Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Are environmentalists scaring your kids?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 4
sunshine1881 1
planemom 4
NoNameNoLastName 2
Mabbers 3
ghostpost 1
Mommyto3kiddos 1
Wilstar77 1
FANCY PANTS 2
♥kerry♥ 2
JohnLynch 2
NewNanna 1
evolved 1
mommie21g1b 2
james osterberg 1
JeffSpicoli 1
theirsalways 1
I_Am_You 1
*momof5* 5
*poe* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Marcia Segelstein - Guest Columnist - 6/30/2009 7:35:00 AM There's a video currently making the rounds among schools (and on the Internet) which purports to explain to children how America's consumption of "stuff" is destroying the planet. Specially made to appeal to kids, with child-like animation, enough adults have bought into the message that it's being shown in classrooms across the country. Annie Leonard created "The Story of Stuff," and narrates the 20-minute video. In that short period of time, she manages to "teach" children quite a bit. I'll try to sum up a few of the highlights. First, the civics lesson -- a la Leonard. It's the government's job to watch out for us and take care of us. But the government has become more interested in taking care of big, bad corporations. The government is naughty for not doing enough for us. And big business is just plain evil. Now the story of how stuff is made. We start with extraction which, according to Leonard, "is a fancy word for natural resource exploitation which is fancy word for trashing the planet." Trees get chopped down, mountaintops are blown off so we can get metals out, and "we use up all the water and we wipe out the animals." Hmmm. I guess I missed the news that we'd used up all the water and wiped out the animal population. But just in case any school children in the audience were having the same thoughts, Leonard assures them that despite the fact that it's hard to hear, "it's the truth." Next we move on to the lesson in anti-Americanism. We, apparently, use up more than our share of natural resources. "My country's response to this limitation [of natural resources] is simply to go take somebody else's," says Leonard. "This is the Third World." Evidently American are just plain selfish. And cruel to poor countries, too. Back to stuff-making and production. What exactly is production? It's when we use energy "to mix toxic chemicals in with the natural resources to make toxic-contaminated products." I always wondered what factories were for. Continuing along the line, so to speak, we come to distribution. How does all this toxic stuff get into our greedy hands and oversized houses? Thanks to stores that keep prices low for consumers by not paying the store workers very much and skimping on health insurance for them. I guess it just can't be said enough: businesses are bad. She manages a few other jabs worth noting. On the topic of how awful it is to be a consumer, she makes fun of President Bush for encouraging people to shop after the attacks of 9/11. (He actually urged people generally to continue with their lives as normally as possible.) Perhaps she would have preferred an economic collapse. (Come to think of it, she probably would have.) She tells us that when choosing a picture to represent government, her friends told her she should use a tank. "After all, more than 50 percent of our federal tax money is now going to our military." (By the way, based on Congressional Budget Office numbers, that "fact" is wrong. It's more like 20 percent.) According to The Heritage Foundation, this little propaganda film isn't only being shown in American classrooms. According to a posting there, "This film has been heavily promoted, translate, and distributed in foreign countries." More self-loathing exported overseas. According to Chris Horner, a senior fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, "This is community college Marxism in a pony tail." The New York Times reports that the video is proving effective. Parents of one nine-year-old boy told the Times that their son worried whether buying a set of Legos would be bad for the planet after watching the video. There actually are important lessons to be taught about consumerism. But, in my opinion, they're more about the fact that money can't buy happiness, and that over-consumption is likely a sign of a sick soul, not a risk factor for killing the planet. If you want to teach your children a good lesson about the down side of over-consuming, I recommend the VeggieTales video Madame Blueberry. No amount of stuff purchased at the Stuff Mart manages to bring the title character true happiness. It will probably come as no surprise that Annie Leonard is a former Greenpeace worker. She's certainly entitled to her opinion, and to make a video espousing her opinion. But for schools to show this one-sided, environmentally-radical, anti-capitalist, anti-American video to children is unconscionable. The New York Times also reports that "hundreds of teachers have written Ms. Leonard to say they have assigned students to view it on the Web. It has also won support from independent groups that advise teachers on curriculum choices. Facing the Future, a curriculum developer for schools in all 50 states, is drafting lesson plans based on the video." So watch out. If your school hasn't already shown the video to your children, they may be planning to in the near future. Plans for a companion book and DVD are in the works. And if you think you can't make a difference, consider the father in Missoula, Montana, who single-handedly convinced the school district there to ban "The Story of Stuff" based on the argument that it violated standards on bias. Liberals don't have a monopoly on activism.  

evolved --- 17 years ago -

they need to be scared since the adults in charge of them are too scared or uneducated to give the truth. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

No. My kids have grew up with a much greater awareness of the footprint we are leaving on this planet than I ever had at their age. They have taught me to be more conscious of reusing and avoiding unnecessary consumption of our world's resources. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

They should be scared. Believe in Global warming or not, we can all agree that the water we drink, the air we breath and the food we eat is important. 

sunshine1881 --- 17 years ago -

The truth can be very scary at times, can't it? They should be scared. We all should. 

theirsalways --- 17 years ago -

The video sounds accurate to me, but my guess is that the public schools out here won't show it. I'm a little shocked that her Greenpeace experience was meant to cast ill repute and leaves some feeling threatened. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

We should all be scared. Trashing our planet is a serious subject. I hope the next generation does a better job than we do. What's the problem with being a former Greenpeace worker? Are you prejudging her ideas based on that? And when you call the video one-sided, etc., well, that's your opinion too. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

whatchamacallit --- Wow,bet Ya didn't see that comming. The Heratige Foundation scares my kids. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

What exactly is production? It's when we use energy "to mix toxic chemicals in with the natural resources to make toxic-contaminated products." I guess we should stop eating. Mixing flour with other products is bad for the environment. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

im glad everyone is getting scared, its about time! 

I_Am_You --- 17 years ago -

I doubt environmentalists are doing it. But I sure do. In my house we have a saying that all wee ones must know how to finish....it starts "greedy children get" and they know the answer "nothing". And greed isn't just about toys. Its about water, fossil fuels, waste, stripping of natural resource and turning a blind eye to the simple little things we can do every day that do help. 

NewNanna --- 17 years ago -

My kids have grew up with a much greater awareness of the footprint we are leaving on this planet than I ever had at their age. They have taught me to be more conscious of reusing and avoiding unnecessary consumption of our world's resources. Once we realized what our careless society was doing to the environment, my whole family started going green. Even my little grandkids know now to throw coke cans in one plastic bin, and paper recyclables into another. They each have their own cloth bags to help Mommy bring stuff home from the supermarkets. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

where are all of Whatchamacallit's supporters? Why aren't they outraged at teaching our children to be responsible for our planet? We are not nearly as green as we should be as a family...and I know a lot of families that are just like us. If children are made aware of recycling and reusing and being concerned with our planet as a whole at a young age, they'll never know anything different. How is that a bad thing? 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Trashing our planet is a serious subject. I see people who are concerned about things that they have no control over while our neighborhoods are being trashed. Why don't Americans start there where they can make a difference? 

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

What a bunch of crap! That's why I Homeschool. Too many libs in public school. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

You better believe that I want my kids to grow up with the self awareness that our resources are finite and not to be taken for granted. I believe taking care of our earth and the precious gifts it has given us is not only the responsible thing to do, but a Godly thing to do. 

JeffSpicoli --- 17 years ago -

Here is a link to a great organization which I have had the pleasure of being involved in: CLEAN (The Citizens League for Environmental Action Now.) The Citizens League for Environmental Action Now is working to clean up the air we breathe and improve the overall quality of the environment we all depend on. We offer solutions to improve Houston's air quality that will benefit Houston socially and economically. We encourage the public to speak out on these issues. cleanhouston.org 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

What a bunch of crap! That's why I Homeschool. Too many libs in public school. And I guess environmental responsibility is not part of your curriculum, right? 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

where are all of Whatchamacallit's supporters? Why aren't they outraged at teaching our children to be responsible for our planet? When I post, I do not need anyone to come to my rescue or even agree with what I post. Thanks for your concern. I post some things because I agree with them, some because I don't, some because they make for good debate and others simply to a rise out of certain people on this board. I have no problem with green living and try my best to practice it on a daily basis as part of my lifestyle. The problem I have with the article/video is it's villification of the American way of life. You can teach children how to do things a healthier, better way without teaching them that their country is evil. At least, I can. Can you? Why can't Annie Leonard? 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

You better believe that I want my kids to grow up with the self awareness that our resources are finite How do you know that they are finite in regards to how much we can use? 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I see people who are concerned about things that they have no control over while our neighborhoods are being trashed. Why don't Americans start there where they can make a difference? I tend to agree there Lynch. Do in your home. Teach your kids. And worry about your neighborhood and community. When the kids see trash, instinctively...they pick it up. It's not difficult. It is difficult to have to listen to monotonous dribble and, quite frankly, noise pollution. LOL. Arguing that is. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

FANCY PANTS --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment What a bunch of crap! That's why I Homeschool. Too many libs in public school. This statement explains so much! I have to say, I am glad and relieved that you homeschool too. Thank you :) 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

I tend to agree there Lynch. Do in your home. Teach your kids. And worry about your neighborhood and community. When the kids see trash, instinctively...they pick it up. It's not difficult. It is difficult to have to listen to monotonous dribble and, quite frankly, noise pollution. LOL. Arguing that is. Certainly you are right. I don't need anyone else to teach my child to do his best to take care of the earth. We simply try our best not to waste or buy lots things we don't need and to recycle as much as we can, not just papers, plastic and glass but to recycle by selling or giving away items we no longer need instead of throwing them away. Using things for other purposes, after their original use, we consolidate trips in our car, no matter the price of gasoline. I still drive a large vehicle because I want to keep my family safe, that is my biggest non-green guilt and I will continue until they either come up with a fuel efficient large vehicle or outlaw suvs. We simply live this way, no need to scare anyone into it, it should come pretty natural, if you are a thinking person. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I don't need snyone else to teach my child to do his best to take care of the earth. That's excellent that you are able to do that for your children. Not everyone is fortunate to have parents that care about the environment, to teach kids about litter and waste...some people don't care. So, if the kids are hearing about it only at school, that's a good thing! Cause they need to hear it somewhere. Why caring about our planet has become a "liberal" issue and something made out to be a bad thing, is beyond me. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

You can teach children to be good stewards of our resources without scaring them. I do feel some groups go to far. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

FANCY PANTS --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment What a bunch of crap! That's why I Homeschool. Too many libs in public school. This statement explains so much! I have to say, I am glad and relieved that you homeschool too. Thank you :) And I guess environmental responsibility is not part of your curriculum, right? You can teach your children to respect the earth and to take care of their surroundings without scare tactics or inflicting liberal bias and with no curriculum, it is a way of life. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I do feel some groups go to far. well, yeah! On every subject known to man! LOL. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Why caring about our planet has become a "liberal" issue and something made out to be a bad thing, is beyond me. There are groups out there that feel we should only be allowed two squares of TP because TP is made from virgin lumber. Some also feel that it's better if third world nations are left in the dark because of all the carbon that would be put into the air if they were allowed to enter the 20th century. This is where the liberal teaching comes in. I know most people don't agree with these statements but they are out there and being taught. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

There are groups out there that feel we should only be allowed two squares of TP because TP is made from virgin lumber. Some also feel that it's better if third world nations are left in the dark because of all the carbon that would be put into the air if they were allowed to enter the 20th century. This is where the liberal teaching comes in. I know most people don't agree with these statements but they are out there and being taught. and there are some christian religious sects that protest outside of military funerals...Do they speak for all Christianity? Are they a true reflection of the religious right? How about the movie "Reefer Madness" made in the 30's about smoking pot? How realistic is that portrayal? Common sense folks, it goes a long way. Are they inviting these groups in to speak to our children? NO. and they never will. Extremes will always exist, but to not teach our children about our environment and everything it entails because we're afraid someone might take it too far, is silly, imo. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

but to not teach our children about our environment and everything it entails because we're afraid someone might take it too far, is silly, imo. Yeah...how can teaching kids to care about their planet be a bad thing? It simply underlines what I say at home, driving home the point better. Mission accomplished. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Common sense folks, it goes a long way Yes, well, not all teachers have common sense. I don't really care that it is discussed in school. However, some of the stuff mentioned in the article is a little silly. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I teach my kids that "stuff" isn't needed. I teach them that the majority of toys are made by kids their age working for pennies in a sweat shop. My kids refuse to even purchase a kids meal with a toy in it because I have driven them by the dump and they were amazed at how high the pile of "stuff" was. I don't see it as a liberal issue, I am very conservative in my values and morals. I don't understand why the religous right believes trashing the planet is our right. I buy almost exclusively organic foods, only natural cleaners and detergents and refuse to allow any "chemicals" in our house if I can avoid it. We recycle everything we can. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

However, some of the stuff mentioned in the article is a little silly. See...I didn't even read it. Lmao. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

Yes, well, not all teachers have common sense. I don't really care that it is discussed in school. However, some of the stuff mentioned in the article is a little silly. Our environmental curriculum is well outlined by the state of Texas. We follow a set curriculum and I can assure you that it a very sound and age appropriate instruction. If you would like to review it, you can easily access the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for each grade level at the TEA web site. It might be a good idea for anyone nervous about what their child is taught to review it. BTW- I just attended a wonderful workshop dealing with teaching envirnomental awareness to elementary age students and there was nothing mentioned about "leaving 3rd world nations in the dark" or limiting oneself to "2 squares of toilet paper", but there were some very motivating and exciting experiments dealing with composting and decomposition in landfills provided by Texas A&M. 

*poe* --- 17 years ago -

Oh yes, god forbid kids learn about the earth and the importance of taking care of our home....what do people plan on doing,moving to Mars when we are done trashing this planet? Oh and TEACHERS teaching kids, Oh the horror!! Head out of A$$ my fellow humans! Havent you heard "Don't sh!t where you eat??!!" I hope and pray our kids do a better job than previous generations have taking care of our enviroment. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

what do people plan on doing,moving to Mars when we are done trashing this planet? Haven't you seen WallE? They will move to spaceships while robots clean up the mess. LOL 

FANCY PANTS --- 17 years ago -

What a bunch of crap! That's why I Homeschool. Too many libs in public school. This statement explains so much! I have to say, I am glad and relieved that you homeschool too. Thank you :) And I guess environmental responsibility is not part of your curriculum, right? You can teach your children to respect the earth and to take care of their surroundings without scare tactics or inflicting liberal bias and with no curriculum, it is a way of life. I teach my kids to respect the earth and use everything wisely. That they have to be responsible for their actions and that it is not the Governments place to take care of them. I how ever do not teach my kids to hate their country and to be ashamed of it. I teach them to be proud of America. America is a great country. Just hope it can stay that way. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground