Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Surrogate refused to abort.

who's talking here?

Shana Su 1
Polly Ester 5
Lillabeth 12
Laurabeth 4
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
TexasOma 6
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
SineadORebellion 1
sheddy 3
photophanatic 2
Semper 1
dogs 1
BrownEyedGirl9287 21
mary of magdala 1
Smoochie and The Bean 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

Surrogate refuses to abort.

Do you think she did the "right" thing? I know, for me, I would have done the same dispite going against the wishes of the parents.

Crystal Kelley, a surrogate who entered into an agreement to have a Connecticut couple’s baby for them last year, found herself embroiled in a bitter battle when an ultrasound found fetal abnormalities, and the couple asked her to have an abortion, a CNN report revealed this week.

More on Shine: Selfless Surrogate Retires After Giving Birth to 15th Baby

Kelley refused to abort, touching off a legal battle that had each side going to great lengths to save the unborn baby in its own way—the parents, by wanting to “have mercy on the child and let her go,” and Kelley, by deciding to “carry and protect” the child until its birth.

More on Yahoo!: Ontario Surrogate Mother Slapped with $1,400 Hospital Bill

After a many-months-long ordeal that involved lawyers, monetary offers, and Kelley’s move from Connecticut to Michigan, where state laws would see her as the rightful mother, “Baby S” was born—with even more health problems than expected. The baby is now 8 months old, living with adoptive parents, has had three surgeries with more to come, and, if she lives, faces a 50 percent chance she won’t be able to ever walk or talk.

But Kelley says she doesn’t regret what she did.

“No one else was feeling this pregnancy the way that I was. No one else could feel her kicking and moving around inside,” she told CNN. “I knew from the beginning that this little girl had an amazing fighting spirit, and whatever challenges were thrown at her, she would go at them with every ounce of spirit that she could possibly have.”

It all began in August of 2011, when Crystal, who has two children of her own, began working with a surrogacy agency; she agreed to work with a couple who wanted but could not have a fourth child. She would be a gestational carrier, meaning she would have no genetic connection to the baby, but would carry a baby formed by a frozen embryo the couple had left from a previous round of in-vitro, and the father’s sperm. Her fee would be $22,000.

Just ten days later Crystal, then 29, conceived. But everyone’s happiness turned to angst when a routine five-month ultrasound revealed many physical abnormalities, including a cleft palate and lip, a brain cyst and serious heart defects.

“Given the ultrasound findings, (the parents) feel that the interventions required to manage (the baby’s medical problems) are overwhelming for an infant, and that it is a more humane option to consider pregnancy termination,” members of the fetal medical staff at Hartford Hospital wrote to Kelley’s midwife, according to CNN. The parents had already gone through three previous premature births that left two of their children with medical problems.

But Kelley, they added, disagreed, and was “adamantly” opposed to aborting.

It was an unfortunate time for both sides to discover such a wide chasm between their philosophical and ethical beliefs, according to at least one surrogacy expert.

“It’s very common to talk about [this type of issue] before there’s an actual pregnancy, and is something that should be agreed upon at the outset, to make sure that philosophically and ethically, parents and the carrier are on the same page,” reproductive law attorney Victoria Ferrara told Yahoo! Shine. “The same issue holds if there’s a triplet pregnancy. You need to have a carrier willing to carry a triplet pregnancy, because it could be risky.”

On the other side, added Ferrara, author of “Gestational Surrogacy, A Primer,” and owner of Worldwide Surrogacy Specialists in Fairfield, CT, parents may want to make sure to find a carrier who would be willing to undergo selective reduction in the case of triplets.

In one particular case of hers, she explained, “the carrier had originally said she would reduce, but when it came time, she had a lot of qualms about it.” She finally agreed, after hearing from a doctor about how high-risk the pregnancy would be, but the case serves as an example of how a situation like this one could arise, Ferrara said.

When Kelley would not agree to abort, according to CNN, she says the couple offered her $10,000 to reconsider. Kelley refused, instead asking for $15,000; the couple would not pay that much, and Kelley said she had changed her mind anyway.

Each side retained a lawyer, Kelley finding Michael DePrimo of Hamden, an anti-abortion First Amendment attorney with connections to the American Family Association who agreed to take on her case for free.

The couple’s attorney reminded Kelley that her contract with them stipulated she would have an abortion in the case of “severe fetus abnormality.” But such an agreement is not legally binding, Ferrara told Shine. “She still has the constitutional right that any woman has, to make decisions about her own body.”

Eventually, Kelley learned she and her children could relocate to Michigan, a state where the birth mother, and not the genetic parents, is considered the legal guardian. She chose this option, and gave birth to the baby there. Baby S was born with a panoply of issues, including holoprosencephaly, which means the brain fails to completely divide into distinct hemispheres, and heterotaxy, which means many of her internal organs are in the wrong places. She also has a misshapen ear and many complex heart problems. Ultimately, though, Kelley, a single mother, realized she could not raise Baby S, and wound up finding her adoptive parents who had experience with high-needs babies.

"S. wakes up every single morning with an infectious smile. She greets her world with a constant sense of enthusiasm," the baby's adoptive mother said in an e-mail to CNN. "Ultimately, we hold onto a faith that in providing S. with love, opportunity, encouragement, she will be the one to show us what is possible for her life and what she is capable of achieving."

Kelley, meanwhile, still wrestles with her decision to not keep the baby. “I know logically I did what was right.. and I know that nobody in the world would dare think that I gave up on Baby S after all the fighting I did for her, but the battle in my head is bigger and stronger than I really know how to handle,” she wrote on her personal blog in February. “I feel myself slipping down that slippery slope, and I am fighting so hard to stay afloat. I just hope I find a foothold soon.”

Ferrara told Shine she hopes that the public won’t “vilify the whole process of surrogacy” based on this one case. “Most often it just goes so beautifully,” the lawyer said, “and everyone understands the nature of the gift that’s been given and received.”
 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

gosh, I just saw her on the news yesterday with the baby but nothing was mentioned about her giving the baby up for adoption. :(

I think it raises a lot of ethical issues in regard to surrogacy. what if the issue had been reversed and the surrogate decided she wanted an abortion against the parents wishes? I wonder how that would be supported.

I don't know how I feel about it now hearing that she gave the baby up. I know as a single mother it would have been very tough for her to raise the child and I am guessing she did what she thought was best for the baby.

I hope the adoptive home is loving and stable for her. 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

This makes me wonder what caused the problems. Was it just genetic or did the science fail her? 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

Well, she had me until she gave the baby up for adoption. It would be so hard to have a child you knew would have to go through surgery after surgery and that no matter what you did, the child would never have a normal life. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

“No one else was feeling this pregnancy the way that I was. No one else could feel her kicking and moving around inside,” she told CNN. “I knew from the beginning that this little girl had an amazing fighting spirit, and whatever challenges were thrown at her, she would go at them with every ounce of spirit that she could possibly have.”

And yet she gave this "amazing fighting spirit" up? That's what got me as well. I would have kept the baby and taken care of her. Not pawned her off. 

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

My feeling is although she refused to abort.... She herself realized she could not care for this child ( as did her biological parents) and she took the easy way out. The biological
Parents knew there limitations. Now this baby will be a medical burden to tax payers for the rest of her life and will have zero quality of life. 

SineadORebellion --- 13 years ago -

Well adoption is better than abortion... 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

I think it is really weird that people get paid to have someone elses baby. I mean technically, it still isn't their baby since they aren't carrying it. It is like playing God. It is God's decision if you have a child or not. I think it is good that she didn't abort it bc i personally believe that abortion is murder since it stops a beating heart and it is sickining how they do it. You bring a baby into the world, it is your responsibility to take care of it. I think adoption is a nice thought but I know a few people that have been adopted and they both turned out bad/rebellious and resentful against their bio parents for giving them up. Some people are just not meant to have kids. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

She never should have agreed to be a surrogate knowing that it contained a clause stating that she agreed to an abortion if there were serious medical issues if she wasn't able to abide by the contract. she was renting her womb and that doesn't come without strings attached.

I know that maybe she didn't know how she would feel once she was carrying the baby, but that is something she should have realized, just like a surrogate who grows attached and decides she can't give the baby to the bio parents after all. At the same time, the bio parents have to realize the risk too.

However, she wanted 15k to abort the baby and the bio parents refused her, so she wasn't as strong in her feelings re abortion if she attempted to try to extort more money from them.

what a sad mess. 

photophanatic --- 13 years ago -

Says you sinead..... Would you adopt such a child? 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

Some people are just not meant to have kids.

Wow!! So all the babies given up for adoption shouldn't be allowed to have parents? And I guess by your logic.... Adoptive parents really aren't parent as they didn't carry them? 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

Would you adopt such a child?


Clearly somebody did: "S. wakes up every single morning with an infectious smile. She greets her world with a constant sense of enthusiasm," the baby's adoptive mother said in an e-mail to CNN. "Ultimately, we hold onto a faith that in providing S. with love, opportunity, encouragement, she will be the one to show us what is possible for her life and what she is capable of achieving." 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 13 years ago -

i read this yesterday and what i read is the adoptive parents were able to handle a special needs child.. not all parents can or are willing to. i think she did what she thought was right for the child, i dont see anything wrong with that. the child is in the best place with people who will love her and give her the best care they can, to me that is what is important. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

Lillabeth .. Didn't mean that. I think parents that chose to have sex should keep their children and not give them up..but since we live in a crappy world.. if they give them up then yes the poor children need parents but they are going to have to live the rest of their lives feeling rejected. .. And yeah, technically they really aren't their parents bc they are not blood, but as long as they love the child and are "fit" parents then so be it 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

Like i said .. I have seen this situation in real life and the adopted kids always turn out with emotional issues or drug/alcohol addictions etc. .. all bc their parents gave them up. 

Shana Su --- 13 years ago -

I think its really sad that this couple worked so hard to have a child and then couldn't handle it when they didn't get the child they wanted. We aren't God. We live with the blessings that God gives us. I'm glad this little girl was seen as a miracle and a life worth saving, because she deserves to be what she is, a gift from God. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

well, if choice is all about a woman being able to chose what to do with her body, then ultimately it was the surrogate's body that was carrying the baby, not the bio parents.

I understand her choice, but I'm not sure about her motives. if a bio parent gave up their baby because it was disabled or had medical conditions I am not sure people would be sympathetic.

it is just a reminder that science can do a lot of wonderful things but sometimes it also gives us moral dilemmas to deal with. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

We live with the blessings that God gives us. I'm glad this little girl was seen as a miracle and a life worth saving, because she deserves to be what she is, a gift from God.


Exactly. Well said, Natu. Beautiful.

Which is why I didn't abort our oldest daughter when the doctors told us after many tests that she would be born with a leg and arm much shorter then "normal". I prayed and prayed and told the doctors, "That we will be happy and are prepared for what God may or may not have instore for us." She was born healthy without any deformations dispite all the tests and even pictures. I truly believe in God and the power of prayer. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

I also have a 9 yr old step son whom we have cutody of and whom I pretty much slaved after for 8 years and really got nothing in return but hate and harassment from his bio mom .. His dad, my Husband really loves me for stepping up and being a mother to a child that isn't mine, but it causes conflict with the child and jealous bio mom, so i decided to step down, have a child of my own with my husband, whom i have been with for 8 years, and experience real motherhood. Blood really is thicker than water, sad to say. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

I am due to have a baby girl in a few weeks and pray that she is healthy and all of the above, but if she weren't I would still love her the same. I could never imagine giving up my child or aborting a child. We live in such a horrible world. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

my Husband really loves me for stepping up and being a mother to a child that isn't mine, but it causes conflict with the child and jealous bio mom, so i decided to step down, have a child of my own with my husband, whom i have been with for 8 years, and experience real motherhood. Blood really is thicker than water, sad to say.

does that mean you are giving up custody of the stepson?

I dont understand "blood is thicker than water" when a child is concerned. I mean, if you are raising a child, then dont you love it just as much as one you gave birth to? isn't that how adoptive parents feel about their children that they didn't give birth to and then go on to have a bio child? don't they love them the same? what about how the child feels? 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

so i decided to step down, have a child of my own with my husband, whom i have been with for 8 years, and experience real motherhood. Blood really is thicker than water, sad to say.

How sad for that little boy. Parents shouldn't have "favorites". Even step-parents. It causes a lot of wounds. Tossing that poor boy out like trash because he isn't YOUR BLOOD. He is your HUSBAND'S blood. Just think if he's willing to toss that child out, how will he be if your marriage doesn't go on as planned? 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

No it would be immoral to give up custody. She was never a real mother to him and never took care of him. My husband wishes that I was his sons real mother, but as much as I try to love a child that isn't mine, I just can't feel the same love that I feel for the baby growing inside me. I know that sounds horrible, but it is just how I feel. It is hard to be loving when his real "mom" has done nothing but cut me down and harass me. My step son will always love his mother no matter what she does, and I honestly don't want to get in the way of that. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

I dont understand "blood is thicker than water" when a child is concerned.

Me either. My husband of almost 12 years isn't the BIO father of our son, but that is his dad. The only dad he's ever known. Yes, he knows he isn't his BIO dad and he is an amazing 15 year old. AP classes, sports, ROTC, and debate. My husband is an amazing man and father. He treats ALL of our kids the same. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

I didn't say I had "favorites" or that i treated him badly. I don't at all. and my Husband would never toss any child of his out. Our marriage will last. Our relationship has lasted for 8 years and we have been married for almost 3 now. We are closer than you could imagine. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

I know that sounds horrible

Sorry, but it does. I just can't fathom EVER feeling that way. My heart breaks for your step-son. Feeling unloved and unwanted by his mother and now by his step-mother. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

My husband wishes that I was his sons real mother, but as much as I try to love a child that isn't mine, I just can't feel the same love that I feel for the baby growing inside me.

dont you worry then about how you will balance those feelings once you have your bio child? don't you worry that he will know you love your child more?

I feel bad for children that are put in these situations and have no say. kids deserve to be loved fully and people who think kids dont sense these things arent giving kids enough credit.

I hope that maybe when your baby arrives you will see that you really do have enough love to go around. maybe you are just in that state of pregnancy bliss and don't realize that you are more capable of loving him as much as your bio baby than you realize. You've had him for 8 year, that must be almost his whole childhood, right? 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

I treat my step son the same. I just don't feel the same love. I was the one who always took him to his after school sports etc. He is starting to rebel against me bc of his mother and bc I am expecting my first. He keeps asking us if we are going to sell her for 500$ .. Not sure if he got that from his mother, or because he is really jealous or what 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

Lillabeth... You did not read correctly. I NEVER treat him badly, and he feels loved. I just feel different about him since I didn't give birth to him. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

Hissyfit .. Yes I have been there for him and treated him like he was my own for 8 years. Things are starting to change though. We are having trouble with him, he is rebelling bc of his bio mom and I feel that in a few years he will want to live with his mother. I have done my share and tried my hardest but there is a time that i need to step down and rest. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 13 years ago -

i dont have legal step kids but in every way possible my bf's kids are my " step kids" they call me step mom etc.. now they are older but i love them as much as i do my own son. i would sacrifice the same that i would for mine.. flesh and blood to mean doesnt mean anything.. my bf's oldest is not his biologically but he has raised her for 24 yrs as his and in every way she is his even if he isnt her biologic dad..

i couldnt see treating any kid any different even if i didnt give birth to them. i know i am not their " mom" but i love the relationship we all have and would never change a thing. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I think some kids are better off if they never see their "real" parents. They can't give them what they need and are jealous of the people who CAN care for them. My husband's sister and her husband worked at a Baptist orphanage in Oklahoma. The kids still had one parent, but they were in jail or rehab or just not capable of taking care of their kids. They would work so hard to get these kids stable and doing good in school. It was a farm atmosphere and they would have them doing chores, etc. Then here would come mom, who would tell them that she would be coming soon to get them, which never happened. Those kids reverted right back to where they were, since they were leaving and didn't have to mind them. She said it happened time after time. I think maybe your stepson is concerned that you ARE going to care more for your baby. I would just tell him I loved him everyday and encourage him to look forward to his new sibling. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

Thank you Sheddy for your advice :)
I will do that. .. It is hard bc we always have to work hard to get him to do well in school and be responsible and right after his visit with his bio mom .. He comes back like a wild animal and rebellious. It is a never ending battle. Hopefully when he becomes an adult, he will see who really raised him and helped him in his life. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

I am an adoptive mother X2 ..... I could not imagine not having had the two precious angels in our life & have never thought of them as 'not our blood'. They are our children from the git-go!!! We have loved with them, laughed with them, cried with them, sympathized with them. We have suffered when they hurt, we have relished the glory when they excelled. When our son died in 2002 we grieved as no other parent could grieve. His 2 children consider us their Oma & Opa, even though they know we are their dad's adoptive parents & they say they have 3 grandmothers --- they also know their dad's birth mother.

Being an adoptive mother is a special honor - we CHOSE to bring these children into our lives - we WANTED them more than anything. Please, never think that adoptive children are doomed. if they give them up then yes the poor children need parents but they are going to have to live the rest of their lives feeling rejected. .. And yeah, technically they really aren't their parents bc they are not blood, but as long as they love the child and are "fit" parents then so be it

It seems to me that your 8 year old boy is crying out for help, please get it for him. He sounds like he needs some counseling with an expert child counselor, not just someone in the neighborhood or out of the yellow pages. Please, please, please get him some help now or he will definitely grow into your expectations of being troubled. If he is starting this at age 8, he will be a really experienced troubled youth at age 13. Please get him some help. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

Thank you for sharing, Oma. I never knew and have gained much respect for you. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

My husband and I are actually doing that bc we don't want him to grow up bad like his bio mom. He is already starting to lie and steal from my room. It is all a mess. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

Excellent. Do not let him talk you out of the counseling. It is one of the most important things you can do for him. 

Laurabeth --- 13 years ago -

It seems to me that your 8 year old boy is crying out for help, please get it for him. He sounds like he needs some counseling with an expert child counselor, not just someone in the neighborhood or out of the yellow pages. Please, please, please get him some help now or he will definitely grow into your expectations of being troubled. If he is starting this at age 8, he will be a really experienced troubled youth at age 13. Please get him some help.


I completely agree with Oma.....I am sure that young boy is seriously confused. Please don't give up on him.....you are his stablity whether you know it or not.

Spend more time with him than you ever have in the past. Show him with your actions that you are there for him and adding a baby to the home will not change that in any way for him.

Do not speak about his mother in a negative way in front of him......I know that will be difficult, but he will respect you for that in the long run.

Protect him and love him as if he was all that you have in this world! 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

TY Lillabeth

And totally agree with the post after mine. The boy is in great turmoil right now and is most likely worried that he will not be loved once the new baby comes. Make sure to involve him in the care but do not FORCE him to take care of the baby....like changing diapers, feeding. You do not want him to resent the baby or you. 

Lillabeth --- 13 years ago -

It seems to me that your 8 year old boy is crying out for help, please get it for him.

Agreed. This boy sounds so lost. Boys need a steady motherly figure. It doesn't help if you're always bad-mouthing his mother. He needs to know you'll always be there for him. Talk to him. Allow him to talk about his mother without making any snide comments. Even if she is making up lies, sit him down and say, "I'm sorry that your mother feels that way, but this how I feel......" Give him lots of hugs. When he is upset by something she's done or said, just hold him and say, "I will always love you no matter what." Remember to call him your SON, not step-son. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground