Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: What does the US Constitution mean to to you?

who's talking here?

randyjet 2
rEVOLution 2
Perfection 6
Melissa 2
anti-antichange 1
Ogre1 5
Shenanigans 1
evolved 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: What does the US Constitution mean to to you?

There really are two positions. Either we follow the Constitution or we don't. Which do you choose?

It is outdated and we should not be tied to what it said. Vote
 
 8.6% (3)
It is the foundation of this country and should be followed as written. Vote
 
 91.4% (32)
Perfection --- 17 years ago -

There really are two positions. Either we follow the Constitution or we don't. Which do you choose? 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't really matter what it means to me if our elected officials don't honor or follow it. (I choose to honor it) 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Are those our only two choices? I disagree with you Chunky, and that attitude doesn't take into account the fact that the Constitution has changed over the years, with numerous amendments. Certain people think that the Constitution is not a living document; most notably Supreme Court Justice Anthony Scalia (who I deeply respect, but disagree with on a regular basis). The Constitution is the supreme law of the land, but there are numerous clauses in it that most people, and many of our leaders, do not completely understand. (The commerce clause comes to mind, particularly the DORMANT Commerce clause...ugh..I hated that topic in class. Let's not forget that the 2nd amendment as well has caused some issues with the way it is interpreted). That leads to questions about what exactly it means to follow the Constitution. This issue is WAY more complex than you want to project. Which is why we have the Judicial branch of government, to interpret that which is and is not constitutional. Of course, I've always thought the Const. was intentionally written to confuse by people who were afraid of a strong federal government. That way, people would be fighting over its meaning for years to come. But that's just my opinion. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't really matter what it means to me if our elected officials don't honor or follow it. (I choose to honor it) So if our elected officials are not following it, who's fault is this? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Ogre1, the Supreme Court is charged with that interpretation of the Constitution, correct. However our elected officials are operating outside of the Constitution and no one is holding them accountable, therefore the question needs to be asked. Do we believe in the Constitution as the law of the land or not. Obviously in practice we do not. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Do we believe in the Constitution as the law of the land or not. Obviously in practice we do not. That's the way I see it to. Many will say the Bible is outdated, misinterpreted, and very few live by it these days but that does not negate the fact that it does contain certain ideals that our laws were created from. But so many people these days dismiss these ideals as old and outdated therefore they should be ignored. The further this nation gets away from God and the ideals that this country was founded on the worst things will be for its citizens. The Constitution does not state that you have to be religious or even believe in God but it does state that the Constitution is the law of the land and there is no expiration date. And Ogre is right, there are many many amendments added as we move through time and evolve as a country but these amendments were created from the same constitution. Unlike an amendment they are trying to get put it right now that would remove term limits. That one is a direct contradiction of what the Constitution is all about. 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

So if our elected officials are not following it, who's fault is this? Chunky, I totally agree with you on this statement. Unfortunately, it takes more than just MY vote to make a difference. I don't feel that the majority of people that vote in this country take the time to do proper research on all the candidates. It takes a lot of time and effort, but I feel it is worth it to do a little digging before you head to the ballot box. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

That is a perfect explanation of how these people got the powers that they are abusing today. We vote based on what the TUBE tells us to vote on. But then again kids are graduating high school these days with little if any knowledge of politics or how to find out the history on who they might be voting for and adults these days are too wrapped up and preoccupied with the Rat Race to take time out to do any research. Coincidence? I don't think so. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

no one is holding them accountable, therefore the question needs to be asked. Do you know why? It's a two stage explanation: 1) the SCOTUS can never be a court of origination (In otherwords, the court cannot initiate actions). 2) The only people who can initiate actions are the very people we're talking about. But again, I still think the problem is much more complex than this survey implies. It's not so much a matter of following the Const. as understanding it. And most people don't. As an example. Does the Constitution say you have a right to privacy? It doesn't. No where in the document does it say that you have that right (Numerous court case and SCOTUS decisions have imparted that right based on interpretation of the Constitution). And yet, everyone screams when their "RIGHT TO PRIVACY" is invaded. These are the same people who want Roe v. Wade overturned, and yet, what R v. W addresses is not abortion, but a person's right to privacy in their affairs... This is just a narrow example of how people do not understand our laws, the constitution or how things work. THE FIRST STEP, is not complaining about our politicians, or even voting them out of office. The first step I think lies in returning our standards of education to what they once were. An educated populace is dangerous to a corrupt government. Right now we have kids who can't read and write when they get out of high school. Can't do basic math. Think Rap Star and Sports figures are heroes. It's sad and pathetic and I think, beyond all the political grandstanding about whatever politician, is the root cause for the current decline in this countries dignitas. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I agree, we need to be educated on what the Constitution is and how we have deviated from it. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

Good posts chunky, I agree with where you are coming from and wonder the same thing all the time. It seems once one becomes an elected official they can do whatever they want with the law and the public is too dumb to realize politicians will work outside the Constitution if they want. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

and how we have deviated from it. Well, I would actually just say "How we have changed it". Deviated has its own connotations. It was designed to be changed over time, and it has been, often for the better, sometimes for the worse. Other times it's simply been ignored. Same ole' song and dance dating back to the founding Fathers. (Look up the history of Marbury v. Madison for an example of the SCOTUS trying to overcome that for the first time..wiki's o.k. on this one.. here ya go.) Same ole song and dance. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I agree, we need to be educated on what the Constitution is and how we have deviated from it. The only President in recent memory who has deviated from it was BUSH when he imprisoned American citizens without charge or trial. I don't recall the GOP getting up in arms about that one. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I dunno Randy, I do kinda think that this whole Czar thing is in violation of Clause 2. But we don't really have a say, it's up to Congress to take a stand and I'm betting $1.00 they don't. And I'm not sure about the legality of the Pres. ordering corp. execs to quit. But of course, no one is going to take issue with that. Mind you, I think it was a good thing, I just ain't sure how legal it is. And I think we need to educate on more than just what the Constitution is. I honestly believe that it is one document that children should be required to memorize and understand. Maybe not higher concepts (i.e. dormant commerce clause...yech), but certainly at least the basics. 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

It's pretty simple even though the survey question is myopic. Judges believing laws to be constitutional have a right to pass sentence of fine and/or imprisonment-because that power was placed in their hands by the Constitution. But the Executive, believing the law unconstitutional is bound to remit execution of it because it has that power designated by the Constitution. The Constitution has ingeniously coordinated it's branches to be checks and balances on one another. To me the term "activist judges" is another politic BS term to align constituencies. They exist on both sides. 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

chunky, you can't say it is outdated when it is a constantly evolving doctrine. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Explain how it is evolving particularly in the definitions of State's Rights and powers of the President? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Explain how it is evolving Well, if you have READ the document, you will notice that there are 27 amendments to it, 17 of which have been added over the years since it was adopted. Not only that, but Congress passes LOTS of laws regarding thousands of things that were never thought of by our founders. ALL of those provide rules, regs, etc.. for a host of things, and they need to be interpreted by the Supreme Court. THAT is how it is evolving. As for the State Rights, it brings back memories of my youth, when the right wing BIGOTS and segregationists were using that in full cry to make sure the N*ggers stayed in their place and were denied their rights. Unfortunately, prior to that, until Brown vs Topeka, they had a case since the Supreme Court had basically overturned the 14th Amendment. NOW THAT is judicial activism on a scale NEVER seen before! It is also against the Constitution for the Supreme Court to overturn an amendment. I guess you sort of like that kind of judicial activism and simply ignoring the Constitution as it is WRITTEN! As for the powers of the President, those have been expanded by the War Powers Act passed by Congress. That was to enable the use of armed force without having to seek a formal declaration of war. There are debates as to the constitutionality of it, but if Congress grants it, and does NOT seek impeachment, there is nothing to say it is not right. Now if by states rights you mean that the states may leave the union on their own, that one has been settled by the blood of close to a million dead Americans. I think that is pretty significant and final. If on the other hand, you think that the states can TELL the Federal government WHAT to do, and HOW to do it, you are also mistaken. I suggest you read the Constitution. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

randyjet, do you understand what State's Rights are and how they are designed to work? I understand you have bias and you own since of discrimination against intelligence, but try to open your mind to some learning. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Jesus, Chunky, I took a whole class on State's Rights and we didn't solve a bloody thing. But basically, we came to the conclusion that after the Civil War, State's Rights do not exist. Forget the war powers act. Look to the Interstate Commerce clause, the Commerce act and the many court decisions related to the power of the Federal Government to act within it's boundaries. Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3 - The clause states that Congress has the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, among the states, and with the Native American tribes. NOW, define Commerce. If you don't look up the legal definition, then I assure you, that YOUR definition, as will Webster's will be WRONG in relation to the Constitution. Basically, ANYTHING that MIGHT be sold between states, from Apples to Zebra's falls into the jurisdiction of the Commerce Clause. They can regulate it civilly, or criminally (Elliot Spencer didn't get busted for banging a hooker, he got busted for transporting her across state lines!). But the Commerce Clause is nice, quiet, boring. So it doesn't get the attention that things like the War Powers Act which sounds really cool. So nobody knows just how pernicious it is. never mind that it include the Dormant Commerce Clause, which NOBODY understands. Basically, it says that anything that might eventually exists someday that could be traded across state line, which is not traded today but may be traded someday falls under the jurisdiction of the Commerce Clause. It doesn't even have to be a physical object; think carbon offsets, futures, heck, alien technology that may someday fall to Earth! And all this power falls to Congress. Which they have used liberally to control, regulate, and mitigate state's rights. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground