Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ok, I think I have lost my mind - teachers told to lie on grades to make students feel better

who's talking here?

planemom 5
*Annie* 2
~sassy~ 5
Perfection 1
JusticeForAll 3
Ogre1 4
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
-Ray 1
Texasteach 3
A Simple Equation 2
Work in Progress 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Thank goodness this was overturned - but just how much of our tax dollars went to fight this?

AUSTIN — A Travis County judge ruled today that Texas public schools are required to give students truthful grades on class assignments and on their report cards under a 2009 state law that 11 school districts were challenging in court.

The school districts — most of them in Harris County - argued that the law applied only to grades on assignments, noting that the statute didn't specifically mention report cards, semester grades, or six- or nine-week averages.

But state District Judge Gisela Triana-Doyal ruled that the statute is "not ambiguous" and clearly means districts cannot require teachers to give students grades they did not earn. The bill's author, Sen. Jane Nelson, R-Flower Mound, has said she intended it to apply to all grades.

Richard Morris, the attorney for the school districts, said he would ask his clients whether they wanted to appeal the decision or to try to lobby for a change in the next Legislative session.

The school districts suing state Education Commissioner Robert Scott were Klein, Fort Bend, Aldine, Alief, Anahuac, Clear Creek, Humble, Deer Park, Eanes, Dickinson and Livingston.

The districts argued that their policies prohibiting teachers from awarding grades lower than a certain number - typically a 50 - helped keep students from getting discouraged and dropping out of school.

Without the policy, Clear Creek ISD Superintendent Greg Smith, said, "I think you close the light at the end of the tunnel for some students."

But the Texas chapter of the American Federation of Teachers, which intervened in the case on the side of the state, countered that the minimum failing grading polices were dishonest and didn't prepare students for college or the workforce.

"I feel like it's unethical," testified Mary Roberts, a teacher in Humble ISD.

Judge Triana-Doyle said she wasn't opining on the merits of the law, noting that both sides had good points. "People have different opinions about what's in the best interest of kids." 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

How sad is it that there needs to be a law requiring teachers to give honest grades? 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

The school districts suing state Education Commissioner Robert Scott were Klein, Fort Bend, Aldine, Alief, Anahuac, Clear Creek, Humble, Deer Park, Eanes, Dickinson and Livingston.


we made the list.


Judge Triana-Doyle said she wasn't opining on the merits of the law, noting that both sides had good points. "People have different opinions about what's in the best interest of kids."


It is weird how things are done today compared to when I was in school. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Did you get your paper written? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

It is weird how things are done today compared to when I was in school.

Isn't it though? A teacher I spoke with this spring had an earful to say about the "no failure" policy. From what she said was, kids are not allowed to fail tests. They have to keep retaking the test until they pass. In theory this sounds good. However, the kids learned to work the system. Kids would purposely fail the test the first time so they could see the questions. They would go home and study just what was on the test and retake it. She said it wasn't uncommon for some kids in her classes to take the same test 3-4 times. 

*Annie* --- 16 years ago -

"Kids would purposely fail the test the first time so they could see the questions."




Some would even purposely be caught cheating so they could get a SECOND CHANCE on the test! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I swear, what's the world coming to?

Participation trophies

unearned passing grades

as if we don't already have enough of an entitlement mentality.

Boy that's teachin' 'em young. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Students should be made to retake the tests until they pass, however, they should keep the original grade. It would ensure that kids are learning and it wouldn't award them for failure. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I was not allowed to give a child below a 50% on EACH assignment! So, if they turned in a sheet of paper with their name on it, it was an automatic 50%.

Plus, our principal made it very clear that if we failed a student, that WE would be called in to account for it. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I was not allowed to give a child below a 50% on EACH assignment! So, if they turned in a sheet of paper with their name on it, it was an automatic 50%.



Easier to just look the other way. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I swear, what's the world coming to?

Participation trophies

unearned passing grades

as if we don't already have enough of an entitlement mentality.

Boy that's teachin' 'em young. 



While I don't want this to turn into some sort of welfare bashing fest, I do agree that in the name of "self esteem", we've done more harm than good. It seems a lot of kids have an inflated sense of self and accomplishment with nothing to back it up.

Not to sound like a jerk, but I think this is the reason we have so many obese kids now too. We don't want to hurt their feelings and say, "hey, you're too young to be this heavy, we need to change this!" Instead, we'll act like you're in the "normal range", make bigger fitting clothing, and you'll just have life long issues and health problems. :|

I realize this had to do with cutting PE out of schools as well...


Making things "ok" when they're not, doesn't do anyone any favors... 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

I was not allowed to give a child below a 50% on EACH assignment! So, if they turned in a sheet of paper with their name on it, it was an automatic 50%.

Plus, our principal made it very clear that if we failed a student, that WE would be called in to account for it. 



wow. :( 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Just something to ponder.........How educating illegals impact schools



In many schools today, the numbers are overwhelming with students who do not speak the language or are several years behind peers.


Almost half of the nation's children under the age of five are now minorities and the numbers are growing because minorities are having more children than the average American.

These minority students will soon be entering our public schools.

Hispanics are responsible for the largest growth in population in schools. The Midwest is still predominantly white, but California, Texas and Florida have large concentrations of minorities. Some Midwestern states have pockets of highly concentrated Hispanics with whites becoming the "minority."

Read more at Suite101: Impact of Illegals on Schools: How are students from illegal populations affecting our public schools?


http://educationalissues.suite101.com/article.cfm/impact_of_illegals_on_schools#ixzz0sBDL7AQm 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

It's all been done BY DESIGN by the social engineers of the past century as chronicled and documented by Charlotte Thompson Iserbyt, former Senior Policy Advisor for the Office of Educational Research and Improvement for the Department of Education under Reagan.

She left in horror after what she found to be the truth about our educational system to research and write this book. Here is more from the Preface:

"Charlotte Iserbyt is to be greatly commended for having put together the most formidable and practical compilation of documentation describing the “deliberate dumbing down” of American children by their education system. Anyone interested in the truth will be shocked by the way American social engineers have systematically gone about destroying the intellect of millions of American children for the purpose of leading the American people into a socialist world government controlled by behavioral and social scientists.

Mrs. Iserbyt has also documented the gradual transformation of our once academically successful education system into one devoted to training children to become compliant human resources to be used by government and industry for their own purposes. This is how fascist-socialist societies train their children to become servants of their government masters. The successful implementation of this new philosophy of education will spell the end of the American dream of individual freedom and opportunity. The government will plan your life for you, and unless you comply with government restrictions and regulations your ability to pursue a career of your own choice will be severely limited.

What is so mind boggling is that all of this is being financed by the American people themselves through their own taxes. In other words, the American people are underwriting the destruction of their own freedom and way of life by lavishly financing through federal grants the very social scientists who are undermining our national sovereignty and preparing our children to become the dumbed-down vassals of the new world order. It reminds one of how the Nazis charged their victims train fare to their own doom."


Perhaps this is why SO MANY OF YOU still implicitly trust our government? You've been indoctrinated by this same system. Think about it... And I highly suggest you all read this book; ESPECIALLY if you have children in a public school system.

The Dumbing Down of America by Charlotte Iserbyt  

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

If I have to give cheaters a second chance instead of failing them outright I'm simply not going to make it as a teacher. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Scary thought ASE 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Ogre, If you are entering the teaching profession to actually make a difference in our world and in the lives of your students, I would recommend you take the time this summer to read the book I just posted above. You can download the PDF at scribd.com 

Texasteach --- 16 years ago -

If I have to give cheaters a second chance instead of failing them outright I'm simply not going to make it as a teacher.

Hey, I don't give second chances! I was happy when 50 for a grade rule was gone. I gave three kids this past year 30's and 40's on report cards each 6 weeks b/c they did almost nothing. They got when they earned. Now, I have had some students that worked their little butts off and tried VERY hard sitting at 68 and 69. Then I would bump to passing. You'll find your rhythm. Once students see you don't have "make-up" tests and let them use their review sheets all the time. Most of them will see that they have to step it up. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

If I have to give cheaters a second chance instead of failing them outright I'm simply not going to make it as a teacher.

It depends on your principal. Most of the time, I was told to allow the child to retake the test, or rewrite the paper.

But, I only taught in low-income schools. My students typically read on a second grade or lower level, and I was teaching Shakespeare. . .I did my best, but the students rarely came to school, and they were distracted by LIFE. Many of them had babies that kept them up at night, home abuse situations, drug addictions, you name it. Parents were non-interested, and often the only advocate I could reach for a kid was a PO.

I had compassion for their circumstances, but constant frustration at the system. I didn't know how to help them! 

*Annie* --- 16 years ago -

" If I have to give cheaters a second chance instead of failing them outright I'm simply not going to make it as a teacher. "



I've not yet been put in that position but I do know others who have. It definitely goes against everything I believe. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

But, I only taught in low-income schools. My students typically read on a second grade or lower level, and I was teaching Shakespeare


My dd had a class this past semester at LSU that required she work as a student mentor/tutor in a low income school district.

She had never been exposed to such poverty.

It had a major impact on her, coming from Kingwood and attending an affluent high school, she had never seen such poor children - and uninvolved parents. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I have no problem giving second chances to students who simply don't understand and are trying, or students who have things happen to them or have bad situations. (hey, Life happens, crap, I had FOUR deaths in the course of six weeks this year).

I can work with that.

But cheaters, plagiarism. NO. NO SECOND CHANCES ever. Fire me. I WILL NOT have students trying to play me. I simply will not be tolerated. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Ogre, they were so bad at cheating that they left in the hyperlinks and footnotes where they cut and pasted their papers from the internet!

And Sassy, yes, I also was from a very successful school district. Teaching inner city was SHOCKING to me. I have a whole new perspective on poverty. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

they were so bad at cheating that they left in the hyperlinks and footnotes

It doesn't change in college. I got in the elevator about the middle of the semester with a professor who had a stack of papers in his hands and was turning one over and over again, flipping back and forth, muttering things like, "unbelievable" under his breath.

Me being nosy and all, I was like, "uh oh, professor t'aint happy with the work..."

The professor looked at me and said, "First three papers are identical to one another except for the cover page."

I about spit!

OOOPS! 

Texasteach --- 16 years ago -

I also give zeros for cheating and plagiarism.

I think every situation can be different though. I work for a school that is classified as Title I and after hurricane IKE I was getting journals about how some kids couldn't wait for school b/c there was no food at home since mom and dad weren't working, no money was there. They received free lunch and breakfast and NEEDED that. One of those same students only did half of a project for a test grade. I talked to her about what was going on and she was in tears (she was also an honors student). I graded just what she had turned in b/c I knew she didn't have food, much less the resources to finish her project. So I guess as a general rule I grade what is earned, I don't retest and give a lot of leniency, but there are things and situations you have to weigh judgment. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

there are things and situations you have to weigh judgment.

No doubt. Fortunately, IKE was an exceptional circumstance.

To be honest, I've always said that if we could stabilize the home system, we could stabilize the education system.

One can't work without the other. 

-Ray --- 16 years ago -

To be honest, I've always said that if we could stabilize the home system, we could stabilize the education system.

One can't work without the other.

Getting Parents involved and active contributes greatly to a childs progress. Sometimes the kids dont like it....we stayed very active in our kids schools, and our diligence has been rewarded tenfold.

I have met a few parents whom simply view the school as a day care for older kids....and wonder why they have problems with their kids.... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

Gee, why couldn't they have had unearned passing grades in my math classes? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Ray,

What you said is so true. Unfortunately, there isn't any way to make parents give a hoot about their child's education. 

Texasteach --- 16 years ago -

So true about parents. Some I would be calling and e-mail constantly about grades and participation and some parents' responses would be "well, there is nothing I can do." Wow. Really? Nothing? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground