Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

You break it, you buy it. Right?

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
love4bdd 1
Lilteapot 1
Sandyr9111 2
Sarah75 3
AuthorMan 1
funmom 1
Cicero 2
Setta 2
Perfection 2
Lillabeth 3
OH SNAP! 1
zapper007 1
Ogre1 2
♥kerry♥ 3
Polly Ester 1
doglady 1
jhjlhar 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

I was at a garage sale this weekend when a lady dropped one of the items and broke it. The lady who was having the garage sale asked her to please pay for the item since she broke it. She said that since she didn't have a sign posted that read,"You break it, you buy it" that she couldn't make her pay for it. It was a glass bowl that the lady was asking $20 for. I can't believe the lady wasn't going to pay for what she broke. I've had several garage sales where people have broken items, but never right in front of me. I would have asked them to pay for if I had seen them break it. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, she should've paid for it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Why should she pay for it? If you are saying she should have felt bad and offered to pay something - that's one thing. But there is no law requiring it. Remember, people are becoming much more rude and selfish and self-centered. So she probably felt no reason to pay for something she broke. On the other hand, the homeowner was having a garage/yard sale and operating outside of State sales tax code (which a lot of people do, I am not saying that is a good or bad thing) - so any business protections that those who follow business regulations receive wouldn't apply to her. Garage sales and yard sales are a great way to make money and a great way to save money, but factually they are breaking the law. Doesn't make them right or wrong, just makes them what they are. A gamble. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Steve --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment Actually according to the comptroller they do not have to collect sales tax if you hold 1-2 sales a year or less. Agreed on that, although many tend to hold more than that - or skirt the law by having them at different locations throughout the year. It's not a big deal, just pointing out that garage sales are NOT businesses so they shouldn't try to act like them. They are what they are - private homes opening up and trying to get rid of unwanted items. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

Garage sales and yard sales are a great way to make money and a great way to save money, but factually they are breaking the law. is this true? i don't have them (we just donate our junk, but i do shop other people's junk ;))....but from what i understood, you even claim the "earnings" from them on taxes At that point the lady would have been in her rights to put a $20 scratch in the other lady's car and say "you didn't have a sign on it...." LOL! 

love4bdd --- 17 years ago -

At my last garage sale I had a Harley Davidson motorcycle telephone and this couple was looking at it, carrying it around with them for a while, asked me how much I wanted for it, and I told them, "$15".....he asked if I would take $10, I told him not this early in the day.....well theyc arried it around a little longer, sat it on the table, started inspecting it, picking up the phone, flipping it over, etc.....and they broke the back part of the seat off while flipping it over.....then had the nerve to come up and ask me if I'd take $10 for it NOW since the seat part was broken it!! I was like, "WTF?? YOU just broke it, and so now you want me to come down on it??" I told him it was $15 and he needed to pay for it..... They hemmed and hawed about it, and wound up giving me $12...... I still wasn't happy about it, but wanted it gone, and knew after that, I wouldn't even be able to get $12 for it broken...so.......But STILL! YOU BREAK! YOU BUY!! 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

Garage sales and yard sales are a great way to make money and a great way to save money, but factually they are breaking the law. is this true? i don't have them (we just donate our junk, but i do shop other people's junk ;))....but from what i understood, you even claim the "earnings" from them on taxes I don't think garage sales are against the law. They are against some deed restrictions, but that isn't the same thing as being against the law. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

It's not a big deal, just pointing out that garage sales are NOT businesses so they shouldn't try to act like them I've been to several Garage Sales where they did charge sales tax. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

BTW- If I broke something (or one of my kids did) I would absolutely think I should pay for it. If I was holding a sale and had something very fragile, I would keep it close to me because I have seen how some people let their kids play with everything as if it was theirs. 

Melanie --- 17 years ago -

BTW- If I broke something (or one of my kids did) I would absolutely think I should pay for it. Ditto! 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

I feel like this about this issue...and am getting ready to have a yard sale too. If I put my things out "neatly", SECURELY where they cannot get broken and am careful to watch the more valuable items closely and someone breaks something regardless of all my precautions used...to me...they should pay for it. It would mean that I used all the caution I could to protect my item, but they were careless causing the break...so they would owe me. Some people put their items on wobbly tables, or on the edge ready to be knocked off or next to something that might slip or slide over and break it and if I am looking at someone's garage sale and that happens and an item breaks because of "their" foolish preparation in display?!!!!...I don't feel obligated to pay...no. If though, I pick something up that they clearly cared about securing it's safety and I accidentally drop and break..."of course"...I wouldn't even have to think about opening my wallet and handing them the money for it...unless it was completely unreasonably priced for the item. 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Oh and if their kiddos break something...they should pay for it. Many times my boys would be picking up something and it would fall apart or break and if it were not fixable...we paid immediately! Oh and Love4...about your motorcycle phone...those dummies should have asked if you'd come off your price and when you said "no"...they should have decided "right then" if they were going to pay your asking price and if not...put the thing down for someone else to look at. To walk around hoarding something for 20 minutes while they "decide" is wrong and loses sales for you. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

I don't think garage sales are against the law. They are against some deed restrictions, but that isn't the same thing as being against the law. i didn't think so either...i've never heard that they were against the law....lots of people have them regularly...on KYS (a whole site dedicated to one having a garage sale), some people have an "on-going" garage sell....then, there are flea markets, which are a group of people having a garage sell.... 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

If you are saying she should have felt bad and offered to pay something - that's one thing. But there is no law requiring it. I am not sure there is a law that people have to pay for something they accidentally break in a store either. If there was..then some stores wouldn't put the signs up. I am sure the signs are put up to avoid haggling if something is broken and to not have to take someone to small claims court. If you break something in a store, it could be argued that you should only have to pay what the store owner paid for it, not what they are selling it for. So, as far as a garage sale..its not enforceable. But if someone breaks something the right thing to do is to pay for it and if a garage seller sells something as working and it isn't..they should refund. 

Lilteapot --- 17 years ago -

If you break you absolutely should pay for it. Of course nowadays, manners, and good moral conduct is becoming less practiced. Sad. 

Polly Ester --- 17 years ago -

Garage sales and yard sales are a great way to make money and a great way to save money, but factually they are breaking the law. Where did you get this? I do not agree that they are against the law. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

I am not sure there is a law that people have to pay for something they accidentally break in a store either. now this, i have experience with....we were at Wal-Mart and my son was carrying a figurine around, that he picked out for a girl's birthday party present....it was maybe $15/$20....we got all the way to counter, he went to put it on the counter, it fell and broke...i was thinking we would have to pay for 2 then (that one, and another for the party), but the lady said they don't do it that way, that no one pays for what they break, they just clean it up and write it up.... 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

While one may ought to have a moral obligation to honor "you break it, you buy it" there is no LEGAL obligation. Even with a sign. HOWEVER, as with anything it is always more complex than that. First, Steve's advise, to scratch the other persons car..uh, don't do that unless you want a trip in a patrol car. That would be willful destruction of property. A criminal act. Accidentally destroying or damaging another person's property is not criminal but the owner CAN if they so desire take civil action. Very basic common law doctrine that has been around forever. But for $20.00, it's likely not worth the hassle since you cannot recover court costs and/or attorney fees in small claims court. Commercial shops are covered by insurance for this sort of thing, art galleries (noted above) may not be due to the ... amorphous value...of their products. While they may threaten to call the cops, the cops can't do a bloody thing since, unless your actions are intentional, this would be a civil action. Garage Sales are only covered by the customer's moral standing. Oh well. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

BTW- If I broke something (or one of my kids did) I would absolutely think I should pay for it. Ditto 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

T Garage Sales or auctions, it is not uncommon for someone to steal a knob on an antique dresser or take a key from a clock or another other critical part of an item, etc. That is why you have to be careful when selling and buying. Check before and during the sale. We had an experience a couple of years ago in PA wher someone stole 6 arrowback chairs while we we taking other stuff home. Total crumbums... 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

T Garage Sales or auctions, it is not uncommon for someone to steal a knob on an antique dresser or take a key from a clock or another other critical part of an item, etc. Yeah, those people suck. Right along with the ones that change tags or take the Brand new with tags off of the clothes just to see if you will go down on the price or forget that it was a NWT's clothes item. Those people really chap my behind. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

I would've hit her in the nose. 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

i think she should have offered to pay for it.. when i had one last year i had a coffee table glass that is real thick well it got crowded and someone let their child run around he picked up a lamp and broke the table and the lamp.. she then had the nerve to ask me to give her some toys i was selling for a friend to her for free she wanted to keep her kids happy.. i told her no i saw her kid break my stuff i asked her about it she walked off. when i have my sales which isnt often it is to make money i take great care of my stuff but i sell it and if i cant i donate it.. i was fuming mad but what could i do. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

take the Brand new with tags off of the clothes just to see if you will go down on the price or forget that it was a NWT's clothes item. OH THOSE MAKE ME MAD! Had a lady pull that crap the last yard sale i had.....she pulled new tags off several things and I remembered what I had them marked and when i told her $15.....she said "Oh no price tags says $1 each on sign" Yeah but you ripped tags off all those items so they arent a freaking $!!! 

jhjlhar --- 17 years ago -

' 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I've been to several Garage Sales where they did charge sales tax. If they did not run the sale as a business venture, I would not pay sales tax. I might ask them for a copy of the last quarterly submission to the Comptroller's office. 

doglady --- 17 years ago -

The lady absolutely should have paid for the item she broke! And yes, garage sales are illegal in some neighborhoods - it is against their deed restrictions. I think most of Kingwood - it is against their restrictions, which is why they hold that community one - once or twice a year??? Don't live in KW so I am not sure. I will remember when I have another sale - to put out a sign that says - you break, you pay - and that way nobody can complain about that one. It's hard to keep an eye on everyone - especially in the early morning when they all show up in droves! You almost need someone to show up and be a "watcher" to prevent breakage and theft! You go to all the trouble to have the bloody sale, then they want to steal and haggle - really burns me up! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

it is against their deed restrictions. Deed restrictions are NOT laws. You violate a contract if you violate your deed restrictions. That does NOT make them illegal. It simply makes them contractually prohibited. You REALLY need to understand the difference. as I said, if someone breaks something accidentally at your garage sale, oh well, too bad for you. You can file suite, but there has been NO criminal activity. NOW, if someone steals something at your garage sale, then that is theft (unless they HONESTLY thought they had purchased the item or had no intent to steal - hey, I'm an airhead, I've walked out of Walgreens with a pair of new shades before...just forgot I had them). THEFT is a criminal act and you can call the police on them. If someone is violating their deed restrictions, and you want to look like an uneducated moron, then you can call the cops. Unless that person is also violating some city ordinance, they'll tell you there is nothing they can do. That is because violating deed restrictions is NOT ILLEGAL. Just in violation of contract. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

unless they HONESTLY thought they had purchased the item or had no intent to steal Heh. Not in Harris County. You accidentally walk out of the store with something and they will arrest you. Ask me how I know this. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground