Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do we have a right to die by our choosing?

who's talking here?

planemom 6
justforfun 2
~sassy~ 6
Shortnsassy 1
rEVOLution 2
Perfection 3
Lillabeth 3
POTUS 6
JusticeForAll 3
oneyedman 1
Ogre1 1
voice of reason 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 5
evolved 2
JeffSpicoli 1
*OH SNAP* 1
Tipsyhic 1
Grumpy 3
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 7
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
In AbsentiaW 7
Max D00gan 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do we have a right to die by our choosing?

[url=http://wcbstv.com/local/right.to.die.2.1805186.html]Is it our choice on how to end our lives with dignity?[/url] The Final Exit Network paid for the advertisement that reads "My Life My Death My Choice" and offers a website. The national non-profit group said it provides guidance to adults who suffer from illnesses that are so painful that they want to end their lives. CBS 2 HD spoke to the group's vice-president on the phone. "People who have Lou Gehrig's disease, Parkinson's disease, emphysema and a whole other range of wasting diseases," Robert Levine said. "It's not right choice. God gives us life and only God knows when he's going to take us from this world," said resident Emiliano Martinez. "It's your life. You should be able to choose where you want to go what you want to do with your life," added resident Richard Barros. The group said it does not assist in deaths but has provided information to at least 300 people nationwide who have ended their own lives since 2004, several of them in New Jersey. "We insist that they give us complete medical records. We have interviews with them. We want to be sure, psychologically, they're sound," Levine said.

Yes Vote
 
 76.3% (29)
No Vote
 
 23.7% (9)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Is it our choice on how to end our lives with dignity?

The Final Exit Network paid for the advertisement that reads "My Life My Death My Choice" and offers a website. The national non-profit group said it provides guidance to adults who suffer from illnesses that are so painful that they want to end their lives.

CBS 2 HD spoke to the group's vice-president on the phone.

"People who have Lou Gehrig's disease, Parkinson's disease, emphysema and a whole other range of wasting diseases," Robert Levine said.

"It's not right choice. God gives us life and only God knows when he's going to take us from this world," said resident Emiliano Martinez.

"It's your life. You should be able to choose where you want to go what you want to do with your life," added resident Richard Barros.

The group said it does not assist in deaths but has provided information to at least 300 people nationwide who have ended their own lives since 2004, several of them in New Jersey.

"We insist that they give us complete medical records. We have interviews with them. We want to be sure, psychologically, they're sound," Levine said. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

I say yes they should be able to stop their suffering. The problem is that this could become a situation where other people are making that decision for a person who did not choose it.


Again, I will say we treat dogs with more humanity than we do people. It is a difficult decision to put an animal down but many many people do it to end the animals suffering. There is no such relief for humans. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

You know, I've thought about this one a lot, and I can't decide what the right thing to do on this is. It seems wrong to choose death, but I've never suffered what these people are suffering, and I cannot blame them for longing for peace.

In terms of law, not personal morality, I think it should be legal. But what are the ramifications of making it legal to kill yourself in situations of terminal illness? Would it lead to people legally killing themselves if not terminally ill? Perhaps just suffering mental problems, or difficult physical abilities?

I usually have such firm opinions on things, but this one I cannot figure out. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -


I usually have such firm opinions on things, but this one I cannot figure out.


Ditto, I really WANT to say yes, but I don't know if that is the right answer.

It saddens me to see someone suffer, but does that make it ok for them to end their life? I just don't know. 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

The state of Oregon has addressed this trying question by making in legal but with several restrictions.

Don't know what I would do. Isn't it God's decision of when you are to die?
Conversely is it against God's will to keep someone alive on extended support if that is all that is prolonging life? 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

The state of Oregon has addressed this trying question by making in legal but with several restrictions.

Don't know what I would do. Isn't it God's decision of when you are to die?
Conversely is it against God's will to keep someone alive on extended support if that is all that is prolonging life? 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Don't know what I would do. Isn't it God's decision of when you are to die?
Conversely is it against God's will to keep someone alive on extended support if that is all that is prolonging life?


All good questions--I don't know the answer. This is a good topic Chunky! Perhaps we could have a debate that would actually change minds here! I know that I could swayed with the right argument. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

So now Chunky is torn?? LMAO

Is hanging around at the insurer's expense the responsible thing to do? 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Is hanging around at the insurer's expense the responsible thing to do?

You bring up a good point evolved. It could come to a point where people are FORCED to die in order to save the money.

It's really a dilemma, isn't it? 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

Is hanging around while all your resources & assets & your children & grand children inheritance is exhausted or used up after the insurance quits paying ? 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I'm just joking Alli. But if Chunky's consistent your grandma if on life support should just go away and be responsible. The Chunky death panel!!

Her logic is no better than rationed care or no care for the risky which won't happen while this is called America. She's getting all fascist on us or Aryan. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

evolved, this isn't about me, but feel free to start a topic about me if you wish.

This is related to the news story about the billboard in NJ that got me thinking.

I am torn. I hate to see people suffer but is it our place to determine when it is time.

Simultaneously, didn't God provide us with the intelligence to make the drugs that could end the suffering and are we NOT doing His will by not taking them? 

Tipsyhic --- 16 years ago -

I have the right to death by doughnuts. LOL 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Is hanging around while all your resources & assets & your children & grand children inheritance is exhausted or used up after the insurance quits paying ?

Fantastic point. If I were bankrupting my family, it would grieve me! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Simultaneously, didn't God provide us with the intelligence to make the drugs that could end the suffering and are we NOT doing His will by not taking them?

lol Chunk, it's posts like this that make us think outside the box.

I'm wondering where the idea originated that it's wrong to take your own life to end pain, misery and suffering when you're already dying in the first place. The bible perhaps? Morals perhaps?

Is it considered morally wrong and that's why it's frowned upon? and if so, then perhaps we really ARE dictating morals. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Again, I will say we treat dogs with more humanity than we do people.

That's an absolute fact. The sad thing is that our lives are not our own. The moment our parents or we entered into the Social Security agreement we became property of the United States Government. We have far fewer rights than people believe. When it's against the law to commit suicide I'd say NO we don't have the "Right" to choose our own death and that's because we are not our own property. We just think we are.

Choosing the way we die also voids any life insurance plan we may have.

It's so sad when people are suffering a miserable existence, not really even living, just existing, and yet our "laws" say let them suffer.

Another perfect example of how few powers the President really has was the case a few years back where Bush was asked to over ride some courts decision to either keep a lady alive or let the husband pull the plug and the President was unable to do anything to help the family. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Simultaneously, didn't God provide us with the intelligence to make the drugs that could end the suffering and are we NOT doing His will by not taking them?


With that logic we would assume that God gave us the knowledge to create chemical weapons that have been used to wipe out tens of millions of humans. But I don't think since he gave us the knowledge to do so meant go ahead and use it.

Adding God to the equation makes it a whole different story. I think that in God's eyes we are to let people meet their own fate. That we not to "play God" so to speak. I don't know it's a touchy topic and I don't know if there's any right or wrong answer. It would have to be a case by case basis. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

One indeed has the power to make this decision for themselves and as with any of the many decisions we make, one will suffer the consequences of it.

As a civilization, should we provide the means for self-destruction? I believe not. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

As a civilization, should we provide the means for self-destruction? I


No, we have BO for that 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Don't we start down a slippery slope if it's decided it's okay to choose how we die? Wouldn't the next step be for outsiders to decide when and how we die? Some people with long term painful diseases may choose death but others will want to hold onto life as long as possible. It may not be convenient or cost effective to allow them to live. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Yes, we should be able to end our own lives without any legal ramifications against us or our families. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Well, the question is; "Do we have a right to die by our choosing?"

The answer is; Not in Texas.

BTW.. arguments about Gods will are inevitably futile.

As to the politics of the situation. Washington should never have any right be involved in this sort of decision.

The fiasco around the Terry Shiavo case is a perfect example of ONE THING that the Bush administration did in an attempt to lessen YOUR RIGHTS to make medical decisions for loved ones.

It was also incredibly hypocritical of Bush to support keeping Terry on life support when while he was governor signed a state law that allows hospitals to take people off life support without consulting the family.

As to what I think about one's right to die. If I have chosen to do so, how are you going to stop me? Laws against suicide are patently insane. As to "assisted suicide"... to be honest I've never understood why we can be kind to our pets but not our parents. But my views on death are not mainstream. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

For those voting yes, do you mean anybody at anytime has a right to choose when and how they die or only people with certain illnesses? Do you feel it's okay for a depressed teen to end it if they choose? 

In AbsentiaW --- 16 years ago -

Euthanasia is legal in the Netherlands and probably in other countries too.

If it's illegal in Texas [aren't most things illegal in Texas anyhow?] one sure fire way to commit suicide is to drive on any freeway during rush hour and particularly next to or in front of an eighteen wheeler. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 16 years ago -

I am torn on this one..
I have watched someone i love in pain and suffering who didnt take their own life but did do a dnr so he wouldnt suffer anymore.. i myself have never lived through any illness that would make me want to end my life.. but i did get a taste of what it was like to be in constant pain for a small amount of time and it got me thinking " how do people that have to live like that everyday do it"..
i do believe we have the right to control what happens to ourselves but should there be a line drawn or not.. interesting question and not sure if there is a good black/white answer for this. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

My answer to this is that I don't think people in pain are choosing death, they only are wanting relief from the pain. Unfortunately death is the only answer for most. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

For those voting yes, do you mean anybody at anytime has a right to choose when and how they die or only people with certain illnesses? Do you feel it's okay for a depressed teen to end it if they choose? 


Doesn't the article cite for folks suffering from incurable/incapacitating illnesses?

That's what I was basing my answer on. I didn't see any mention of depressed teens in the article. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

I absolutely believe it should be legal. The "slippery slope" arguments are neither here nor there. We are talking about whether or not someone who is terminally ill should be able to end their life with dignity, the same dignity we give our dying pets. For anyone who says no on the basis of religious reasons and it supposedly being God's will when we die, wouldn't it also be God's will to give us the terminal illness in the first place? Or, at least, to let us die from it? I think the whole assisted suicide ban thing is people's irrational fear that people who commit suicide go to hell, which is fine for them, but I do think it should be a legal option. 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

Ever seen the movie - Soylent Green ? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Doesn't the article cite for folks suffering from incurable/incapacitating illnesses?

That's what I was basing my answer on. I didn't see any mention of depressed teens in the article.


The article only mentions incurable/incapacitating illnesses. The other thread regarding suicided prompted me to ask the question. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

The article only mentions incurable/incapacitating illnesses. The other thread regarding suicided prompted me to ask the question. 

I didn't see the other thread, so, I had no way of knowing you meant another thread...sorry!

Depression is an entirely different thing from terminal cancer and should be treated as such. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Ever seen the movie - Soylent Green ?

Yeah. That is a disgusting movie. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Depression is an entirely different thing from terminal cancer and should be treated as such.

I agree, but was curious what other's thought. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

first of all, have a living will!!!!!!It states that they can't resusitate-have a copy at all the local hospitals, as well as your spouse, etc,.- they may not get to the hospital in time, with the living will-- 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

If you are *for* this right, but *against* abortion.... you just might be an idiot. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

I have the right to death by doughnuts. LOL


i am sure you are doing a good job. was the poll question rhetorical? it seems so. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

If you are *for* this right, but *against* abortion.... you just might be an idiot.

Not even the same thing. The baby doesn't choose to die. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

POTUS --- 3 min ago - quote - flag comment
If you are *for* this right, but *against* abortion.... you just might be an idiot.


Umm, not really. The difference is.... an adult has a choice to end their life, a baby doesn't. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

was the poll question rhetorical?

At this point, it appears so. However, it may be something that is discussed with more frequency and more seriously as time goes by. 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

Umm, not really. The difference is.... an adult has a choice to end their life, a baby doesn't.

An unborn fetus is NOT a baby. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground