give more time, I believe now it's a full 48 hours AFTER the baby is born for monitoring mom and baby. 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

JFA, my oldest will be 17 next month. We were required to stay in the hospital for 72 hours (Air Force hospital in another state).

I remembr people being upset by the short recovery time women were allowed. Do you have any facts on the rate of after birth complications? I ask honestly because I definitely want to evaluate facts/statistics as part of the decision making process. (I'm not asking in a challenging, rude way.)

If labor and delivery proceed without any complications, what kinds of complications can arise? Are these complications something n observant, experienced parent wouldn't notice and know to seek medical treatment? Again... honest questions, no sarcasm :) 

4boys --- 16 years ago -

I am a huge fan of non-hospital births. I did all the research too before I did it. There are many people who are dead set against anything but a hospital birth (I think most of them are in my family!) The biggest reason most of them give is that in the hospital they are "better" prepared for an emergency. You have to make the right choice for you. For me, the hospital was awful! I loved taking my newborn home and giving him his 1st bath at my house. We went home 4-6 hours after each were born. The midwife came to our house the next day to check on us and we went to the pedi office on day 2. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

I think the birth of a child is not the time to experiment.

If you chose to have a child in a place other than a hospital and the child dies or has life long repercussions can you accept that?

Not trying to be rude, just something to consider. 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

What if you have a baby in the hospital and the child dies or has life long repercussions?
What are the statistics surrounding these types of risks? Hospitals are cess pool of germs and disease. What's to say that the baby or mother wouldn't contract something from the hospital?
I know there's a prevailing perception that hospitals are safer. What is that perception based on? Do the medical interventions pushed by hospitals and the related need for c-sections outweigh the risks of a birthing center?

It is definitely not a cut and dry decision. There are risks to childbirth. Albeit, in a normal pregnancy, these risks are low. it seems to me that one would have to weigh the risks for both, including rates of occurance, and decide which set of risks are more tolerable. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

For me my son stopped breathing shortly after birth and has to be resuscitated. They never figured out why but he had to stay in the hospital for observation. For me it's not a risk I am willing to take. I would never forgive myself if something happened that could have been prevented. Maybe that is where your husband is coming from.

Was your first child born in the hospital? If so was there a problem that has change your mind? 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 16 years ago -

I would never not have a baby in a hospital.. but i never judge someone who choses not to have their's there. for me i was young, healthy and still came so very close to loosing my son in childbirth.. it came down to me or him and by some miracle we were both saved.. i spent a week in a coma and he spent a week in the hospital with scars from his emergency c section.. i was so glad i was in the care and safety of the hospital at the time i cant even imagine what could have happened. 

blessed --- 16 years ago -

There are more deaths due to hospital births because they are more invasive. However, when you have a homebirth, make sure you choose a midwife who has a GREAT history of births. Find out the facts about her. Interview her. Research her. I had 2 births in the hospital and 5 at home. My homebirths were much easier than my hospital births. My babies recovered so well as did I.
Birth is a subject that every mom feels she knows best about. We all have our own stories and opinions. You have to have peace about what you decide. Don't let anyone scare you into either. Do your research. Most people who are against homebirths assume that midwives are stupid and don't have capabilities to handle "emergencies". For those of you who are ignorant and assume that your baby will automatically die if there are complications at home, midwifes have to take continuing education each year whereas doctors don't.
So to answer your question about water births..... I had number 5 in water. I wasn't in awe of it like I expected to be. I will say, being in the water felt much better with the contractions. They were a little more tolerable. However, for me, I choose where I am going to birth when I actually go into labor. Each labor has been a little different, so I might feel more comfortable one place rather than the other. Hope that makes sense. 

lawl --- 16 years ago -

the new water birth on northpark is a great place to eat. Love the breakfast taquitos! 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Birth is a subject that every mom feels she knows best about. We all have our own stories and opinions. You have to have peace about what you decide. Don't let anyone scare you into either.

Well said. When my dd had her baby last year, she had to have a blood transfusion as soon as the baby was delivered. I was so glad she was in the hospital in good hands. I know women who have had their babies at birthing centers and they were very happy with their decision. Good luck lizandmike and congrats on a new baby. 

ForestMama --- 16 years ago -

I haven't read any of the other responses, so I might have missed someone already bringing this up.

Have you checked with all the birthing centers in the Houston and surrounding areas? I have had friends (not in Houston) have very wonderful, successful, water births, in the safety of a birthing center (I've also had friends have them in assisted homebirths, and unassisted homebirths, all successful) and they all said they would do it again if given the chance.

So, check around. Thre's bound to be a place that does it. Most birthing centers are connected to a hospital, so there would be emergency help right there. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

Amazing how the human race survived so long without modern birthing techniques... 

planemom --- 16 years ago -


Amazing how the human race survived so long without modern birthing techniques... 


Just think of how many women and babies would have died without them. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Amazing how the human race survived so long without modern birthing techniques...

Just think of how many women and babies would have died without them.



exactly.

I'm a huge fan of modern medicine...I can't imagine living life like it's 1899...no thank you!

Vaccinations, hospital births, antibiotics, pain medications, fever reducers, autoclave cleaned instruments....I wouldn't want to live without these modern miracles. :) 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

The difference is today you can have a natural birth and still have modern interventions if needed.

Modern medicine is great, the danger is when things are overused or used when they aren't needed (i.e. antibiotics). If you ever get the chance to, have your blood tested to see how many antibiotics you are immune to. Scared the crap out of me! 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

I woul be interested to see statistics on that Planemom.
In fact, the u.s. has one of the highest rates of babies born in hospitals and also has one of the highest infant mortality rates among industrialized countries.
Midwives are very well trained medical professionals. They are probably better trained in normal vaginal deliveries than most obs.
IF a problem develops during labor and delivery, they immediately take the mother to the hospital. If a baby needs help, the hospital is less than 3 minutes away.
So many of these comments make it sound as if I want to crawl off into the woods and squat in a pond. Midwives are highly trained.
Many many of you see P.A.s at the dr's office with no thought of it but wouldn't imagine seeing a midwife. (The number of people seeing pas will dramatically increase when healthcare goes into effect).
I appreciate your opinions and see that a lot of people aren't interested in anything other than a hospital birth. But so much speculation about something without anything to back it up is how myths and misperceptions are perpetuated and strengthened.

So many people champion the European healthcare system.... most women in those countries are delivered by midwives.

It's late and I'm rambling a bit. I do appreciate every opinion presented here. I would love to see some facts surrounding these opinions. Statistics, journal reports, something to support these ideas. A lot of wat I have been reading does support the safety of birthing centers and the competencies of midwives. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I'm a big hospital fan because they saved me when I was born. My mother's water broke 9 weeks early with me (we're wondering if my own water breaking at 15 weeks could have had a genetic component). She held me 9 more days, then rushed to the hospital when she started giving birth to the cord.

Of course, she wasn't a candidate for a home birth. However, I often think that I would not have even made it past the womb if I had existed in any other century. Thank God for modern medicine. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground