Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Liberalize your mind to Hitler and Stalin

who's talking here?

smartypants 1
randyjet 18
Mabbers 1
~sassy~ 4
Perfection 3
Possum 1
PS 1
POTUS 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
JusticeForAll 4
Ogre1 20
voice of reason 2
ladyjane 1
JohnLynch 18
NewNanna 1
evolved 1
JeffSpicoli 2
truthmiser 1
Zombie Slayer! 1
*OH SNAP* 17

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

And while we are at it, let's make this part of the school curriculum Oliver Stone's 'Secret History' to put Hitler 'in context' TCA -- Director Oliver Stone's upcoming Showtime documentary miniseries "Secret History of America" promises to put mass murderers such as Stalin and Hitler "in context." "Stalin, Hitler, Mao, McCarthy -- these people have been vilified pretty thoroughly by history," Stone told reporters at the Television Critics Association's semi-annual press tour in Pasadena. "Stalin has a complete other story," Stone said. "Not to paint him as a hero, but to tell a more factual representation. He fought the German war machine more than any single person. We can't judge people as only 'bad' or 'good.' Hitler is an easy scapegoat throughout history and its been used cheaply. He's the product of a series of actions. It's cause and effect ... People in America don't know the connection between WWI and WWII ... I've been able to walk in Stalin's shoes and Hitler's shoes to understand their point of view. We're going to educate our minds and liberalize them and broaden them. We want to move beyond opinions ... Go into the funding of the Nazi party. How many American corporations were involved, from GM through IBM. Hitler is just a man who could have easily been assassinated." The controversial director's 10-part documentary series for Showtime promises to focus on events that "at the time went under-reported, but crucially shaped America's unique and complex history of the last 60 years." Subjects in "History" include President Harry Truman’s decision to drop the atomic bomb on Japan and the origins of the Cold War with the Soviet Union. "You cannot approach history unless you have empathy for the person you may hate," Stone said during the show's trailer, which promised to put historical villains "in context." "I don't want to put out conventional History Channel product where it's easy to like it." "He's not saying we're going to come out with a more positive view of Hitler," emphasized professor Peter Kuznick, the lead writer on the project. "But we're going to describe him as a historical phenomenon and not just somebody who appeared out of nowhere." Stone said that conservative pundits will dislike the show. "Obviously, Rush Limbaugh is not going to like this history and, as usual, we're going to get those kind of ignorant attacks," said Stone, who also also compared the experience of sympathizing with war criminals to making his "W" movie about George W. Bush. "I'm trying to understand somebody I thoroughly despised." Stone also warned that the same military industrial complex forces that he's explored in movies such as "JFK" and in "Secret History," are now corrupting Barack Obama. "You can understand why Obama is following in Bush's footsteps in Afghanistan," Stone said."Obama is very much trapped, we believe, in that system. And so that's what we're going to try and show you -- the way it works." The project will also show lesser-known positive aspects of American history and unsung heroes. Stone eventually hopes to send "Secret History" to schools as a teaching curriculum. "It would be a very different counterweight to what they're learning," Stone said. "Nobody is going to force it down anybody's throat." A critic also asked Stone "the Sarah Palin question" of what he likes to read. "My father was a voracious New York Times reader," he said. "We consider that in The Middle. Sarah Palin would disagree."  

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Can I get a brief synopsis? LOL. 

NewNanna --- 16 years ago -

Liberalizing minds just means to open them and take on a new view.  Sort of like the word  ‘catholic’  which doesn’t always necessarily mean the Catholic church.  The show looks to be kind of interesting IMO. 

PS --- 16 years ago -

 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

excellent post, NewNanna...I hadn't heard of this documentary until Chunky's post, but it seems like it would be interesting to see a different perspective. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

I really wish CH would spend more time absorbing what she reads as opposed to hunting for anything she can twist into a political argument. What Stone is saying here is basically that we've blown Hitler and the Nazis up to be some crazed boogeymen instead of actually looking at how and why these events happened. If we don't understand history, we'll never learn from it. The holocaust didn't happen overnight. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

another excellent post, Oh Snap. Couldn't have said it better myself. :) 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

Actually, my friend summed it best in his own colorful way. Edited for language. "We need to understand Hitler better. I'm not saying we should forgive the f*ck. He was an evil douche, no doubt about it. I'm not some mouth-breathing hillbilly with a third-grade education, a giant swastika flag on my trailer home wall, and fewer teeth than shotguns, claiming that the holocaust was faked. The problem we've had is that worldwide, Hitler and the Nazi Party have become boogeymen. There were lessons to be learned over the whole ordeal, and I fear humanity has utterly forgotten them. To be fair, the Nazis made it easy for us to forget the lessons. They did a LOT of evil sh*t, from the top-ranking soldiers to the civilian population. We still need to focus on the more intellectual lessons than the simple: - Don't let your government tell you who to hate. - Don't let your government drive you to commit acts of hatred. - Don't be a nationalist prick. - Don't fall for propaganda. - Don't spy on your neighbors out of a sense of civic duty. - Don't let your government demand to see your papers. - Especially important, keep an eye out, and don't let that kind of sh*t happen again without saying or doing something. Instead, having watched my country go nuts for most of the last decade, it appears the only lesson learned was: - Nazis are bad, and Hitler was the Devil. And we're not that bad because we're not Nazis. So I say: Go Oliver. Go, you magnificent bast*rd." 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

*OH SNAP* --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment I really wish CH would spend more time absorbing what she reads as opposed to hunting for anything she can twist into a political argument. Interesting. 1. How did I politicize it? 2. How do you know what I think about it since I did not post any of my own comments. Nice way to jump to conclusions and attempt to profile and stereotype. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

What. the. eff. ever. *giant eye roll* 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Chunky, the words in the link are not your words? Were you being serious or sarcastic there? 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

(it doesn't matter what YOU think about it. Your intent was to stir people up with your selective bolding. SSDD) 

truthmiser --- 16 years ago -

I sense a leftist-socialist complex on this tread Yah Think 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

Way to also miss the point. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

JusticeForAll --- 33 min ago - quote - flag comment Chunky, the words in the link are not your words? Were you being serious or sarcastic there? You never asked before, you only assumed and attempted to stereotype me. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

"We need to understand Hitler better. just like a liberal to tell you that you should "liberalize your mind". next, they'll be telling us we need to have empathy for satan so that we can understand satan better 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

We don't need none of that there learnin' nonsense. You tell em'! 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

(or maybe, just maybe, some people see the value in understanding WHY something happened in order to prevent it from happening again.) 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

(or maybe, just maybe, some people see the value in understanding WHY something happened in order to prevent it from happening again.) lol, if you paid attention in history class you would already know btw, having empathy for someone means that you have "walked in their shoes". just like a liberal to advocate that we should do as they did to "understand" them 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

Right. Because what they teach us in public schools is 100% of the story. Kinda like how we're taught the civil war was fought over slavery. Good grief. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Chunky, the words in the link are not your words? Were you being serious or sarcastic there? You never asked before, you only assumed and attempted to stereotype me. What are you talking about? I was asking you two questions there... Were those your own words typed in the link? Were you being sarcastic or serious with those words? Instead of trying to twist my questions, just answer them, for crying out loud! 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

Kinda like how we're taught the civil war was fought over slavery. lol, it was 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

btw, having empathy for someone means that you have "walked in their shoes". just like a liberal to advocate that I could see how empathy could be a tough concept for you to understand, but here's a start. em⋅pa⋅thy   –noun 1. the intellectual identification with or vicarious experiencing of the feelings, thoughts, or attitudes of another. 2. the imaginative ascribing to an object, as a natural object or work of art, feelings or attitudes present in oneself: By means of empathy, a great painting becomes a mirror of the self. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Kinda like how we're taught the civil war was fought over slavery. I agree with you here, but people like these, nothing more I need to learn. They were evil, period. Don't need to know why, don't care. But there are many like minded individuals living in the world today. Who feel individual liberties are not in our best interest, who feel we need to be told what to do, who feel we need big brother to take care of us. Kinda sounds like our own Government. Shudder! 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

I could see how empathy could be a tough concept for you to understand, but here's a start. apparently YOU don't understand the words "vicarious experiencing of the feelings, thoughts, or attitudes of another" btw, vicarious means "taking the place of another person or thing". lol, do you advocate taking Hitler's place so you can understand what he was going through? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I sense a leftist-socialist complex on this tread No way! 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

I agree with you here, but people like these, nothing more I need to learn. They were evil, period. Don't need to know why, don't care. But there are many like minded individuals living in the world today. Who feel individual liberties are not in our best interest, who feel we need to be told what to do, who feel we need big brother to take care of us. Kinda sounds like our own Government. Shudder! “Know thy enemy and know thy self and you will win a hundred battles.” Sun Tzu Wu 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I have no idea of what Stone will present, but it should let people know that Hitler was viewed as a wonderful guy by most American conservatives. Hitler was viewed by western governments as the bulwark against their main enemy, the Soviet Union. Only Churchill and a few others among conservatives in the UK had enough wit to read Mein Kampf and figure out that tanks can go WEST as easily as EAST. His take on Stalin is absurd since Stalin was the MAIN reason the Soviet Union suffered so badly at the beginning of the war. Stalin's response to the invasion was to stay drunk for five days, and only came out of hiding when the rest of his toadies sent for him. Stalin initially thought they were going to arrest him! Having extensively read history of this period and the Soviet Union, I can find no place where Stalin made a significant contribution to the Soviet war effort. At least Stalin had enough wit, unlike Hitler to stay out of planning military ops and simply delegated Zhukov as his fireman. He was fortunate in having a general of that caliber. The rest of the Soviet generals were not as good. Stalin also contributed to killing a lot more troops for bad objectives that had no reason for being done. The Soviet Union won despite Stalin, NOT because of him. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

do you advocate taking Hitler's place so you can understand what he was going through? Well, obviously what Oliver is advocating is that we all go out and slaughter a few million Jews to truly understand where Hitler is coming from. Because, you know, that makes sense. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

but it should let people know that Hitler was viewed as a wonderful guy by most American conservatives. nonsense randy, but good try at rewrite 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

understanding the spirit of the times or zeitgeist, is important. educated people understand this. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

lol, it was If you believe that, you need to pick up a book or two. 

JeffSpicoli --- 16 years ago -

next, they'll be telling us we need to have empathy for satan so that we can understand satan better    No, we all know he's a mythological boogieman. Not worth wasting brain time on him.  Hitler, however, was an important 20th century historical figure. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I agree with you here, but people like these, nothing more I need to learn The point is that it could happen HERE as well as Germany. Hitler did not rise to power because the Germans are bad and evil people. They saw him as many in the US did as an answer to their problems. The firm Texaco, Ford, and many others contributed money to Hitler. Even Joe Kennedy, while not a big fan of Hitler thought he was the wave of the future, even in the US. He and most conservatives prefered a Hitler to a BLum, Attlee, or any other left politicians in the west. I can detect the same view in many of the folks on this site. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

I can detect the same view in many of the folks on this site. yep, there are many libs on this site 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

yep, there are many libs on this site Actually, it is the conservatives who supported Hitler in Germany and the US. These people were faced with the choice of Hitler or a left wing party in power, and they CHOSE HITLER! I can see that almost all the conservatives on this site would make the SAME choice if it came down to it. I can see it in the support for rightwing dictatorships and apologizing for military takeovers. A good example is the howl of protest that went up when Clinton insisted that the ELECTED President of Haiti be restored. The GOP blasted that idea and the dictators hired a GOP public PR firm to make their case. Sen. Dole was very outspoken against the idea of letting a freely elected guy back in. So from all the past actions of conservatives, I can state definitely that they prefer dictatorship if any government threatens their money or privileges. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

Actually, it is the conservatives who supported Hitler in Germany and the US. actually, you are trying that rewrite function again 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

If you believe that, you need to pick up a book or two. take a look at Top Five Causes of the Civil War. if you look carefully, you will see that they all have a basis in slavery 

Possum --- 16 years ago -

I can see it in the support for rightwing dictatorships and apologizing for military takeovers. A good example is the howl of protest that went up when Clinton insisted that the ELECTED President of Haiti be restored. The GOP blasted that idea and the dictators hired a GOP public PR firm to make their case. Sen. Dole was very outspoken against the idea of letting a freely elected guy back in.   The violent overthrow of the democratically-elected Popular Unity government of Salvador Allende in Chile was orchestrated through CIA covert intervention in Chile, and the repressive character of General Pinochet's rule, the coup became the most notorious military takeover in the annals of Latin American history. Revelations that President Nixon had ordered the CIA to "make the economy scream" in Chile to "prevent Allende from coming to power or to unseat him," prompted a major scandal in the mid-1970s, and a major investigation by the U.S. Senate. Since the coup, however, few U.S. documents relating to Chile have been actually declassified- -until recently. Through Freedom of Information Act requests, and other avenues of declassification, the National Security Archive has been able to compile a collection of declassified records that shed light on events in Chile between 1970 and 1976. These documents include: ** Cables written by U.S. Ambassador Edward Korry after Allende's election, detailing conversations with President Eduardo Frei on how to block the president-elect from being inaugurated. The cables contain detailed descriptions and opinions on the various political forces in Chile, including the Chilean military, the Christian Democrat Party, and the U.S. business community. ** CIA memoranda and reports on "Project FUBELT"--the codename for covert operations to promote a military coup and undermine Allende's government. The documents, including minutes of meetings between Henry Kissinger and CIA officials, CIA cables to its Santiago station, and summaries of covert action in 1970, provide a clear paper trail to the decisions and operations against Allende's government ** National Security Council strategy papers which record efforts to "destabilize" Chile economically, and isolate Allende's government diplomatically, between 1970 and 1973. ** State Department and NSC memoranda and cables after the coup, providing evidence of human rights atrocities under the new military regime led by General Pinochet. ** FBI documents on Operation Condor--the state-sponsored terrorism of the Chilean secret police, DINA. The documents, including summaries of prison letters written by DINA agent Michael Townley, provide evidence on the carbombing assassination of Orlando Letelier and Ronni Moffitt in Washington D.C., and the murder of Chilean General Carlos Prats and his wife in Buenos Aires, among other operations.   

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

., and the murder of Chilean General Carlos Prats and his wife in Buenos Aires, among other operations. It is not terrorism when conservatives do it. Facts and reality mean nothing to these folks. History to them is something to be written to suit their political ends, just like Hitler and Stalin. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground