Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Kingwood Teacher Resigns Over Texts

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
wayward1 1
SueRDH 2
Holling Vincoeur 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Gigix4 3
*LOL* 4
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 11
needsleep 1
Miss Understanding 1
TinktheSprite 6
Emperor of Kingwood 2
witchywoman 1
Butterbean 1
Prolix Raconteur 1
mutton 1
them 4
Karras 1
a889438uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

Did anyone else see this??

By Tracy Clemons
Thursday, December 08, 2016 11:10PM
HOUSTON (KTRK) -- A teacher in Humble ISD has resigned after a picture of a racially insensitive text message she sent circulated on social media.

The text read, "I'm so sick of playing black people."

A woman in the stands for a girl's basketball game between Kingwood High and Nimitz High (Aldine ISD) sent the message to someone. A Nimitz parent saw it and whipped out her phone to take a picture.

"I think that's not acceptable. Especially in this day and time," said Humble ISD parent Ed Dubois.

We've learned the woman who sent the text was a teacher at Greentree Elementary School. The parent who took the picture of the text sent it to Houston-area activist Gerry Monroe, who took his concerns to Humble ISD.

"If you want to say things or convey messages like that, then you have to realistically not allow it to become public because words are like bullets. Once you shoot them, you can't take them back," Monroe said.

"Humble ISD expects educators to show respect for all students and to demonstrate good sportsmanship at student events," the district said in a statement. "The text message does not represent the values of the district."

"I've seen people do foolish things in the public thinking it was being done privately," said attorney and ABC13 legal analyst Joel Androphy.

The big question is whether the picture that led to this teacher's resignation was an invasion of her privacy. Androphy said absolutely not.

"If you're outside your house then you say things at your own risk that you can be held accountable for," he explained. "If I'm at a football game and I'm texting my family and the guy behind me looks to see what I'm doing, it's my fault for exposing it there."

ABC13 went to the teacher's house to get her side of the story. Her husband said they're not a racist family, and they don't raise their kids that way.

"She is devastated that her comment on the text has hurt people. She feels that what she said by hurting the kids and families was absolutely wrong and she apologizes for her comments," he said.


"She has no business teaching children if she's going to be like that," Dubois said.

Here is Humble ISD's full statement:

Humble ISD expects educators to show respect for all students and to demonstrate good sportsmanship at student events. The text message does not represent the values of the district. Upon being made aware of the photo, the district took immediate action by investigating. That investigation revealed that a person employed as an elementary school teacher sent the text. She has resigned.
Related Topics:
newsracismtext messagesHumble
Email
(Copyright ©2016 KTRK-TV. All Rights Reserved.)




Now, keep in mind this was a private text message sent from one person to another. Someone behind her took the pic of her private text and exposed her to school officials. There's no doubt it was racially insensitive. But she wasn't in school or teaching or directing it at someone who was the recipient. We ALL know we've done or said something "insensitive" or had jokes sent to us or whatever...

Two questions:
1) should private text messages be vulnerable like this? (Considering someone took a pic of it)

2) is this an issue of privacy invasion? 

*LOL* --- 9 years ago -

Two questions:
1) should private text messages be vulnerable like this? (Considering someone took a pic of it)

2) is this an issue of privacy invasion??


If you are representing your employer then you had better make sure you are not posting crap on any media that could come back to bite you. She lost the right to privacy when she posted something that could be viewed by another individual in not only a public place, but at a school function.

Her husband said they're not a racist family, and they don't raise their kids that way.


Well, she sure does a damn good imitation of a racist person if that's the case. Kids out on the court playing a sport and being judged by an educator based on their race sounds pretty racist to me.

Maybe it was nosey of someone to be reading her texts but she sounds like a big idiot for writing it in the first place. 

whatchamacallit --- 9 years ago -

No and Yes 

Gigix4 --- 9 years ago -

I have mixed emotions about this. After 40+ yrs of working, I can't tell you how many hours and hours of diversity training I went through. The one thing that still sticks is that you never, never, EVER put something in writing that can be construed as discrimination!!! Don't even utter it if someone could be listening!

Sure it was a private message but once it's in writing - it's there! If she had a private message to someone, then don't send it in a public location. Send or say it in private.

I'm sure there is more to this story that none of us will ever know. I can't imagine being at a sports event and "minding someone else's business". Creepy! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

"She sounds like a big idiot for writing it"


What if she didn't mean it to be negative but was actually trying to say they always LOSE to those teams and was tired of getting beat kind of thing??

I'll tell you what, if we are now going to post and take pics of text messages that were not posted PUBLICALLY and were never meant to be, and were private, we'd all be in trouble for something insensitive. You never said someone was an idiot, stupid or worse on a private text message??

It was stupid, and insensitive, but whatever happened with our right to free speech? even if it's dumb, a slur or untrue? The Internet is full of it. 

*LOL* --- 9 years ago -

It was stupid, and insensitive, but whatever happened with our right to free speech? even if it's dumb, a slur or untrue?

I see your point but I think the fact that she was a teacher at a school event is what made it an issue. Free speech does not mean no consequences. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

I agree LOL. It does not mean there aren't consequences- and there should be. But to have someone invade your privacy by taking a pic of a private PM and then she has to resign and looses a job over it? Why not a warning? IDK, I think she could fight it.

Remember: I don't agree with what you say but I defend your right to say it?

If she's a flaming racist then there would be backlash from everywhere, that doesn't mean she doesn't have the right to say it. Or am I wrong? In this situation of a private convo, idk.. 

mutton --- 9 years ago -

I say it just shows, what you post is never private. Think before you hit enter... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

What's funny is, how pious Humble ISD sounds and we all know the truth: people are people. They say dumb, untrue, racially insensitive and derogatory things... It only matters if you get caught bc almost everyone has offended someone, only they weren't exposed by an invasion of private conversations. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 9 years ago -

unfortunately for her it was a slow news day... 

them --- 9 years ago -

Behold! Salons #5 best article of 2015



I?m tired of suppressing myself to get along with white people


Trump will end the double-standard. 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

Most companys and places of work now have policy in place about using Social Media texts, and email that it cannot reflect publicly on the company. Her bad. No filters. 

*LOL* --- 9 years ago -

unfortunately for her it was a slow news day...?



And that it was a Kingwood teacher. You know the news just loves to drive those vans out here The story was hilarious, in the dark in front of Greentree Elem. You could just barely make out the school building. They had to go back the next morning for daylight video . 

SueRDH --- 9 years ago -

I feel bad for this teacher. I don't feel she should have resigned or been reprimanded. 

Dorothy Parker --- 9 years ago -

I know this teacher, I believe she is a good person and my kids love her. It's beyond a shame that this situation has happened. She was being a poor sport over losing a basketball game, it brought out the worst in her and now she's paying for it. It's a huge price to pay for someone reading over your shoulder. Should she have said it? No. Should a stranger have been reading her phone over her shoulder and then ruining her life over it? No.

It's a horrible situation all the way around.
:( 

them --- 9 years ago -

its illegal to record someone else's private conversation. This teacher should sue the eavesdropper into oblivion. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

If she has a good record as an employee, I'm thinking a reprimand would have been in order but to make her quit, seems extreme. But I suppose it's a matter of HISD policy.

I think if she wanted to fight some of this, she could. It might not be over yet.. 

a889438uu --- 9 years ago -

Then shouldn't it be illegal for ex boss to use your personal and confidential texts against you to get out of unemployment???? Was private info about my family issues I was having and totally trusted him. Now who knows where else that text went to!!! Not good. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Teachers and many people have employment contracts (I do). In many of those contracts there's a clause about public utterances. Since there is no expectation of privacy while in public, the text could violate the employment contract. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

I totally get the employment contract thing. Many companies have these. Here's the thing: it wasn't a public post, FB, Twitter or Snapchat. This was a private text message. And IMO, this is a slippery slope. Do we really want an employer telling us we can't have private phone convos?? I totally get the public posting and social media thing. But this wasn't that. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Problem is, that it became public when she viewed it in a public place and took no proactive measures to keep it private. I don't like it either. SCOTUS ruled on that a few years ago.

I don't like that my employer can enforce those provisions of my contract basically on a whim. 

*LOL* --- 9 years ago -

Then shouldn't it be illegal for ex boss to use your personal and confidential texts against you to get out of unemployment???? Was private info about my family issues I was having and totally trusted him. Now who knows where else that text went to!!! Not good.?

I don't think so. You willingly shared them with him, you sent them to him. You have to be very careful about what you put in writing but a person can share written communication they receive from another person. Another person can even take something you send them (say to a personal friend) and show it to a supervisor or even the police and it can be used against you.

It happens in court all the time, look at that Anthony Wiener guy.

People need to use their brain when sending texts and emails. Why do you think Law Enforcement gets search warrants for phones and computers when seeking an arrest? Because it is court admissible evidence. 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

I have friends and family who are doctors and lawyers who refuse to text us or use Social Media. They know whatever is written is"on record" and can be turned against them for whatever reason. So they didn't start the"habit". They simply call us. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 9 years ago -

Trump will end the double-standard.


You should have voted for him, that way you wouldnt just be jumping on the bandwagon... 

witchywoman --- 9 years ago -

Based on the article I read here I think it was wrong to fire her. 

Gigix4 --- 9 years ago -

I think it was wrong to fire her.

I don't think she was fired ... I think they strongly "suggested"/encouraged, that she would be better off to resign ... which she did. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

I'd fight it. The remark in question is questionably, possibly, not even derogatory....

They probably lost a good teacher to political correctness run amuck. 

Gigix4 --- 9 years ago -

They probably lost a good teacher to political correctness run amuck.

That's my thoughts as well. Sad! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

As with all things, balance is needed. We have a history of racial prejudice and we need to always be working on that. And The whole employer social media restrictions are understandable but it needs tempering. Public is different than private, and just bc someone went out of their way to invade her private communications and then exposed them, that's where balance is lost. What if she lost her phone or it was stolen and someone exposed her convos? I think the school district would have STILL pressured her even tho it wasn't even viewed in public in that case... 

them --- 9 years ago -

We have a history of racial prejudice and we need to always be working on that.


Nobody in my family lived in the US until after 1910. According to the history books slavery had long been abolished by then. 

wayward1 --- 9 years ago -

Never put your employer in a public, compromising situation. You'll always be fired. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 9 years ago -

the irony is her text was a left handed compliment- she was saying black kids are better athletes, and her team can't win against them. It reminds me of what happened with Jimmy the Greek- 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

#1: This was SO RUDE! this parent should have confronted the person. I wonder if she knew she was a teacher?
"A Nimitz parent saw it and whipped out her phone to take a picture."

#2: WRONG on so many levels! No matter if you are a teacher or no! How else could this statement be interpreted.
"The text read, "I'm so sick of playing black people.""

#3: Agree
""If you're outside your house then you say things at your own risk that you can be held accountable for," he explained. "If I'm at a football game and I'm texting my family and the guy behind me looks to see what I'm doing, it's my fault for exposing it there."" 

them --- 9 years ago -

the irony is her text was a left handed compliment- she was saying black kids are better athletes, and her team can't win against them.


How did you derive that from "I'm so sick of playing black people."? 

Miss Understanding --- 9 years ago -

"She has no business teaching children if she's going to be like that," Dubois said


EXACTLY!!! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

".....I'm so sick of playing black people"


In circles where people are sports fanatics, that sentiment is often expressed when they are trying to say they are SUPERIOR ATHLETES and therefor unbeatable. It's a compliment. No different than suggesting a (short) Italian long jumper may not have a chance against a tall 6 foot African American. Is that mean to say of the Italian? They are not tall people in general.

Whether it was meant that way or not, idk. But the question is should we be free to make remarks, good or bad, like this in private? 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

If it was meant to be in private then it should have never been seen by others. Texting using privacy techniques, covering the screen, putting the phone away, privacy screens etc. Apparently, she didn't attempt to hide her private text remark no longer making it private. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 9 years ago -

What if the text read "I'm so sick of competing against Asians at the Mathlympics"?

Racist? Bigoted? Or are they just typically better at that kind of thing? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 9 years ago -

Tink, you're right, it should not have been seen by others but she thought the convo was private. She was not trying to make it public at all. It was never meant to be public. But that's the rub, someone invaded her private conversation to get that info. And THEY went to great lengths to expose it. Going to a social activist and they then took it to the school district.

It's a terrible thing to think we have to crouch over our phones now bc someone might be looking over your shoulder and reading/ reporting your comments to the news, or maybe even you employer.

I know I've had bad days and said not so nice things via text complaining about something or someone, venting, even about people I love. We all have. And it's pretty awful to think you truly have no privacy. 

needsleep --- 9 years ago -

Kingwood won against Nimitz by a small margin. 42-39 So maybe there was some heated "cheering" going on... I have no clue but I have seen it before. I have also seen where fans were not allowed to sit in the same sections...visitor vs home sections...

BUT I ageee what sag said about going to great lengths to expose it. I have seen people's text accidentally...and I am embarrassed to have seen clearly what they are messaging. You all can thank these large screen phones.... I wasn't looking for it but unless it was something like "light the bombs now"..I don't give two trucks what you all are texting about. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground