Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

do you think this punishment is fair?

who's talking here?

cmi 1
Fallon 4
randyjet 1
Sandyr9111 1
steinhoister 1
Deltadawn 1
Zionist NightOwl 1
Going off air 1
Mygirl01 7
Mr Mark 1
Mom's Taxi Service 4
curlygirl 1
ghostpost 1
Perfection 2
Scottie's Hottie 11
justcat 1
Paige Paige 1
voice of reason 1
*OH SNAP* 1
JTC 1
A Simple Equation 1
Hope 1
needrnr 1
Work in Progress 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hope --- 16 years ago -

A friend of mine is a teacher also. Last Thursday, she took her students to lunch and accidently left a student in the room asleep (they had been reading a book). The room door was left unlocked and opened. The student is in third grade. She was alerted to the situation by the principal and told she would be written up for endangering the safety of the child. She apologized profusely for not checking the room better. She took Friday off because her son was sick. She was planning on returning to work on Monday. The principal called her at home today and told her she is being suspended for the rest of the school year (13 days) and she has to totally be checked out of the school by lunchtime on Monday. She received less than 24 hours notice, she had 4 hours at school to pack up everything, finalize grade, turn in textbooks, turn in library materials, and a bunch of other stuff. She thought her punishment was a little unfair, she admits she was wrong to not check the room before leaving for lunch. What do you think, sorry so long. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Yes, that is unnecessarily harsh. No one was harmed, it was obviously an innocent mistake and she apologized. It sounds like the school principal has a personal vendetta to me... Just my opinion from dealing with the politics of the corporate world. =) I hope they don't decide to take her job away... She may want to take it up with the school board. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Sounds a little harsh to me, too, although we don't have the other side's version of the story. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Sounds very harsh unless there is a missing pc to the story. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

The principal is under a lot of pressure now because of other teachers who have been in the news for not doing their jobs correctly. He has to protect the school and while it may seem harsh he has to think of more than just this situation. If the parents of the boy go on a talk show and say their child was harmed by this, it brings unwarranted publicity on the school - now he can say he has acted swiftly and took action. It's the new way of the world. Enjoy it. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

It all depends on what the child's story was. Did she wake up scared, and really not know what to do? 3rd grade is older, but not all 3rd graders are mature enough to handle that situation. Had my child been left, I would imagine I would have been one ticked off parent. I would have wanted to know how the teacher was being punished too. And is this the first time she has ever had a problem in the classroom? There are many variables that come into play with this. However, if it was her one and only mess up, so to speak, she should take this up with the school board. 

curlygirl --- 16 years ago -

HowNow did the principal find out? Why didn't the children say something? Usually when there is sleeping child in the class, they think it is funny. Everyone is eager to be the first to wake the sleeping child. How long has your friend been teaching? There are a lot of questions. Sounds like the principal talked to someone above her given the strange timeline. Also, to turn everything in, the people who collect such things have to be present and the class will need the equipment while she is gone. I'm guessing a long term sub has been hired. Sounds like a set up for failure. Wonder what the parents have to say. Dumb decision if you ask me. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

It's the new way of the world. Enjoy it. Gotta love the chunkster!!!! more of what she said 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Ditto planemon, chunky, and steve. If I was in sling with a principal where the words child endangerment was thrown out I would be finding some help with my kiddo when they were sick. Regardless I feel sorry for your friend for the stress she is going through, would not wish that on anyone. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

If the child were actually sleeping in class was she sick? If so, heck no you do not leave a sick child asleep in class. When you get down to it, it is a big deal, and a huge liability for the school. I hope that the parents do not take this further. Sad, but that is the world we live in. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

One of our flight crews left a sleeping pax on board after their last flight. This was on a 50 pax plane and it is hard to see all the way down from the front. This is not an exact situation, but the crew was FIRED. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

I feel for your friend - I mean, we all make mistakes...but as a parent, I would be furious! We send our kids to school knowing they will be in a safe environment under the care of people we trust. One of my teacher friends (also a third grade teacher) does a count EVERY SINGLE TIME she lines the kids up for any reason, lunch, recess, P.E., Music, etc. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

exactly randyjet. This is a big deal. Mistakes happen all the time, but you don't leave a child behind. You just cannot do this. Now if the child was counted in the line, and then darted back into the room to hide, well that would be another matter. You have a child asleep in a classroom, problem 1. You leave this child behind, HUGE problem 2. Who found the child, btw? At what point did the teacher even realize all her students weren't with her? 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Yep. I would have been the irrational totally beyond comprehension ticked off parent who showed up at school wanting answers, if this had been my child. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

I was at my son's school last week and have to say that the kids were so wild and not following directions easily at all! I asked his teacher (she has been teaching for 25 years and is damn good if I do say so myself) if this happens every year at the end of the year and she said every year the kids can almost sense the end to school is near! I am just wondering if the kids had perhaps been a little harder to control than the norm and possibly the teacher was a little frazzled to begin with. On another note; this is a school. It happened in a classroom. Not sure how much of a safety issue that is. Even us as parents don't sit in a room and watch every move (for me my youngest is 3 and I don't) they make. The child wasn't left on a school bus or at a playground, etc. I just don't see how the child was "unsafe." I am not in Kingwood schools but where we live you can't get any further than the front desk without showing proper id and being scanned into the system. So not like the child was in danger of being kidnapped and again in the 3rd grade you are in the 8-9 year old range. Being left alone (a sleep part of the time) is not dangerous. While I agree the teacher needs to be disciplined this is quite harsh. I as a parent wouldn't be upset at my child's teacher if this indeed was the one and only incident. If she has been a stellar teacher besides this I would just agree that mistakes do sometimes happen. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

It says the principal alerted her to the situation, so it sounds like the teacher didn't realize the mistake on her own. I think where the safety issue comes into play is that theoretically the child could have woken up and wandered off and no one would know where he/she was. Also, it seems odd she would call in the very next day. Probably seemed odd to the principal as well. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

My question would be why was the child sleeping in class to begin with? Was the child ill? Did the child not go to bed at a proper hour? Possibly not have breakfast? That in itself is odd to me. I could understand middle school or high school where you are being lectured for an entire period but 3rd grade is usually much more hands on. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

this is a school. It happened in a classroom. Not sure how much of a safety issue that is So not like the child was in danger of being kidnapped and again in the 3rd grade you are in the 8-9 year old range. Being left alone (a sleep part of the time) is not dangerous. WRONG There are doors in this school right? This child could have went outside (thinking the class was at recess maybe) and never been seen again! So just because this was in a school doesn't mean it isn't a big deal. Even us as parents don't sit in a room and watch every move (for me my youngest is 3 and I don't) they make My home has the door chimes on all of my downstairs doors and windows, so while I may not be in the room with my dd at all times, I know if a something has been opened and if I hear that sound then I would check it out. My dd is 8 and in the 2nd grade and I would be one extremly mad Mama if it had been my dd! 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

Oh Snap: At my child's school teachers rotate lunch room duty. One day the teacher walks the class down there and then goes to the teacher lunch room to eat lunch herself while another teacher watches her class and the other teacher's class. After lunch they switch. One teacher takes both classes to recess and the other teacher eats lunch. They switch every other day. So possibly she wasn't in the lunchroom after she brought the kids down there. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

You are right about third grade being more "hands on", which makes it even more questionable that 1) the sleeping child was not noticed and 2) never realized the child was not with the class. It does get crazy at the end of the year - really crazy! We have a lot of friends that are teachers and let me tell you those last few weeks, I think they are counting down to summer even more than the kids. I guess the "safety" issue would depend on the particular child and would they get into anything they shouldn't when left unattended or like someone else said, would they wake up scared? I think the school district may be trying to protect themselves from anything parents may bring forward by making such a quick and harsh punishment. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

where we live you can't get any further than the front desk without showing proper id and being scanned into the system But you can leave out of any door in that school without anyone being alerted. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

There are doors in this school right? This child could have went outside (thinking the class was at recess maybe) and never been seen again! So just because this was in a school doesn't mean it isn't a big deal. I guess all schools are different. You can't get out or in the interior doors from my child's school that lead to the front of the school. The only doors you can exit are the ones that lead to the playground and the playground is surrounded by a fence that is at least 8 feet tall. My home has the door chimes on all of my downstairs doors and windows, so while I may not be in the room with my dd at all times, I know if a something has been opened and if I hear that sound then I would check it out. I think for most parents this is not the norm. I have no door chimes on my doors but then again my kids would never go outside without asking. That would be a great idea if you had little ones who liked to "escape" but I have been fortunate with my 3 in that regards. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

My DD did attend Timberwood MS in Atascocita and the doors at that school were also locked from the inside during the day. I am sure more of a deterent from kids just walking out and skipping class at that age but also to avoid people opening the doors to let someone in that didn't check in at the front office. I am sure some would feel different than I do but this is my particular POV on the matter. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

You can't get out or in the interior doors that from my child's school that lead to the front of the school That is against fire code and illegal. So what happen in case of a fire, you stand by the door and wait for someone to bust it down? 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

I also have a lot of questions before I could answer as to if it was fair or not. There are a lot of factors here, but I can say without a doubt if it had been my child left behind I would be one angry momma. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

Locking school doors from the inside is not legal. If that school is doing that it needs to be reported. In an emergency situation that could cost kids their lives (fire, etc). 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

Honestly I am not sure but I am assuming the fire drill leads all the children out a different exit. There are doors on both ends of the hallways and towards the back and of course out the front where the office is. I know my child's class exits the front of the school in a fire drill by the office. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

My DD did attend Timberwood MS in Atascocita and the doors at that school were also locked from the inside during the day I would report that to the Fire Marshall and have the school fined for such dangerous practices. 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

During fire drills the classes leave from the nearest exit door...sometimes it is a main entrance, but could be a door at the end of a hallway, etc. Either way, it is against the law for a school to lock a door from the inside. I know at the schools where my kids go to school, the ONLY door unlocked from the outside is the front door of the school. All others are locked from the outside but can be opened from the inside. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

Locking school doors from the inside is not legal. If that school is doing that it needs to be reported. In an emergency situation that could cost kids their lives (fire, etc). That is what I am saying, they may be locked from the outside but you can walk up and get out of the building at any time. I taught in Humble ISD and no school would ever take such a risk. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

Well there are 2 doors at the front of the school and to my knowledge you cannot exit them. I know whenever I am at the school people will say oh you can't go that way the doors are locked??? There are no classrooms on that small strip but there are doors there. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

I am going to call and ask them. Not Timberwood but the school my son attends now. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

SH, if they have 1 locked door they are in violation, and I would report it if it was my dd's school. They may not want people to leave out that door but by law it can not be locked from the inside. All exit's must be unlocked from the inside as long as the building is occupied. What if that was the only way for a class to escape? 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

I stand corrected. They are not locked from the inside. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

Either way knowing my child's teacher the way I do (I volunteer at his school as often as I am able) I don't think I would have ever felt my child was in danger. A big oversight on the teacher's part that yes she should be disciplined for but not to this extent. 

Mygirl01 --- 16 years ago -

I stand corrected. They are not locked from the inside That would be a bigger issue than a child left unattended. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

That is me Fallon, too many unanswered questions. Agreed. That being said; If there is no harm done, a repremend should cover the school's part of the responsibility. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

its not too harsh at all...if a banker comes up a hundred dollars short they could be fired...i think leaving someones child behind in class is negligent. that teacher is lucky if all they do is suspend her for the rest of the year. if it was my kid...they wouldnt be able to just explain it away. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

And just a couple of posts from here is a mom upset about the care of her child and everyone saying all the stuff that should happen to the day care provider. Ya can't have it both ways, you can't want anonymous people to be held accountable and not those you know to be not held accountable. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

Chunky: You mean the baby who had a head injury? These 2 incidents are not the same at all. The baby in the other incident was being watched, an accident happened but the facility is at fault for not contacting the parent when the accident occured. This is an 8-9 year old child who was not injured and I am sure the parents were contacted. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground