Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What would you do if...

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 2
GCan 11
la guerita 1
Fallon 3
needrnr 3
Zionist NightOwl 1
crrc 1
Going off air 1
Mabbers 2
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 1
getreal 1
Elf :) 3
2girlygirls 1
~sassy~ 4
Unichic™ 7
Rhea 1
OH SNAP! 3
mommy2three 24
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 28
keepinitreal09 2
ladybughomeschool 1
PHSMOMOF2 2
♥kerry♥ 4
N.S. Sherlock 12
Mooky 11
Shenanigans 2
*momof5* 35
Pollys Crackers 1
~hopscotch~ 6
!PiratePrincess! 1
**Fancy** 2
sm417 1
just lisa 3
tennis anyone? 1
p&p 1
NotaPassiveSouthernBelle 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

What grade is this? If it was kinder, I would be frustrated. I want my child to be with a more sympathetic adult at such a young age. Now fifth grade would be a totally different story :) 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

Well...it was 4th grade. What I don't understand is why everyone was punished. The whole head on the desk thing reminds me of the nuns I had in elementary school. But, yes, I would be really upset if this was my kindergartener. 

!PiratePrincess! --- 17 years ago -

Hmmm...if it were my child I would be upset because it was MY child. Some people like strict teachers for their kids and some do not. If you think she would do better with a different type of teacher then talk to someone about your concerns. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Well...it was 4th grade. What I don't understand is why everyone was punished. because children are less likely to repeat the offense if it affects EVERYONE. Kind of a peer pressure/guilt tactic. It usually works! Why is your child crying at school in the 4th grade? I would be more concerned with that, than the teacher's reaction to it. I have a 5th grader and if he was crying at school, I'd be worried. 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

Caddiness(sp?) at the end of last year. I got her and consoled her, and she has had no problem since. she was overwhelmed because of the first day of school, and hormones, too, I guess... trust me, she is fine now. But, yes, I was worried about it. because children are less likely to repeat the offense if it affects EVERYONE. Kind of a peer pressure/guilt tactic. It usually works! interesting, I have never thought of it that way. Is there research that backs that up? 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

and hormones, too, I guess In the 4th grade? It sounds unlikely but ok. 

Elf :) --- 17 years ago -

I never taught elementary school, but 6 minutes seems excessive. The teacher is probably trying to establish their discipline and the fact that talking is not permitted at certain times. Nip it in the bud early and hope to avoid behavior problems in the future. Some teachers take the "no mercy" approach as a way of showing that they mean business. In one of my college teaching courses they told us not to smile until December! Hopefully those that are acting out will take the hint and future consequences will be given on a more individual basis. As for the crying, could the teacher have been trying to spare your child the embarassment of calling attention to the tears? Maybe she thought it would make it worse to address it? I would respond with more compassion, but that is me. Using proximity control, she could have simply moved herself around the room and patted your child on the back, without breaking stride or instruction. I wish that had been handled better! The first week is so tough on everyone, hopefully things will improve from here! 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

In the 4th grade? It sounds unlikely but ok. My 4th grader is definitely starting to get hormonal on me. I was sooooo not ready for this. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I never taught elementary school, but 6 minutes seems excessive Really? I was always told that "time out" should be the same in minutes as the child's age. So, considering that 4th graders are 9 and 10, 6 mins doesn't seem like a big deal at all, imo. because children are less likely to repeat the offense if it affects EVERYONE. Kind of a peer pressure/guilt tactic. It usually works! interesting, I have never thought of it that way. Is there research that backs that up?  My research is years of being a student and having 5 kids! LOL. It doesn't seem fair, because it isn't, and the kids know this and are less likely to do it again. 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

My 4th grader is definitely starting to get hormonal on me. I was sooooo not ready for this. Well I guess the all natural diet does work then huh? My oldest dd just started during the summer between 6th and 7th grade. Dammit son, I made another good choice for my kiddos 5 years ago! WOOO HOOO 

needrnr --- 17 years ago -

Definitely the first week of school is very hard. Sounds like the girls are establishing the pecking order early on too. Maybe left over from last school year?? She has the "new" teacher thought running in her head too. My youngest dd could get very teary and I knew back in 2nd grade to start nipping it in the bud. If the teacher saw the girls being mean today at 4th grade she might not want to intervene just yet, to give your dd the opportunity to stand up for herself. Unfortunately in 4th grade(9 and 10 year olds) are not too young to have the hormone bug start working on their emotions. What I would do? Talk to you dd to start being more assertive and give it more time with the teacher. 3rd day of school is too early worry. I would be wondering who is in class with my dd. You know by now the kids. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

My 4th grader is definitely starting to get hormonal on me. I was sooooo not ready for this. Yikes! This is precisely why I limit foods with added hormones, like milk. Only organic here. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Well I guess the all natural diet does work then huh? My oldest dd just started during the summer between 6th and 7th grade. Dammit son, I made another good choice for my kiddos 5 years ago! WOOO HOOO Oh, she hasn't got that far yet. This is just the precursor to all of that. She just has to wear deodorant now and wash her hair more carefully. 

Elf :) --- 17 years ago -

6 minutes is lost educational time, even during the first week of school. I would think that the grade level coordinator and administration would be concerned with that. If this consequence became habit, is there any motivation to stay on task if you are constantly getting punished for proper behavior? 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

My 4th grader is definitely starting to get hormonal on me. I was sooooo not ready for this. Yikes! This is precisely why I limit foods with added hormones, like milk. Only organic here.  I know, I'll probably get bashed for this...BUT I knew girls when I was in school that got boobs and their periods in 4th and 5th grade. Was it hormones in food then too? Some people just develop earlier, why are we blaming the food for everything? (IE gluten, red dye, corn syrup etc) We had ALL of this crap in food when we were kids, and we were just fine. I find it odd that parents are blaming everything but themselves or just life in general for the way their kids behave. Let the bashing begin!!! 

★ † 12 Stones † ★ --- 17 years ago -

and hormones, too, I guess In the 4th grade? It sounds unlikely but ok. I beg to differ I have a 4th grade girl who is 9 and she is in full blown puberty, BELIEVE me she has got hormones going all right! 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

We had ALL of this crap in food when we were kids, and we were just fine. Actually, we didn't, initially. We used to have neighbors across the street from us who worked for the USDA and they no longer eat meat. They said your hair would curl if you only knew how the animals are overcrowded, stressed out (which means you ingest all THEIR stress hormones), injected with hormones and a whole lot more that NO oNE in the outside world knows about. Momof5, you have an autoimmune disease. Don't you find it odd that everyone these days has an autoimmune disease? I don't kow, call me crazy, but I will pay the extra buck to feed my kids hormone free stuff. I was almost 15 when I started my period, so by rights my daughter should follow suit. 

Elf :) --- 17 years ago -

No bashing from me, and I think things have strayed a little off topic. While everyone is certainly entitled to their opinion on hormones and healthy foods, I am not sure this is what mommy2three was looking for. 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

Let the bashing begin!!! Ok Im first in line!!!! lol No bashing mom, I remember when I was in school, girls didnt even have boobs until 9th or 10th grade. Much less have a period. Sure there are the ones that are the exception to the rule, but it just wasnt the norm back then. You can check out drfeingold.com (sorry dont know how to link it) and see what has been discovered about the chemicals in our foods. I hope its helpful! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Momof5, you have an autoimmune disease. Don't you find it odd that everyone these days has an autoimmune disease? I don't kow, call me crazy, but I will pay the extra buck to feed my kids hormone free stuff. I was almost 15 when I started my period, so by rights my daughter should follow suit.  My Mom has this same disease/issue and was raised in the 1950's and 60's. I ate homemade meals MOST of my young life. My mom cooked real meals, not boxed stuff too often and was HUGE on greens and salads. I don't know what's wrong with me, and neither does any friggin' doctor! GRRR! Sorry for the hijack mommy2three. 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

In the 4th grade? It sounds unlikely but ok. Yes, Hormonal changes take place in the body starting at age 9. That is a medical fact. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

High fructose corn syrup, HFCS. ... This inexpensive sweetener flooded the American food supply in the early 1980s Sorry mommy2three, I am invading your thread. I won't post anymore. BTW, I agree with ELF. Maybe the teacher was sparing her feelings and that is why she chose to ignore her. kids can be so cruel! 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

Let's stick to the topic, please. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

... 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

6 minutes is lost educational time, even during the first week of school. I would think that the grade level coordinator and administration would be concerned with that. If this consequence became habit, is there any motivation to stay on task if you are constantly getting punished for proper behavior? I feel the same way. The 6 minutes was recess time, though. I believe in positive reinforcement for good behavior, etc. I am considering going and observing the class next week. The teacher will probably be on her best behavior, but at least she will know that I am not a passive parent. I will ALWAYS be my child's advocate. 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

Yes, Hormonal changes take place in the body starting at age 9. That is a medical fact. Let's stick to the topic, please. Ok fine, Ill stick to the original topic with ya! These are the things that I have done with my children, it may work for ya. Options: 1. Let it ride for a couple of weeks and see how things work out. 2. Volunteer at the school and spend as much time in that class as you possibly can. 3. Homeschool your children. 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

Thanks! 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I just realized mom2three that I misread and thought you said your child was new to the school. If your child went there last year, then you should be familiar with the staff there. I'm sorry I misunderstood that part of your post. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

It is generally not good practice for a teacher to use group punishment. Positive reinforcement of the kids doing the right thing goes a lot further than the kind of discipline you have described. Wouldn't it depend on the situation? Also, I have a question... People are CONSTANTLY complaining about the way kids are today. They are lazy, they are underachievers, we cater to them instead of having them reach their fullest potential, they aren't respectful of authority, they aren't taught personal responsiblity or accountability etc etc etc. So, my question is, all of these "positive reinforcement" tactics and self esteem boosters...are they working? 

Pollys Crackers --- 17 years ago -

I wouldn't trade places with any teacher. All of my teacher friends tell stories of terrible, rude, behaviors from their students and then have to put up with parents questioning why Johnny and Suzie were disciplined. Putting heads down for 6 minutes to regain quiet and control in the classroom is absolutely nothing in my book. No wonder teachers are leaving the field in droves! 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

Actually Jo, it is a wonderful and rewarding career with good job security in economically stressful times. For the most part, in this district we have wonderful students that are eager to learn and wonderfully supportive parents that send their children to school prepared to learn. We are trained to deal with behavior issues as they arise and yes, it can be stressful at times, but the rewards are worth it. 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

People are CONSTANTLY complaining about the way kids are today. They are lazy, they are underachievers, we cater to them instead of having them reach their fullest potential, they aren't respectful of authority, they aren't taught personal responsiblity or accountability etc etc etc. So, my question is, all of these "positive reinforcement" tactics and self esteem boosters...are they working? My daughter did nothing to deserve this punishment. If you are implying that my child is lazy, you should bite your tongue. She is a straight A student and has never had a discipline problem at school. Just because I don't beat my kid doesn't mean that I cater to her! I saw a woman in the grocery store parking lot slap her 2 little girls when they got to the car and it made me sick. Is the latter a way of boosting a child's self-esteem? 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

Kerry, Thanks for your input. I do trust HHE and my children have thrived there. I would hate to see one new teacher spoil the bunch, though. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

Wouldn't it depend on the situation? Also, I have a question... People are CONSTANTLY complaining about the way kids are today. They are lazy, they are underachievers, we cater to them instead of having them reach their fullest potential, they aren't respectful of authority, they aren't taught personal responsiblity or accountability etc etc etc. So, my question is, all of these "positive reinforcement" tactics and self esteem boosters...are they working? Well, I suppose everything depends on the situation. But for the most part, there should be a good balance between rewards and consequences for behavior. If you are punished even though you have done the right thing and continue to do the right thing..what is the incentive to continue to do the right thing? Having a positive atmosphere does not mean there are no consequences for misbehavior but a good teacher will have rewards built into her routines and the consequence of misbehavior will be to not be rewarded. I am not talking about material rewards either..most of the time children will work their hearts out for a special note home, a chance to help the teacher, to get to be in charge of something..stuff like that. Research has been very supportive of positive approaches to discipline. We all work harder for positive recognition so it isn't something unique to schools. The workplace has long recognized this. The biggest reason there are more discipline issues in schools (IMO and according to research) has been the lack of educationally supportive homes and the upheaval many children have in their homes and the lack of involved parents. It is very hard to take a child from a very unstructured home life with little or no emphasis on education to the realities of school. But most of the schools in our district are not overrun with discipline problems..granted a few can make it very challenging..but for the most part, the schools in Kingwood do not have huge problems with discipline. The teachers in our district have been trained in positive behavior supports and the schools have adopted the techniques. Postive Behavior and Supports 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

So, my question is, all of these "positive reinforcement" tactics and self esteem boosters...are they working? My daughter did nothing to deserve this punishment. I was speaking generally...I don't know your kid and to be honest with you, if she's crying in the 4th grade, I would be worried if I were you. Why are you getting so defensive? I was asking Kerry a question regarding discipline tactics in the classroom since she's a teacher. 

Rhea --- 17 years ago -

I don't think that it's ok to have six minutes of wasted time, expecially during recess. These kids need that time to run and excersise. They need to get their heart rates up so they can think and learn. I'm really against punishment during recess or PE. How about punishment before or after school if it has to be done and to the individual child needing the punishment. Let's not waste more of our children's days than we have to. I wonder about some teachers I see. IF you don't love these kids and what you do then get out. There are consequences when you do a bad job as a teacher. I had a bad teacher in the fifth grade. I still wouldn't spit on that woman if she were on fire, but she's bound to be dead by now. Watch out for your kiddo and let the teacher know your eyes are open. A good teacher would appreciate the involvement, and bad one needs to be watched. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

thanks for the response Kerry. :) I don't agree with the some of the measures taken to boost kids self esteem. Especially when it comes to sports and competitions, IE Science Fair, etc. I really feel that we are setting our kids up for failure because REAL LIFE doesn't give everyone second and third chances. In REAL LIFE, not everyone gets a trophy just because they signed up for a team. We don't need a snack after every single thing they do as a reward... The list goes on and on. I think the teachers have their hands tied a lot of times because placating the parents and child comes before education or discipline. This is jmo, of course. :) 

mommy2three --- 17 years ago -

...I don't know your kid and to be honest with you, if she's crying in the 4th grade, I would be worried if I were you. Maybe it's because the teacher is such a bi%&h and hardly spoke to the children on the first day of school. The fact that the first day of school may have been overwhelming to her may have caused her to get emotional, as well. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground