Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Shot while obeying orders

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
SleightOfHand 6
Hiro Protagonist 4
Holling Vincoeur 6
sheddy 1
DatBoyHooD 1
Emperor of Kingwood 8
a889324uu 1
AMDG 11
them 3
Barnstormer 1
Karras 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

This may be a little controversial, but has anyone ever seen a police shooting video, where the suspect was obeying the police instructions.

I don't think I can ever remember seeing one. Seems to me this is part of the problem.

I don't know the answer to this one, but it seems that African Americans are more apt to struggle, or resist. There may be very good reasons for this. But it sure appears that their needs to be a better job done of teaching some that - right or wrong, do what the police tell you to do - fight the injustice later.

I didn't do any research on this, and may be very wrong - but sure seems that way. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

Slippery slope. Police already have an issue with superiority, training everyone to be submissive is training them to accept whatever the government tells you to do...I agree with emp on this subject. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Offlimits - I think the slippery slope is in the other direction. It just can't be alright to not obey the police instructions. Not the time or place to fight a perceived injustice or violation of your rights.

Those issues should be fought in the courts. We need to restore some belief and faith in the system to the disenfranchised - to help them believe that if treated unfairly on the street, it will be corrected in the courts.

But we can't encourage people to resist the police - even if they feel justified - can't see how that can end well for anyone. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

I'm not saying don't cooperate, but most people don't know what their rights are and law enforcement will use that against them, I think people need to know what the police can and can't do when interacting with citizens... 

whatchamacallit --- 10 years ago -

I have taught my kids to be respectful of the police when enteracting with them and to do what they ask. It makes sense to me that they should, chances are they are an ok person just doing their job. Even if the policeman is a bad person, they have a gun and they may shoot you if you do not comply. Why be agressive and increase the possiblity of escalation? 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

We need to restore some belief and faith in the system to the disenfranchised - to help them believe that if treated unfairly on the street, it will be corrected in the courts.



I don't think that burden is on the citizens...it's on the mayors and chiefs of police to restore faith and trust...that's what they're elected and paid for. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

I don't think that burden is on the citizens...it's on the mayors and chiefs of police to restore faith and trust...that's what they're elected and paid for.

"We" was a collective - but yes the larger burden would be on those involved in the system. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

I don't think that burden is on the citizens...it's on the mayors and chiefs of police to restore faith and trust...that's what they're elected and paid for

You should also add the anti-police media and the president, who from the very beginning of his presidency went after the police. Remember him saying a police officer acted stupidly? 

whatchamacallit --- 10 years ago -

No doubt Obama does his best to inflame the population any time there is a chance to stir things up and he always plays the race card in an effort to keep us divided. 

them --- 10 years ago -

There are many, many hip-hop and rap songs promoting disobedience with law enforcement (watch Straight Outta Compton if you want to be "enlightened").

Why isn't anyone discussing the culture of disobedience toward law enforcement? 

a889324uu --- 10 years ago -

Even when people DO cooperate, they get shot. The MN incident is a prime example. I think I read it was ruled a homicide, and I do hope the cop/shooter is held accountable. He has to be.

The police have not set good examples over the last few years when it comes to making sound decisions. Often times, their first instinct is to shoot, and because there is a lack of accountability and they are all but guaranteed a paid vacation as a result, how can you expect the black community to respect cops?
Heck, the cops have NEVER set a good example - yes, we have pockets of "good" cops, but until they call out and stop tolerating the "bad" cops, nothing will change.

It is so easy for white people, living in the Kingwood bubble, to boast about how they have taught their children to respect police, but how often are the police in their neighborhoods, harassing them, profiling them, killing their neighbors? You can't compare the two.

Because cops have itchy trigger fingers and often kill as a first resort (Tamir Rice, for example) you can't expect the black community to respect them - wouldn't you resist, too?
Resisting is the only way some feel they have a chance of survival.
Resist, you die.
Comply, you die.

That is the reality of the situation in many black communities.

Why isn't anyone discussing the culture of disobedience toward law enforcement?

The culture of disobedience arose from the brutality of cops abusing their power. It is a response to the actions of cops who have not always engaged in meaningful dialogue and actions. So yeah, watch Straight Outta Compton to understand why there might be promotion of "disobedience" towards the police, but also keep in mind the time frame and location of the rise of NWA.

Again, it's easy to pass judgmental when the biggest issue you face is the city removing trees in your community. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

Is it really that bad Jams ? Is it really true that police are routinely shooting people who are complying with their instructions ?? Maybe I have spent too much time in the bubble, but I just don't think that is true. 

Karras --- 10 years ago -

The MN incident is a prime example. I think I read it was ruled a homicide

Why don't we wait for the investigation to conclude. Same with the shooting in Baton Rouge. Seems all the rioters, er protestors, jump the gun on these events and are proven wrong time after time.

A lot of people get hurt as well as property damage because people can't wait for the justice system to render a final verdict.

Often times, their first instinct is to shoot, and because there is a lack of accountability and they are all but guaranteed a paid vacation as a result, how can you expect the black community to respect cops?

You can't be serious?

The culture of disobedience arose from the brutality of cops abusing their power.

No, it arose out of the breakup of the traditional family. No father's around to raise the kids, properly. You can thank the demoncrats for that. 

sheddy --- 10 years ago -

You probably have seen videos where the driver is filming the stop and keeps telling the officer he doesn't have to do whatever, because he knows his rights. My dad always said be polite and do as you are told. If you think you are right you can go to court and fight it. Sandra Bland keep arguing with the officer. If she'd just said yes sir, she would never have gone to jail. I think a large part of the problem is attitude. 

SleightOfHand --- 10 years ago -

"I think I read it was ruled a homicide"

Derp, homicide is not murder but murder is homicide 

DatBoyHooD --- 10 years ago -

Cops said he was reaching for a gun

0undefined 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

It just can't be alright to not obey the police instructions.

Sure it can, if its not a lawful command.

Those issues should be fought in the courts.

How do you unring that bell?

it will be corrected in the courts.

Fat chance of that when the DA's office won't even bring charges because they are afraid of the police. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Why isn't anyone discussing the culture of disobedience toward law enforcement?

You are not required to obey unlawful police commands. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

Is it really true that police are routinely shooting people who are complying with their instructions

Maybe not shooting, but certainly roughing up, abusing, striking, choking, etc if they don't like your attitude. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

I think there is a difference between refusing in a respectfull and in a non threatening way to not comply. Such as "officer, am I under arrest ?? "May I leave" "With respect, I do not have to answer your questions"

But once an officer gives you an instruction. Get out of the car, turn around, put your hands on my car, get on the ground, whatever it is - IMO it is now escalating the situation if you do not comply, you may well be right, but you may end up dead right. 

them --- 10 years ago -

It is so easy for white people, living in the Kingwood bubble, to boast about how they have taught their children to respect police, but how often are the police in their neighborhoods, harassing them, profiling them, killing their neighbors? You can't compare the two.
...

Again, it's easy to pass judgmental when the biggest issue you face is the city removing trees in your community.






What race do you identify with? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

if you do not comply, you may well be right, but you may end up dead right.?

That's the kind of government we want? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

That's the kind of government we want?

Of course not - we all wish that police officers never made mistakes, and that people new all their rights perfectly, but don't see that as a reality.

The reality I think exists, is that the overwhelming number of police instructions given are legal, and should be complied with. I think in the vast majority of interactions between the police and the civilians, the police are more knowledgeable about what he/she can do or not do, because he/she has been trained.

In the remaining small minority of cases where the police may be over stepping their authority, I think the situation has a better chance of ending with everyone living if the police instructions are followed. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

we all wish that police officers never made mistakes,

The intentional overstepping of the boundaries and the law is not a mistake, Its a criminal act for which they are not held accountable as you and I would be. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

I think the situation has a better chance of ending with everyone living if the police instructions are followed.

It takes patriots willing to die for human rights to stop abuses. I reference our founders. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

The intentional overstepping of the boundaries and the law is not a mistake, Its a criminal act for which they are not held accountable as you and I would be

Is this something that you feel is happening all the time??? I am sure it happens, but can't think it is all that rampant.

I know this is an issue that matters to you, and of course these cops should be found out and the proper action taken - whatever that is.

But I still hold that at the scene, in the heat of the moment is not the time for a discussion on your rights, certainly not a place to disregard the officers instructions, and sure not the time to struggle while they try to handcuff you.

Again - my point is not philosophic, it is pragmatic, right or wrong - legal, illegal, IMO you have a much better chance of not getting shot if you do what the cop says. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

It takes patriots willing to die for human rights to stop abuses. I reference our founders.

Not sure I am quite ready to elevate Alton Sterling to patriotic martyr just yet. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

my point is not philosophic, it is pragmatic,

I don't disagree from a pragmatic point of view. But, who stands up for our hard won rights in the face of police tyranny? 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -

But, who stands up for our hard won rights in the face of police tyranny?

Guess I don't think we have a rampant problem of police tyranny, more like a handful of bad cops, and some amount of poor decisions under pressure. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 10 years ago -

more like a handful of bad cops, and some amount of poor decisions under pressure.

Most likely.

"Giver me Liberty or, Give me Death. - Patrick Henry 

SleightOfHand --- 10 years ago -

"Cops said he was reaching for a gun "
One second after that screen shot, his hand broke free from the officer's grip and disappears. You the. Hear the officer yell " he's going for the gun" 

Hiro Protagonist --- 10 years ago -

Seems all the rioters, er protestors, jump the gun on these events and are proven wrong time after time.



Found innocent does not mean anyone was "proven wrong." 

Hiro Protagonist --- 10 years ago -

Deciding not to prosecute certainly doesn't prove anyone wrong either. The police have every advantage in the courtroom and in considering a case for trial. 

them --- 10 years ago -


Found innocent does not mean anyone was "proven wrong."?



Hillary 2016 

Hiro Protagonist --- 10 years ago -

This may be a little controversial, but has anyone ever seen a police shooting video, where the suspect was obeying the police instructions.

I don't think I can ever remember seeing one. Seems to me this is part of the problem.



How about when they don't give you time to respond to orders? Like that kid that got shot with the toy gun, or that guy they shot within a second of pulling up to him. 

SleightOfHand --- 10 years ago -

"Deciding not to prosecute certainly doesn't prove anyone wrong either. The police have every advantage in the courtroom and in considering a case for trial. "

That court room advantage sure worked well for them in Baltimore. 

AMDG --- 10 years ago -


How about when they don't give you time to respond to orders? Like that kid that got shot with the toy gun, or that guy they shot within a second of pulling up to him.


I will look them up Hiro - can you give something else to help find them, dates, city, name ? 

SleightOfHand --- 10 years ago -

One that comes to mind though I don't remember where it was, an officer ordered a male to identify himself then shot him as he was reaching for his ID. The officer quickly realized he screwed up and began apologizing. The man didn't die but the officer was convicted, and rightly so. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

I'd yell GUN too if I was a cop about to shoot someone...it creates plausible deniability. 

Holling Vincoeur --- 10 years ago -

Why isn't anyone discussing the culture of disobedience toward law enforcement?


This ^^^^^^


Ever notice that Will Smith was never taken seriously as a rapper?


Parents just don't understand... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground