Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

'Bioidenticals' not FDA-approved, contain estrogen

who's talking here?

planemom 1
AFWife 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Diamom 3
Unichic™ 3
Jpgirl 1
ladybughomeschool 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
ladyjane 3
NewNanna 1
mommie21g1b 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
LoveMyDoggies 3
crazypinetrees 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Morgan1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

I have never heard anything negative about these so I though this article was interesting EDITOR'S NOTE: Ten years and $2.5 billion in research have found no cures from alternative medicine. Yet these mostly unproven treatments are now mainstream and used by more than a third of all Americans. This is one in an occasional series examining their use and potential risks. ___ Miserable in menopause, Elizabeth Alsgaard pondered an awful choice: Drenching hot flashes or hormone therapies that might raise the risk of cancer. What former actress Suzanne Somers raved about held much more appeal — custom-mixed "bioidentical" hormones, just like ones the body makes. "Anything I can put into my body that's natural has to be better," said Alsgaard, a California audiologist who admitted having "no knowledge base to go on other than fear" when she took Somers' advice. Millions of women have tried custom-compounded hormones or herbal supplements like black cohosh and red clover since 2002, when a big federal study found risks from traditional hormone replacement therapy, or HRT. Alternative remedies are especially popular with upscale, educated women who like to research and find their own solutions to medical problems. They like the idea of personalized treatments versus off-the-shelf prescription drugs. However, instead of a safer option, they are getting products of unknown risk that still contain the estrogen many of them fear, women's health experts say. "Misinformation is rampant" about bioidenticals, said Dr. JoAnn Manson, preventive medicine chief at Harvard-affiliated Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston. "It really is buyer beware." She and other experts explain: _"Bioidentical" is a marketing term that has no accepted medical meaning. Its implied benefit is not unique to alternative remedies; many prescription drugs contain hormones that chemically match estrogens and progesterones made naturally by the body. _Custom-compounded hormones are not approved by the federal Food and Drug Administration and have not been proved safe or effective. They may carry the same cancer and heart risks as traditional treatments and have had even less testing to find out. _Hormone preparations do not need to be customized for each woman; a few standard doses work for almost everyone, medical experts say. The saliva tests that some women are given to tailor formulas are of dubious value because hormone levels fluctuate widely throughout the day. _Compounding pharmacists use such different methods that a customized prescription can contain widely varying amounts of hormones depending on who fills it. _Many compounders use estriol, a form of estrogen not approved for sale in the United States. The FDA is in a battle with compounding pharmacies over its use. The bottom line? "Women need to understand there's no rigorous evidence these preparations are any more effective or any safer than traditional hormone therapy. In fact, there's much less evidence for efficacy and very little research on long-term safety," said Manson, who has no industry ties and was a key researcher in the big federal study that warned women in 2002 of the health risks from long-term hormone use. For years, medical groups have warned against custom-compounded hormones. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists has denounced claims about their safety. The American Medical Association has urged more FDA oversight. The Federal Trade Commission has filed complaints against online sellers who made health claims for natural progesterone creams without supporting evidence. In 2001, the government tested 29 products from compounding pharmacies and found that one-third did not meet standard quality benchmarks, including potency problems, Manson writes in her book, "Hot Flashes, Hormones and Your Health." That has not stopped their popularity, and Somers has promoted them in several best-selling books and on "The Oprah Winfrey Show" earlier this year. "I laugh when they call me a quack," said Somers, who rubs hormones on her arms, injects them vaginally and takes some 60 supplement pills each day. In a phone interview, Somers said she is not trying to play doctor but to share with women what worked for her. The issue flared last year, when the FDA declared that custom-mixed hormones were no safer than traditional treatments and warned pharmacies to stop using estriol, which is not approved in the United States for any use. (Most traditional menopause therapies use a different form of estrogen with a similar name — estradiol.) The industry claimed it was being persecuted and fought back. In full-page ads in major newspapers, several alternative medicine groups claimed that estriol is safe, criticized "synthetic, hyper-expensive" prescription drugs, and asked, "Why is the FDA so hostile to 'natural' medicine?" There are several thousand compounding pharmacies in the United States and hormones are a significant part of their business, said L.D. King, executive director of the International Academy of Compounding Pharmacists in Missouri City, Texas. No one knows how many women use these products, but "we believe the FDA action on the estriol issue would have affected hundreds of thousands of women," King said. A group of nine compounding pharmacies sued the FDA. After a murky ruling by a federal court in Louisiana centering on federal versus states' authority, neither side appealed, King said. "It gets complicated and there's not a win," he said. "We continue to advocate that FDA's action is wrong." Alsgaard was not aware of the flap. She was 52 and living in San Diego when she stopped taking birth control pills, and menopause symptoms "hit me like a brick wall." Her doctor, a specialist in women's health, urged traditional hormone replacement therapy. "She was just so aggressive it really flipped me out," said Alsgaard, who feared a cancer risk from the pills. After reading one of Somers' books, Alsgaard went to a different doctor specializing in bioidentical hormones. "She spoke at a physician's level, talked about metabolic things I didn't understand and sold me a couple hundred dollars of supplements I never took," Alsgaard said. "I was so desperate it was like, 'OK, OK, just give me whatever I need.'" Although Alsgaard did not use the supplements, she did spend about $1,000 for saliva tests, hormone creams and custom-compounded hormone pills the doctor prescribed. Six months later, she was still miserable. Disgusted with the doctor and in the middle of moving to Los Angeles, she found a new doctor and asked again for a natural remedy, believing those are safer than traditional hormone pills. "He did a lot more extensive workup on me and put me on a bioidentical implant, a pellet implanted into the hip," she said. Pellets containing estrogen, testosterone or both are the latest craze in this field. They are implanted just under the skin every few months under a local anesthetic, and are not FDA-approved for treating menopause. Problems that have been reported include difficulty removing the pellets if the therapy has to be discontinued, infection or pain at the injection site and fluctuating blood levels of estrogen, including a potentially high cumulative effect over several years. Alsgaard did not know the pellets lack FDA approval. Her first, implanted in April, has done the trick, she said. "I feel awesome. I have no night sweats, no hot flashes, no mood swings. After feeling so terrible, I'd forgotten how good it feels to feel normal," she said. Whether her estrogen pellet is any safer than traditional estrogen pills is unknown. Her physician, Dr. Kevin Pimstone, an internist at UCLA, said hormone pellets are "a very small part of my practice" — a few patients a month. "I'm a really conventional doctor who offers this to patients who ask for it," he said. "I don't think there's any evidence that bioidentical hormones are any safer than conventional hormones." ___ National Writer Joceyln Noveck contributed to this report from New York. ___ On the Net: FDA on hormone compounds: http://tinyurl.com/kv7sqb Federal alternative medicine center: http://nccam.nih.gov/health/menopause/menopausesymptoms.htm  

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

_Custom-compounded hormones are not approved by the federal Food and Drug Administration and have not been proved safe or effective. They may carry the same cancer and heart risks as traditional treatments and have had even less testing to find out. Dessicated thyroid, such as Armor, has been used very effectively for many years before the big pharmaceuticals patented their synthetic formulas (Synthroid, for example). With the increased competition from cheaper, natural forms of thyroid, Big Pharma is trying to shut them down. What you'd really have to dig for is the studies that showed it was actually the synthetics that were less reliable and varied in effectiveness, pill to pill. Big Pharma and our FDA have teamed to try to run less-expensive, un-patentable options out of business. _Many compounders use estriol, a form of estrogen not approved for sale in the United States. The FDA is in a battle with compounding pharmacies over its use. Same thing is true of estrogen and progesterone. Anything that doesn't fall under Big Pharma's umbrella, they want gone. It's not that there are no risks with hormones, that's not what I'm saying - but the scary studies were done with synthetics, and of course this is rarely pointed out..... What makes me mad is that any female from 12 to, I don't know, probably 60 could go to any medical person with prescription privileges and get birth control pills. This is hormone therapy, hello! But it's synthetic, so you won't hear bad things about it....... And what about the women who are going through menopause - Most doctors, I'd say 95 percent, wouldn't hesitate to give "safe" antidepressants, antianxiety meds, the whole cocktail instead of the horrible hormones the person is, uh, actually suffering for lack of. All of these psychotropic meds are synthetic, Big Pharma babies, most with NO testing regarding long-term effects. I'm absolutely not trying to give medical advice, but I get pretty darn skeptical when I think about what's going on for so many poor people suffering with physical symptoms which could be fixed quickly, easily, and CHEAPLY and our government is busy trying to run anyone who makes or prescribes the potential cures out of business. Ask anyone who runs a compounding pharmacy - they are fighting for their lives from the FDA. Think about the threat to Big Pharma. If you compound, or make from scratch, someone's capsules, you can put whatever you need to in there (within limits, but could be several things in one capsule). Fewer capsules, lower cost, big threat to Big Pharma. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Excellent post Ladyjane!!! 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I have never heard anything negative about these so I though this article was interesting Whether it's all natural or synthetic, if it can help you it can hurt you. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

so true, and anytime you are changing your hormonal balance you are playing with fire IMO. I don't know much about bioidentical, but I am amazed at how many women use hormones as birth control and think it has no impact on their body. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I never understood how bioidentical hormones could help your cancer risk. My cancer grew in the presence of estrogen that my own body produced. Estrogen of any form is a big no no for me. The bioidentical claims are misleading and dangerous. . 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Go, ladyjane! I work with someone who is over 60 and he has been on Armor for most of his adult life. His doctor has tried to switch him to synthetics and he says they absolutely do NOT work for him. Yes, the pharmaceutical companies are trying to run the bioidenticals out of business so they can profit from it. I just recently went to listen to a doctor speak on this very subject. As she explained it, a pharmaceutical company can take a natural occurring substance, change 1 molecule of that substance, and then patent it. That's right, change it so they can patent it and then profit from it. To what benefit? Only to line their pockets, because you cannot patent something that occurs naturally. 

NewNanna --- 17 years ago -

I never understood how bioidentical hormones could help your cancer risk. My cancer grew in the presence of estrogen that my own body produced. Estrogen of any form is a big no no for me. The bioidentical claims are misleading and dangerous. . My friend just had a double mastectomy due to cancer. She had been on HRT for 15 years following a hysterectomy. I take hot flashes over cancer any day. 

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

I thought what the compounding pharmacies were making was the bioidentical??? 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

Excellent post Ladyjane!!!  Go, ladyjane! Thank you, sweeties! If just one person will think about this and avoid being on synthetic hormones or antidepressants when what their body is screaming for is more of what it produces naturally, I will be so happy. I wish more people would investigate specific conditions and how they respond to estrogen, then educate their doctors! If bone loss, Alzheimers, or high blood pressure are family trends, it would definitely be worth one's while to really research the possible protective effects of estrogen. And low thyroid is linked to so many physical, emotional, and behavioral malfunctions, I wouldn't even know where to start - and what an easy fix it is with the right, so CHEAP medication! If we can just keep our government's hands off 'em. 

Jpgirl --- 17 years ago -

Well of course they contain estrogen. I swear-everyone needs to be an advocate for themselves and research EVERYTHING and understand what they are putting inside themselves. I had a TAH 2 years ago and have been suffering horribly and have been very tempted to use bioidenticals but I know I can't-my Mom died of breast cancer and I have fibrocystic breast disease and ANY estrogen (even plant estrogen) increase my risks. Education is key to any decision making. I was recently diagnosed with Osteopenia-did the research and won't take the drugs for that either. We all have to be very careful 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

I never understood how bioidentical hormones could help your cancer risk. My cancer grew in the presence of estrogen that my own body produced. Likely because it was unopposed by progesterone. If you are low in progesterone, not only do you become estrogen dominant, but estrogen binds with thyroid, zapping energy and killing your metabolism. Also, there are three estrogens. One that is forgotten is the "good" estrogen" called estriol. MUCH different than taking estradial. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

I had a TAH 2 years ago and have been suffering horribly and have been very tempted to use bioidenticals but I know I can't-my Mom died of breast cancer and I have fibrocystic breast disease and ANY estrogen (even plant estrogen) increase my risks. If you have fibrocystic breast disease (which I had while on BCPs), then you have hormonal imbalance. If you are that afraid to do bio-identicals (even estriol), you could at least try oral iodine, which has marvelous protective qualities against breast cancer and will eliminate fibrocyctic breast disease within a month of taking it. 

Morgan1 --- 15 years ago -

It is difficult for most doctors to understand hormone therapy let alone the average person. Who has more cancer, young or old? When are hormone levels at their highest, young or old? Optimizing your hormone levels (bringing them up to a point to alleviate menopausal symptoms) is NOT bad nor does it cause cancer. If a person has cancer, it can be aggravated by estrogen but specifically (E1) estradiol. Estriol (E2) which is the main ingredient in Biest (the bio-identical) was petitioned by Senator Kennedy to be taken off the market because of lack of proof that it was beneficial. Progesterone is also proven to be cancer protective. Any medication in highly concentrated forms over long periods of time will have side effects but the misinformation that hormone replacement is dangerous is outrageous and the quality of life for millions of women can be improved with a little hormone replacement.....personal opinion only, Robert Morgan ACNP 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

I've used several different compounded meds in the last 20 years, some topical & some oral. I appreciate pharmacists who offer these services.

As for the FDA...the can go suck an egg. I've come to understand that they are a bunch of crooks or asinine idiots. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I have been using bio identical hormones since 2005. If not for them and Dr. Taylor I would be on Zombie medication. I as put on to counter panic attacks.

Never had another since. 

ladyjane --- 15 years ago -

Where, oh where, is Unichic???? I miss having her wisdom here to discuss these vital issues.....Does anyone know? 

Diamom --- 15 years ago -

So ladyjane - what do you take in place of the bio identicals? 

LoveMyDoggies --- 15 years ago -

Interesting info. Thanks for posting. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

Ive taken the bio identicals. Im also currently using hormone cream and its made a bigger difference in the life than the bio identicals did.

Hormones can REALLY jack up your system more than people think. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

I asked my Gynocologist for bios last year, and she refused, due to family history-regardless of symtoms, I'm afraid to disregard her advice- 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Bump for LMD.. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I asked my GYN about them-I wanted to know if I could take them when I needed something, as she's told me i couldn't take hormones of any kind, like bc pills-she adamantly said NO-she added, unless the doctor had monitored your hormone levels for years before you need bio- identicals, (even people who, unlike me, could take hormones later on)there's no way a doctor could possibly know how much to give you-she's a really good doctor, so I won't be looking for them when I need them- 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Tat what kind of doctor is this? 

LoveMyDoggies --- 14 years ago -

Thanks for bumping this :) Interesting read 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Supposedly Suzanne Sommers did a lot of research on Bioidentical hormones for herself. I think it is probably an interesting read. She has worked out a regimen with the doc's help for herself, and wrote the book to share the info.

I'm uber leary about all of this stuff..I can't get past putting stuff in my body...tho it might very well be helpful to people. 

LoveMyDoggies --- 14 years ago -

Supposedly Suzanne Sommers did a lot of research on Bioidentical hormones for herself

Yes, I saw that. I plan to borrow that book from someone to read. I saw a couple of interviews with her, one was on the Dr. Oz show, where she discussed all of that. I read this a while back and forgot that I'd read it. I plan to do more research on my own but know several folks who have undergone this. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground