Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: If the state allows medical marijuana, can the employer fire for a failed drug test?

who's talking here?

smartypants 5
planemom 5
Justwatching72 1
Sandyr9111 2
steinhoister 2
thekat 2
AuthorMan 2
Zionist NightOwl 2
Joybell 1
Tylers Journey 1
AFWife 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Fin and Feather 3
Setta 1
rEVOLution 3
Perfection 9
Betty 1
POTUS 1
JusticeForAll 1
TakeTheGlovesOff 1
Ogre1 8
AwesomeTattooedDragon 6
MxMike. 8
moribundmaverick 2
Dr Aborto 2
kwjboy 1
johnregalman517 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: If the state allows medical marijuana, can the employer fire for a failed drug test?

Does the employer still have the right to project its business and other employers even if it is prescribed by a doctor?

Yes Vote
 
 55.0% (22)
No Vote
 
 45.0% (18)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Does the employer still have the right to project its business and other employers even if it is prescribed by a doctor? 

thekat --- 16 years ago -

from what I understand yes.

it is still an employers decision because it is their co. just like a dress code is their decision. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

ACLU is suing Walmart in Michigan for firing an employee for a failed drug test. Employee has a prescription for medical marijuana.

Employer's stance is that they are still obligated to protect their image and their employees and their customers and that marijuana is no different than being impaired by other prescribed medications (which can also get you fired). 

thekat --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Wal-Mart. Its sad for the employee but Wal-Mart has that right. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

So should you lose your job for legally consuming alcohol? What about if you take adderal and you fail for amphetamines? What if you are prescribed xanax or opiate pain killers by a doctor for pain or anxiety? Should you lose your job? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

So should you lose your job for drinking alcohol, even if it's legal?

If you're drunk on the job, then yes. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

MxMike, yes. When you are employed, you represent the person/business paying you. If you are unable to perform the job safely it is not you who is held accountable but the employer.

Let's just toss this out there (and I by NO means want to suggest this is the truth, but it is for discussion only).... what if the BP operator at the time of the explosion was under the influence of drugs or alcohol, so that the explosion was not BP's fault, but rather the actions of the employee. Would you still blame BP for employing them? Of course you would. Yet it was the employee who was under the influence and unable to think/react clearly. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Who's to say "this guy" was stoned on the job? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

MxMike. --- 3 min ago - quote - flag comment

So should you lose your job for legally consuming alcohol? What about if you take adderal and you fail for amphetamines? What if you are prescribed xanax or opiate pain killers by a doctor for pain or anxiety? Should you lose your job?
-------------------

MxMike, most jobs have drug policies and yes, prescription drugs on on that list. So yes, you could be fired. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

MxMike. --- 28 sec ago - quote - flag comment

Who's to say "this guy" was stoned on the job?



He failed a drug test while on the job. His defense is that he didn't do it while on the job but rather before. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Is it acceptable to use prescribed drugs like adderal while on the job? Or anxiety drugs like xanax?

Amphetamines and barbiturates... 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

He failed a drug test while on the job. His defense is that he didn't do it while on the job but rather before.


Well that means absolutely nothing...marijuana is detectable for a month or more after one use. If you used marijuana on July 1 and took a drug test on Aug 1st you would most likely fail it. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

MxMike. --- 59 sec ago - quote - flag comment

Is it acceptable to use prescribed drugs like adderal while on the job? Or anxiety drugs like xanax?

Amphetamines and barbiturates...



When you accept a job, you know the drug policy up front. You agree to be employed under those conditions. If however you are grandfathered in then that is another story. 

TakeTheGlovesOff --- 16 years ago -

The companies are protecting themselves against liabilities from an employee's possible unsafe and irrational actions. Drug testing is due diligence on part of the employer in identifying risk. 

Tylers Journey --- 16 years ago -

I would think if it is medical no they can't fire you. They can't fire you if you take medication given by a doctor. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Alcohol is far more inebriating, far more dangerous and causes one to become far more out of control than marijuana ever could. Liabilities? Risk? HILARIOUS.

So this guy (since I haven't seen a story I'm assuming this is hypothetical) fails a drug test for THC, which means he could have used at any point in time within the past month, and loses his job even though it was legally prescribed to him?

I fail to see the problem.

Unless he was obviously IMPAIRED while on the job I can't see why anyone would mess with him. If it interfered with the performance of his work, then of course...fire him...but that's no different than if someone was drunk on the job.

A quarter of all parents send their children to school doped up on amphetamines for god's sake! 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Tyler's Journey --- 4 min ago - quote - flag comment

I would think if it is medical no they can't fire you. They can't fire you if you take medication given by a doctor.


That depends on the job.

Where I work, we are required to report all prescription medications we take and if we are tested and something else is in our system (even if it is prescribed) we can be fired. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

That depends on the job.

Where I work, we are required to report all prescription medications we take and if we are tested and something else is in our system (even if it is prescribed) we can be fired.

Yep. And we accepted that policy when we hired on. If we don't accept our employers' policies, our option is to quit (or not accept the job in the first place). 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

Marijuana stays in your system for up to a month-if you have a prescription, unless you're stoned on the job, it ridiculous to fire you for having it in your system-that man has grounds for a lawsuit, IMO- 

AFWife --- 16 years ago -

Depends on what type of job you are performing...THAT to me would be a huge factor. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Depends on what type of job you are performing...THAT to me would be a huge factor.
Yeah i doubt Walmarts all that dangerous unless u drive a forklift or something. Hell most of those folks arent right to begin with! 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

There are many jobs where the employee can't work and take certain prescription medications. Why should pot be any different? 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I have not read any of the responses yet but I'm going to say that no matter what the state law is, if an employer wants to fire someone for something that they have put in writing is a no no, then they can fire you for that reason or any other reason they see fit.

Let's say an employer has a zero tolerance for hung over employees coming to work after a night out on the town I'm pretty sure if that's their policy, they can fire someone for not following their rules. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

These conversations always seem to bring out the pot smokers! ROFL

KIDDING.....sorta! 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

So should you lose your job for legally consuming alcohol? What about if you take adderal and you fail for amphetamines? What if you are prescribed xanax or opiate pain killers by a doctor for pain or anxiety? Should you lose your job?


If I'm an employer and I have written rules that someone agreed to when they got hired then yes, as an employer I have every write to fire someone for disobeying those rules.

What it really boils down to IMO is that if your personal life prevents you from performing your job duties while at work, then I have every right to fire them. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

I fired an employee once for testing .38 blood alcohol level.
He was a D8 dozer operator. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

So should you lose your job for legally consuming alcohol? What about if you take adderal and you fail for amphetamines? What if you are prescribed xanax or opiate pain killers by a doctor for pain or anxiety? Should you lose your job?


If I'm an employer and I have written rules that someone agreed to when they got hired then yes, as an employer I have every write to fire someone for disobeying those rules.

What it really boils down to IMO is that if your personal life prevents you from performing your job duties while at work, then I have every right to fire them. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

omw, authorman! 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

I voted no. If the state is okay with the medical use of marijuana and the employer is operating a business in that state, and the employee is working in that state, I don't see the problem.

If the employee was operating heavy equipment, I think a case could be made for finding him or her a different position without firing. This is Walmart for pete's sake, not a hospital ER or Air Traffic Control.

Drug screenings are allowed in order to screen out people who are abusing drugs, not people who are ill. Sorry, but I don't support kicking someone when they're down. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Should you lose your job?

Depends on the job.
Do you want to be in an airplane with an impaired pilot?
Plus, employers are ultimately responsible for the actions of employees. I would hate to have a wasted employee cost me my business.
How many of you advocates have ever owned a business? 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Air Traffic would be a tough one. I don't know how that could be resolved, because it is intense work. While I was writing my post, I was thinking about that but don't have a good answer.

Walmart though? I don't think their business is in jeopardy. But I don't know all the details of the case either.

It probably should be considered on an individual basis, not as across the board policy. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

How fast would somebody sue Wal-Mart if something happened to them that was the fault of the pot using employee? He forgets the wet floor sign or stacks something the wrong way causing it to fall and hurt someone. From that standpoint the business cannot take a chance. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Employer's stance is that they are still obligated to protect their image

What does the employee's illness and treatment have to do with their "image"? Isn't an employees health supposed to be private?

Walmart has a terrible rap already with their image. They are notorious for discrimination. 

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

If you hold a CDL federal regulations require you to be tested for drugs P test.. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

I read somewhere that if you juice the raw plant, you don't get high but still get the medicinal benefit. Don't know if that's true or not.

source 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

The story I found says he hurt himself on the job and a follow up drug test showed the pot in his system. It also says he says he didn't smoke before work or show up to work high. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

actually... marijuana only is in your system for 30 days or more if you smoke 4 or 5 joints(approx 2.0 grams) a day constantly..... if you are a very occasional smoker, you will not test positive for marijuana after 3 or 4 days. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Wow. 50-50. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

O.K., I'm NOT reading all this, but here is my thoughts.

1. if you have a medical NEED for the drug, and it is prescribed by a licensed physician, then the employer cannot legally fire you for using it.

Why do I say this? Well, there are plenty of drugs that employers today test for. Marijuana and the other illegal drugs being just one of them. Prescription drugs are tested for as well and in some job, alcohol and even tobacco.

Drug screens are used to weed out those breaking the law, but they are also used in many industries to weed out those who are impaired at that time.

BUT IN TEXAS, if a drug has been prescribed by a doctor, then that employer, with very specific exceptions, can take no action against the employee.

Those exceptions include any position which could put the employee, other employees, or the public in danger.

I.E. Police, Firefighter, Bus Driver, CDL holders, Airplane Pilot, Maritime workers, etc.

WALMART employees (unless they fall into one of the excepted categories) do not generally fall into that category (I see no mention of what this person did for Walmart). How dangerous is a stoned check-out person? or a stoned stocker? or the stoned greeter (and would we notice a difference?)

Any position in which a physical or mental impairment could endanger themselves or others would be required to either take a leave of absence, or take sick leave. But they would not be allowed to do their normal job.

But this is already the case with those jobs and it doesn't matter whether MJ is legal or not.

So I say that if the Walmart employee was not in an excepted category, then he may have a case under the ADA. And even if he is in an excepted category, he may still have a case under the ADA. Depends on those nit-picky details. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

One other note, in Texas, they don't need a reason to fire you. They can just fire you without giving you a reason and you likely will have no recourse.

I spent a week researching this in my Legal Writing and Research Class at South Texas, and I did not find a single case where a plaintiff (fired person) won.

Right to Work=Right to Fire 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground