Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

OK,Obvious question here.How would you feel if they were a Muslim group?

who's talking here?

wayward1 1
Zionist NightOwl 2
Joybell 1
R.E.B. 2
~sassy~ 3
Meme2my5 4
zapper007 1
quiettype 1
oneyedman 3
NewNanna 2
james osterberg 3
TexasOma 3
Puppydoglover 1
pdwriter 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti — Ten members of a U.S. missionary group who said they were trying to rescue 33 child victims of Haiti's devastating earthquake were charged with child kidnapping and criminal association on Thursday, their lawyer said. Edwin Coq said after a court hearing that a judge found sufficient evidence to charge the Americans, who were arrested Friday at Haiti's border with the Dominican Republic. Coq attended Thursday's hearing and represents the entire group in Haiti. Group leader Laura Silsby has said they were trying to take orphans and abandoned children to an orphanage in the neighboring Dominican Republic. She acknowledged they had not sought permission from Haitian officials, but said they just meant to help victims of the quake. The children taken from the group, ranging in age from 2 to 12, were being cared for at the Austrian-run SOS Children's Village in Port-au-Prince on Wednesday. The U.S. citizens, most of them members of an Idaho-based church group, were whisked away from the closed court hearing to jail in Port-au-Prince, the capital. Silsby waved and smiled faintly to reporters but declined to answer questions. Coq said that under Haiti's legal system, there won't be an open trial, but a judge will consider the evidence and could render a verdict in about three months. Coq said a Haitian prosecutor told him the Americans were charged because they had the children in their possession. No one from the Haitian government could be reached immediately for comment. Each kidnapping count carries a possible sentence of five to 15 years in prison. Each criminal association count has a potential sentence of three to nine years.  

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

I'd remind them just how close they are to that special little prison of ours in Cuba. I think a better question would be, "What would you think about these people if they took American children out of the country after a natural disaster?" 

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

Do Muslim groups even do missionary type work? I can't say I have heard either way. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

What does Muslim have to do with it??? You trolling for outrage? 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

I think a better question would be, "What would you think about these people if they took American children out of the country after a natural disaster?" Fantastic question......if these were American children taken away from their family & homes ---- say after Katrina....how outraged would we be? What if it was NO parents sending their children off with missionaries from a foreign country "to be saved & have a better life" --- how would we look at those parents? What would we do to them? We would take the children away from the parents and put them in foster care...we would try the parents for neglect, we would charge the missionaries with human trafficking. These so called missionaries had absolutely no business going into a foreign country and STEALING the children of another country. There is absolutely no excuse for their self righteous behavior. I'm hoping they enjoy their time in a Haitian jail. Stay here and help the needy in this country - don't go stealing kids because you think it's the right thing to do --- 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

How would you feel if they were a Muslim group? Do Muslim groups even do missionary type work? I don't know whether they are actively involved in "missionary work", i.e., in proselytizing, if that is how you are using the term. But if you meant charity or humanitarian work, then absolutely; Muslim groups operate many humanitarian relief operations. As such, then I would support them if they were the ones being held under similar circumstances. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

These people had NO right to move/steal these children away to another country, regardless of their intentions. Help them in Haiti (they were already in an orphanage) From my view these people were stupid and criminal.... the former not excusing the latter.... 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

These people had NO right to move/steal these children away to another country, regardless of their intentions. Help them in Haiti (they were already in an orphanage) From my view these people were stupid and criminal.... the former not excusing the latter.... Agreed. If they really were concerned, they would have just asked for permission through the proper channels. You dont steal a country's children when they are suffering through something like this. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

article continues: State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley said in Washington the U.S. was open to discuss "other legal avenues" for the defendants – an apparent reference to the Haitian prime minister's earlier suggestion that Haiti could consider sending the Americans back to the United States for prosecution. Several parents of the children in Callebas, a quake-wracked Haitian village near the capital, told The Associated Press Wednesday they had handed over their children willingly because they were unable to feed or clothe their children and the American missionaries promised to give them a better life. Their accounts contradicted statements by Silsby, of Meridian, Idaho. In a jailhouse interview Saturday, Silsby told the AP that most of the children had been delivered to the Americans by distant relatives, while some came from orphanages that had collapsed in the quake. "They are very precious kids that have lost their homes and families and are so deeply in need of, most of all, God's love and his compassion," she said. 

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

Muslim groups operate many humanitarian relief operations. That is good. I have never heard of them doing that. Come to think of it, I usually only hear of Christian missionary work through the church. I guess that stuff is just not mentioned much in the media. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

so deeply in need of, most of all, God's love and his compassion, They already had that dumba$$..... They needed food and clothing. How about taking the shirt off your back and the food from your pocket? 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

Why does it matter if missionaries are Jewish, Baptists, Agnostics, or Muslims --- why????? BTW, how many Muslims have you known well enough to meet their family and spend time in their home??? 

pdwriter --- 16 years ago -

There can only be one scale in which to judge these people. It doesn't make any difference if they believed they were doing the Lord's work or not. How would you feel if a group came into town uninvited and picked up your child or grandchild with intentions of taking them from their home country? All without having sought permission from the host country. You would want to tear them limb from limb. That group was wrong in going into the country, without clearance. God gets no glory from bullheaded people like this. Desiring to do only good doesn't make it right. There is doing the right thing, even when it hurts. 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

what does being Muslim have to do with rescuing children from a horrible disaster? 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

First off, you should ask yourself what is your definition of rescue as it pertains to this situation. Then, ask yourself the question in the title. Entities involved in this kind of work should have a working knowledge of the line that is not crossed.If they don't,they are suspect. That is what it "have to do with". 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

If this group were child trafficking then it wouldn't matter if they were Christians or Muslims. It's deplorable no matter who does it. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Do Muslim groups even do missionary type work? I can't say I have heard either way. Not in Christian thinking parts of the world they don't. lol They think we're the great infidel 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

If this group were child trafficking then it wouldn't matter if they were Christians or Muslims. It's deplorable no matter who does it. true. I wonder if this person was out to help or sell kids 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Some Muslims in Michigan and other states actually work on Christmas day to give their Christian co workers the day off. They also took the place of Christians in volunteer work, soup kitchens, etc so they could enjoy Christmas with their family. There is room for us all together, there is just no room for fighting. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Some Muslims in Michigan and other states actually work on Christmas day to give their Christian co workers the day off. They also took the place of Christians in volunteer work, soup kitchens, etc so they could enjoy Christmas with their family. There is room for us all together, there is just no room for fighting. Alright, I feel bad. I guess it's the lunatic extremists who hate us. That's nice to hear meme :) 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Alright, I feel bad. I guess it's the lunatic extremists who hate us. Don't feel bad, there are so many extremists that want us dead. But I still think there is more to this story about this group taking the kids out. I don't know why jo brings in the Muslims, so I will re read his post again.. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

I read his intent as this: He reasons that the only people supporting them are Christians, who are doing so because they believe the group was acting in good faith. So, if I understand his reasoning correctly, he is asking Christians whether they would still be supportive of this group if they were, say, Muslim, rather than of their own faith. Thus, my answer was "yes": I would support Muslims in the same situation. My understanding, based on the more in-depth article someone posted on here, is that these people were setting up an orphanage/school across the border. When the quake hit, they sped up their time line and offered the schooling opportunity to a group of displaced, destitute families. The families saw this chance at a better life and willingly gave their children over to the group. So, I support the group and believe that they were not attempting to kidnap anyone, regardless of what their faith is. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

He reasons that the only people supporting them are Christians, who are doing so because they believe the group was acting in good faith. So, if I understand his reasoning correctly, he is asking Christians whether they would still be supportive of this group if they were, say, Muslim, rather than of their own faith. I would treat each group the same whether I supported them or did not support them based on the facts of the actions they took. In this case all I can say is the road to hell is paved with good intentions. These people are either stupid or criminals, either way they are in a heap of trouble that they brought on themselves. 

Meme2my5 --- 16 years ago -

Thanks ZO, kind of how I read it too. It seems like there are several conflicting reports about what was going on. First they said the kids were kidnapped and the group intended to sell them for $10,000 each, then they said that the families had given them to the group to have a better life. I tend to believe the latter. 

NewNanna --- 16 years ago -

How would you feel if a group came into town uninvited and picked up your child or grandchild with intentions of taking them from their home country? All without having sought permission from the host country. The Dominican consul in Haiti, Carlos Castillo, told the AP on Thursday that the day the Americans departed for the border, Silsby visited him and said he had a document from Dominican migration officials authorizing her to extract the children from Haiti. Castillo said he warned Silsby that if she lacked adoption papers signed by the appropriate Haitian officials her mission would be considered child trafficking. "We were very specific," he said. 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

Castillo said he warned Silsby that if she lacked adoption papers signed by the appropriate Haitian officials her mission would be considered child trafficking. "We were very specific," he said. It's at this point that anyone with a grain of common sense would stop and make sure all the paperwork was in order. This group was kidnapping children to bring back to the US so they could relish in the glory that they saved the little children from a horrible life. They are nothing but kidnappers. 

NewNanna --- 16 years ago -

Interesting side note.  This is from the New York Times.: Last Updated | 9:30 p.m. Laura Silsby, who led a Baptist group on a mission that resulted in all 10 members of her team being charged with kidnapping on Thursday by Haitian authorities, also faces legal troubles back home in Boise, Idaho, in the form of two lawsuits. According to a report in her hometown newspaper, the Idaho Statesman, Ms. Silsby, the founder and C.E.O. of PersonalShopper.com, is being sued by a former employee for unpaid wages and by a law firm for unpaid fees. On Thursday, the Idaho Department of Labor confirmed to The Lede that 14 claims for nonpayment of wages were filed against Personal Shopper Inc. in 2008 and 2009.  The state Department of Labor initially put liens on a company bank account to get the money.” The Idaho newspaper also notes that Ms. Silsby has been sued four other times in the past three years by businesses seeking payment. 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

Sounds like a fine upstanding person.... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground