Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

does anyone think it is wrong to use religion...

who's talking here?

Fallon 1
randyjet 2
planemom 2
Pet Lover 1
Zionist NightOwl 1
txdaddy 1
Perfection 1
Sebastian 1
ladybughomeschool 3
Ogre1 7
Turd Burglar 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Sebastian --- 17 years ago -

as a basis for a discussion that will effect many people? i.e. gay rights, abortion, ext.. I'm writing a paper about this and wanted to get some input. i personally believe as an atheist that ones religious views and arguments have no merit in a debate considering that no religion is proven or dis-proven. thankyou for you comments 

Turd Burglar --- 17 years ago -

no because religion influences peoples beliefs and drives their opinions 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

Why should whether religion is objective or subjective matter? If it governs how people treat their fellow man, then it's relevant. Religion permeates our whole culture, either directly or indirectly (as in your case). Why in the world would you want to discount its influence? 

Pet Lover --- 17 years ago -

If it governs how people treat their fellow man, then it's relevant. I agree with this statement. Don't forget where you came from. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

considering that no religion is proven or dis-proven do tell what "theory" has been proven? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Depends on the context of the discussion. If we're talking about a political discussion, (and your suggested topics tend to lean that way) then, in this country, I think the answer is that it is inappropriate to base the legislation on religion, but think that the attitude will be affected by the prevailing religion at the time. The problem starts when the prevailing religion is interpreted for politcal purposes. One example of this is our social more about polygamy which has been elevated to the status of religious dogma. While the Bible does address the issue of polyandry, it does not address the issue of Polygamy. (though many try to interpret passages saying it does, as a legal scholar reading those passages, I don't see it.) BUT, despite maybe someone wanting more than one wife in this country, it is illegal. And the reasons given are "biblically" based. So in this case, the majority religion, badly interpreted and twisted, affects the rights of numerous minority religions (Mormons, Muslims, Pagans who support Polyandry, etc.). This is the most obvious example. But misinterpretation of religion is the prime problem in using to govern people. Ever wonder what the difference between a Shite and Suni Muslim is??? It's ain't much. But people die because of it. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

considering that no religion is proven or dis-proven Hmmm.. you can't really DISPROVE a theory. You can only prove a theory. And NO religion, not even my own, has ever been proven. Religion is based on faith. IF there is such a thing. Science is based on fact. If there is such a thing. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I think you are confusing religion with the belief of God. Religion is a vector which some people use to worship God. Religion is very real. It is the basic structure of churches and other groups. It is tangible and solid. The existence of God is a real feeling and relationship to those who believe. You cannot prove "love" either but it is the basis of so much of what we do. Our love of God is as real as our love for our families.Therefore it is real and valid. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

But that's not the question, Ladybug. The question was about RELIGION. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Right, Ogre, religion is real. The belief and God is real. It should be just as part of any debate as love would be. Maybe my early morning words are not expressing what I mean very well. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Maybe my early morning words are not expressing what I mean very well. Maybe, but I do get what you're saying. I'm just saying that it doesn't really address the question posed here. The belief and God is real. That's true for every person who has a faith. But I can just about guarantee that my vision of God and your vision of God do not coincide (except maybe in some very basic ways), and that's true not just of Christian (which I assume you are) and Pagan (which I am), it's true between Christians as well. GOD is like a snowflake. (wow, that's deep..not). But even then, that just goes towards the problem of our interpretations of God as a means to govern society. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

do tell what "theory" has been proven? Gravity, theory of relativity, all scientific laws and theories. I suggest you try defying gravity and put your trust in God and step off a VERY high place. We need more contestants for the Darwin Awards. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Thanks for the response Ogre. I would like to discuss it later. I am not abandoning the conversation but the kids at church are very real and I have the priviledge of teaching this morning. Have a super day. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

you can't really DISPROVE a theory. Science does that all the time. They get a theory, test it, if it works, the theory is valid, if not, it is disproven, and either modified or tossed. You cannot disprove a negative I think may be what you are thinking. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I don't see how a person who is religious could discuss those topics without referring to their religion. A truly religious persons' religion would permeate all facets of their life. Could they discuss it without mentioning the Bible, yes. But all the knowledge they have obtained by reading the Bible and believing what it says would still be there. Since they believe what the Bible says, it would influence their point of view, even if they didn't reference any specific passages. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I have the priviledge of teaching this morning. Have fun. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Frame of reference always matters. If you don't understand the culture of whom you are dealing with you will fail. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

They get a theory, test it, if it works, the theory is valid, if not, it is disproven, and either modified or tossed. Randy, you don't know how scientific theory works. They DO NOT disprove a theory. BUT, they may replace it with another proven theory. I.E., you don't disprove that the sun circles the earth, you PROVE that the Earth circles the sun. You don't disprove that man can't fly, you prove that man can fly by building a hot air balloon. Scientific theory is based on positivism. When some scientist says "let's prove them wrong" what he's really saying is "Let's prove us right." It's pedantic. But that's the way it's really done. Why? because proving something wrong leaves a vacuum in knowledge. This is why you don't see reputable scientist arguing against "Intelligent design" (plenty of "political" scientists do), it's because they have nothing positive to replace it with. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

If you don't understand the culture of whom you are dealing with you will fail. True... The Romans were masters at this. I prefer to refer to the Mongols. The were GREAT invaders. Made the Romans look like pikers when it came to taking over countries. BUT, when the finally successfully took China, what happened? They didn't take into account the Chinese social structure and wound up being absorbed into it. Thus, no more Mongols. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Lets take the gay marriage issue in CA right now. It did not pass - by a huge majority. Were the votes against is based on the voters religion? Try to separate out a persons fundamental beliefs, from the way they vote. Can it be done? Abortion too. I am not for it, but I also do not thing it should be a legal issue. It is a medical issue. Period. A doc makes the call. So if this happens, do you think that after one woman comes in for the 4th or 5th time, that the doc is going to keep doing this? And good luck finding any doctor who will perform a late term abortion. Babies can usually survive outside the womb at this time. I personally know several doctors, not one has said that they have ever heard, or could imagine, that a late term abortion would ever be necessary to save a woman's life. So most doctors would view that as murder. Murder is wrong. Why? Why are taught murder is wrong? Religion. Fundamentally religion has always been used to elevate a society to a higher lever. Be kind to other, be charitable, do no kill, do not be envious of others, etc. But do you have to be religious to have these values? Heck no. Plenty of good atheists around. Several on here, who are the first ones to step up and donate and help when the KU Angels ask for help for someone. I don't see that it is a bad thing to have a guide of goodness to go by, aka religion. But you do not have to be religious to be a good person. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

But you do not have to be religious to be a good person. That is true. Nor does being religious make somebody a good person. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground