Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Daughter says she wants to go live with her dad. I'm distraught

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 1
napoleon 1
Perfection 1
Paige Paige 1
kimmer 1
Laurabeth 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
susie q 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 9
Mabs 1
FlowersGirl 1
Bornanraisedkw 3
Dorothy Parker 8
Lela 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
Kingwood Pressure Washing 1
needsleep 3
Nature Girl 1
nooneishome 6
4ever love3 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lela --- 15 years ago -

My 7 year old daughter just came home from spending a month at her dad's house, and now says she wants to go live over there.

I know what the problem is. When she is over at her dad's house they buy her affection. She gets basically whatever she wants. Plus they are always telling her how much better her life would be if she lived with them. Mind you, her dad doesn't spend any sort of quality time with her at all. He just buys her crap, and makes his other daughter watch her most of the time.


Over here, we can't afford to give her that kind of lifestyle. We are struggling just to pay the bills. Right now we are in a 2 bedroom apt, and she has been having to share a room with her brother. That isn't the best situation...but it's all we can do until we move into a house next month. I just don't know what to do. We are spending our absolute last on a deposit for our house, so I can't afford a lawyer. Most of all, I know this is not what she really wants. My daughter and I are so close. I know I will absolutely lose it if she is gone. But I can't compete with him. I just don't know what to do. I feel helpless and my heart is ripped to shreds. 

kimmer --- 15 years ago -

I'm so sorry you are going thru this. I know its tough but there isn't an easy answer. On one hand you can let her go but then she could start the back and forth thing whenever shes unhappy with one parent. second you could put your foot down and tell her no, but then have her doing the "I hate you" thing... ugh all I can tell you for sure is sit down with her and ask her to list why she wants to move then go over it with her explaining the "truth" of what it will be. then tell her your reasons why you really dont want her to go and how much you love her. hopefully its just a passing thing and she will rethink it. 

Lela --- 15 years ago -

She already has told me why. It is because she has her own room in their brand new house, and all of her toys are over there, and because she says her younger brother gets on her nerves. Mostly though, it's because her dad is so manipulative. The thought would have never crossed her mind if he wouldn't have put it there. There is no way I will ever let her go. Her dad and I divorced when she was a baby. She has never lived with him, so she doesn't know how he really is. When she is there, she is treated like a guest. No responsibilities or anything like that. 

FlowersGirl --- 15 years ago -

First of all he would have to prove you unfit! Otherwise she can't make that decision on her own until she is about 12 years old. There is nothing that either of them can do. I go through this occasionally with my middle dd. If you need someone to talk to send me a pm. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

First of all he would have to prove you unfit! Otherwise she can't make that decision on her own until she is about 12 years old.


Exactly and she cannot even decide at 12 the judge will just listen to what she want but will still make the decision based on the best interest of the child not what she wants.

I would have a conversation with your ex and explain that the only one he hurts and confuses is his daughter. Then I would tell him that you would fight him until your last breath before you let it happen. Then sit down and explain to your daughter that it would be very different there if she lived there full time, that she would have chores, home work and everything that goes on at your house. Good luck. 

Paige Paige --- 15 years ago -

She is 7... Not 17. My 7 year old asks for things daily that are never going to happen. Have a chat with her, tell her how much you love her, take her for an ice cream cone and to the park. Things will be fine :-) 

Nature Girl --- 15 years ago -

On top of all the things mentioned above, remind her of all the good things that she'll have when you get the new house, like her own room and more space. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

She is 7. Don't let her make the decision for you. You are the mommy. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

My daughter and I are so close. I know I will absolutely lose it if she is gone.

Focus on what's best for her. Sometimes that's hard, but honestly, which is the better situation for her? 

susie q --- 15 years ago -

Don't give in. I went through this with my daughter. Everytime she went to Tx. from Fl. to visit her Dad and wife, I had a hard time with discipline and stuff for a little while. He, like your ex, didn't pay that much attention to her. It was his wife who did, and yes, he was able to "buy" her more than I was. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 15 years ago -

she doesnt know any better , she is 7. First of all you need to be a mother and not her friend. The relationship you have with her needs boundaries. Let her know she must respect you.. She can want all she wants but bottom line you are the boss.

She will be upset and try you. She will get over it. If you do not nip this now it will get worse as she gets older.

Then you have the option to really think what is best for her... Since you are already struggling , can her father provide a better home?.

Is there a way you and him can talk about this. You did have a child together and need to co parent. 

napoleon --- 15 years ago -

She's only 7 and doesn't know what's best for her. 

4ever love3 --- 15 years ago -

Everyone e is giving great edvise leason to them. My family is going thro the same thing with my aunt and her ex. The dad has the kids bought so much that they say that my aunt is hitting them. Dont let it go that far. Talk to her explain things ether way if she gets mad with you shell get happy after a while. You know best and are the best chose for her. 

Kingwood Pressure Washing --- 15 years ago -

I've been through the same thing. My 6 year old daughter just did this to me. It's hard not to make them happy and give them what they want, but you have to think about what's best for them.

Obviously the best thing for my daughter was to stay living with me. I'm sure it's the same with you. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

you need to have a face to face talk with your and your spouse and him and his spouse....your need to bring to his attention that "DISNEYLAND DAD" and the syndrome does more harm than good. She cant go and make her own choice just yet.... i know this is heartbreaking! i am sorry sweet lady. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Her dad and I divorced when she was a baby. She has never lived with him, so she doesn't know how he really is.


This statement bothers me...

Now, playing devil's advocate here, why would you think that because you and he didn't get along, he would treat his daughter the same way?

This sounds like you're going to attempt to tell her what her father is "really like" and let me warn you, that WILL come back to bite you in the butt.

Your child is not a pawn for either of you to play...you do have to do what's best for her.

There's a lot of unanswered questions here...

How long has she known him and had regular visitation in his home? What is her relationship like with her sister and step-mom? How far does he live from you and could you have shared custody instead of weekend visitation?

There's a lot of info we (KU) don't know to give you an honest opinion of your situation. Going on emotion alone, yes, it is heartbreaking when your child chooses your ex over you, but, putting that aside, what situation would be best for her? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I REALLY hate it when adults, especially parents, play these games with kids. Oh, the pain and heartache it has caused.

It's possible and preferable to keep things amiable in most circumstances. Don't belittle each other and speak negative about each other at a bare minimum.

The kid is only 7, she's old enough to notice the differences in the households, it's normal. But you didn't say the FATHER wants her to live with him, that's the key. If he is going to challenge you for custody that's one thing, it's another if the little girl is just speaking her mind about what she sees and notices.. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Didn't read everything but I did go through this with oldest ds for quite a while when he was younger. I'd ground him and his time spent with his father was always opposite of my wishes. It was FUN time! ALWAYS. But I never let him know how useless I thought his dad was (lol) and living with me was written in stone. Like it, or don't like it, I didn't care. And then he grew up. And realized. And knew. And thanks me every day. Stick to your guns and watch your mouth. Keep everything to yourself and simply parent your child. That's my two cents. :p 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

But you didn't say the FATHER wants her to live with him, that's the key. If he is going to challenge you for custody that's one thing, it's another if the little girl is just speaking her mind about what she sees and notices..

I was thinking the same thing.

For all we know, the dad may not have any such plans.

That said, I can understand if the dad did want her to stay with him for a while. He may think it would be best since you all are struggling. He may also see it as an opportunity to really connect with a child he left behind.

Not saying he is right, but he just may have good motives... 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

He may also see it as an opportunity to really connect with a child he left behind.


How do we know he left her behind? Just because they divorced when she was a baby, doesn't mean he's been a dead beat father... 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

How do we know he left her behind? Just because they divorced when she was a baby, doesn't mean he's been a dead beat father...

I wasn't assuming he was. But there is a difference b/w seeing a child on an irregular basis and full time. You really connect when you actually have to parent. And if he has her full time for a while, he would have to do that. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

We don't know how the visitation has worked in this situation, because she hasn't told us. All we know is the child has never lived with him full time.

I don't like to assume the guy's an a-hole because he's never had full custody...most men DON'T get full custody, that doesn't mean every single one of them is a dead beat. 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

I don't like to assume the guy's an a-hole because he's never had full custody...most men DON'T get full custody, that doesn't mean every single one of them is a dead beat.

Did I say dead beat?

Man, I have to be more careful in how I word things around here. Geeeezz...

I'm a techie, not a professional writer. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Most men don't get custody, even the ones that really want it.

I think Lela is feeling hurt and upset b/c the little girl is expressing some things that are making her feel as though she has to "compete" for her daughters' affection. I'd say ditch the emo stuff and just realize this is very normal. And since the dad has not made any legal moves (from what we can assume has been said here), nothing has changed. Your daughter is being very normal.

Just keep being a good mom and encourage your ex husband to be an active and participatory father. It IS possible for you all to be a tight family unit. I have a step son, I know it can be done. But you have to be logical and not emotional sometimes. :) 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Did I say dead beat?


You said, "the child he left behind"...so, I took that to mean, "dead beat." Is there another way to take that? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

You said, "the child he left behind"...so, I took that to mean, "dead beat." Is there another way to take that? 


When you move out of living with your child you are in a sense leaving them behind. No more day to day interaction, no more tucking them in bed every night, no more soothing them when they are scared from a bad dream in the middle of the night unless its your scheduled day of visitation.

I wonder how much he took his visitation when she was a baby? 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

When you move out of living with your child you are in a sense leaving them behind.


Who says he moved out? Isn't it possible the Mom moved out and took the child with her? She was a baby, after all...


It's odd that everyone is assuming this guy is some sort of scumbag. He's obviously including this child into his home with her own bedroom and toys...not many dead beats that have moved on with their "new" family, do that...

just sayin'...


I'm just giving the guy the benefit of the doubt instead of assuming he has some sinister motive for his child... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

You said, "the child he left behind"...so, I took that to mean, "dead beat." Is there another way to take that?


When you move out of living with your child you are in a sense leaving them behind. No more day to day interaction, no more tucking them in bed every night, no more soothing them when they are scared from a bad dream in the middle of the night unless its your scheduled day of visitation.



I think that's what Aragon was referring to. That the child isn't living with the father on a day to day basis.

It would be interesting now to see what the arrangement was since they divorced when she was a baby. Maybe Lela can give us some info on that? 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

You said, "the child he left behind"...so, I took that to mean, "dead beat." Is there another way to take that?

Yes, there is.

But you are just looking for a fight and I'm not going to engage. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

But you are just looking for a fight and I'm not going to engage.


actually, I wasn't, but, I thank you for not engaging... :) 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Who says he moved out?


Mincing words here a little bit let me be really clear so that there is no more confusion at least on my part. He doesn't live with her and hasn't since she was a baby. In this situation the CHILD can feel left behind. I doubt the child really care about who moved out the end result is the same. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

It's odd that everyone is assuming this guy is some sort of scumbag.


Never said he was a scumbag, I believe most of the time women are better nurtures. Not all the time as there are some really f'ed up women but most of the time. Especially when raising a daughter. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

He doesn't live with her and hasn't since she was a baby.


I'm curious how the visitation worked out from the time they separated until now.

Did years go by with no contact then suddenly he shows up wanting to be a Dad? Or, did he adhere to the visitation schedule like clockwork? I think knowing details like that makes a difference.

I would find it odd if the child wanted to live there if she didn't know him or feel comfortable there...the fact that she does actually reflects well on him, imo.

There just aren't enough details given to see the big picture, so I'm hesistant to jump on the "bad Dad" bandwagon. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I would find it odd if the child wanted to live there if she didn't know him or feel comfortable there...the fact that she does actually reflects well on him, imo.



My nephews little brothers dad is in prison and has been since he was a baby. He wants every guy he meets to be his dad and starts telling them he wants them to be his dad and hugging them. Children want a father and want their father to want them. 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

actually, I wasn't, but, I thank you for not engaging... :)

If you had put my comment in context, with the rest of my post, it should have been obvious what I meant.

I said that I believe he likely had good motives. Whywhywhy and sighfi got what I meant.

As for looking for a fight, you do tend to be aggressive in your posting style. You like to argue and you find stuff to nitpick. I do that at times as well, so I know it when I see it. :)

But, I'm not in the mood today. I'll have to give you a rain check on a good argument. LOL 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

My nephews little brothers dad is in prison and has been since he was a baby. He wants every guy he meets to be his dad and starts telling them he wants them to be his dad and hugging them. Children want a father and want their father to want them.

That's very sad. Maybe he could be part of the big brother program? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

My nephews little brothers dad is in prison and has been since he was a baby. He wants every guy he meets to be his dad and starts telling them he wants them to be his dad and hugging them. Children want a father and want their father to want them.

That's very sad. Maybe he could be part of the big brother program? 



Tried to get the mom to do it, instead she has a revolving door of men in his life. Big time F'ed up. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Children want a father and want their father to want them.


Your nephew's brother's situation is not the norm...

I too have a child from a previous marriage, and though she LOVED to visit with her Dad because she was spoiled rotten, not ONE TIME did she tell me she wanted to live there. She didn't know him very well and it wasn't her 'home'....

All kids are different, but based on what I know from my experience, I would say that Lela's daughter loves both her parents and feels comfortable with them...that's a good thing, it doesn't have to be a negative. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Your nephew's brother's situation is not the norm...


Agreed it is totally not normal on so many levels.



I too have a child from a previous marriage, and though she LOVED to visit with her Dad because she was spoiled rotten, not ONE TIME did she tell me she wanted to live there. She didn't know him very well and it wasn't her 'home'....

I would say that this is also not the norm. Many kids of divorced parents ask or think about living with the other parent or actually do, some more back and forth many times.


All kids are different, but based on what I know from my experience, I would say that Lela's daughter loves both her parents and feels comfortable with them...that's a good thing, it doesn't have to be a negative. 



Possibly but I don't have enough information to make that determination. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

My nephews little brothers dad is in prison and has been since he was a baby. He wants every guy he meets to be his dad and starts telling them he wants them to be his dad and hugging them. Children want a father and want their father to want them. my son did this.. he always asked men would they be his dad ( his walked out when he was 7 and never saw him again)

i am just now seeing what custody and divorce does to kids with my bf's. his oldest son choose to move in with us a few months ago and his youngest has made the suggestion.. but they are teenagers so it is a different situation. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground