Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Am I a bad parent?

who's talking here?

Fancy 1
ET 1
Deltadawn 1
random 1
*Vanessa* 1
RX8LVR 1
Setta 11
Perfection 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
soccer14drama 1
N.S. Sherlock 1
Yeah Im a John so what? 4
JustEngaged 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Setta --- 17 years ago -

This year we "owe" taxes. I "could" claim DS still (20) because he still lives at home and goes to college and works (only part time in 08)...but is here rent free..no bills other than his own. Last year I told him "tough"..we were claiming him, and he got really upset over that. This year though, we have decided to let him claim himself, which gave him close to 1100.00 more than had we claimed him! Because he claims himself, WE lose now money that could have been applied to "our" taxes...1500 of it almost. Do you think it's only fair that we should get some of the return he gets? Had we claimed him as we should have, he'd only have recv'd 530 back...but since we didn't...he is getting over 1500. DH said that we should let him get 1000 and take the 500....but I am feeling very bad about that. DH said that we're still doing him a favor because even at that he still gets 500 more than he would have otherwise. I just don't know what to do here!..and we REALLY "NEED" the money badly right now! I just don't want DS to feel like we're bad parents by taking "his" money! Opinions please...I need to know what to do and this one is boggling to me! Love DS and want to do right by him, but don't want to rip ourselves off either! 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I think it is fair. And it teaches him that life isn't a free ride. At 20, it is time for that lesson. 

Deltadawn --- 17 years ago -

Is he on your car insurance? Health insurance? Since he works and you do not charge him any room & board, you would think that he would want to give something back. 

ET --- 17 years ago -

Is he a full time student (or almost full time)? If he is and isn't paying rent then you should claim the deduction. If he isn't in school you should be collecting rent from him and he gets the deduction. 

random --- 17 years ago -

ditto ET's answer 

soccer14drama --- 17 years ago -

I think you have every right to his refund. He is blessed to have parents who allow him to live at home while he goes to college. I remember my brother having this same issue with my parents long ago and they explained that they were paying for his college, insurance, meals, etc., and until he was on his own, his refund was to help out with expenses. Maybe let him buy himself a "treat" of some sort, but the rest should be yours. 

N.S. Sherlock --- 17 years ago -

You are entitled to the deduction for a reason. Basically, by giving him the deduction you are entitled to, you are just writing him a check out of your own pocket on top of what you are ready handing over to him. There is nothing wrong with supporting your child through college if you can afford it, but to let him profit off of it is ridiculous. Why are you letting him call the shots? 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

He is on our insurance to save him money, but he pays his portion himself. He pays his own car note too and his own food for the most part as he eats out a lot. He pays his credit cards, but in 08, he ran short sometimes because he was only part time and so we sort of filled in the gap for him. We should get part of his refund based on the water usage from him alone!!!!!!!!..lol...he showers three times a day...morning when he wakes, when he comes in from work and before bed!...not to mention we are constantly turning lights off behind him and he has a big screen tv in his room he leaves on a lot too that uses energy. DH and I got home from seeing Blynda's Gbaby last night (adorable I might add), and pulled in the driveway, looked up and his TV lights flickering through the shades and he was not home!...ugh. 

Fancy --- 17 years ago -

There is nothing wrong with supporting your child through college if you can afford it, but to let him profit off of it is ridiculous. Why are you letting him call the shots? I agree and in this house, it wouldn't even be up for discussion. He'd get what he normally gets. If he wants it all, tell him to support himself. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

My husband and I had conversations about this, although our oldest doesnt live with us but if he did we would not take his money. the decision is yours, talk to your son communicate, every family is different explain to him the financial or whatever you guys are going thru. Maybe he will understand and help out. Dont be so torn. Good luck 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Well, he is sitting this semester out because he didn't get registered in time. He pretty much pays his own school fees but I have helped in the beginning and a little the second semester but the third, he paid it all himself. We do not charge him rent and his school schedule is only part time also...half time they call it. Now though starting in Jan 09, they put him to full time at his job, and he will be still half hours at school next semester...but no rent here...or utilities or groceries....he pays his gas, car, insurance, credit cards and pleasure money (although I bought him a nice pair of shoes at Dillards the other day that were on sale...told him he needed to pay me back but then told him I'd buy them for him...ugh..I'm weak!) 

Yeah Im a John so what? --- 17 years ago -

You should call the cops on him like you do people on KU 

RX8LVR --- 17 years ago -

I think I would let him know that as long as he lives at home, under your roof, rent free, etc., that YOU will continue to claim him. On the flip side, if you let him claim himself, then you should suck it up and be proud for him... That money now belongs to him, unless he owe's you money, etc. Maybe it is time to consider charging him rent? 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

You should call the cops on him like you do people on KU LOL...Okaaaaay...whatever you say guskk =) 

Yeah Im a John so what? --- 17 years ago -

LOL...Okaaaaay...whatever you say guskk =) are you denying you called the cops on anyone on KU? 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

I think I would let him know that as long as he lives at home, under your roof, rent free, etc., that YOU will continue to claim him. On the flip side, if you let him claim himself, then you should suck it up and be proud for him... That money now belongs to him, unless he owe's you money, etc. Maybe it is time to consider charging him rent? Well, I think he'd prefer to offer part of the refund then to have to pay "monthly" rent...so I guess I should give him the options and see how he handles his own decision. I also want to leave "how much" of his refund he desires to let go of...just to see how he thinks when it comes to appreciating living here for nothing. 

*Vanessa* --- 17 years ago -

I have mixed feelings on this... I clearly remember the day my mom asked for my Tax Refund. I'm not sure how old I was but I think I was still in High School. I was sooooo upset because I worked hard for my money. But now as a parent myself I see how much we spend on our kids. Seeing as how your son is 20 I would not ask for part of his return but I would start charging him rent. He is an adult now and it's time for him to pay his own way. Even if it's just $100 a month he should be paying something. 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

are you denying you called the cops on anyone on KU? What is your point?...do I know you? Should I care about "you" and any question you have for me...is there a POINT?...if there is something beneficial that will come from answering your question, please by all means let me know...will ya? 

Yeah Im a John so what? --- 17 years ago -

What is your point?... To show that you call the cops on people that dont agree with you. So you did call the cops on KU 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Seeing as how your son is 20 I would not ask for part of his return but I would start charging him rent. He is an adult now and it's time for him to pay his own way. Even if it's just $100 a month he should be paying something. Well, if I charge him rent, I'll have to pay part of his other bills...lol...it's catch 22 really. We need the money right now, and I know he can't afford to pay rent really, so this is one way to recoup "some" of what we spend on him throughout the year...that is why typically I would claim him...but this year wanted him to feel that he is grown up and let him pay us a portion...but it's just a hard thing to do..ask your kid for money even though he "should" pay it...you know? 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

To show that you call the cops on people that dont agree with you. So you did call the cops on KU So who wants to know this?..."you"...rofl...go away...you are insignificant. Now, if someone I know wants to ask me questions...I'll give it some thought...why would I want to talk to a perfect stranger that is creepy?...lol 

JustEngaged --- 17 years ago -

I don't think you should especially if he is paying for his own schooling and working part time. And i don't think it is a good idea to charge him rent either cause him just going to school and working speaks a lot on his character. Why would you discourage what he is doing by making it that much harder and stressful on him. You need to chill out its not easy for him I know I did the same thing working and paying for school and it was the most stressful time I have ever been through. How would you feel if he wants to charge you rent when you are old and he is taking care of you. So you reap what you sow just think about it.... Just be proud that you have such a self motivated boy and support him and chill about the little stuff it will pay off for the both of you in the end. 

Yeah Im a John so what? --- 17 years ago -

why would I want to talk to a perfect stranger that is creepy?... ok you are calling me creepy when you are the one calling the cops on people for not agreeing with you. thats the point im making. 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

I don't think you should especially if he is paying for his own schooling and working part time. And i don't think it is a good idea to charge him rent either cause him just going to school and working speaks a lot on his character. Why would you discourage what he is doing by making it that much harder and stressful on him. You need to chill out its not easy for him I know I did the same thing working and paying for school and it was the most stressful time I have ever been through. How would you feel if he wants to charge you rent when you are old and he is taking care of you. So you reap what you sow just think about it.... Just be proud that you have such a self motivated boy and support him and chill about the little stuff it will pay off for the both of you in the end. If we had plenty of money right now I would...believe me. When we get old, he'll have our retirement money and SS to help support us...we have nothing to help support him now. He is an awesome young man...seriously a great kid. If he keeps it, he'll probably blow it...and then we'll still have to help him throughout the year. He is working but he loves his job...it's not really like "work" when he's there...he'd be there if he didn't work there anyway most of the time. His school, isn't costing him that much and we do help him usually with that. He uses a lot of water and electricity and does eat at home and I do give him money for gas in his car and pay part of his cell phone for him because he just "had" to have that G1 and now his monthly bill is 80 bucks so he can have the added internet service on it! I do feel justified in taking some of his refund...maybe 350 or 400 of it and let him keep the rest, only because we need the money right now, but it's still hard to ask..even though it feels right...wish I didn't need to ask. 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

ok you are calling me creepy when you are the one calling the cops on people for not agreeing with you. thats the point im making. Oh ok...ok then, you have made your important "point"...so what did you accomplish?...are you OK now?...feeling alright?...everything OK?...are you? 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Ok...thanks for all the advice...I think I will just have a talk with him and leave the choice up to him and see where it goes from there. If he doesn't want to give any of it...that'll be his choice, but then I do think we'll probably be enforcing some rent money. If he does and does it freely and because he wants to to help with his expenses here, then we'll let it go a while longer for him to get more ahead. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground