Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can the Bible be discussed with an open mind?

who's talking here?

Carla 4
Red Heifer 5
Perfection 1
Agent of Change 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
voice of reason 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 7
JohnLynch 7
Longhorn Mom 1
Work in Progress 7
thankfulformyfour 6
SagaciousSighFiGurl 14
Kyobungee 3
ZUULisBACK 3
justinCASE 10
Open Minded Belief 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Open Minded Belief --- 14 years ago -

Only by some, I guess.

"Closed-minded debate is what takes place between one or more contestants with no intention of changing point-of-view on the subject at hand.

While it may afford some entertainment for the participants and/or spectator-lurkers, of what real value is it?

It’s kind of like idling an engine for a few hours just to generate heat. No actual work gets done; no real result accrues from it.

How do you recognize when closed-minded debate is taking place? (Especially if you happen to be involved, and of the open-minded variety?)

The closed-minded debater will not concede any point. After all, he is right; why should he?
The closed-minded debater will insist on framing the issue/wording the question. This is to her advantage.
The closed-minded debater will frame the issue / word the question in personal terms if possible. This is to his advantage, as it opens to the door to personal attack as a diversion.
The closed-minded debater will make use of diversions frequently when unable to respond logically and accurately to a point made by her opponent.
The closed-minded debater will divert to side issues (relevant or not) in order to lengthen the discussion. (Some dogs bark because they like to hear the sound of their own voices. My neighbor has one.)
The closed-minded debater will show no interest in learning; learning is not the point. The closed-minded debater will show no interest in consensus; consensus is not the point. Winning is paramount. After all, he is right; why should he show such interest in collaboration with someone who is wrong?
The closed-minded debater will only recognize authorities and commentators who agree with her, and will discredit (substantively or not, usually not) those referenced by her opponent.
The closed-minded debater will only be able to see facts and citations of authorities one way, the way presently seen, and no other possibilities.
The closed-minded debater will accuse his opponent: of evading, of illogic, of intellectual dishonesty. After all, she is right; why shouldn’t she?
The closed-minded debater will frequently take offense at comments made with no intention of offending. This establishes power and calls into question his opponent’s character and therefore (ostensibly) generates sympathy for himself among the spectator-lurkers. No comment is too small to be magnified into a personal insult. This is also, often, a diversion.
The closed-minded debater will show little regard for conversational or personal ethic in the process. As stated before, winning is paramount; and when one is right, the end justifies the means.
The closed-minded debater will not be persuaded. Will. Not. Be. Persuaded.


These are fairly widespread tactics; you’ll see them all over the Web and on every so-called news network. What is truly disappointing to this believer is the size of the culture of closed-minded debate within Christendom. Believers –who of all people should be the first to understand the difference between faith and fact; the necessity of being open-minded and selfless with others; the victory that comes through saying “I was wrong” — seem to be among the very worst in many instances.

[i]Their language may not (or may!) be as offensive, but their utter contempt for those who disagree with them on dearly-held beliefs — whether well-founded or not — is absolutely unmistakable … whether by another believer, or someone who does not believe, does not know the Story, has never really even heard of Jesus of Nazareth (other than as part of a curse or epithet).[/i]

Christian discourse should be light-years above simply civil discourse. It should be persuasive in its humility, its love and its deep concern for others above self. It should be unyielding in matters of faith, and understanding in matters of opinion, and sufficiently mature in spirit to discern them.

I have gone past being weary of the level of discourse among believers that I’ve seen (and, sadly, been a part of) and my tolerance for it has reached an all-time low.

So I’ve set some goals for myself when I feel drawn (or sucked) into closed-minded debate:

I will not be the closed-minded party.
I will love and pray for the one(s) who disagree(s) with me.
I will not argue matters of opinion anymore. You’re entitled to my opinion any time you like it; just read it here. I’ll be glad to read yours. I’ll probably be secretly delighted that we’re alike or different in certain ways because I believe that such commonality and diversity will both enrich and strengthen the body of believers. But I’m not going to go into hours and paragraphs and billions of pixels over something we don’t have to agree upon.
I will argue matters of faith. When I encounter something that challenges faith, has the potential to enlighten or strengthen or deepen it, I will argue it and argue it passionately.
I will admit when I am wrong. And I am frequently wrong.
I will continue to tell you when something is my opinion, my conclusion … and when something is simply the fact as virtually everyone else in the known universe agrees upon it, citing reference when possible.
I will do my best to discern the difference between those two.
I will concede my opponent’s points when they are correct. Hey, it happens.
I will always try to be a brother to a sibling in Christ, a fellow believer, and share fellowship with her.
I will always try to be a brother to someone who does not believe, and share fellowship with him as well.
I will continue to believe that Jesus loves without precondition, which is my example to follow.
If I cannot foresee a worthwhile outcome, I reserve the right to not participate in a challenged debate at all. I may well ask the challenger: “Is there really a possibility that either of us is going to change the other’s mind on this matter? If not, is there really any point in proceding?”
Well, that’s my short list. It’s a start.

But I think it’s a good one."

Keith Brenton, 2011 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Have you been reading on here awhile? LOL.

Interesting and good article, BUT the answer to your question is probably a "no".

Religion discourse rarely stays civil on here. This will prolly be my only post b/c of that...

If you are trollin', carry on. And pop the corn. :) 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

only by people willing to learn 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Now that right there is funny. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Now that right there is funny. 

yep...it is...funny things always have truth to them 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

You are going to have people who can discuss the Bible with an open mind...and there will be those who can't.

I believe the word of God...and can back up most of my convictions right away or get back with someone in a short time period.

I don't argue nor will I stand for attacks on my faith...but if anyone just wants to learn more and even gently debate, I am in. 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

I didn't read that long post BTW...lol 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

you should've-it was very good- 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It doesnt matter how we debate it, there is truth in the Bible that we should seek, and that is all that matters. HIS truth, not our debate skills. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Very well stated Work in Progress.

Not all of us learn the same way and we should respect that.

Some are visual learners, others are audio. others are slow, others need to be left alone to learn on their own, some need a more direct learning of being told.

It doesn't matter if that learning style isn't right for me, when it isn't I move on. Only a simpleton would attempt to stop someone from learning if a particular style works for them. 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

HIS truth, not our debate skills.

of course...perhaps I was unclear. If someone wants to challenge my faith and is there for the purpose of simply arguing, I will not stand there and take their abuse. If they want to learn and ask challenging questions then its another thing all together. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I was referring to the OP, it's not about having an open mind, but a focused mind. You read the Bible trying to discover HIS truth, not your own interpretation.

Even when the debating, the objective is truth. You interpret scripture with scripture, and remain faithful to the message. It's not about our skill, but it is about yearning to know the truth of what God has revealed in the word. 

thankfulformyfour --- 14 years ago -

Got it :) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I was referring to the OP, it's not about having an open mind, but a focused mind.


I have to disagree a bit there. We do have to realize no one person or church knows it all. We also have to realize there are many grey areas. Once someone choses to believe, the journey begins. And I have found the more I learned, the more I realize I don't know. We learn a lot from faith experiences, just like in the physical world. I know of folks who received a true physical miracle of healing. I know many, many more who haven't. That ONE subject right there can be debated without ending. Both will tell you that their experience can be validated by scriprure...LOL.

One needs an open mind to even find God. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I have to disagree a bit there. We do have to realize no one person or church knows it all. We also have to realize there are many grey areas. Once someone choses to believe, the journey begins. And I have found the more I learned, the more I realize I don't know. We learn a lot from faith experiences, just like in the physical world. I know of folks who received a true physical miracle of healing. I know many, many more who haven't. That ONE subject right there can be debated without ending. Both will tell you that their experience can be validated by scriprure...LOL.

One needs an open mind to even find God.


Well, I don't disagree with anything that you have said there. However, I believe that there is ONE truth, as revealed by the scriptures. We are supposed to seek THAT truth. Our opinions don't matter, the scripture matters.

On those situations where scripture can be used to back up both arguments, which, let's face it, is the whole reason for multiple denominations, there is still ONE truth, we just don't know which it is. Probably no one denomination has it all right, but they should still seek to find the answer from scripture, with the help of the Holy Spirit.

I guess where I get my britches all contorted is because these days, having an "open mind", means that we can dismiss scripture and approach God however we want, doing whatever sins we want, and speaking things about Him that are contrary to scripture. Obviously, I think this is heresy.

It's also called postmodernism, and it's creeping into the churches all around us. I think that Christians need to be warned now more than ever to hold fast to the scriptures that define the faith, rather than following what the world defines as "Christianity." The world will always steer us wrong. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

guess where I get my britches all contorted is because these days, having an "open mind", means that we can dismiss scripture and approach God however we want, doing whatever sins we want, and speaking things about Him that are contrary to scripture. Obviously, I think this is heresy.


I know what you are saying. I guess I was referring to those who had already accepted God.

I still like the letters written in red the best. But that's just moi. And I think the truth is, there are countless levels and degrees of faith. Even after you have faith, it can wax and wane as well. The Bible says that faith is based on knowledge. And taking that into consideration, you are going to have wildly varrying degrees of experience. And you are right, it is why man had divided himself into so many fractions of those who all call themselves "believers". ALL this is what I mean by GREY areas. 

Kyobungee --- 14 years ago -

Lets start with the first two books of the bible and Genesis.
The first chapter states that God creates Adam and Eve at the same time,

In the 2nd chapter God creates Adam, then Adam wanders around, names the animals does a few things, then he talks to God and Say's he is lonely, so God says Ok i will provide you with a mate so he takes the Rib and creates Eve.

In the first Two chapters of the book are conflicting Creation stories , so which is true? Now Believers will say "well it's just two different versions of the same story" this is fine but then don't say in the next Breath that the Bible is meant to be taken literally and when it says something it means it!! because it obviously does not. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

what SiFi said- 

Longhorn Mom --- 14 years ago -

GOD SAID IT, THAT SETTLES IT.
NO DEBATE NEEDED! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I also think, learning is a process that takes a lifetime- there are things that I believe, that are subject to change, I'm sure-I'm by nature a moderate, shades of gray person, so I listen to people when they sound reasonable-who knows where I'll be in a year? my one complete belief is, I love Jesus, and have accepted him as my Lord and Savior- 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

God said it. To people. In Hebrew (or was it Aramaic?). Who interpreted what He said and wrote it down. And others translated it, to Greek, Latin, English. And others spend their lives in study to understand what it means, and can't entirely agree. Otherwise, it is as clear as day. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

God said it. To people. In Hebrew (or was it Aramaic?). Who interpreted what He said and wrote it down. And others translated it, to Greek, Latin, English. And others spend their lives in study to understand what it means, and can't entirely agree. Otherwise, it is as clear as day.

And this is the difficulty. However, that does not mean that anything goes. . .we still have the responsibility of the study! 

Kyobungee --- 14 years ago -

Can be talked about, or is it only closed minded people?

The Golden Rule is nothing but a lie in the bible 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Kyo, did you read the link you posted???? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

Red, you're on target, for sure, and so is WIP- 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

God said it. To people. In Hebrew (or was it Aramaic?). Who interpreted what He said and wrote it down. And others translated it, to Greek, Latin, English. And others spend their lives in study to understand what it means, and can't entirely agree. Otherwise, it is as clear as day.


The Bible was originally written in Hebrew (with some Aramaic in Daniel) for the Old Testament and Greek for the New Testament. The New Testament was originally written in Koine (common) Greek.

But yes. That's the truth and why an open mind is necessary. But I agree with WIP, some things regarding faith in God aren't negotiable if you really believe. As in believing in multiple gods and yada yada. The Bible says that we become part of God's family when we believe, and receive an inheritance in doing so.

Another thing, while the Bible is filled with a ton of mystery and all, and can't truly be verified in the scientific type realm, it makes general sense to me, that there is a supreme intelligent power that created life. I just can't get away from that. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

What SiFi said-LOL!! 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

I still like the letters written in red the best.

You should consider that the whole Bible is written in red. The whole Bible is about Jesus Christ.


In the first Two chapters of the book are conflicting Creation stories , so which is true?

Both Chapters are true. They don't conflict. In Genesis 1, God tells us they were made on the same day(day six), not at the same time. Chapter 2 is just a more detailed description of what happened on day six.


so I listen to people when they sound reasonable

If you are a Christian, you are to check out what someone says with Scripture. You have said "my feeling is for rape, incest, and to protect the life of the mother" that abortion should be allowed. Scripture doesn't say that, so if you are a Christian, you will go with what Scripture says, and not your feelings.


God said it. To people. In Hebrew (or was it Aramaic?). Who interpreted what He said and wrote it down.

There was no interpretation needed for someone to write down what God said. Also, you are confusing translation with interpretation. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

still like the letters written in red the best.

You should consider that the whole Bible is written in red. The whole Bible is about Jesus


Did you ever do that little experiment in school where one person tells another person a simple statement and then it is passed along thru like 10 other people, and at the end of the line the statement doesn't resemble the original?

Not everything in it is, "thus sayeth the Lord". Stuff written in red is. Well, for the most part. It got translated too. LOL 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

Did you ever do that little experiment in school where one person tells another person a simple statement and then it is passed along thru like 10 other people, and at the end of the line the statement doesn't resemble the original?

That analogy doesn't hold water. It is no where near what happened with the Bible.

Yes, everything is "thus sayeth the Lord". Read 2 Timothy 3:16. "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness". That means "God breathed".

That is backed up by Job 32:8. "But there is a spirit in man: and the inspiration of the Almighty giveth them understanding". Inspiration means breath, spirit. 

Carla --- 14 years ago -

Another thing, while the Bible is filled with a ton of mystery and all, and can't truly be verified in the scientific type realm, it makes general sense to me, that there is a supreme intelligent power that created life. I just can't get away from that.

There are some concepts in the Bible that are difficult for us to understand because we are to see through God's eye's rather than react through human nature.

There are some references that raise questions.

But those are the exceptions rather than the rule. Most of the Bible is straightforward and plain speaking.

So when people say that, I have to ask, "Have you read it?"

When the Jews were getting ready to enter the land of Canaan, they were given a warning and a promise. It ends with a statement in Deuteronomy 30:11:

11 Now what I am commanding you today is not too difficult for you or beyond your reach. 12 It is not up in heaven, so that you have to ask, “Who will ascend into heaven to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?” 13 Nor is it beyond the sea, so that you have to ask, “Who will cross the sea to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?” 14 No, the word is very near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart so you may obey it.

God doesn't make it hard to understand or difficult to discover. He lays it out.

I think it is the simple straightforwardness that bothers people because there really isn't room for equivocation.

To people that try to dismiss it by saying it was "written by man, translated, interpreted," etc., etc., etc. Again I have to say, Have you read it?

Because if you have and truly believe that, then if you have any honesty in you, you would have no choice but to acknowledge how truly miraculous the book is.

It is so internally consistent in spite of being written over the course of 1,500 years, three languages, and 40 authors.

Not only is it consistent in its message and themes, but it also is unique in the fact of the number of prophecies that have been fulfilled. The fact that one of our main topics of conversation in the nation today is relations with Israel is proof of that.

People don't even bring up that anymore because the fulfilled prophecies are irrefutable.

And then you bring up the "scientific type realm." Really? You really think that the Bible and science are divorced?

Seriously?

Have you read about the DNA project and their tracing the Jewish people to four women (Abraham's two wives and their handmaids?)

Have you read about Hans Jenny and Cymatics and the Hebrew language?

Have you read about the archaeological discoveries that prove that, yes, there were Semetic communities during the time claimed by the Bible for the Jew's time in Israel.

It goes on and on.

I read the National Geographic web site fairly often and I can't tell you how many times I actually laugh out loud. There are so many discoveries that disprove the commonly taught theory of evolution. I'm sure that someone who has invested their entire life in that worldview finds it frightening.

One article was actually titled, "Evolution: Got it Right the First Time." (If it didn't change it's not evolution.) 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

Carla, that was an awesome post. Deuteronomy 30:11 does make it very clear. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

when people say that, I have to ask, "Have you read it?"

I was referring to proving it is true beyond someone's choice to believe it. You can't prove there is a God and that the Bible is truth. It is based on FAITH, an unseen power of belief.


And then you bring up the "scientific type realm." Really? You really think that the Bible and science are divorced?

Seriously?


No. I was again referring to proving something like the physical sciences do, which you can't always do with biblical issues. If Noah's Ark is indeed sitting on Mt. Ararat, then you have physical science to look into.

The Bible says that faith is the "essence of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

The Bible says that faith is the "essence of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen."

Christians are to believe in Jesus by faith. That doesn't mean it stops there. Once you truly believe in Jesus, the proof is made clear to you. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Christians are to believe in Jesus by faith. That doesn't mean it stops there. Once you truly believe in Jesus, the proof is made clear to you.

I didn't say it did stop there. I've said numerous times, it's a journey.

And HOW is it made clear to you? I know the answer BTW, just seeing if you do.

No matter what anyone says, you have to admit we are talking about the unseen here, God is unseen, faith is unseen, spirituality is ALL unseen. Evidence that God exists is mostly unseen, unless you believe in creationism of course.

That's why the Bible says you'll know people by the fruit in their lives... 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

Evidence that God exists is mostly unseen, unless you believe in creationism of course.

Why would a Christian believe in anything else? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

Carla is my "go to" girl, for all things biblical-Carla, do you think that once the Greek's culture took over, there was a definite Pagan influence? Like Christmas, the fun part of Easter,the sabbath changing to Sunday? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Evidence that God exists is mostly unseen, unless you believe in creationism of course.

Why would a Christian believe in anything else?


Just again, making the point it's a choice to believe in the unseen realm of faith and faith issues. Some don't chose to believe in creationism, hence that is no proof to them...they believe in pure evolution.


And HOW is it made clear to you? I know the answer BTW, just seeing if you do.

What do you think? 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

Some don't chose to believe in creationism, hence that is no proof to them...they believe in pure evolution.

Not Christians.

do you think that once the Greek's culture took over

It was Roman influence. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

And HOW is it made clear to you? I know the answer BTW, just seeing if you do.

What do you think?
 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground