Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Medical Bankruptcies - ABC fact check - Obama miscalculations and misrepresentations

who's talking here?

ukchristine 1
CommonSense 2
BaylorMom 2
justforfun 1
Perfection 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
Allimama 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

link title Medical Bankruptcies: A Data-Check March 05, 2009 12:37 PM President Obama’s kicking off his health care reform today in the worst possible way: with a mischaracterization of data. “The cost of health care now causes a bankruptcy in America every thirty seconds," Obama said at the opening of his White House forum on health care reform. The problem: That claim, based on a 2001 survey, is simply unsupportable. The figure comes from a 2005 Harvard University study saying that 54 percent of bankruptcies in 2001 were caused by health expenses. We reviewed it internally and knocked it down at the time; an academic reviewer did the same in 2006. Recalculating Harvard’s own data, he came up with a far lower figure – 17 percent. A more recent study by another group, approaching it another way, indicates that in 2007 about eight-tenths of one percent of Americans lived in families that filed for bankruptcy as a result of medical costs. That rings a little less loudly than “one every 30 seconds.” The extrapolation of Harvard’s data to “a bankruptcy every 30 seconds,” which Obama also mentioned in his address to a joint session of Congress last month, comes, per the White House, from a 2005 Washington Post op-ed by Prof. Elizabeth Warren, a co-author of the Harvard paper. Fact-check.org has noted that even using Harvard’s numbers, it’s more like a bankruptcy every minute; indeed if you add up all bankrputcies in a year you barely get one every 30 seconds. (I've e-mailed Warren for comment.) But more to the point is that the Harvard data are clearly inflated, or at best, mischaracterized. Himmelstein tells me that the reason for the difference is a change in federal law that sharply reduced the number of bankruptcies. In 2005, the year he and Warren wrote their op-ed, there were just over 2 million bankruptcies. Data out just today say that in 2008 there were 1.1 million (up sharply, by the way, over 2007). So this error in the White House claim stems simply from the fact that it's using out-of-date information. The next question is whether the estimate of “medical bankruptcies” is reliable in the first place. A good part of the problem is definitional. The Harvard report claims to measure the extent to which medical costs are “the cause” of bankruptcies. In reality its survey asked if these costs were “a reason” – potentially one of many – for such bankruptcies. Beyond those who gave medical costs as “a reason,” the Harvard researchers chose to add in any bankruptcy filers who had at least $1,000 in unreimbursed medical expenses in the previous two years. Given deductibles and copays, that’s a heck of a lot of people. Moreover, Harvard’s definition of “medical” expenses includes situations that aren’t necessarily medical in common parlance, e.g., a gambling problem, or the death of a family member. If your main wage-earning spouse gets hit by a bus and dies, and you have to file, that’s included as a “medical bankruptcy.” When I asked the lead author, Dr. David Himmelstein, about his definitions of medical bankruptcy back in 2005, he said, “It’s a judgment call,” and added that any death, for example, “to our mind is a medical event.” A last problem was sampling: The Harvard researchers surveyed bankruptcy filers in five federal court districts accounting for 14 percent of bankruptcies nationally; projecting this to the other 86 percent is sketchy. Said Himmelstein: “Obviously the extrapolation is rough.” Of such rough extrapolations are presidential pronouncements made. Himmelstein today told me that he’s comfortable saying medical costs, as his study defines them, are “a cause” but not “the cause” of bankruptcies. In his view, “It’s accurate to say medical problems cause half of bankruptcies. There may be other conditions as well but medical problems were causal. I wouldn’t be comfortable with it as the ‘only’ cause.” Worth keeping in mind is the fact that no one (apparently) disagrees about the pain medical expenses can cause to uninsured Americans. Prof. David Dranove of Northwestern University, who wrote the 2006 paper picking apart the Harvard study, noted that he has a new paper in the works showing that uninsured people who have a severe illness lose a substantial portion of their retirement assets. "There is general agreement: Being uninsured and getting sick in the United States is really a bad thing,” Dranove told me today. “But for academics the validity of the research matters.” In the Harvard paper, he says, "The methods were so poor they gave cover to those who want to dismiss the problems of the uninsured – they can say the only paper out there uses a suspect method." There’s been a fair amount of academic back-biting about this issue. On one hand Himmelstein, the lead Harvard researcher, is a co-founder of Physicians for a National Health Program, created to promote a government-run single-payer health system. On the other, Dranove took $5,000 from the nation’s health insurance industry for his report, which he says he now regrets for the criticism of his impartiality it’s engendered. Both papers were peer-reviewed. “It stinks to be uninsured. I don’t want to be quoted saying anything else,” Dranove says. “But there are correct studies, and incorrect studies. For academics, the validity of the research methods matters.” It should for the rest of us, too. Himmelstein’s referred me to a 2006 paper in which he replied to Dranove, whom he accuses of “several out and out errors.” Says Himmelstein: “They were paid by the insurance industry to make this critique… They were hired guns out to try and make a point, and used a variety of illegitimate techniques to make that point.” Science marches on.  

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

So seriously, is Obama that misguided, or is he selling us down the river on purpose? 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

it’s more like a bankruptcy every minute; well then.....this is definitely a much better scenario! “It stinks to be uninsured. I don’t want to be quoted saying anything else,” Dranove says. it stinks....congratulations for the understatement of the century. 

BaylorMom --- 17 years ago -

Are you surprised by this? Let's make up some figures to push our propaganda through. Of course I am pretty sure people will soon come on here and say it was just a gaffe, since he is so tired from running this country. 

BaylorMom --- 17 years ago -

I guess no democrats will comment on this thread. Their way of making O's mistakes go away. Yet if Bush or some republican was doing this they would be commenting left and right. 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

I guess no democrats will comment on this thread. Their way of making O's mistakes go away. Yet if Bush or some republican was doing this they would be commenting left and right. It's morning, since we don't have jobs we all get to sleep in. The drugs, orgies and late-night devil/Obama The Anti-Christ worship wear us out! Before anyone takes me seriously this is a joke, all the dems I know work hard at their jobs. Busy day at the office today but I will try to reply: Read the actual study!!! If you are lazy FactCheck went over it themselves in much nore concise details. The study is forthcoming in stating that it is hard to define a medical bankruptcy, and that sometimes an illness was the straw that broke the horse's back. They separated the data out very well if you take time to go through it. Here is an excerpt that shows that having health insurance is a factor: "A lapse in health insurance coverage during the two years before filing was a strong predictor of a medical cause of bankruptcy (Exhibit 3). Nearly four-tenths (38.4 percent) of debtors who had a “major medical bankruptcy” had experienced a lapse, compared with 27.1 percent of debtors with no medical cause" Regardless of data this country does need health care reform. Those with insurance are seeing premiums go through the roof and insurance companies are making record profits. Those without are clogging up out ERs and not seeking care until problems become much more serious (and expensive). This is more costly to us. We pay more taxes to cover it, and higher interest rates to cover those who put it on credit and went bankrupt. The cost on society will go down with the reform. The current system is inefficient and a lot of people needlessly die. There is also the serious matter of those who are responsible but are denied coverage. People who have insurance (good insurance) but whose company refuses to pay for a procedure or decides not to pay and sticks the person with the bill. I have personally been a victim of this, and I am sure everyone knows a person with a horror story. No matter how responsible you are if you get stuck with a 5-digit bill because your health insurance decided "it wasn't necessary" after doctors checked to confirm everything was okay it's not easy to pay in 90 days. There is also the fact that health insurance companies deny coverage to anyone with a "pre-existing" condition. 25% of Americans get cancer - they won't be able to get coverage. Well over one and a quarter million a year have heart attacks, and well over half live. Angina? Tough luck, even if it was just a little anxiety. Many live with chronic conditions - no coverage.Your only way out is a group plan. But what if you want to start or own your own small business? What if your company does not offer it? What about small businesses who offer it but then are weighed down in costs after an employee has a catastrophic illness and can no longer offer it? 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

So seriously, is Obama that misguided, or is he selling us down the river on purpose? It doesn't matter what O does or what he says there are always excuses made for him. I think media works harder on making up lies to cover O's butt then they report the news. 

CommonSense --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't matter what O does or what he says there are always excuses made for him. I think media works harder on making up lies to cover O's butt then they report the news. Great reply, way to read what I posted. Seriously, it's quite obvious you had no intelligent rebuttal to what I said. You're not fooling anyone. 

ukchristine --- 17 years ago -

“Himmelstein, the lead Harvard researcher, is a co-founder of Physicians for a National Health Program, created to promote a government-run single-payer health system” Good heavens…research under the auspices of a prestigious University was headed by a Prof with an AGENDA!!!!! “Prof. David Dranove of Northwestern University, who wrote the 2006 paper picking apart the Harvard study…………..”………….” took $5,000 from the nation’s health insurance industry for his report. Another Prof with an AGENDA!!!!!! “But for academics the validity of the research matters.” Clearly NOT for the Academic in Chief “Worth keeping in mind is the fact that no one (apparently) disagrees about the pain medical expenses can cause to uninsured Americans” This REALLY IS SO OBVIOS …BUT when the President quotes WRONG FACTS the serious issues get destroyed. Some will jump on that and therefore the REAL problem gets dismissed so much easier because he is twisting and misquoting the REAL FACTS. Panties situation is very real and really bad. Those kind of situations speak for themselves the Pres does not need to LIE. It does nothing to further the cause and just turns people off. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground