Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

President Obama misunderstood yet again

who's talking here?

planemom 3
MonzaRacer 1
* 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
justforfun 7
Porter Wagoner 1
~sassy~ 3
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 5
Meme2my5 2
Squareduck 1
needrnr 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
oscarmayerweiner 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

What wasn't a tax before now is a tax

WASHINGTON — When Congress required most Americans to obtain health insurance or pay a penalty, Democrats denied that they were creating a new tax. But in court, the Obama administration and its allies now defend the requirement as an exercise of the government’s “power to lay and collect taxes.”

And that power, they say, is even more sweeping than the federal power to regulate interstate commerce.

Administration officials say the tax argument is a linchpin of their legal case in defense of the health care overhaul and its individual mandate, now being challenged in court by more than 20 states and several private organizations.

Under the legislation signed by President Obama in March, most Americans will have to maintain “minimum essential coverage” starting in 2014. Many people will be eligible for federal subsidies to help them pay premiums.

In a brief defending the law, the Justice Department says the requirement for people to carry insurance or pay the penalty is “a valid exercise” of Congress’s power to impose taxes.

Congress can use its taxing power “even for purposes that would exceed its powers under other provisions” of the Constitution, the department said. For more than a century, it added, the Supreme Court has held that Congress can tax activities that it could not reach by using its power to regulate commerce.

While Congress was working on the health care legislation, Mr. Obama refused to accept the argument that a mandate to buy insurance, enforced by financial penalties, was equivalent to a tax.

“For us to say that you’ve got to take a responsibility to get health insurance is absolutely not a tax increase,” the president said last September, in a spirited exchange with George Stephanopoulos on the ABC News program “This Week.”

When Mr. Stephanopoulos said the penalty appeared to fit the dictionary definition of a tax, Mr. Obama replied, “I absolutely reject that notion.”

Congress anticipated a constitutional challenge to the individual mandate. Accordingly, the law includes 10 detailed findings meant to show that the mandate regulates commercial activity important to the nation’s economy. Nowhere does Congress cite its taxing power as a source of authority.

Under the Constitution, Congress can exercise its taxing power to provide for the “general welfare.” It is for Congress, not courts, to decide which taxes are “conducive to the general welfare,” the Supreme Court said 73 years ago in upholding the Social Security Act.

Dan Pfeiffer, the White House communications director, described the tax power as an alternative source of authority.

“The Commerce Clause supplies sufficient authority for the shared-responsibility requirements in the new health reform law,” Mr. Pfeiffer said. “To the extent that there is any question of additional authority — and we don’t believe there is — it would be available through the General Welfare Clause.”

The law describes the levy on the uninsured as a “penalty” rather than a tax. The Justice Department brushes aside the distinction, saying “the statutory label” does not matter. The constitutionality of a tax law depends on “its practical operation,” not the precise form of words used to describe it, the department says, citing a long line of Supreme Court cases.

Moreover, the department says the penalty is a tax because it will raise substantial revenue: $4 billion a year by 2017, according to the Congressional Budget Office.

In addition, the department notes, the penalty is imposed and collected under the Internal Revenue Code, and people must report it on their tax returns “as an addition to income tax liability.”

Because the penalty is a tax, the department says, no one can challenge it in court before paying it and seeking a refund.

Jack M. Balkin, a professor at Yale Law School who supports the new law, said, “The tax argument is the strongest argument for upholding” the individual-coverage requirement.

Mr. Obama “has not been honest with the American people about the nature of this bill,” Mr. Balkin said last month at a meeting of the American Constitution Society, a progressive legal organization. “This bill is a tax. Because it’s a tax, it’s completely constitutional.”

Mr. Balkin and other law professors pressed that argument in a friend-of-the-court brief filed in one of the pending cases.

Opponents contend that the “minimum coverage provision” is unconstitutional because it exceeds Congress’s power to regulate commerce.

“This is the first time that Congress has ever ordered Americans to use their own money to purchase a particular good or service,” said Senator Orrin G. Hatch, Republican of Utah.

In their lawsuit, Florida and other states say: “Congress is attempting to regulate and penalize Americans for choosing not to engage in economic activity. If Congress can do this much, there will be virtually no sphere of private decision-making beyond the reach of federal power.”

In reply, the administration and its allies say that a person who goes without insurance is simply choosing to pay for health care out of pocket at a later date. In the aggregate, they say, these decisions have a substantial effect on the interstate market for health care and health insurance.

In its legal briefs, the Obama administration points to a famous New Deal case, Wickard v. Filburn, in which the Supreme Court upheld a penalty imposed on an Ohio farmer who had grown a small amount of wheat, in excess of his production quota, purely for his own use.

The wheat grown by Roscoe Filburn “may be trivial by itself,” the court said, but when combined with the output of other small farmers, it significantly affected interstate commerce and could therefore be regulated by the government as part of a broad scheme regulating interstate commerce. 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

I am going to make a couple of predictions, here.

Within the next hour, Chunky's post will be "kindly deleted".

The thread will go red (and my reasoning behind ot will be the libs are just too embarassed, because they voted for him).

Someone will come on here and make a comment, and that poster will be called a ^#@&$#% idiot, $^#@^&^* moron or something of the like.

Momof5 (at least) will come on here and say she won't mind paying the tax, because everyone deserves to have insurance.

This comment be me will probably also be "kindly deleted" by the children on the board that realize how foolish they really are.

Now, back on topic, it's common sense we would all end up being taxed, because the money for the (more than likely) worthless programs have to come from somewhere. Most intelligent people know you can't get blood out of a turnip. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

A tax by any other name is still a tax. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -


When Mr. Stephanopoulos said the penalty appeared to fit the dictionary definition of a tax, Mr. Obama replied, “I absolutely reject that notion.”



Mr. Obama replied "I absolutely reject that notion."

Well there we go, we need to just trust him and not see reality.

His butt must hurt from having so many peoples heads buried up it. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

The other comment that comes to mind is: It's a good thing he didn't say "Read my lips, no new taxes" when he was campaigning. Isn't that what cost the first President Bush his re-election? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Ex-Lady In Blue --- 10 min ago - quote - flag comment

I am going to make a couple of predictions, here.

Within the next hour, Chunky's post will be "kindly deleted".

The thread will go red (and my reasoning behind ot will be the libs are just too embarassed, because they voted for him).

Someone will come on here and make a comment, and that poster will be called a ^#@&$#% idiot, $^#@^&^* moron or something of the like.

Momof5 (at least) will come on here and say she won't mind paying the tax, because everyone deserves to have insurance.

This comment be me will probably also be "kindly deleted" by the children on the board that realize how foolish they really are.

Now, back on topic, it's common sense we would all end up being taxed, because the money for the (more than likely) worthless programs have to come from somewhere. Most intelligent people know you can't get blood out of a turnip.



You might be pushing it on the hour - you have to give them time to get up.


But great predictions!!! 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

planemom --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment

The other comment that comes to mind is: It's a good thing he didn't say "Read my lips, no new taxes" when he was campaigning. Isn't that what cost the first President Bush his re-election?



Yes it is. But he did say something similar with the infamous no tax increase for anyone under $250K. But he isn't being held accountable for anything he says 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

But he isn't being held accountable for anything he says

We'll see. It'll be interesting to watch what happens in November. Despite what the news says, people vote with their pocketbooks. President Obama promised much, but for most people things have stagnated or become worse. Will they vote for more of the same or will they want change yet again? 

Porter Wagoner (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

It's Bush's fault. 

MonzaRacer --- 16 years ago -

aw heck, i just flagged everything....just because i could.... j/k...LOL 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Read my teleprompter, no new taxes. lol 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Did he say "Let me be clear"? again again again 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

November is going to be a brutal month for the Dems. Time to take the wheel from the irresponsible Liberals. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Within the next hour, Chunky's post will be "kindly deleted".

The thread will go red (and my reasoning behind ot will be the libs are just too embarassed, because they voted for him).



I'd give it a little longer than that....our lefties don't wake up til the crack of noon. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Did he say "Let me be clear"? again again again


If I hear that declaration one more time! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

From the Obama dictionary:

Let me be clear = I'm now going to lie to you. 

Squareduck --- 16 years ago -

Instead of saying let me be clear....
He should say....
America I'm going to BS you..!
Is that clear enough? 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Did he say "Let me be clear"? again again again




Pop quiz: When President Obama uses the phrase “let me be clear,” it means:

a) Pencils up: This is the takeaway.

b) What I’ve said doesn’t mean what you might fear it means – or what my opponents will tell you it means.

c) I am not going to get rolled on this one.

d) All of the above, and then some.

“Let me be clear.”

In the first six months of Obama’s presidency, this simple sentence has gone from political pet phrase to full-on rhetorical signature, appearing (along with its variants “let’s be clear” and “I want to be clear”) scores of times in the commander in chief’s pre-written and extemporaneous remarks – sometimes more than once in a given speech. 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Instead of saying let me be clear....

that is the same thing as him saying he and his admin would be "transparent" and then went on to hold secret closed door meetings with the dems in congress and the Union leaders.. oh yea, he has made it "real clear".. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Does anyone still believe anything Obama says? 

* --- 16 years ago -

yes. this scum promised change. its all anyone has left in their pockets. certainly the worst ever by far in our history. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

for some reason NTLBS(not the least bit surprised) and PWND just brushes on similarities with “I want to be clear”  

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Wow, this one isn't red yet.

So will it last 10 more minutes? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Shocked the wild life thread isn't red......yet. Now we see whose doing the flagging don't we? But wait, wait! It's neither side, it's teenagers. Uh huh, sure sure. 

oscarmayerweiner --- 16 years ago -

0undefined 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

This will help it go red. lol




0 

oscarmayerweiner --- 16 years ago -

0undefined 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

0 

oscarmayerweiner --- 16 years ago -

0undefined 

oscarmayerweiner --- 16 years ago -

0undefined 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

lol, those are funny oscar.. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

0 

oscarmayerweiner --- 16 years ago -

0 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

0 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground