Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Obama Criticizes McCain on Veterans' Benefits

who's talking here?

JDB2 5
planemom 1
Anderson 2
RotorHead 2
irt339 1
Renace 2
haroldoftherocks 1
clever 2
Perfection 2
brian* 1
bidingmytime 1
UmSeriously 1
Peakoiler 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Renace --- 18 years ago -

Obama criticizes McCain on veterans' benefits By CHRISTOPHER WILLS – 7 hours ago BAYAMON, Puerto Rico (AP) — Barack Obama told veterans Saturday that he can't understand why Republican John McCain opposes legislation that would provide college scholarships to people who have served in the U.S. military. "Now, let me be clear: No one can dispute John McCain's love for this country or his concern for veterans. But here's what I don't understand. I don't understand why John McCain would side with George Bush and oppose our plan to make college more affordable for our veterans," the Democratic presidential candidate said. "George Bush and John McCain may think our plan is too generous. I could not disagree more." Obama's criticism renews a clash that turned personal after the Senate approved the scholarship bill Thursday. During the Senate debate, the Illinois senator questioned why McCain a Navy veteran and former prisoner of war would oppose the measure. McCain responded with a sharp statement saying that he wouldn't listen to any lectures on veterans' affairs from Obama, "who did not feel it was his responsibility to serve our country in uniform." Obama, speaking to reporters aboard his plane Saturday, countered that the idea that he can't speak on veterans' issues because he didn't serve in the military "makes no sense whatsoever." "I didn't serve, as many people my age, because the Vietnam war was over by the time I was of draft age and we went to an all-volunteer Army. But obviously I revere our soldiers and want to make sure they are being treated with honor and respect," he added. The Arizona senator opposes the scholarship measure, as does the Pentagon, because it applies to people who serve just three years. He fears that would encourage people to leave the military after only one enlistment even as the U.S. fights two wars and is trying to increase the size of the Army and Marine Corps. Instead, McCain and Republican colleagues proposed a bill to increase benefits in conjunction with a veteran's length of service. Senate Democrats blocked that measure. "While Barack Obama engages in the same tired partisan politics that has failed our veterans time and again, John McCain has offered legislation that will expand needed education benefits for veterans while promoting retention in our armed forces," McCain spokesman Brian Rogers said Saturday. Only three primaries are left in the battle for the Democratic nomination, and Puerto Rico is holding one of them. Puerto Ricans can vote in party primaries but not in the fall general election. Clinton spoke at an evening rally in Aguadilla, where she reminded the crowd of her ties to Puerto Rico as a first lady and then as senator from New York, which has approximately 1 million Puerto Rican residents. "My commitment to Puerto Rico did not start last month or last year," she said. "I will always be your voice as president." Through her speech, Clinton drew applause by insisting Puerto Ricans should get the same tax breaks, health care and economic opportunity afforded mainland U.S. citizens. "You deserve a president who will give Puerto Rico's issues as much attention as the president gives to any state," she said. Both candidates are hoping to increase their share of the 55 delegates who will be chosen June 1. After Obama's speech, he led a caminata a short political parade through the streets of Old San Juan. With an oceanfront park on one side and colorful colonial buildings on the other, Obama shook hands with cheering fans as scores of supporters marched behind. Occasionally, he clapped or wiggled his hips to the Latin beat of his campaign song. About 100 pro-independence advocates noisily protested a couple of blocks away. "Presidential primary is colonial trickery!" they chanted, criticizing both Obama and Clinton for not pledging to resolve Puerto Rico's status remain a territory, become a state or declare independence. But Obama was careful not to get caught up in the controversy, repeatedly saying that Puerto Ricans should be given a chance to decide their status for themselves. Associated Press Writers Andrew O. Selsky and Devlin Barrett contributed to this report.  

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Renace, do you truly believe that no one here has access to the internet to read news stories? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

renace/accent doesn't have any independent thought capabilities CH. He likes to get folks to comment on the bs articles he posts and then he offers some name-calling rebuttals. 

irt339 --- 18 years ago -

But you never do the same, BBJ? 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

anyone that thinks I am BBJ is a dumba$$. Would BBJ say that? 

haroldoftherocks --- 18 years ago -

renace/accent doesn't have any independent thought capabilities CH. He likes to get folks to comment on the bs articles he posts and then he offers some name-calling rebuttals. Why don't you enlighten us, post some BS articles in support of...whoever it is you support. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Only three primaries are left in the battle for the Democratic nomination, and Puerto Rico is holding one of them. Puerto Ricans can vote in party primaries but not in the fall general election. Clinton spoke at an evening rally in Aguadilla, where she reminded the crowd of her ties to Puerto Rico as a first lady and then as senator from New York, which Why is that? 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Here is where we get lazy as a society. We fall into these traps of "talking points" where we read a headline and all is taken out of context. Anyone want to hazard a guess as to why McCain might oppose this bill? Because he thinks it's a good idea to screw the veterans? Let's think this through: McCain was a POW for several years. Does it make any sense he would oppose a good program for veterans? Of course not. So let's keep thinking. Perhaps it's a bad bill. Think the Congress has ever passed one like that? Yep. Think there might be a boatload of pork or unnecessary riders attached that makes this thing a lousy bill? Very possible. How about if we pass a veteran's bill that makes sense and is really comprehensive and not just a feel good talking point? Don't get lazy, folks. That's what these politicians are all hoping for. They want to speak one or two sentences, elicit loud applause, then move on to the next talking point. They are expecting you to be lazy and not think about this stuff. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

McCain believes this bill would lead to veterans serving one term for the benefits and then leaving the service. I am very passionate about this subject. Many of you guys don't seem to understand the first thing about the military and the people that join. We can assign an arbitrary figure to what service is worth (we can do the same for teachers, policemen...). Let's give them $2,000,000 for three years of service. Then what? Come on people, think about what you are suggesting on these threads. Trying to appeal to a persons patriotism (but these guys are putting their life on the line, damn that McCain--nevermind nobama's comments and actions...) with headlines like this is truly a sorry attempt. 

Anderson --- 18 years ago -

article quote, "Instead, McCain and Republican colleagues proposed a bill to increase benefits in conjunction with a veteran's length of service. Senate Democrats blocked that measure." Makes sense to me. Why should everyone get "the same thing"...earn it if you want more!!! 

bidingmytime --- 18 years ago -

Perhaps it's a bad bill. Think the Congress has ever passed one like that? Yep. Think there might be a boatload of pork or unnecessary riders attached that makes this thing a lousy bill? Very possible. This is an EXCELLANT point, brian. This same point can and should be made on some of the ways that Senator Obama voted in his career. I checked every reason that Obama voted the way that he did and feel comfortable still with my vote for him. just saying...good point. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

she reminded the crowd of her ties to Puerto Rico as a first lady February 8, 2000 Web posted at: 6:08 p.m. EST (2308 GMT) WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Fallout from President Clinton's controversial pardons of 16 members of a Puerto Rican nationalist group last summer prompted Republicans Tuesday to introduce a measure to reform the pardon process and require input from victims and their families. President Clinton was widely criticized after he granted clemency to the FALN members over the objections of law enforcement officials, and after the Justice Department consulted representatives of the FALN prisoners, but not the victims. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

article quote, "Instead, McCain and Republican colleagues proposed a bill to increase benefits in conjunction with a veteran's length of service. Senate Democrats blocked that measure." Makes sense to me. Why should everyone get "the same thing"...earn it if you want more!!! I agree with you. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

article quote, "Instead, McCain and Republican colleagues proposed a bill to increase benefits in conjunction with a veteran's length of service. Senate Democrats blocked that measure." Makes sense to me. Why should everyone get "the same thing"...earn it if you want more!!! But that is the difference in the democratic and republican views this election season. The Democratic candidates, Senators Clinton and Obama favor a system that is more socialistic in nature. Everyone treated the same without regard to effort, production or worth. The Republican candidate, Senator McCain favors a system more capitalistic in nature, one where you earn what you work for and those who desire more, work more. That people is the difference. Make your choice, be informed and be passionate, just be willing to accept the consequences of your choices. 

Renace --- 18 years ago -

do you truly believe that no one here has access to the internet to read news stories? ChunkyHeifer, it would not trouble me if you chose not to read or participate on any of these threads that contain news stories that are indeed very readily available on the internet. I'm sorry if you have perceived anything that I've posted as force. 

Anderson --- 18 years ago -

Heifer, "The Democratic candidates, Senators Clinton and Obama favor a system that is more socialistic in nature. Everyone treated the same without regard to effort, production or worth. The Republican candidate, Senator McCain favors a system more capitalistic in nature, one where you earn what you work for and those who desire more, work more." LOL...I know, can you imagine working for a large company for 4 years, then quitting and DEMANDING life-long benefits??? I'm a vet as well as my spouse and half of my sibblings. The GI Bill as it is currently written is sufficient. 

RotorHead --- 18 years ago -

Anderson, I'm sure Renace and his ilk have no clue what the GI Bill is and what it entails. As you stated the GI Bill provides sufficent reimbersement for post service educational pursuits. GI education benefits more than provided for my educational needs as I'm sure you have experienced. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Puerto Ricans can vote in party primaries but not in the fall general election. Peurto Rico can vote in the Presidential election but since they don't have any representatives in the electoral college the votes don't count. I believe they have people they elect to congress. However, they are non-voting members of congress. I'm pretty sure I'll be corrected if I'm mistaken. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

GI education benefits more than provided for my educational needs as I'm sure you have experienced. I agree...two undergraduate degrees and an MBA. I could still go get a PhD if I wanted one. What about all of the other benefits? Soldiers that enlist for multiple terms should recieve more than I did for my one three-year term. 

UmSeriously --- 18 years ago -

Perhaps it's a bad bill. Think the Congress has ever passed one like that? Yep. Think there might be a boatload of pork or unnecessary riders attached that makes this thing a lousy bill? Very possible. He opposes it because he believes that if military men and women are given a full college scholarship after 3 years that the re-enlistment rates, which are already alarmingly low, are going to go down. It's business. Nothing more, nothing less. 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

It's business. Nothing more, nothing less. that's not business because there is no profit motive for the government. It could be considered capitalistic because it rewards those that exert more effort...again, shouldn't a lifer have more benefits than those of us that spent three years in? 

Peakoiler --- 18 years ago -

Dog and pony show. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground