Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Health Care: a right or a privilege?

who's talking here?

Fiona 1
randyjet 3
sunshine1881 2
Fancy 2
Texas Girl 2
maverick 19
auntmarsa 3
Zionist NightOwl 1
stacy99 1
Cicero 1
txdaddy 5
Spartacus 1
RX8LVR 1
david 3
justforfun 10
BarNone 1
~sassy~ 9
rEVOLution 6
momof5 20
Perfection 10
fishlady 30
~Songbird~ 1
OH SNAP! 10
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 32
TurboPop 1
Wilstar77 2
Hiro Protagonist 4
anti-antichange 1
voice of reason 8
Jennifer 2
MomofTwins* 7
Nina 5
freefallin 6
Shenanigans 3
zombie slayer 10
CouchPotato 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Health Care: a right or a privilege?

With all the talk about socialized medicine, I was wondering if you all feel it is a right or a privilege to have health care. Health care is a right: Health care for every one, even if you do not work to pay for it. Health care is a privilege: You work to provide health care for yourself and family.

Health care is a right: Health care for every one, even if you do not work to pay for it. Vote
 
 64.2% (77)
Health care is a privilege: You work to provide health care for yourself and family. Vote
 
 35.8% (43)
Texas Girl --- 17 years ago -

With all the talk about socialized medicine, I was wondering if you all feel it is a right or a privilege to have health care. Health care is a right: Health care for every one, even if you do not work to pay for it. Health care is a privilege: You work to provide health care for yourself and family.  

Texas Girl --- 17 years ago -

I have unlocked this post. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

ok, i'll ask it over here.... for those of you who voted privilege....what exactly does one have to do to earn this privilege? 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

what exactly does one have to do to earn this privilege? hmmmmmm....looks like work and pay for it. at least that is what the answer says i think. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Thanks. I look at health care the same way I look at most things. If I want my family to eat and have a home then it's up to me to provide it. I could take my money and spend it foolishly and my family would suffer. I could allow my family to go without health care but they would suffer. I decide what my priorities are and take care of them. It's my family, why wouldn't I take care of them. I could just say no and ask the government to do it but then I wouldn't be doing my job. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

See I like the poll and what I think it is asking. I think that healthcare is a right. But the ability to pay for it dictates where you can receive it. If you cannot pay, you need to use the free community based clinics and Ben Taub. If you can afford insurance and/or to pay for the care, you have other options. The access to care is provided. Whether or not you want upgrades are something you have to purchase. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

hmmmmmm....looks like work and pay for it. at least that is what the answer says i think. well, my family works..... 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I think Healthcare should be like education and public safety. There is public education for everyone to take advantage of and if you can afford it, Private School is available too. The Fire Dept. is a "socialized" service never brought up. Imagine how it would be if your house was on fire and the Privatized Fire Department showed up and said, "Before we turn on the hose, it's going to be $5000 to save the bedroom, $10,000 for the living room and $2,000 to save your cat." 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I don't think health care itself is a privilege, rather the QUALITY of care is a privilege...and for THAT ya hafta pay. priv·i·lege (prv-lj, prvlj) n. 1. a. A special advantage, immunity, permission, right, or benefit granted to or enjoyed by an individual, class, or caste. See Synonyms at right. b. Such an advantage, immunity, or right held as a prerogative of status or rank, (and exercised to the exclusion or detriment of others.) 2. The principle of granting and maintaining a special right or immunity: a society based on privilege. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

See I like the poll and what I think it is asking. I think that healthcare is a right. But the ability to pay for it dictates where you can receive it. If you cannot pay, you need to use the free community based clinics and Ben Taub. If you can afford insurance and/or to pay for the care, you have other options. The access to care is provided. Whether or not you want upgrades are something you have to purchase. I thought we had the same opinion. We looked at it differently. It's my family and my responsibility to provide for them, not the government. How can anyone look their children in the eyes and say I don't want to pay for health care because I'm selfish and want to spend it on other things I don't need. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

How can anyone look their children in the eyes and say I don't want to pay for health care because I'm selfish and want to spend it on other things I don't need. I agree with you on this, we do need to be sure that people are making the right choices. But that comes with educating the parents, not hurting the children. Require budgeting courses. Now some people work hard, but they work at places where there isn't group coverage. They need a hand up, not a hand out. We can do better in this. We have to work to help those helping themselves and not focus on the ones who are beyond help. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

How can anyone look their children in the eyes and say I don't want to pay for health care because I'm selfish and want to spend it on other things I don't need. ok, seriously....i really take offense to that statement. i don't live an extravagant lifestyle, i don't drive fancy car, no mani-pedis, no new clothes, i made my kids' christmas gifts, i make some of their clothes, we don't eat expensive food, i gg to save money on groceries.....so how dare you say such a thing. i really hope your family never has to deal with the things my family has had to go through, i wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy.... 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

but *sigh* now that i've considered the source...i'm no longer offended. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

Is the ability to buy a loaf of bread a right or a privilege? I don't care what name you call it, you still have to pay for it. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

What I don't understand is don't we already have free clinics out the wazzoo? And medicaid too? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

you still have to pay for it. Well 'somebody' has to pay for it...and theirin lies the problem lol 

freefallin --- 17 years ago -

I have seen both ends of this and believe me you get better care when you can pay, I think the system in our country sucks, my mother for example works her butt off and has so called insurance but It isnt enough she is in debt with credit cards because she can't afford all the ridiculous co pays, prescriptions it is disgusting.....your right to proper care, sometimes with your LIFE hanging in the balance should not depend on the size of your bank account, with Insurance or not 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

I think that healthcare is a right. But the ability to pay for it dictates where you can receive it. If you cannot pay, you need to use the free community based clinics and Ben Taub. If you can afford insurance and/or to pay for the care, you have other options. The access to care is provided. Whether or not you want upgrades are something you have to purchase. I agree there are already ways to recieve care without having a nationlized healthcare system. My brother had 4 stints put in at Ben Taub and had no insurance and couldn't pay......they didn't tell him "sorry" can't help you. there are programs out there already. If you want better healthcare or more choices you should have to work to upgrade what you have now to afford better. 

freefallin --- 17 years ago -

It pisses me off and makes me sad at the same time the way we treat our sick and poor in this country, it is a disgrace, anyone remember the hospital that got caught dumping people on the street when they couldnt pay, they werent transferred to a "free" hospital , dumped on the STREET!!! 

CouchPotato --- 17 years ago -

I believe that every AMERICAN has the RIGHT to basic healthcare. Some people can't afford to pay for healthcare for their families, as it can be very costly, and I believe that the ones who can't afford it, should be the ones to recieve help. 

Fiona --- 17 years ago -

I agree we should have to pay for health coverage but at the same time $1000 a month for coverage is crazy. It should be more affordable and better coverage. Something needs to be done. 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

I agree freefalling, my parents monthly prescriptions cost over 500.00 and they only recieve less than 1600 in social securtiy yet they are expected to live off that, well my dad has always had other jobs to help pay for his social securtiy. I do however think that there should be a different reporting system for bad medical debts.....it goes on your credit report and can ruin your credit because you couldn't afford to pay that 20% of that surgery.......I know I will catch a lot of heat for this but my parents have always paid every bill on time, but they have so many medical bills and they pay a little on each every month but it still is on their credit bringing it down, making thier interest rates higher on everything else they purchase....leaving less money to pay the medical bills....... Medical bills are tough on everyone, but I still do not think socialized medicine is the answer. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

It pisses me off and makes me sad at the same time the way we treat our sick and poor in this country just curious....what country treats their sick and poor well? whichever one it is, maybe you should move there. maybe you would not be sick all the time. 

freefallin --- 17 years ago -

just curious....what country treats their sick and poor well? whichever one it is, maybe you should move there. maybe you would not be sick all the time. Lots of them Oh wait but that is Socialized medicine isnt it?? Yes that's right, I need to move instead of the USA taking a stand and doing what's right. 

auntmarsa --- 17 years ago -

The problem with all of this is that the doctors are not and should not have to work for free therefore, someone IS going to pay for it. If you say it's a "right" then in the same breath you're saying that someone has the "right" to charge one person for another person's care and I don't think that's what the country is built on. I think, I should have the "right" to help only if I choose. 

david --- 17 years ago -

I agree we should have to pay for our healthcare there are free clinics and help out there but don't force me to lose my insurance that I pay for because others can't or won't where are my rights as a consumer to choose what's best for my family. We have to have Food and electricity last time I checked randalls and reliant were still cashing my checks 

Nina --- 17 years ago -

I believe that every AMERICAN has the RIGHT to basic healthcare I will side with you there. I believe that the question is too broad for a real answer. What about the people that work and still can't afford healthcare? They pay taxes, should they suffer along with the people who have never worked? I think that you should have the privilage to choose your provider if you can afford it. Not wether or not to have healthcare. 

CouchPotato --- 17 years ago -

I agree freefalling, my parents monthly prescriptions cost over 500.00 and they only recieve less than 1600 in social securtiy yet they are expected to live off that, well my dad has always had other jobs to help pay for his social securtiy. I do however think that there should be a different reporting system for bad medical debts.....it goes on your credit report and can ruin your credit because you couldn't afford to pay that 20% of that surgery.......I know I will catch a lot of heat for this but my parents have always paid every bill on time, but they have so many medical bills and they pay a little on each every month but it still is on their credit bringing it down, making thier interest rates higher on everything else they purchase....leaving less money to pay the medical bills....... Medical bills are tough on everyone, but I still do not think socialized medicine is the answer. Why would you catch heat for this, it's YOU OPINION! We all agree that everyone in this country, young, old, rich or poor needs some form of healthcare, and that something needs to be done to lower the rising costs. Now if we could just agree on how to do that... LOL. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

Fishlady, if you watch the movie Sicko, I know you probably don't like Michael Moore. But it's not about giving free health care to the poor, it's about the need to improve the healthcare situation with the middle class. It's kinda like the mess that you're parents are going through. 

CouchPotato --- 17 years ago -

I think, I should have the "right" to help only if I choose. But WHO would do that choosing? 

auntmarsa --- 17 years ago -

I HAVE chosen, CouchPotato, to help people with their healthcare costs. In addition, my church helps those in difficult situations also so my tithe goes towards that. Obviously, I'm happy with either of those choices. Letting the government choose for me? not so happy with that option. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

Lots of them Oh wait but that is Socialized medicine isnt it?? Yes that's right, I need to move instead of the USA taking a stand and doing what's right. name one. i want to tear it apart on other things to find out if it's worth giving up other freedoms to treat the sick and poor better. 

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

The access to care is provided. Whether or not you want upgrades are something you have to purchase. please tell me you do realize that you have described socialized medicine here. 

CouchPotato --- 17 years ago -

I am one of the lucky ones, my DH is in the union, and they pay for our healthcare insurance, but we still have a deductible, and even then the copays after that can be outrageous. But it's the ones who do work and CAN'T afford it that I am talking about. The poor should have access to free healthcare, and should undergo a screening process to make sure they qualify, but there should also be in place a system to help out the ones who work their hineys off and still can't afford it. 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

Wilstar, there is no way i could ever stomach to watch Michael M. I don't even want to type his name....he is nuts! LOL I personaly think the healthcare with the middle class is not the problem, it is with our elderly and poor, like single parents, MW earners.....those people need options and they have them it is called medicaid and here in Houston Ben Taub...... Couch Potato.......LOL, well I thought I would "hear" it because there are several people on KU that do not think you are entitled to your own opinion....lol 

auntmarsa --- 17 years ago -

CouchPotato, The government has done such a pitiful job of screening for current programs, why in the world would we think they'd do a good job on this one? 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

I personaly think the healthcare with the middle class is not the problem, it is with our elderly and poor, i don't even know what "class" we fall under, but i don't consider us poor.....and we barely survive because of the cost of the healthcare. 

freefallin --- 17 years ago -

tx daddy due to your obvious lack of compassion I'm guessing you havent been poor? Or subjected to sub standard healthcare, like others maybe then you wouldnt sound so heartless, I lost a loved one due to lack of quality healthcare because he didnt have enough money/coverage, if we had been in France or England he would still be here because he would have recieved his care no questions asked. As far as me proving stuff to you- do your own research before you run your mouth at me !! 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

The problem I have is the government having control over my healthcare....... the next thing is if he nationlizes healthcare who the heck is going to want to go to school to be a doctor. I am sorry I think they deserve what they make in MOST instances.......they went to school for over 8 years, had plenty of all nighters, internships, their jobs has the lives of other people literally in their hands, the pressures, the hours, being on call.....I know a couple of doctors and they work 14 hour days sometimes 7 days a week.........who is going to want to go through all that to be a doctor when it is nationlized healthcare and the government is telling them what they can and cannot do? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

but there should also be in place a system to help out the ones who work their hineys off and still can't afford it. You got that right! It should chap all our arses that illegals can sneak over here and have their babies delivered at NO cost while our own poor can go to hell. Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground