Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Group Project assignments (school/college)

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
planemom 1
ukchristine 4
HsMommy 1
LadyScot31 1
Perfection 1
Danielle 1
txnkingwood 1
Yosamitesa 1
guido. 1
Squareduck 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ukchristine --- 18 years ago -

I have heard stories of how (for example) in a group project consisting of 4/5 people 1 or 2 do most of the work, 1 or 2 do little or nothing and 1 or 2 go with the flow. At the end of the day project is presented and everyone gets the same grade. Does this just put unfair pressure on the ones who really care and do not want to risk a bad grade and therefore forced to work much harder? Does it give an advantage to the slackers? I believe this type of teaching was invented as it was thought it mirrors the work place ….”working together”…but does it? In real life situations how many people work on a project with others as a large part of their job? I would be interested to hear opinions from teachers at the high school and especially college level if they know how much some students work versus how little others work. And from the point of view of those in the work force…is this type of teaching useful? I am also interested in hearing from the students themselves. Are group projects a good or bad idea? Do you learn a lot this way...or end up resentful? Is this good prep for real life?  

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

At Quest HS, much of the work is done this way. Since it is a small school, it quickly becomes apparent which students are the slackers, and nobody wants to work with them. Peer pressure is very strong there, and eventually the slackers either learn to pull their own weight, or transfer out. My son went there, and just graduated from college. He is more prepared than most for that type of work, and can take over the leadership role easily. 

Yosamitesa --- 18 years ago -

I did this in high school and in college a lot. I had fun in high school when we would get everyone together, one person deligated out who did what and we all worked on it together. In college, my favorite group project was in my Organic Chem II class. We got an evaluation by the class and the professor for presentation, however we also go an evaluation for each individual in the group on how we felt the work load was distributed. The grades were given based on the individual evalutation first, the teacher evaluation second, and the class evaluation. It was split like 50%, 35%, 15%. 

HsMommy --- 18 years ago -

For the most part I do not like group projects because of your above mentioned reasons. On the otherhand they can be fun too if you have a group you enjoy working with. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

I have heard stories of how (for example) in a group project consisting of 4/5 people 1 or 2 do most of the work, 1 or 2 do little or nothing and 1 or 2 go with the flow. At the end of the day project is presented and everyone gets the same grade. Does this just put unfair pressure on the ones who really care and do not want to risk a bad grade and therefore forced to work much harder? Does it give an advantage to the slackers? Isn't this much more fair - this way there is no differentiation between those that do well and those that don't. We want to be fair after all. 

ukchristine --- 18 years ago -

Chunky...sarcasm (I hope) And.....anybody else have an opinion? I know a lot of this type of teaching goes on and perhaps it works better when the group meets during class and the teacher knows who is doing the work. But how do they (teachers) know that when the group meet outside classroom? 

LadyScot31 --- 18 years ago -

I do group work in my class, but I assign (or let the kids choose) specific tasks that need to get done. Then I give two grades: one for the individual and one for the project as a whole. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

You forgot to mention the person that wants to do the entire project by themselves and doesn't want input from anybody. IMHO, group projects are like life. You'll have some groups that work well and some that don't. You need to have the skills to work in both. 

Squareduck --- 18 years ago -

I am currently involved in a group effort in two of my classes at Lonstar College. I have been disapointed in both groups. It seems to me that some people have the attitude that since they are apart of a group it is not necessary for them to do the work or particpate. Some of us have had to pick up the slack because we would be out points or grades if the work does not get done. Just this week my group flaked on me. I had turn in my part of the project alone and hope that the instructor wouldn't mark me down for my groups failure to particpate. 

guido. --- 18 years ago -

It happens every time I go swinging. I am the one doing most of the work and the ladies just lay there. 

Danielle --- 18 years ago -

and the ladies just lay there. Why did I peg you for the kind that wanted a take control kind of woman? 

ukchristine --- 18 years ago -

Planemom...you make a very good point...and yes, real life can be just as frustrating and require adapting I do, however think squareduck described the more common senario. My "kid" described what is happening with a group project and it sounds like what you describe.....perhaps YOU are my "kid"!!!!LOL 

ukchristine --- 18 years ago -

Guido...are you complaining..or boasting? I had better not say anymore on THAT subject.....just in case squareduck IS my "kid"""...LOL And..BTW please don't hi-jack my thread!!!!!(What the heck am I doing by replying...I am just encouraging you!!!LOL 

txnkingwood --- 18 years ago -

As the mother of three, (college graduates or in college now), I think group projects are ridiculous, especially at the middle school and high school level. It happens exactly as the original poster described. One or two do all the work, one or two do a little of the work, one or two do none of the work, and they all get the same grade. My older child was not afraid to tell teachers about 'problem' students in her assigned groups (and sometimes the teacher adjusted grades accordingly, but not always), but the other two were not as vocal as the first, and got the shaft many times. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground