Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should there be a limit?

who's talking here?

Fallon 4
randyjet 1
sunshine1881 4
planemom 3
Sandyr9111 5
needrnr 1
Going off air 1
Mr Mark 6
d:-] 1
justforfun 1
fergie 1
3monkeysmomma 3
~sassy~ 12
Perfection 4
Hiro Protagonist 4
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 6
desiprincess 1
I_Am_You 4
***maryc 2
Dr Aborto 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should there be a limit?

Should the be a limit on how much someone receives in assistance?

Yes however the cap should allow for them to have training and education and day care as needed so they can get off of assistance. Vote
 
 71.8% (28)
Yes, a hard cap and once they reach the limit they are left to their own devices. Vote
 
 17.9% (7)
No limits, what people need they should be able to get regardless of the cost to the rest of us. Vote
 
 10.3% (4)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Should there be a limit on how much someone receives in assistance? 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Yes, assistance should not always mean free. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

needrnr --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment Yes, assistance should not always mean free. That makes too much sense. 

I_Am_You --- 16 years ago -

What I would like to see is a plan that was more about teaching people to fish. If you get assistance you should be required to learn a trade or go to college. I know find the time can be hard, but there are alot of non-traditional education options. There should also be a requirement for work, no more everyone in the family sitting home and whistling dixie. I also agree with the drug testing, as I do not wish to fund someone's addiction! 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

It's a mute point. Assistance will never be limited because it would hurt children. Nobody wants to cut off aid to somebody with kids. At this point, we are unable to stop assistance to the parent without negatively affecting children. 

I_Am_You --- 16 years ago -

too true planemom:( 

***maryc --- 16 years ago -

"Assistance will never be limited because it would hurt children. Nobody wants to cut off aid to somebody with kids" I would agree with this statement, but if the parents are making no effort to improve their lifestyle, how much of the assistance do we really believe the kids are getting. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Do you want to be the person making that decision? 

I_Am_You --- 16 years ago -

I was at the store the other day and watched a lady pay using THREE wic cards and TWO food stamp cards. Now that kind of thing could be stopped! There should also be a regulation on WHAT you can buy with food stamps. IMO "junk" food shouldn't be allowed: soda chips twinkies etc. Like how WIC controls the cereal you can buy. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

needrnr --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment Yes, assistance should not always mean free. That makes too much sense. However!!! if Government mandated you work for your assistance (pick up trash off our hiways, serve in community serive etc.) i guarannnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnteeee less folks wud be sucking the life out of us Disclaimer: it should be for those who truly need and do appreciate it. This driving caddies parked in brick homes waiting on the porch with a beer & cigarette for tha check to come each 3'rd of the month has gotta end 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

As usual your questions are loaded to one side. One of these days your limited view of assistance is going to bite you. Every one needs some kind of assistance. No exceptions. Why is cost always an issue? What about the return on that cost? Have you never considered that? You are going to be in need of something someday. If it hasn't happened yet. It will. If you haven't learned by now, you will taught again. 

I_Am_You --- 16 years ago -

People needing assitance is not the problem. People abusing the system IS the problem. If caps and regulations were put in place, fewer people could abuse the system. If fewere people abused the system, there would be more assistance available for those that DO need it! 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I think for TANF you have to do community service....which I agree with. Why not? Make them responsible for the mile in front of their house for garbage pickup or mowing depengin on where they live. They get a check....we should get a service out of them. Maybe they would work a lil harder to not have to be on "the check". I know alot of people right now who are on Food Stamps who have never been in their life and I dont have a problem with that at all....they have paid....fallen on hard times and will work to dig out of the hole. These who want it monthly for years.....thats BS. They dont pay in EVER and want a hand out. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Why is cost always an issue? Unless you can figure out how to help folks for free then how can this not be the issue? At what point do you bleed people, who support those that do not support themselves, to death? Or are people who work and save, suppose to be penalized for this forever? If so, at what point do you really, honestly, think that those people are just going to say the he!! with this, and become the very ones who need to be supported? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

Chunky, before I can vote, there would have to be a time limit on training time-the incentive to get on your feet should be after one year, if you can't take care of yourself, WIC would be it-another incentive could be, if you limit your amount of kids, you're rewarded with some extra training, or something-right now, more kids, more money-I knew i couldn't afford more than 2 kids-every hear of birth control? 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

At what point. While I don't have all the answers. My view is from the top down. The view presented is from the bottom up. I want to squeeze profit out of the top equation to allow for more care for all at the bottom. Abuse is a case by case basis and comes from both top and bottom. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

I Am You, that is exactly the problem. Those who are abusing the system. And those who have been on assistance their entire life. And those very same people who have their children living this same life. Generational welfare is the problem. Welfare should be available to those like Sandy is talking about. They have fallen on hard times, and need a hand up. They have been working and paying into the system, and now they need some help. But these are the people who get off of assistance just as darn fast as they can. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Like I said Mr Mark, at what point do you really think people are going to continue to bust their a@@es to be successful, and watch that money be taken from them? After awhile, why even bother. Then everyone will be at the bottom. And what then? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

one more thing-I wonder if more big companies could get involved, and offer child care-that's an enormous expense,even middle class people can hardly afford-there are companies now that take on ex-cons-why not ex welfare mothers? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

lisbeth, those are both good considerations. But perhaps it could be a trade off for assistance. If someone needs skills training and daycare, then have them work in an approved day care. This way they learn how to operate a legal daycare and their children get services. Incentives are great as well. Give them increases for passing milestones. Look at unemployment. Right now someone can make more on unemployment than they can at a minimum wage job. Now I am NOT saying that everyone should take minimum wage jobs, but there should be an incentive that allows someone to work and still receive unemployment. Look at people who are on assistance, there was an article posted by someone the other day (sorry I can't give the person credit, I honestly forgot who it is), but the article highlighted some younger people (mid 20s) who receive food stamps and use them at whole foods and organic stores. One of the comments in the article noted that the person felt entitled to live how they wanted on the public assistance and why should they have to comparison shop or settle for less. Being on assistance should not have a stigma attached but it should come with strings and guidelines. And perhaps there needs to be more oversight after somone hits a specific length of time on public assistance to see what is the root cause of the problem. This way it could identify those who need help and need continued help (we need to help those) and those who have not done enough to help themselves. 

3monkeysmomma --- 16 years ago -

I want to squeeze profit out of the top equation to allow for more care for all at the bottom. Aaah, yes...that would be called SOCIALISM. 

***maryc --- 16 years ago -

"more care for all at the bottom. " I would prefer to see production and lifestyle changes at the bottom and a lot less squeezing at the top. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It's a mute point. Assistance will never be limited because it would hurt children. Nobody wants to cut off aid to somebody with kids. Yet we won't tie education to welfare so these parents can one day care for their own kids. Instead we look the other way and send 'em a check like clockwork every month from cradle to grave. What good does THIS do kids, as it keeps them tied to poverty for life. Poverty begets poverty. The FOURTH generation of welfare recipients are now raising the FIFTH. This is a travesty. There should be certain expectations when receiving long term aid. Steve is SO right. So if we won't cut them off for the kids sake, best to make the parents get their lazy arses to school so they can one day compete for a job. Welfare is the worst thing that's happened to lazy dead beat people. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

But these are the people who get off of assistance just as darn fast as they can. Yep because ive heard the tales of all the BS u have to go through to get Food Stamps and if i HAD to id do it.....BUT i would try every way in the world NOT to have to. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

exactly maryc. If behaviors at the bottom do not change, no amount of money in the world can fix this. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

General welfare is not the problem. General welfare has its problems. I think I understand what Fallon means when she mentions those whom bust there A$$es to see it taxed by those that dont. It accurately describes a problem. Not the problem. I consider that a bottom problem. My issue is mainly at the top, for profit. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

there are companies now that take on ex-cons-why not ex welfare mothers? There are companies that accept both....if the welfare mothers WANT to work! 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

Steve, you almost nailed it! Every one must vote. We get the country we deserve if we sit on our butts and don't vote. Just curious. Why "May not vote"? 

3monkeysmomma --- 16 years ago -

Love it Steve! 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

OMW Steve....peeps would fall over gasping at the thought of your system! LOL 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Just curious. Why "May not vote"? Cause thats how we got Obama! LOL 

sunshine1881 --- 16 years ago -

The problem with our system is that it rewards those who sit on their butts. It's a sweeter deal for many to just not work or work under the table or part time and bring in their $300+ a month in food stamps and free medical insurance. That's even without taking into account those who are cheating the system, which I think should have VERY stiff penalties. The system almost punishes you for acutally working. My BIL quit working to go to school fulltime. His daughter has diabetes. His wife works fulltime for a small company so health insurance is insanely expensive for her. So, they put the kids on CHIPS. My BIL decided things were a little too tight, so he'd go back to work while he continued school. He started looking into it, and basically if he made anything more than minimum wage, they'd lose the CHIPS for the kids. With the price of insurance, he was actually better off not working. Now, I will say, they are using the system the way it should be used -- temporarily to provide the necessities while he works to further himself, but with no requirements for job training or education or looking for a job connected to qualifying for benefits, there's not much incentive for people to get off them. Especially when prices for things like health insurance are so high. Hopefully, some of that will start to change a bit. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Deleted by myself. 

sunshine1881 --- 16 years ago -

I love your solution Steve!! How many "government" sort of things aren't being completed right now because of manpower and budget issues. We wouldn't even have to replace current government workers, just add to the staffing levels since we're already paying them anyway. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Education is the key. However, you can't force somebody to learn if they don't want to. Our public education system is proof of that. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

A reduced rate child care, run by welfare graduates,at a lower pay (they would be saving on their child care!) would really help those women! They could woek lower paying jobs, without that huge expense-(usually the excusr is, " It's cheaper to stay home, then to pay for child care-) 

3monkeysmomma --- 16 years ago -

So according to Steve, this guy will work 8 hours a day for assistance and he can't vote How incredibly discriminatory you are! Because someone may have a physical disability they can't be a productive member of society? What makes you think welfare would even need to be involved here? 

desiprincess --- 16 years ago -

I was married most of my adult life as a SAHM. One day out of the blue, my husband up and left. I got a job to support my two children. I was doing great. Recently I was laid off. Now yes, I am on financial aid to go back to college to finish my bachelor's, and get food stamps to help out with groceries. With that help I can go to school while my kids are in school. That prevents me from having to pay for daycare. Does that make me a bad person? For using the assistance that is available to better myself for my future? Which will also give my children a better future? 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

Ok, fair enough. We disagree. I feel the system is there for the people. I agree that it should not be abused and disincentives should be part of that assistance. I just think voting is key. Alot of people fought and died for that right. Some of those families suffered losses as a result of that fight and might need assistance. One size doesn't fit all. But your plan come pretty close. 

sunshine1881 --- 16 years ago -

Does that make me a bad person? For using the assistance that is available to better myself for my future? Which will also give my children a better future? No, I don't think anyone here is saying that. That's exactly how the system should be used. In an ideal world, that's how everyone would use it, and if they did, we wouldn't even be having this discussion. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground