Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What is the role of government?

who's talking here?

smartypants 1
RRay 1
planemom 2
Sandyr9111 1
NoNameNoLastName 10
mamajulie 2
lemingrebel 4
Forecaster 1
rEVOLution 3
Perfection 5
justcat 1
flyonthewall 1
keepinitreal09 2
BigBlue 1
POTUS 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I see a lot of comments stating what government should NOT do. I have a different question - what, in your opinion, should the government provide to us? Security? Education? Let's keep the discussion around what the role of the government should be, and not around what it should NOT be. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

http://www.capitalism.org/faq/government.htm Now I am not going to copy and paste that here since it is rather long but it is a great review of what government should really do. In my own words - there are different levels of government that each should have their own seperate powers. Federal government - protect us militarily from harm both inside and outside the country. Provide us with interstate guidelines for commerce - yes including business standards for safety. We need to remember, it is the governments repsonsibility to protect ALL citizens - not just some. You cannot protect some citizens at the expense of others - there is no equity in that. Allow each person to live and work on their own merits - give them the ball and let them run with it, don't hinder them by taxes. 

BigBlue --- 18 years ago -

The U.S. Government should collect just enough taxes to fund a military to protect our borders. Anything else should be left to state and local government. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

The U.S. Government should collect just enough taxes to fund a military to protect our borders. Anything else should be left to state and local government. I don't know you - but I think I love you!!! 

justcat --- 18 years ago -

Great for those of us in Texas,probably not so much for those in Wyoming. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Great for those of us in Texas,probably not so much for those in Wyoming. But that is their choice to live in Wyoming. See that is the great thing about States rights - it gives citizens the freedom to choose. 

lemingrebel --- 18 years ago -

The Federal Government's job is to protect our boarders by maintaining a well trained and equipped military. Keep our highways fixed and efficient to keep interstate commerce going. To establish good trade relations with other countries so they will buy as much of our stuff as we buy from them. That last part is where we're really screwing up now. Thanks Wal-Mart! Other than that, the fed should leave the rest to the states to figure out. Most importantly, they need to stay out of my wallet and my bedroom. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Let's make the question more generic - government in all levels, as I don't want to enter in a discussion of which level should provide what, but rather what we, as citizens, should expect in exchange for the money we pay in taxes. What should it provide us? I see an agreement around national security, and I believe most people would agree with that. I also see another good point - interstate commerce regulation. How about international commerce regulation? Should the government have a role on this? Should the government define the standards for countries that want to do business with us? Or create import taxes for goods and services coming from countries that do not follow standards similar to ours? How about transportation infrastructure - i.e., highways, public metropolitan transportation such as buses, subways, etc.? Should people have an opportunity to find work away from where they live without having to depend on a car? Nobody mentioned education. Can a democracy, a government of the people, by the people, and for the people, survive without educated citizens? Can we succeed as a nation without educated people? If not the government, who will provide equality of opportunities through education? Nobody mentioned retirement either. Personally I think you can measure the dignity of a nation by the way it treats its senior people. Health Care - as it is today, we all finance free health care. People without health insurance wait until they are sick enough and go to the emergency room. We foot the bill. I can't think of a stupider way to provide basic health care to people. Is there a better way to do this, and should the government have a role? For example, medicare administrative costs run at 5%, while insurance companies spend on average 15% (and that's not taking profits in account, which push the number even higher). 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

To establish good trade relations with other countries so they will buy as much of our stuff as we buy from them. What do you think of this - - Trade policy and agreements that spread minimum labor and environmental standards. - Pressure the World Trade Organization to stop countries from continuing unfair government subsidies to foreign exporters. Do you think this would help? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

On our trade deficit, here is a very interesting article by Warren Buffett, published in 2003. I'm about to deliver a warning regarding the U.S. trade deficit and also suggest a remedy for the problem. But first I need to mention two reasons you might want to be skeptical about what I say. To begin, my forecasting record with respect to macroeconomics is far from inspiring. For example, over the past two decades I was excessively fearful of inflation. More to the point at hand, I started way back in 1987 to publicly worry about our mounting trade deficits -- and, as you know, we've not only survived but also thrived. So on the trade front, score at least one "wolf" for me. Nevertheless, I am crying wolf again and this time backing it with Berkshire Hathaway's money. Through the spring of 2002, I had lived nearly 72 years without purchasing a foreign currency. Since then Berkshire has made significant investments in -- and today holds -- several currencies. I won't give you particulars; in fact, it is largely irrelevant which currencies they are. What does matter is the underlying point: To hold other currencies is to believe that the dollar will decline. Full article. It's long, but very good, and particularly interesting if you consider it was written 5 years ago. 

lemingrebel --- 18 years ago -

Well NoName, All that was not mentioned because the government should be made to stay as far from those subjects as possible. They already are in charge of our so called "retirement". Thanks uncle Sam, all my money that I have to pay (there is no way around paying SS unless you're a private contractor or self=employed) is going to the "Baby Boomer" and I'll be left with a nice IOU when I retire. Those jag offs in Washington can't figure out how use their money. Why would I want them to take care or my retirement? Government has too much of a role in education as it is. The last thing we need is the government to decide what should be taught. Considering the political winds change all the time, education would never get a chance to settle in. As for health care. You're insane if you think the government should take care of health care. Could you image a doctors office being run like the post office. or better yet, go down to the Homeland Security office and apply for a TWIC card. Which is some new hair brained ID card the came up with to keep terrorist from working offshore. All in all, what you are propsing is not so much a government, but a mommy and daddy to hold your hand through life. I'll pass, thank you. I've worked hard to get what I have, and I don't want it taken away by some self righteous do gooders who think that they can same me from myself. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Unfortunately you cannot make a discussion on government generic. We have a structure of government that has limited powers for the Federal branch (military, protections, interstate commerce). As for international commerce regulation? Should the government have a role on this? Should the government define the standards for countries that want to do business with us? Or create import taxes for goods and services coming from countries that do not follow standards similar to ours? the answer to this is NO for many reasons, first because it is NOT the governments place to tell another country how to be. Second, the consumer is the one ultimately responsible for choosing what product to purchase and where to purchase it from, not government. As for education, transportation, and healthcare - those are strictly STATES Rights and are NOT the domain of the Federal government. The citizens of each state are empowered to determine those items. Now as for retirement - that is an individual responsibility. Each person is responsible (NOT THE GOVERNMENT) for saving for retirement. The federal government started an assistance program (read - welfare or social security) for elderly that was designed to supplement retirement savings, not to be the entire amount. The items you care about are personal, self responsibility items and/or State responsibility items. You need to be sure you are not trying to merge our Federal responsibilities to overshadow them. Our country was designed so that each person maintained choice and rights and responsibilities over themselves, the States then have rights and responsibilities over the collectives of citizens in the State..........the Federal government only has a responsibility to protect the COUNTRY thereby protecting the States who protect the citizens who are free to choose their own path. Got it? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

lemingrebel, I see your point. Now let me ask you a question - why do you trust the government to protect our borders and take care of national security? Or don't you? In Switzerland, citizens are in charge of national security, should we follow a similar model? 

flyonthewall --- 18 years ago -

there is no way around paying SS unless you're a private contractor or self=employed Well, there are two ways around it...teachers don't pay or collect it, and congress doesn't pay into the system, but they can collect it. Pretty screwy, huh? P.S. lemingbrel....I agree with gov't staying out of education. They screw up everything they get their hands on. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

first because it is NOT the governments place to tell another country how to be. But shouldn't the government protect American companies against countries that have unfair advantages against us? For example, should we lower our wages across the board to match those of China, so we can compete with them? Got it? No need to be aggressive - I'm just trying to have a debate of ideas here. I understand your points, and I agree with your separation of federal vs. state responsibilities. Let me see if I understand you correctly - do you think the state government should have a role in education, transportation and basic health care? And you made it clear you are against government sponsored retirement - at all levels. Do I get this right? 

lemingrebel --- 18 years ago -

lemingrebel, I see your point. Now let me ask you a question - why do you trust the government to protect our borders and take care of national security? Or don't you? In Switzerland, citizens are in charge of national security, should we follow a similar model? Because the only thing our government has ever been good at is killing people and breaking stuff. I say, go with what you know. The Switzerland thing is a good idea, except that the geographical size of our country makes that concept difficult at best. We don't have enough people living along our north and south boarders to give them proper protection. Are you aware of the details for Switzerland's defense force? That every land owner is required to have an assault rifle and 1000 rounds of ammo. So every man defends is property. Also, with the Alps and Switzerland's neutrality on everything except taking money, they are not a likely target for an invasion by an outside aggressor. Unless they have lots of elephants. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Wasn't trying to be aggressive but I will tone it down some. But shouldn't the government protect American companies against countries that have unfair advantages against us? For example, should we lower our wages across the board to match those of China, so we can compete with them? No, the marketplace - the global marketplace will force all businesses to produce and sell items in ways that are profitable, not government. do you think the state government should have a role in education, transportation and basic health care? Yes, but those roles are not in providing free services, but rather having the infrastructure there so that its citizens have choices, for example, I can choose to drive myself to work on 59 and sit in stopped traffic or I can choose to carpool and take the HOV. both are provided, but I as a citizen can choose which to take. And you made it clear you are against government sponsored retirement - at all levels. Social security should be a supplement only, not the only basis for retirement income. That responsibility rests solely with the individuals. 

lemingrebel --- 18 years ago -

Social security should be a supplement only, not the only basis for retirement income. That responsibility rests solely with the individuals. I'd rather take my chances and invest that money myself than let the government squander it away on male prostitutes and foreign aide. 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

As little as possible... Maintain a standing army... Maintain infastructure..ie..roads, bridges, damms...etc..etc.. And stay the hell out the way...Comp is good, picks up everyones game... The more important a decision, the closer to home it should be made... The more buracracy we create the harder it is for things to happen, to many hands in the pot so to speak.. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

No, the marketplace - the global marketplace will force all businesses to produce and sell items in ways that are profitable, not government. And how do we compete with people making $1 a day in China, and engineers making 1/4th of what we make in India? Do we bleed money until the market adjusts itself? but I as a citizen can choose which to take. I don't think the issue is to remove your choices, but to provide multiple choices. Nobody said people shouldn't save for retirement, or be forced to take the bus, etc., but those services need to be available. Social security should be a supplement only, not the only basis for retirement income. That responsibility rests solely with the individuals. I agree, but some form of social security should be in place. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

Are you aware of the details for Switzerland's defense force? I agree with you - the Swiss approach wouldn't work for a country of our size. Also, since many rich people shelter their money there, I don't think anyone wants to invade it. Not ever Hitler did... 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

"Today’s political rhetoric demonstrates that the servant has become the master. Most politicians, and too many Americans, have accepted the premise that government should plan our lives and control the economy. This subservient mindset encourages political pandering, as candidates strive to convince voters of their superior plans to take care of all of us. For a nation founded upon rugged individualism and self-reliance, the modern political landscape represents a wake-up call. Unless and until Americans begin to reclaim the mentality that made us great, we are destined to slide further into an economic and political malaise that cannot be solved by the grandiose plans of politicians." Congressman Ron Paul The Ron Paul Library 

keepinitreal09 --- 18 years ago -

Great post Rev!!! 

POTUS --- 18 years ago -

Short answer: The Government should UPHOLD and DEFEND the Constitution of the United States of America. Nothing more, nothing less. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

Short answer: The Government should UPHOLD and DEFEND the Constitution of the United States of America. Nothing more, nothing less. Could not have said so better myself. 

rEVOLution --- 18 years ago -

For anyone interested please come join my new Humble Campaign for Liberty discussion group. It's a place where we can all share information and Ideas about what is going on in our Great Nation and ideas on what we can do about it. Humble Campaign for Liberty 

mamajulie --- 18 years ago -

. Second, the consumer is the one ultimately responsible for choosing what product to purchase and where to purchase it from, not government. So good luck with all the leaded paint toys you will purchase for your kids. But you were the consumer, so its your fault? That is not acceptable for me. 

mamajulie --- 18 years ago -

A good question was raised about education. There can not be an "informed" electorate without education. And IMHO public education should be available, ie free, to every citizen of the US. And, I am not talking about custodial care until a child reaches 18, but actual education. I favor the federal government setting standards that MUST be met; it should be up to the states and local jurisdictions how to EXCEED those standards. Jefferson believed in public education so much that he founded the University of Virginia; at that time it was a state sponsored free university. Interesting concept. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

What is the role of government? To leave me my money so I can pursue life, liberty and happiness. 

POTUS --- 18 years ago -

The current Department of Education was set in place to DUMB down the general public, on purpose and by design. Is there anyone out there that would like to see my proof of this? Or will you all just claim it's just another conspiracy theory? 

smartypants --- 18 years ago -

A good question was raised about education. There can not be an "informed" electorate without education. And IMHO public education should be available, ie free, to every citizen of the US A good first step towards achieving this goal would be to stop playing footsie and FUND the darn schools already! (sorry, pet peeve) 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

The current Department of Education was set in place to DUMB down the general public, on purpose and by design. Ironically, I agree with you on this. Public education was encouraged by industries so they would have workers educated enough to do entry level work. In the early 1900's that meant they could read and do basic math. I think it's the local/state governments to oversee education. The federal government is too far away to effectively manage education. All the current unfunded federal mandates are an example. Education should be made available to everyone. That doesn't include sports or many other activities schools choose to spend their money on. Also, being made available doesn't mean the schools should have to keep kids who are constantly in trouble. The big trouble makers (violent) ought to be shown the door. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Should the government define the standards for countries that want to do business with us? Where would we buy the curly light bulbs from if we couldn't business with China? 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

Defense of the country, control of our borders, waterways, land masses and the oceans to our limits. Basic Education to our CITIZENS period. Maintain infrastructure within our borders and police, fire etc. AND THAT IS IT. stay the hell out of the way and allow America to be great. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

too many Americans, have accepted the premise that government should plan our lives and control the economy Question for you - seriously, I would like to hear your opinion on this. Our economy is in a real mess. Starting with Clinton and continuing with Bush, we left up to Wall Street to regulate the lending industry. Companies like Bear Stearns set up the benchmarks for what acceptable lending practices were, and the rules were greatly relaxed over time. Granted, I think people taking the loans should have taken a more active role analyzing their finances and their abilities to pay; however, we also know that lenders sweetened the deals and pushed really hard to close them, as they would simply sell them in the wholesale market. To me, this is an example where market-only regulation lead to an economic disaster. What's your take on this? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 18 years ago -

I agree. When China artificially sets the exchange rate for the dollar, they are telling us how to do business with them... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground