Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What is the "greater good" and who defines it?

who's talking here?

MAR 1
eldiablo 2
Mabbers 6
get_the_lead_out! 3
~sassy~ 1
Perfection 6
oneyedman 3
voice of reason 1
sadiesmom 1
jamie 1
*momof5* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I don't know what it is or how it is defined or who defines it. Is greater good - majority rules? Help me understand here please. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Good question....I'd like the answer to that one myself 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Are you talking about utilitarianism? 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

greater good to me is when the benefits outweigh the drawbacks/risks. who decides what's a benefit? I guess that depends on the specific situation you're talking about. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

God help you if your not deemed part of the greater good..... Does "greater good" outweigh the individual rights? It shouldn't.... This language is a sure path to genocide. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

God help you if your not deemed part of the greater good..... LOL, dh thinks the online communities are simply priming us for the greater good philosophies. It's just a matter of time. Soon...we won't think about individual rights. Lmao. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 17 years ago -

I googled "greater good" and apparently it can be found in Dickinson. Good to know it's always close by! 

get_the_lead_out! --- 17 years ago -

Greater Good 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

"Greater Good" is a theory. A theory that it is good for all people as a whole. 

get_the_lead_out! --- 17 years ago -

I always thought good was the enemy of great 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

Soon...we won't think about individual rights. Lmao And that is funny? why? 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

Depends on who's making the rules. Seems to me it's usually used to make the argument that the person about the change the rules wants it done and the good they're referring to is aligned with their personal philosophies. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

And that is funny? why? Because to be fearful is not an option. If I can't single-handily make a difference, my choices are to move or acquiesce albeit noisily...perhaps. Yours truly laughs. I laugh at everything as the serious stuff happens all too often and I'm an emotional type. I won't show my kids fear. I won't show anger. I will, however, show them how to take things in stride, to hold onto their morals, to question everything and to do it with a smile on their face. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

Are you talking about utilitarianism? Ahhhh so you read Wikipedia! ;-) the opposite of "the greater good" is selfishness. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Ahhhh so you read Wikipedia! LOL, no...but I should as a refresher, cuz I can hardly remember the different types. It was in my favorite college course...philosophy. I really miss those classes. Fun, fun, fun. Beats formulas and equations any second of the day. LOL. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I just googled the greater good and saw this...we can discuss the notion with this playing in the background. I do believe it's apropos, sets a nice background. :D  

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

show them how to take things in stride Odd... When do things get serious? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I am just wondering because I have seen and heard people using this phrase but don't know why they seem to think something they want is for the greater good while what someone else wants isn't. What defines what is for the greater good? Who defines it? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

oneyedman --- 2 hours ago - quote - flag comment God help you if your not deemed part of the greater good..... Does "greater good" outweigh the individual rights? It shouldn't.... This language is a sure path to genocide. oneeydman, I am wondering what happens if you are not on the side of the greater good........ do you lose your rights? 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

I tend to agree with critics of utilitarianism...that an assemblage of utility is essentially futile as personal affliction and contentment are intrinsic and inseparable from that which is felt...personal awareness so to speak. This makes it virtually impossible to determine various levels of acceptance of each individual within a society, nation or civilization. 

eldiablo --- 17 years ago -

From the perspective of the Chinese government, limiting couples to one child each and aborting additional pregnancies is for the greater good; however, this conflicts with the individual rights of the parents to have a family of whatever size they choose (not to mention the rights of the unborn person). Its a question of convenience for governments or the rights of individuals. The US thrives only because of personal liberty and the right we all have to fail in our chosen endeavors. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

The US thrives only because of personal liberty and the right we all have to fail in our chosen endeavors. eldiablo, so how do you feel that people within the U.S. are using "the greater good" as justification for things they want to do? This could be anything from as simple as HOA rules to more complex social changes such as religion or education. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

bump for thoughts from the evening crew 

eldiablo --- 17 years ago -

eldiablo, so how do you feel that people within the U.S. are using "the greater good" as justification for things they want to do? I generally think that almost anyone who talks about the "greater good" is attempting to justify their flawed position, or is too lazy to come up with a solid argument. Try this...the greater good is served when individuals are free to pursue their dreams and are operating on a level playing field. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Interesting thought eldiablo. Seems that those who are using "the greater good" as their argument are simply trying to push through their own self-serving agenda. 

MAR --- 17 years ago -

Yep, look at what happened in the movie "I, Robot" It was all for "the greater good" 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground