Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Cap and Trade

who's talking here?

Fallon 1
planemom 13
Justwatching72 1
AuthorMan 5
NoNameNoLastName 7
KWPlanner 2
irt339 1
USNA Mom 1
justforfun 3
~sassy~ 2
Perfection 1
jtcitrus 9
Shenanigans 3
james osterberg 2
proud mama 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

planemom --- 17 years ago -

A bill with cap and trade may be voted on tomorrow in the House of Representatives. Any thoughts? Why isn't this being talked about as much as healthcare? It'll have a huge impact on everyone if passed. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

It'll have a huge impact on everyone if passed. Can you post something about it? What's O and his little band of minions screwing up now? lol 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

In his first year as Prez he's outspent more than any other by FaaaaaaaR....and he still ain't done. This guy REALLY DOES believe money grows on trees 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Cap and trade is bad news. Did you see the interview with Warren Buffet yesterday? He is not too positive right now. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Did you see the interview with Warren Buffet yesterday? No I didn't. I'll look for them. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Can you post something about it? Well I haven't read the 1000+ page bill so I don't know exactly what is in it. However, the essence of cap and trade is to limit carbon emissions. Each polluter (manufacturers, utility companies, ect...) will have to buy credits. If they pollute more than they are allowed they will be fined. What this will do is raise not just your utility bill but the cost of everything. Warren Buffet says it's a major regressive tax. It'll have a much more adverse affect on low income earners since they will have to pay a larger portion of their income for basic necessities. My opinion is it will do little to reduce carbon emissions while causing even more economic problems. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Bottom line- it's just another tax to try to squeeze more money from the hands of the folks to the government till. They try to justify this insanity by saying the planet will benefit. 

irt339 --- 17 years ago -

Warren Buffet says it's a major regressive tax. It'll have a much more adverse affect on low income earners since they will have to pay a larger portion of their income for basic necessities. The legislation would cost the average household $175 a year by 2020, according to the Congressional Budget Office, far below the figure commonly used by critics of the House bill. The CBO said yesterday that the poorest 20 percent of American households would actually receive a $40 benefit in 2020 from the legislation, which would establish a cap-and-trade system to limit greenhouse gas emissions, while the richest 20 percent of households would see a net cost of $245 a year. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

The cap and trade legislation is stupid. flat out. It represents a huge reallocation of assets to dealing with these trades, increases the size of the government, adds another appointee to be captured by industry etc, etc... If we must curb emissions, some kind of carbon tax would be far more efficient. Don't want to increase taxes? Make a "revenue neutral" tax swap for lower corporate/private income tax. The incentive to reduce remains, less admin costs for everyone than C&T, and smaller government than w/ C&T. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

The legislation would cost the average household $175 a year by 2020, according to the Congressional Budget Office, far below the figure commonly used by critics of the House bill. Is that the amount utilities will go up or does it include the increase of all the products we buy? If the price of gasoline goes up, the farmer has to pay more to produce food. The price of food will go up. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

What bothers me most is another 1000 + page bill is getting rammed through without debate. The final bill was released Friday. 

proud mama --- 17 years ago -

What bothers me most is another 1000 + page bill is getting rammed through without debate. That seems to be the strategy of this administration. Push, push, push so that things get done quickly. The O supporters praise him even more for the quick work he's done. In essence, he and his buddies are pulling a fast one over on the American people. As responsible adults, do you take on large amounts of debt without taking the time to study all the ramifications? Why is it ok for our government to do the same??? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Does the proposed cap and trade legislation call for the government owning the exchange? I find it hard to believe. My guess is that the exchange will be private, the government only dictates the cap, and companies choose how or if they want to reduce emissions. We already have cap and trade in place to regulate SO2, which causes acid rain. It's been in place since the early 90s, and it has been very effective in reducing the levels of SO2 at a low cost. I don't see why people are so upset about extending a mechanism that works. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

the concept is flawed.How do we determine what businesses will be included? The paper industry is the 3dr leading cause of environmental destruction.not only the trees but water usage,water polution,and more. How much polution does the internet cause?total electric usage,discarded toxic waste from IT Technoligy. Chemical usage and water to keep golf courses green. The 800 lb. gorilla,being Commie China's coal burning plants being built at warp speed. You could go on and on. It's a weak way to say you solved the problem. This is not the answer. 

USNA Mom --- 17 years ago -

The taxes from the cap and trade are supposed to help pay for our new socializes medicine. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

It's a weak way to say you solved the problem The problem we are trying to solve with this - CO2 emissions. Although all you said is perfectly valid, stating that a bill is bad because it is not solving problems it did not intend to solve does not make sense. I'm all for better controls over water and power consumption, but for those, supply and demand should take care of them. CO2, there is no incentive in reducing emissions. A very effective way to control is to define limits and create a market where allowances can be traded. Companies have a choice - invest on cleaning up their act, or buy allowances. Let the marketplace regulate the costs. What's wrong with that? As for China, simple solution - impose tariffs on crap we import from them to buy carbon credits. If they don't want to clean up their act, we will clean it up for them. It's their choice. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

What's wrong with that? It represents a huge reallocation of assets to dealing with these trades, increases the size of the government, adds another appointee to be captured by industry etc, etc... If we must curb emissions, some kind of carbon tax would be far more efficient. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

As for China, IMO ,this would be a devistating descision.It would signal protectionism to the rest of the world.That discussion could be a whole day worth of threard on here.Getting Commie China to become a part of the solution is important but I don't know 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

james, focus on the remote possibility of cataclysm 200 years from now... don't worry about imminent, ongoing, and virtually irretrievable ecological disasters in our own backyards that you could personally do something about! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

It represents a huge reallocation of assets to dealing with these trades, increases the size of the government, adds another appointee to be captured by industry etc, etc... If we must curb emissions, some kind of carbon tax would be far more efficient. Carbon tax is applied across the board by the government. Cap and trade gives companies options - reduce emissions, or buy allowances. Market regulates the cost of the allowances. Government only sets the cap. Cap and trade translates to smaller government, and creates profit opportunities for companies managing the carbon exchange. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

IMO ,this would be a devistating descision.It would signal protectionism to the rest of the world. And when China pegs its currency against the dollar, what do you call that? When Europe imposes tariffs to protect their farms, what do you call that? I'm sorry, no nation can criticize us if we decide to protect our industry and our jobs. They are guilty of the same sin. We are the only ones playing by the "free market" book. Then we wonder why our jobs are being exported. It's plain stupid. Instead of rising the bar for the rest of the world, we look for excuses to lower ours for everything - pollution, salaries, whatever. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Carbon tax is applied across the board by the government. to all or some firms or to all people. amount you pay is based on usage: incentive is to reduce usage. Cap and trade gives companies options - reduce emissions, or buy allowances. both of which are costs: reduce pollution (decrease output and/or buy new technology) or buy credits (purchase someone else's excess pollution rights. it's better than command and control, but now the firm has to pay someone to manage the contracts/transactions either in house or contracted out to firm. Government only sets the cap. Cap and trade translates to smaller government wrong. government sets the cap, polices the market, and most importantly: determines the distribution of pollution rights either annually or as often as they change the cap. Initial distribution of rights when can greatly affect the equilibrium market outcomes that are possible. translation: another Bureaucrat to lobby/bribe/capture. Advatage: largest firms. and creates profit opportunities for companies managing the carbon exchange. these companies(or branches of companies, or guy in an office) wouldn't exist with out the legislation. Therefore it's a reallocation of assets (time/human capital) from the efficient market outcome i.e. wasteful. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

And when China pegs its currency against the dollar, what do you call that? stupid. it's part of a desperate attempt to maintain an export based economy, and doesn't reflect the real economic growth going on at home. it benefits a few people, and generally prevents china's economy from developing as dynamically as it could. When Europe imposes tariffs to protect their farms, what do you call that? stupid. it keeps domestic food prices artificially high, misallocates resources into markets where they have a distinct comparative disadvantage, and as a bonus it keeps their agrarian/developing neighbors from selling some of the only stuff they can produce at lower marginal cost: food. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

both of which are costs And tax is not a cost? wrong. government sets the cap, polices the market, and most importantly: determines the distribution of pollution rights either annually or as often as they change the cap. Not the distribution of rights, only the caps. The distribution is determined by the carbon exchange, and the government stays out of it. Companies decide from whom they buy the credits. these companies(or branches of companies, or guy in an office) wouldn't exist with out the legislation. Therefore it's a reallocation of assets (time/human capital) from the efficient market outcome i.e. wasteful. Nope - you buy and sell in an exchange, like you buy and sell stocks or commodities. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

So if I am an American company being gigged because of all these new taxes, I guess I should not consider passing this cost on to the good old consumer. And, if I tire of all of the legislative bs- I guess it would be frugal to take my means of production to a more 'business friendly' country. When I do this, I bet the tree huggers are happy but the rest of the yappers will claim 'foul' at the loss of jobs. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

And tax is not a cost? yes it is. that's the point. either way represents an increased cost. which is what matters. The distribution is determined by the carbon exchange "Initial" distributions is what I was referring to... So initial distributions will be determined by auction? by previous emissions? by mandate? how? Nope - you buy and sell in an exchange, like you buy and sell stocks or commodities. and they'll have to pay someone to do that. someone who would be doing something else otherwise. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

I guess I should not consider passing this cost on to the good old consumer. of course you would, as much of it as you can get away with anyway. The whole thing is conditional on believing that fewer carbon emissions domestically is more beneficial than the costs associated with it... 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

It's like the Federal Reserve and the rediscount rate. If you are a bank and fall below the mandated reserve level, you 'borrow' the amount needed at the current rate. If the fed wants to penalize banks, just increase the reserve requirement and the rate and all will be lovely (for the fed, that is). 

KWPlanner --- 17 years ago -

There was a good Opinion piece in today's Wall Street Journal that discusses this exact topic: House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has put cap-and-trade legislation on a forced march through the House, and the bill may get a full vote as early as Friday. It looks as if the Democrats will have to destroy the discipline of economics to get it done. Despite House Energy and Commerce Chairman Henry Waxman's many payoffs to Members, rural and Blue Dog Democrats remain wary of voting for a bill that will impose crushing costs on their home-district businesses and consumers. The leadership's solution to this problem is to simply claim the bill defies the laws of economics. Their gambit got a boost this week, when the Congressional Budget Office did an analysis of what has come to be known as the Waxman-Markey bill. According to the CBO, the climate legislation would cost the average household only $175 a year by 2020. Edward Markey, Mr. Waxman's co-author, instantly set to crowing that the cost of upending the entire energy economy would be no more than a postage stamp a day for the average household. Amazing. A closer look at the CBO analysis finds that it contains so many caveats as to render it useless. For starters, the CBO estimate is a one-year snapshot of taxes that will extend to infinity. Under a cap-and-trade system, government sets a cap on the total amount of carbon that can be emitted nationally; companies then buy or sell permits to emit CO2. The cap gets cranked down over time to reduce total carbon emissions. To get support for his bill, Mr. Waxman was forced to water down the cap in early years to please rural Democrats, and then severely ratchet it up in later years to please liberal Democrats. The CBO's analysis looks solely at the year 2020, before most of the tough restrictions kick in. As the cap is tightened and companies are stripped of initial opportunities to "offset" their emissions, the price of permits will skyrocket beyond the CBO estimate of $28 per ton of carbon. The corporate costs of buying these expensive permits will be passed to consumers. The biggest doozy in the CBO analysis was its extraordinary decision to look only at the day-to-day costs of operating a trading program, rather than the wider consequences energy restriction would have on the economy. The CBO acknowledges this in a footnote: "The resource cost does not indicate the potential decrease in gross domestic product (GDP) that could result from the cap." The hit to GDP is the real threat in this bill. The whole point of cap and trade is to hike the price of electricity and gas so that Americans will use less. These higher prices will show up not just in electricity bills or at the gas station but in every manufactured good, from food to cars. Consumers will cut back on spending, which in turn will cut back on production, which results in fewer jobs created or higher unemployment. Some companies will instead move their operations overseas, with the same result. When the Heritage Foundation did its analysis of Waxman-Markey, it broadly compared the economy with and without the carbon tax. Under this more comprehensive scenario, it found Waxman-Markey would cost the economy $161 billion in 2020, which is $1,870 for a family of four. As the bill's restrictions kick in, that number rises to $6,800 for a family of four by 2035. Note also that the CBO analysis is an average for the country as a whole. It doesn't take into account the fact that certain regions and populations will be more severely hit than others -- manufacturing states more than service states; coal producing states more than states that rely on hydro or natural gas. Low-income Americans, who devote more of their disposable income to energy, have more to lose than high-income families. Even as Democrats have promised that this cap-and-trade legislation won't pinch wallets, behind the scenes they've acknowledged the energy price tsunami that is coming. During the brief few days in which the bill was debated in the House Energy Committee, Republicans offered three amendments: one to suspend the program if gas hit $5 a gallon; one to suspend the program if electricity prices rose 10% over 2009; and one to suspend the program if unemployment rates hit 15%. Democrats defeated all of them. The reality is that cost estimates for climate legislation are as unreliable as the models predicting climate change. What comes out of the computer is a function of what politicians type in. A better indicator might be what other countries are already experiencing. Britain's Taxpayer Alliance estimates the average family there is paying nearly $1,300 a year in green taxes for carbon-cutting programs in effect only a few years. Americans should know that those Members who vote for this climate bill are voting for what is likely to be the biggest tax in American history. Even Democrats can't repeal that reality. 

Justwatching72 --- 17 years ago -

The distribution is determined by the carbon exchange, and the government stays out of it. Which carbon exchange? 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I've searched and haven't been able to find a decent source for my next question. How much pork was added to the bill to get people to vote for it? 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

How much pork was added to the bill to get people to vote for it? Has to be zero. All of the pork for the next 20 years is in the stimulus package. :-) 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

And taxes will only be raised on the top 5% of taxpayers. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

How much pork was added to the bill to get people to vote for it? I don't know, but it went from 900+ pages to 1200+ pages over the weekend. check out: Read The Bill and Open Congress 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

From what I understand, Cap and Trade will increase utility bills on average 55%. That's gas and electric plus an increase in gasoline costs. It will be the biggest tax increase on Americans in history and is silently being pushed through while healthcare (which is becoming iffy at best) keeps the spotlight. These kinds of bills are what are dangerous and this administration sees the benefit in throwing three or four out there at one time. Eventually something they want will get passed with Americans having little to no idea what's going on. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

From what I understand, Cap and Trade will increase utility bills on average 55%. From what the news was reporting our utilities will increase 90%, our gas will increase almost 60% and natural gas will be at 58 to 60 %. Don't you just love this? 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

From what the news was reporting our utilities will increase 90%, our gas will increase almost 60% and natural gas will be at 58 to 60 %. Don't you just love this? Yeah, hit the American people in a place they can't possibly avoid it, their utilities. It's not like we can just turn off our electricity to avoid the tax. To me, it's very scary, our electric bills are high enough during this time of year. We don't have credit cards, school loans or anything like that. I just don't see what we are supposed to cut to pay for that. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

There goes my $13. :-((((((((( 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, hit the American people in a place they can't possibly avoid it, their utilities. It's not like we can just turn off our electricity to avoid the tax. To me, it's very scary, our electric bills are high enough during this time of year. We don't have credit cards, school loans or anything like that. I just don't see what we are supposed to cut to pay for that. This country is becoming scary. We will be taxed to death while some will find joy in it. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

There goes my $13. :-((((((((( You may need a bailout. ROFL All of us are gonna need one. lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground