Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

100 + Human Trafficking Victims found in SE Houston

who's talking here?

randyjet 14
d:-] 3
Perfection 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
gunsnroses 1
FabFive 1
Ender 2
Ogre13 19
mutton 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Article

This is insane.

I'm interested to see how this one shakes out. This SEEMS to be what happens when an illegal immigration scheme goes wrong for the illegal immigrant and it turns into a human trafficking/slavery scheme.

No indication of anyone being sexually exploited, or exploited for labor (yet), so it may just be that the Coyotes got greedy and wanted more money.

We'll see. But 109 people? That's the biggest bust in a while. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Saw that, way nutty! 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

So if the people didn't choose to use coyotes, if the chose to enter the country through legal means, would that eliminate this issue?

I say yes.

These individuals were not brought here by force, they chose this path.

True human trafficking is don't not by choice. True human trafficking is by force and typically involves multiple forms of abuse. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

So if the people didn't choose to use coyotes, if the chose to enter the country through legal means, would that eliminate this issue?

Only in THIS narrow instance.

A BETTER solution would be to create SANE immigration laws, provide a guest worker system like we had in WWII, and MUCH GREATER punishment for those who exploit people.

There are still 17,000-20,000 men, women and children - mostly women and female children - who are trafficked through Houston every year into the sex, labor and agricultural slave market IN THIS COUNTRY. at any one time there are up to 50,000 slaves in the United States. The vast majority of them are NOT paying to come here, but are lured here by the Coyotes with promises of jobs. (I prefer the term slavers).

And nobody knows how many domestic slaves there are out there. Those poor souls are hidden away and usually only discovered by accident. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

I am wholly supportive of improvements in this area but using the terms correctly is key to identify and exposing the problem.

you cannot call every situation human trafficking for the shock value, when overused it dilutes the importance of the battle. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

you cannot call every situation human trafficking

The term is actually used to describe a wide range of activities and illegal immigration via Coyote does fall under that category when it becomes a hostage situation. Before that, without the hostage element it's considered human smuggling, which while still held under the broad category of human trafficking but covered under separate laws.

But there does NOT have to be a border crossing for their to be human trafficking, Domestic human trafficking is rampant as well.

In fact, movement is not even a requirement for trafficking. A step-father can traffic his own step-daughter from the comfort of his own home.

Think of Human Trafficking in the same way you'd think of the term Autism. It's a spectrum of behavior. Or pickles....there can be MANY kinds of pickles.

THIS was a human trafficking event. The Coyotes were human traffickers. The people in the house started as illegal immigrants, but ended as trafficking victims. Not uncommon. But not common at this scale. I can't recall the last case where this many people were found in one spot. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

That's horrible, humans can be so disgusting to each other. 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

When you see how disgusting humans can be to other humans it's not hard to see how they can be so disgusting to animals. 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

A BETTER solution would be to create SANE immigration laws, provide a guest worker system like we had in WWII, and MUCH GREATER punishment for those who exploit people.

We have sane immigration laws. We limit the number of people from each country that are allowed to immigrate each year. Mexico and South America easily exceed their limits years in advance.

The 109 people in this story don't respect you or our laws. Plus, those people aren't doctors or rocket scientists. They're people who couldn't find work in their home countries so they take a chance to come here. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

We have sane immigration laws.

Actually we don't. Our immigration laws, just like our "War on Drugs" encourage this sort of behavior. And it's because they are based on prohibition. And Prohibition has NEVER and will never be a good policy because all it does is encourage the growth of a powerful, wealthy and often violent criminal class. In this case, the Coyotes.

If you actually study our immigration laws, they didn't even effectively exist until AFTER WWII with very few exceptions. Those being the Chinese Exclusion Acts (which were based on fears, innuendo and lies), and the various acts designed to prevent the importation of FEMALE prostitutes into the United States. And yes, they were specific to FEMALE prostitutes.

During WWII we had laws that allowed guest workers (i.e. itinerant farm workers in particular) to come across the border to find jobs. Human trafficking was not so prevalent because there wasn't a market for "illegals."

And let's be honest, the minimum wage in Mexico is about $2.00 a DAY. The rest of S. and C. America isn't much better. What these people (the victims here in this case, and not the Coyotes) are concerned about is not "respecting laws", but in survival. No amount of "laws" could keep me in Northern Mexico, or many of the S. and C. American countries that these people come from.

Instead of addressing the ROOT cause of the problems (which are many and complex) we have to keep bashing our heads against the wall and not learn from history. How many people escaped from W. Berlin? Arguably the most secure border in the WORLD. Guards, Fences, Barbed Wire, minefields WILL NOT prevent a determined person from escaping from HEII.

Our current laws, and the "quota" system stem from the Immigration Act of 1924. It further barred ALL immigrants from Asia as they were viewed as "dirty" (except for Filipinos who as a colony of the United States were already considered American nationals (as opposed to citizens)). Prior to that the 1917 act established a literary test (immigrants over 16 had to be literate in ANY language).

HOWEVER, neither the 1917 nor the 1924 act prevented a long-standing guest worker program from operating.

It wasn't until 1952 that the act was revised again and THAT was when the trouble really started. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Actually we don't. Our immigration laws, just like our "War on Drugs" encourage this sort of behavior. And it's because they are based on prohibition. And Prohibition has NEVER and will never be a good policy because all it does is encourage the growth of a powerful, wealthy and often violent criminal class.

Those are two completely unrelated issues. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

That is like saying that since prohibitionist tactics do not work with murder, we should start issuing actual "licenses to kill" to qualifying citizens in hopes that it will stop illegal murder. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

You're conflating two unrelated issues.

We're not talking about crime in general, we're talking about crime with a market basis.

To be more accurate... PROHIBITION, in the face of an active market, is a failed policy. 100% of the time. I PERSONALLY have attempted to find a case of prohibition in the face of an active market that was successful and my research has taken me back to the very beginnings of this country and into Britain and parts of Europe and I have yet to find a single case.

The chief difference, Ender, is that the market for murder is very, very small.

The chief cause of murder is NOT market forces. I.e. the number of paid hitmen who are hired to kill someone for reasons beyond being related to the various prohibited smuggling industries, is microscopic.

No one has done a detailed study because it is an incredibly difficult topic to research, but the FBI GUESSES that apx. 3.2% of all murders are contractual. There are no figures beyond that other than, in 2013, there were 140 cases NOT tied to organized crime pending with the FBI. That is equivalent to about 1% of all murders in the U.S. annually.

The reasons people murder each other are varied, but I would dare say you were several hundred, if not thousands times more likely to murdered for your shoes, or because you wore the wrong color of clothing in the bad part of town than you are likely to be killed by a professional (Assuming you're not Heisenberg of course). And you are several if not many times more likely to be murdered by someone in your family, or someone you know than you are to be murdered by a stranger.

In other words, MURDER is NOT driven by market factors. These other things...they are.

The chief cause of drug trafficking, slavery, human trafficking, and all sorts of smuggling - which is what we're really talking about here. ARE market forces.

prohibition, over-taxation, excessive duties (which is really just a tax). Those all result in a black-market, run by a powerful, wealthy and often violent criminal class. And it's not just drugs, guns, people either..the big three. Mushroom smugglers in the Northern U.S. are the reason park rangers near the Canadian border carry AR's. Truffle smugglers in France have murdered people who have tried to interfere with them. A pair of Garlic smugglers in Europe were sentenced to twenty years just a couple of years ago. A gang of CHEESE smugglers, including a Canadian Cop were busted in 2012. Why? Because the duties on dairy in Canada are so excessive, it creates a black market. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

orge, Using numbers I got from a speech by Sen. Kennedy, he stated that before 19886 and the Reagan amnesty, the numbers of illegals entering the US was about 40,000/yr and until recently it was running at 500,000/yr. The reason for that increase was the fact that numerous people saw that wide open border and the higher wages here and no enforcement measures being taken. Thus the flood of illegals. So it is no wonder that we got this happening. Then add to it the desire of the wealthy GOP donors to keep them coming to drive down wages, and that contributes to this.

The funniest thing from the last session of the GOP Texas legislature was that they REFUSED to even let a mandatory E-Verify law come out of committee. That was because the home builder Robert Perry has over half his workforce made up of illegals. Instead they pass a symbolic no sanctuary city bill to fool the stupid GOP voters. The wealthy LOVE illegals and want to keep them coming. The immigration system is only broken because politicians refuse to enforce the law.

As for the effectiveness of border security, I have been in East Berlin many times and I can tell you it was VERY effective and secure. As was most of the Eastern borders in Europe. There is no such thing as an impermeable border, but it stops most illegal crossings. Just as there are escapes from prisons, that hardly means we need to take down the walls and fencing since they didn't stop ALL. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Yep, of course, we're talking about two different issues here. Illegal immigration and Human trafficking (Smuggling).

My opinions on illegal immigration are complex. I don't think "Amnesty" is the answer at all. For the reasons you state above, because I think the Reagan Amnesty was essentially a starting gun for this sort of thing.

But at the same time, deporting kids who were brought here at a young age to a country that really isn't their home doesn't seem to be very American either.

As to east Berlin, even there, arguably one of, if not the most heavily fortified border in the world during its day (Possibly right behind the DMZ in Korea), over 5000 people crossed that border.

But how long was that wall? As compared to the ...and I assume we're talking about the Southern US Border, not the border with Canada... That border is simply impossible to police without turning it into an armed camp.

There are better ways. For one, reinstitute the guest worker program, then companies like Robert Perry will have their laborers. I was actually listening to a report on the news just the other day... I'll see if I can find it... saying that home contracts are WAY behind schedule because home builders can't find either skilled or unskilled labor. IF AMERICANS don't' want those jobs, then we need someone who will take them.

AHA...fond the NAHB report. It's a year old though. THIS is more recent: Article

It's like in martial arts, you basically have two broad schools of thought...Hard Forms and Soft Forms. Our policies tend to all be hard forms, we hit and kick and expend our own energy to achieve goals, and half the time we don't achieve them. We need to develop SOFT forms wherein we use the other persons energy (or take energy away from the other person) to achieve our goals. Therein we can combine the two and have some very strong Kung Fu.

Reforming our immigration laws, doing SOMETHING about Mexico (I'd start with legalizing ALL drugs and cutting the nads off the cartels), Passing the Dream Act, etc, combined with increased penalties for EMPLOYERS who hire illegal aliens, increased sentencing for illegals who commit violent crimes here (not just the crime of crossing the border to wash dishes at a taqueria - I'm talking gang-bangers), things like that.

As to the Fence. IF ALL the fence did was stop or hinder illegal border crossings, then I'd be fine with that. But that's not all it does. The border fence ignores the fact that borderlands are permeable in so many ways, sociologically, ecologically and economically. Crap, man the border fence originally was supposed to cut THROUGH UT-Brownsville's campus...who thought THAT was a good idea???? UT was of course able to fight the fence and come up with a solution. But what about people whose land was condemned? People don't seem to realize that people lost their homes because of this. SOME PEOPLE had their properties split in two and now have to go to border crossing to access parts of their land. The fence is BADLY designed and takes advantage of those who can least afford to fight for their rights.

UTB has done a study on the negative effects of the Fence. And they are significant. About the study. I don't' have access t this journal for some reason.... SHSU doesn't seem to subscribe to it. So I can't link the actual article...mmmm. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

That is equivalent to about 1% of all murders in the U.S. annually.

There is a reason I'm a Liberal Arts major...Math is hard...

That should read; That is about 0.01% of all murders in the US Annually.

(how sad is it that I passed the exam to be a 4-8th grad math teacher?) 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

But at the same time, deporting kids who were brought here at a young age to a country that really isn't their home doesn't seem to be very American either.

I suggest you read just how old this amnesty for DREAMers are. The last time I looked it was up to age16. I sure remember my neighborhood and schools when I was that age. To say it is only for kids who have no memory of their native land is absurd. They ALL speak their native language fluently, otherwise why do we need bilingual classes? Of course, they should be sent back with their families. It is stupid to let the parents stay,or to have taxpayers foot the bill for family reunification when the minors are caught crossing illegally. The illegal parent should be deported along with the child.

Violent crimes should not be the only criterion for deportation. It should be ANY felony. Being here illegally should not be a shield from obeying the laws the rest of us MUST OBEY OR GO TO PRISON. Then we have the silly idea that all those who have not committed any crime should be allowed to stay. That means that all those who get a tourist visa can make that an immigration visa and a green card.

There is no shortage of workers for any occupation. What exists is low pay for most of those unfilled jobs. My next door neighbor in McAllen was a LEGAL immigrant from Mexico who was a skilled auto mechanic. His pay was $8/hr because most of his co workers were working in the US illegally and commuted to work every day from their homes in Mexico. There is an Anglo farmworker who worked in the fields when the UFW had contracts. His pay for field work was in todays dollars $50/hr. For that kind of money, I WILL get out there. He made so much money, he took half the year off after harvest.

The only kind of reform needed is to enforce the laws we have now and expedite deportations and finish the fencing. The siting of the fence can be flexible and does not have to be right on the Rio Grande, but can be outside towns. We already have checkpoints set up on all the roads leading out, so this fencing can be put along and string all those check points together. All the fence can do is slow down illegals to allow BP agents to catch them and to keep southbound guns and money from going south. 

gunsnroses --- 12 years ago -

The BEST way to handle this mess is to heavily patrol our borders to protect Texans! 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

I suggest you read just how old this amnesty for DREAMers are. The last time I looked it was up to age16.

While I think that's a little old, I don't REALLY have a major problem with that. How many 16 y.o.kids have say in what their parents do? My example of kids being deporting not knowing their mother country is an example, not every possible permutation.

But I do Not think there should be amnesty for the parents.

It should be ANY felony.

AGAIN, an example. NOT every possible permutation.

That means that all those who get a tourist visa can make that an immigration visa and a green card.

That's a detail and could be worked out.

The siting of the fence can be flexible

But it hasn't been. And people who have been in their land for GENERATIONS have lost it. Just search "family loses land to border fence" for examples.

Additionally, Tribal lands of three American Indian nations would be divided by the proposed border fence.

And at $4.1bn, it's more costly than the entire border patrol which has a budget of $3.8 bn.

A Fence works great for a yard, or a building, or even a large structure...but a 1951 mile border? I think another term for it should be the U.S. Maginot Line.

BOONDOGGLE. It's there just to make scared people feel good.

As to; The BEST way to handle this mess is to heavily patrol our borders to protect Texans!

Yep, that's what people have been saying for over 100 years now, and even when the border is heavily patrolled, it doesn't work.

AGAIN, Bashing our head against a wall until it breaks is not the solution. There are better, more cost effective ways to control illegal immigration than thousands or tens of thousands of border guards and a ridiculous fence that's easily defeated. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

I remember when the US was deporting even naturalized US citizens, much less crooks who are not even citizens. The Mafia can tell us all about that. So any felony conviction should be sufficient to toss even LEGAL immigrants, not only illegal ones.

I travelled along much of the Eastern European borders which had secure borders over a lot longer stretch and more difficult terrain and those were quite secure. I even know a person who managed to escape from East Germany and the pilots who did it. It was written up in FLYING under the article title Freedom Bell. So I know that no border is completely secure. During WWII, the Army built a ROAD that was almost as long as our border with Mexico, it is called the ALCAN highway. The terrain was FAR worse than any along the southern border too. The cost projections are absurd since we do not need anything more than a double cyclone fence with razor wire on top.

If we can do something like the ALCAN highway in less than one year, we sure can construct a fence in less time and cost. We do not need to make it secure against tanks or vehicles. Of course, it needs to be patrolled by BP agents otherwise it is useless. All that is needed are some low tech sensors to alert for breeches. I think that even most people can design a fence that would work and get input from landowners so that they are accommodated.

Of course, the best defense is to mandate an E-Verify system for employers so that no illegal can get an on the books job. Then there has to be enforcement of off the books workers who are employed by crooked businessmen like many of the GOP moneymen who are fighting against enforcement. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

So any felony conviction should be sufficient to toss even LEGAL immigrants, not only illegal ones.

Hmmm... dunno about the legality of that today. The cases would be interesting to review. Maybe some day.

Also, the only thing I know about the Alcan is that it took something like 11,000 troops to build it.... I don't see that happening in this day and age.

As to the rest, it's just same-ole, same-ole. Though I agree that we need the E-verify, but we also need to revisit our WWII era guest worker program as well. But you know what the definition of insanity is, right? 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

but we also need to revisit our WWII era guest worker program as wel

The bracero program was instituted as a war measure since the US was short of farm workers. They were hired by the US government which took out a good portion of their pay as savings which went to the Mexican government payable upon return to Mexico. Of course, you know what happened to that money that was supposed to go to the workers. Part of the reason the money was not repaid was that most of the workers stayed in the US after the war, thus never went back to Mexico to collect. Of course, they probably knew that if they went back their chances of getting their money was zero. We already have a guest worker program, but most farmers find it easier to simply hire the illegals off the road, rather than obeying the law.

The problem is that the UFW was so successful in raising wages, their folks in Mexico heard about this and flooded into the US and destroyed the union and the higher wages. Most people forget that the original border vigilantes were Cesar Chavez and the UFW monitoring the border and reporting illegals to the INS and BP. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

The bracero program was instituted as a war measure since the US was short of farm workers.

We're short farm workers again, RJ. As well as housing workers. Jobs that apparently Americans won't do.

And yeah, I'm very aware of the issues with the WWII program. But those are details that CAN be learned from.

We actually have TWO guest worker programs. H2-A and H2-B, but both are significantly flawed.

But to be honest, I'm just beat... I was up off and on last night...so I'm going to bed. If you want to continue, let me know. Maybe tomorrow I'll feel alive. Tonight I'm brain dead. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

(for some reason, the above post was still sitting here cycling this morning) 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Actually we do NOT have a shortage of workers in any field. We still have over 10 million unemployed. The real problem is that the jobs those who complain are going begging don't want to pay enough.

I don't know if you get up to the New Caney area on I-59. About one year ago the Walmart distribution center here put up a help wanted billboard along 59. The advertised wage started at about $11/hr. Next week it went to $12/hr, the week after that it went to $13/hr and after that it came down.

Given the rednecks around here, I can guarantee you, these employers will not hire a black American under any circumstances. If the employers do not want to pay a good wage, or will not hire black Americans, TOUGH! They can do the work themselves, pay more or go out of business and work for somebody else. It is not our job to subsidize them by providing cheap illegal labor and having US pay the costs.

The minimum wage adjusted for inflation would now be about $22/hr. THAT should be the minimum paid for workers in these so called unfilled jobs. When those jobs are paying $30/hr and they go unfilled, THEN I will agree that there is a worker shortage. NOT before. That is called supply and demand of the free market. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

The minimum wage adjusted for inflation would now be about $22/hr. THAT should be the minimum paid for workers in these so called unfilled jobs. When those jobs are paying $30/hr and they go unfilled, THEN I will agree that there is a worker shortage. NOT before. That is called supply and demand of the free market.?



Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahah.


Unskilled labor at 22.00 an hour. LMAO 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

The minimum wage adjusted for inflation would now be about $22/hr. THAT should be the minimum paid for workers in these so called unfilled jobs. When those jobs are paying $30/hr and they go unfilled, THEN I will agree that there is a worker shortage. NOT before.

Oh really? You're failing to factor in numerous variables that would require a Graduate degree in Economics to understand. You people stop talking about minimum wage. You don't understand it.

Here's a simple concept for you:
Minimum wage hasn't risen because the number of workers earning minimum wage has decreased significantly since 1950. ie: People don't rely on it like they used to.
Also, the workforce is significantly different than it was in 1950. I know teenagers that make more than MW doing their summer part time job. MW is not the problem you think it is. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

Oh really? You're failing to factor in numerous variables that would require a Graduate degree in Economics to understand. You people stop talking about minimum wage. You don't understand it.

Actually it is YOU who does not understand the economics of raising the minimum wage. Until you can show me a PhD in economics from MIT and a Nobel Prize in economics, I will take the reasoning of a REAL expert on the subject, Paul Krugman who wrote a column in the NYTimes about that subject recently. Your opinion is not worth much to rational folks.

I remember I had an economics prof in college who was decrying the high wages of auto workers on assembly lines. I asked him if he had ever worked on one. He said no. I informed him that I had, and that if anything, they were underpaid. They do more work and produce more in one hour that he or any other pencil pusher ever did. They also work EIGHT hours a day, not one hour, and then take a break for an hour. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Actually we do NOT have a shortage of workers in any field.

If they're not applying for the jobs then there's a shortage, RJ. And BOTH agriculture and home building are reporting shortages of workers.

The minimum wage adjusted for inflation would now be about $22/hr.

I don't see THAT ever happening, RJ.

And the wage for a crop picker is closer to about $4.00 an hour on a good day because they're generally paid on a "per piece" basis which makes them exempt from the FLSA. Never mind the fact that a lot of these employees are not reported to begin with. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

If they're not applying for the jobs then there's a shortage, RJ. And BOTH agriculture and home building are reporting shortages of workers.

This is the classic supply/demand curve. There will be more workers as the wages rise, just as commodities demand will rise as prices decline. This is not absolutely that simple, but the process is basically the same. As the example I cited from the Walmart distribution center showed. They DID get enough workers once the wages rose high enough. For agriculture it is more complex, but as one writer who actually worked on a crew during the heyday for the UFW, he reported that with his crew, he was earning $50/hr in todays dollars. You start paying that kind of money, there will be no shortage. The only place that there is a real shortage now is in flying. The requirements for airline pilots have gone up significantly, and one cannot just come in off the street into those jobs. But even there, the reason for the shortage is that the wages are so low that fewer people are going into that as a career. Until those wages go up, there will continue to be a real shortage. For the building trades, until the wages go up, there will be few applicants. It used to be that the unions had apprenticeship programs, but since the unions don't exist here any more, they no longer have those programs. The irony is that by getting rid of the building trades unions, the employers cut their own throats. So now they want to get cheap illegal labor and complain about no workers. The problem is THEM, not us or the law. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

There will be more workers as the wages rise

Yeah... ummmmm... that sounds a lot like "The Job Creators will take advantage of the tax breaks and create jobs"

That hasn't happened either.

Maybe I'm just cycnical. BUT..... 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

That hasn't happened either.

That proposition flies in the face of reality, while the FACT is that we have about 11 million unemployed and about the same number of illegals. While they are not exactly equal and interchangeable, they are close enough to make a BIG dent in the unemployed. Then if there are shortages, we can make a fair assessment as long as the border is secured, and we have internal controls on employment. AFTER that, then we will be able to devise our immigration policies to make up for any deficiencies in the labor pool. THAT is the only rational way to proceed. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

That proposition flies in the face of reality

How so? You know what I see when I look for jobs out there in this country right now? Bunch of low wage, non-career jobs. Crap, I saw a restaurant looking for EXPERIENCED Bussers... Really? REALLY??? You don't want to train your own bussers???

And those two populations of people are only interchangeable if they WANT TO BE interchangeable. Since both agribusiness and home builders (using only TWO examples - I'm sure there are more) are complaining that they don't have enough workers, then clearly those two populations are NOT interchangeable. Unless you want to go all fascist and require unemployed to take jobs or something... is that what you're suggesting here?

THAT is the only rational way to proceed.

So if we don't do it the way Randjet does it, then it's stupid? You sound like John Lynch now.

A: The border will NEVER be secured. No border ever has been.

B: What you're proposing is unrealistic on its face in the current economic climate.

C: and yes, I'll admit that what I'm proposing would require a government that can act efficiently and thus is at least as pie-in-the-sky as what you're proposing.

BUT, D: YOUR suggestions are NOT the only RATIONAL way to proceed. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

So if we don't do it the way Randjet does it, then it's stupid? You sound like John Lynch now.A: The border will NEVER be secured. No border ever has been.

No I am open to any rational proposals. The fact is that any border can be made secure and has been done before as the Eastern European border during communist control proved. You confuse secure with impermeable. That is clearly an impossible task. For your info, the EU is constructing a border fence now to keep Ukrainians, and Russians out of the EU. They seem to know that fences work quite well. As do the anti-fencing folks who complain that the fences work so well that it forces illegals out into the desert and hard places to cross. You cannot say fences don't work, and then complain that they DO work too well.

So far I have seen no workable proposals that don't leave so many unintended consequences that they are a farce. Even the DREAM act is absurd since it allows "kids" up to 16 to enter and get amnesty. The last version allowed those up to age 35 to claim amnesty. Such proposals are absurd on their faces, since they say we cannot deport 11 million illegals, but ICE CAN process that number of people to gain amnesty! That is clearly impossible, and it is easier and more reliable to determine if they are US citizens and if they are here legally. If they are not, out they go. We don't even have to have their real name to do that. They can use whatever name they want, and they will still get booted. Now if they wish to prove WHO they are, that will take a LOT OF WORK and checking. Then we will have to do even more work to determine WHEN they came in illegally and to check on that. The last amnesty, they simply refused to check on anything, and fraud was rampant so that DOUBLE the number of people were amnestied. So unless we wish to hire another 50,000 ICE agents to run all these checks, we might as well say, the border is open and anybody can enter and use aliases to wash their criminal past. think that will work to our interest? 

d:-] --- 12 years ago -

Actually it is YOU who does not understand the economics of raising the minimum wage. Until you can show me a PhD in economics from MIT and a Nobel Prize in economics, I will take the reasoning of a REAL expert on the subject, Paul Krugman who wrote a column in the NYTimes about that subject recently. Your opinion is not worth much to rational folks.


If "take the reasoning" means just repeating what other people have said then keep going. You can claim those word for yourself and look really smart on the internet. We don't have to tell anyone, it can be our secret. ;)

I'll let you get back to solving the country's problems from the convenience of your keyboard ... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

You cannot say fences don't work, and then complain that they DO work too well.

I don't complain that they work too well. You couldn't convince me that they work at all against someone who has say... a home made - and disposable - ladder....

0

0

(as far as illegals dying in the out of the way places, he11, that's just p1ss poor planning on their part... get a canteen! some jerky and a compass would be nice too!)

Or say, some creative smugglers with a welding machine (and a tiny bit more sense than these idiots).

0

Article

And since when does EUROPE doing something mean that it works????

we might as well say, the border is open and anybody can enter and use aliases to wash their criminal past.

Actually, I have a solution to that. We're using it in Afghanistan. It's a facial recognition program.

Troops go out, and take pictures of all the people at a certain location. They have a handheld device that compares fingerprints and iris and facial photos against a biometric watch list. My cousin who was deployed until last year was telling me about these patrols they went on doing this. I suspect my nephew who is over there now may be doing the same thing unless he get onto the C-RAM project. (BTW...you like hardware, right? Check out he C-Ram - basically it's a truck mounted Vulcan Phalanx system)

Article 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

You couldn't convince me that they work at all against someone who has say... a home made - and disposable - ladder....

I have to admit that I wonder where they get the designers of these border fences. All that is needed is a 20' high cyclone fence with razor or concertina wire on top leaning out about three feet. Make it a double fence, with a road down the middle. That would defeat all the shown measures to get over. Then just join all the checkpoints with a cyclone fence of the same construction 25 miles from the border, and problem solved. If an illegal can haul a thirty foot ladder 25 miles across the desert, to the final fence. I think we need to let him in and sign him up for our Olympic teams.

We already have a biometric system called Secure Communities which compares fingerprints with a data base of illegals who have been caught before. Of course, the pro-illegals are against that since it catches too many illegals who have re-entered the US and thus have become felons. CA has banned all their law enforcement agencies from sending fingerprints to the Federal data base. I guess that they want to keep those murderers, thieves, etc.. and don't want them to leave courtesy of ICE. Getting a fingerprint or biometric data means only that you have them listed before. It does NOT tell you their real name, or place or country of origin.

I would consider the border secure if we got the rate of illegal crossers down to 1-2000/yr. That is a manageable number that poses little problem. One also has to look at interior measures such as E-Verify for all employers. The previous border fencing such as eastern Europe had which was quite effective had one failing which was once one was over the fence, you were home free. Nobody was going to come after you once you entered illegally. We have the fact that once across, the illegals should not be home free at all. Their problems should just be beginning and get worse the longer they stay. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

meh

Moral of the story...if you want to go to another country, do it legally. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

20' high cyclone fence with razor or concertina

Also easily defeated... one or two saddle blankets does the trick....and I KNOW Mexico has saddle blankets.

Plus, Cyclone?

0

I've defeated your undefeatable fence, RJ. 

randyjet --- 12 years ago -

I've defeated your undefeatable fence, RJ.

I never said it is supposed to be undefeatable. In FACT, the whole point is to allow illegals to get through and to allow for easy repair. You cannot arrest a person on the opposite side of the fence. You need observation posts along the fence or have sensors to alert the BP when the fence is being cut. The nice thing about cyclone fencing is you can see through it and can see a group of people approaching it. You do not want to alert them before they cut and want to wait until they are ALL across. Then they have the problem of finding the hole in the dark while being chased. Then they have another fence waiting for them 25 miles ahead. this is NOT rocket science. The only thing a fence is supposed to do is to define the border, and be barrier to slow down any violators. It will also make it harder for guns and cash going south. Simple



 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground