Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The perils of groupthink

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
smartypants 1
ladybeachbum 6
Mabbers 1
~sassy~ 2
ExLady In Blue 1
Dynomite 1
Perfection 9
Shana 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Does this sound like something familiar? Groupthink occurs when the pressure to conform within a group interferes with that group's analysis of a problem and causes poor group decision making. Individual creativity, uniqueness, and independent thinking are lost in the pursuit of group cohesiveness, as are the advantages that can sometimes be obtained by making a decision as a group—bringing different sources of ideas, knowledge, and experience together to solve a problem. Psychologist Irving Janis defines groupthink as: "a mode of thinking people engage in when they are deeply involved in a cohesive in-group, when the members' striving for unanimity override their motivation to realistically appraise alternative courses of action. Groupthink refers to a deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing, and moral judgment that results from in-group pressures." It can also refer to the tendency of groups to agree with powerful, intimidating bosses. The concept of groupthink provides a summary explanation of reasons groups sometimes make poor decisions. Indeed, groups are supposed to be better than individuals at making complex decisions, because, through the membership, a variety of differing perspectives are brought to bear. Group members not only serve to bring new ideas into the discussion but also act as error-correcting mechanisms. Groups also provide social support, which is especially critical for new ideas. But when new perspectives are rejected (as in the "not invented here" syndrome), it is hard to correct errors. And if the social support is geared toward supporting the group's "accepted wisdom," the elements that can make groups better decision makers than individuals become inverted, and instead make them worse. Just as groups can work to promote effective thinking/decision making, the same processes which enhance the group's operation can backfire and lead to disastrous results. How Groupthink Works Janis identified seven points on how groupthink works. First, the group's discussions are limited to a few alternative courses of action (often only two), without a survey of the full range of alternatives. Second, the group does not survey the objectives to be fulfilled and the values implicated by the choice. Third, the group fails to reexamine the course of action initially preferred by the majority of members from the standpoint of the nonobvious risks and drawbacks that had not been considered when it was originally evaluated. Fourth, the members neglect courses of action initially evaluated as unsatisfactory—they spend little or no time discussing whether they have overlooked nonobvious gain. Fifth, the members make little or no attempt to obtain information from experts who can supply sound estimates of gains and losses to be expected from alternative courses of action. Sixth, selective bias is shown in the way the group reacts to factual information and relevant judgments from experts. Seventh, the members spend little time deliberating about how the chosen policy might be hindered by bureaucratic inertia or sabotaged by political opponents; consequently, they fail to work out contingency plans. Three general problems seem to be at work: overestimation of group power and morality, closed mindedness, and pressures toward uniformity. Group-think occurs when a group feels too good about itself. The group feels both invulnerable and optimistic. The group feels morally right. Linked to this attitude of perfection is a correlative close mindedness. Warnings are ignored. Messengers of difference are dismissed. Negative, stereotypical views of opponents are created and used. Finally, there is pressure for uniformity. A certain amount of self-censorship occurs. If individuals have questions, they keep them to themselves. This lack of dissent results in what Janis calls an "illusion of unanimity." If any difference does occur, group pressure is applied to bring the dissident into line. Janis also mentions "the emergence of self-appointed mindguards—members who protect the group from adverse information that might shatter their shared complacency." If these precipitating problems support tendencies to groupthink, there are predisposing conditions as well. Janis suggests four conditions that predispose a group to groupthink: cohesiveness, group isolation/ insulation, leader intimidation, and an absence of decision-making procedures. As a group "hangs together" and members grow to like each other, there will be greater pressure not to introduce disturbing information and opinions that might tear at that cohesiveness. Maintaining the good feelings that come from such cohesion become part of the group's "hidden agenda." The insulation of the policy-making group is another factor. Frequently groupthinking groups are removed from interaction with others, perhaps because of their position within the organization. Lack of impartial leadership is a third contributing cause. When powerful leaders want to "get their way" they can overtly and covertly pressure the group into agreement. Finally, the lack of a template or protocol for decision making, or what Janis calls "norms requiring methodological procedures for dealing with decision making tasks," can also contribute to groupthink. How to Avoid Groupthink There are several things businesspeople can do to avoid groupthink: follow good meeting procedures, including the development of an agenda; aim for proper and balanced staff work; present competing views; and attend to correlative meeting problems, like exhaustion. A template for discussion might also be useful. One suggestion is to use an "options memo technique" in which information is presented as a problem statement, a list of options, and a preliminary recommendation. The group then looks at the preliminary recommendation with at least four questions in mind: 1) is the logic correct? (in selecting the preliminary recommendation from among the options); 2) is the judgment correct? (the logic may be fine, but the judgment may be poor); 3) are there any problems or errors remaining in the preliminary recommendation?; and 4) can the preliminary recommendation be improved? In order to prevent group isolation, it may be helpful to bring in new participants on a regular basis, use outside experts, and invite the group to meet off-site so that changes in settings and surroundings are a stimulant. To avoid groupthink, it is vital for the group leader to become a statesperson or conductor instead of a partisan virtuoso. Leadership almost always involves getting work done through others. High-quality decisions are not made through intimidation, whether intentional or unintentional. Some bosses have no idea why people do not speak up, while the reason they do not is because they are likely to be attacked. Bosses encourage the best performance from groups when they can alert them to the kind of review that is expected. If the leader can be clear, and temperate, there is a great likelihood that norms of disagreement will develop. Finally, there is the cohesion process itself. Decision making tears at the fabric of group cohesion, and it is the desire to preserve cohesion that is an underlying dynamic of groupthink. But if decisions lower group cohesion it is not necessary to avoid decisions; an alternative is to rebuild cohesion each time. One way to accomplish this rebuilding is to complete decision making by about 65 percent of the way through the meeting, then move on to brainstorming for the last 20-30 percent of the meeting. People who have differed before have a chance to continue to interact, now around less threatening, future-oriented items. This meeting technique allows for decompression, and for rebonding of the group. Because of the flaws of individual decision making—selective perception, excessive self-interest, limited knowledge, limited time—most important decisions today are made in groups. And groups can do a spectacular job; but they often do not. Meetings, the place where groups do their decision-making work, have a bad reputation these days, largely because of processes such as groupthink. Groupthink is the result of flawed procedures, poor leadership, insulation, and an unmanaged desire for the maintenance of group cohesion and its good feelings. These factors can be addressed positively, and group decision making improved, while groupthink is kept to a minimum.  

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Precisely why I'm a rebel. LOL. And I encourage my kids to do the same. :D Heh heh. Shh, I didn't read it all. :) 

Dynomite --- 18 years ago -

Thank you for pointing this out. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Yet another where I tried to help you avoid the trap. Don't say you weren't warned. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Look at what is happening on here these past few days.

Groupthink?

Mob mentality?


Just askin. 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

You did mean MOD mentality, right? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

No ladybeachbum, I meant mob mentality just as I stated.

It will be nice when Adam does show all that the mods have done, and then I will wait for everyone's apologies.

Until then, enjoy the mob mentality of groupthink that you all are falling in to. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

It will be nice when Adam does show all that the mods have done, and then I will wait for everyone's apologies.


Did you just say that out loud? 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

Chunky, I don't see a mob. I see over moderating. I see anyone going against the mob getting shown the POWER of the MOD group. No one is saying any one MOD is doing what, but when threads are locked and people are iced at a rapid rate, what else are we to think? I admit, I scanned the post because it is too long. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

After what and your buds did to me and my Gay Group Meeting Thread? 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

WWWOOOOOOOOWWWWWWWWWWW!!!!!!!!!!!! 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

Earlier today, someone posted about the mods "flexing their muscles" right off of the bat, yet everyone FAILED TO ACKNOWLEDGE that there were a lot of people on KU that were acting like a 5th grade class that had a substitute teacher that didn't know any better. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

I invite you to go with me next time Chunk. I really think you will get to experience the truth in what you just posted.
You will only have one regret...That you didn't go sooner:D 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

Sorry, Ex, I was knee deep in working on my other house full of crap and mold and wasn't on KU. Sometimes, I just have to work! Now, if all of that wasn't deleted, then I could see what you are talking about, but really shouldn't we be able to decide by looking at the threads?
KU used to be so much better, then got really bland when many left, now it is hanging on by a very thin thread. Over 100 people on but only a handful brave enough to speak. Sad. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It will be nice when Adam does show all that the mods have done, and then I will wait for everyone's apologies.


Same here chunk, same here


I sit back and shake my head at what some of these THINK they know.

Seriously, it's almost laughable. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

What's happening here isn't group think. What's happening is Newton's Law: for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.

Mods wouldn't be getting so much attention if they were doing a better job. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I get a good chuckle from it.

Groupthink is a bad trap to fall in to, the mentality just feeds upon itself much like locusts looking for their next meal until they have consumed not only their food source but each other too. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

smartypants, it is a little of both, agreed. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

But I am a firm believer in people should be able to moderate themselves. That is where the groupthink comes in to play, as does the mob mentality.

People are being egged on and the guesses as to what is happening are more and more off base. 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

I think if the mods would give it a break, the Group would settle down and be able to have some good KU threads. This site isn't and has never been something obscene or I would not give it any of my time. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

I invite you to go with me next time Chunk. I really think you will get to experience the truth in what you just posted.
You will only have one regret...That you didn't go sooner:D



And again...Just keep poking Chunk.
This is what Bullies do.



Come to the meeting:D 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

I haven't gotten in any trouble with the Moderators....hmmm.... 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

Who exactly do you think is egging our Group on? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

ladybeachbum, not who but what. groupthink is an entity all its own.

It is bigger than a person.

Doesn't make it wrong, doesn't make it right. It is what it is. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Mods wouldn't be getting so much attention if they were doing a better job.


It's the SAME group, day in, day out - the SAME 25%.

They didn't like us yesterday, they don't like us today and they won't like us tomorrow.

We're damned if we do, we're damned if we don't.

I will do my job to the best of my ability - and for those who don't like it, they should hit revolt.

Now, I have an apple cake to decorate. 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

I guess I don't follow because I don't follow the group unless the group makes sense. I am sorry, I am going to out myself on this thread because I am too tired to read the entire post and maybe I should. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

ladybeachbum, a good lesson is groupthink is the Cuban missile crisis during the Kennedy administration. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

Lets all take advice from Chunk....No thank you.


Your actions are your words. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

But I still invite you to the meeting :D 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

ghostpost --- 3 hours ago - quote - flag comment
I will be honest and say this mod bashing by mostly libs is getting very old. Take the blinders off and honestly look at what is happening.

I'm not a liberal, and many other people posting opinions are not either. It seems whenever there are differences on here it has to boil down to that..tiresome.

However, it certainly appears that there are some personal issues going on with some of the mods. It is sort of like management 101..if you go in as a new manager and start throwing your weight around and flexing your muscle right off the bat..you can guarantee people will take notice.

I was completely on board with the new mods and really try to be objective on issues. I would prefer to let a few things go here and there without complaining and accept that there is a learning curve. But blatant stuff is pretty hard to ignore.

Why all of a sudden this heavy handed moderating? Was the forum having such a hard time before this new election? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground