Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Serious question for Christians(or any other religion)

who's talking here?

RoseSr 1
~grandma again~ 3
smartypants 2
steinhoister 4
Mabbers 7
rEVOLution 1
combatkenpo 1
Polly Ester 3
racefan 1
RedMulch 1
allday 3
Bringit 6
Zombie Slayer! 11
Bob Ross 2
johnregalman517 7
kidsfan3 1
~ MARY C ~ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

In light of all the prayer threads, I have a question. This is not open to Lynch or Sassy, but anyone else I would like to know what they think.

Where was God when the bad thing happened?

If you pray for your family every night for their protection and then something horrible happens, why then do people pray for healing?

Is it to feel better?

Where was God on the original prayer?


This is a serious question, and I would appreciate serious replies. 

~grandma again~ --- 16 years ago -

God says He will never leave or forsake us. He is always with us. God does not "let" bad things happen. Free will lets bad things happen. When bad things do happen, he is there to give us strength to get through those things.

I pray to talk to God, because He is my Father. He is my friend. Does it make me feel better to pray? Yes, it does because I know He will hear my prayers. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Define "bad". 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

He is always with us. God does not "let" bad things happen. Free will lets bad things happen. When bad things do happen, he is there to give us strength to get through those things.

ok, fair enough. but if he has the power to heal..then why let it happen at all?

i understand the comfort and strength part, just not the other part. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

bad

like being hurt-kidnapped, raped, murdered, dismembered, that kind of stuff. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

GMAA you could not have said it better. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

I believe that God let's the situation happen so that people will call out for him. He wants you to seek him out. If you only call out to him in times of trouble, you might stay in trouble all the time. 

combatkenpo --- 16 years ago -

Great question ZS. I've struggled with understanding this over the years as well. The only answers I've ever gotten tend to be from an apologist perspective as GA did above.

GA, I read a lot of your posts, and please understand I've much respect for you. I don't mean it in any derogatory or accusational way toward you, but I've heard your answer before and it just doesn't pass the common-sense test. This line of thinking assumes that I'm responsible for the bad things and God only gets the credit for the good. Doesn't add up, sorry. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

I don't think I'll ever understand why rape happens. On the other hand...Johnny got dismembered by a cotton gin...well that might be "good" in a way. Someone cares enough to develop a prosthesis, which benefits many others. Or Johnny's neighbors' parents quit beating their kids because suddenly they realize how lucky they are their kids are healthy. Maybe Johnny is a highly evolved essence who chose to come to earth and be dismembered, in order to help those other things take place.

If that's true, then God, or whatever you call creator, is there, alpha and omega and everything in between. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

This line of thinking assumes that I'm responsible for the bad things and God only gets the credit for the good.

Why would you think like that anyway. I do not think that every good thing that happens to me comes from God. But, I do know what he has done for me. You see, when you have a relationship with God, he speaks to you, and you know he is there. I will give you an instance...I was so overwhelmed with grief over my fathers passing, that I could not stop crying. I prayed to God in Jesus name to please give me relief. In other words, I prayed for the blood of Jesus to to wash away my pain. And it does work. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Faith helps you rise above the crap Zombie. Doesn't make the crap go away, just buffers those with that faith through life. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

Faith helps you rise above the crap Zombie. Doesn't make the crap go away, just buffers those with faith through life. 

Nope, not it at all. 

~grandma again~ --- 16 years ago -

combatkenpo, i can understand what you are saying. it has to do with one thing...faith. there is no way i can explain something that one does not feel or have in their heart. when you have real, true faith, it is just there. you do not offend me at all, by the way. 

kidsfan3 --- 16 years ago -

Sometimes we don't understand God's will for our lives. He may bring us through something difficult that may help us with something many years down the road. We just can't see it now. He has a will for all of us and works all things for good for us in his time. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

Faith helps you rise above the crap Zombie.

i guess for some it does and that cant be a bad thing. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

"Nope, not it at all."

LOL, excuse me? Was that TOO layman for you? 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

LOL, excuse me? Was that TOO layman for you?

me?? lol, not at all. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

Was that TOO layman for you? 

I do not believe that God is a buffer for hard times in my life. LOL....imo. And your excused. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

"I do not believe that God is a buffer for hard times in my life"

Faith, honey, FAITH. Not the Almighty himself. 

~grandma again~ --- 16 years ago -

jmabs..what are you talking about? it is faith in the Almighty Father. 

Bringit --- 16 years ago -

Faith, honey, FAITH. Not the Almighty himself. 

Faith in what? Yourself? My faith remains in God the Almighty. He knows what is best for me and my family. Sorry you don't get it. I can promise you, that if you call out to him, he will answer. Have to go..tata 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

"jmabs..what are you talking about? it is faith in the Almighty Father."

Faith is a conduit. It's a confidence or trust in something. God asks for faith. It is faith we work on daily. 

Polly Ester --- 16 years ago -

I have never understood it, Zombie. I have been a believer though for a short time compared to many others.

I pray that God will guide the caretakers and the physicians. I pray for mercy and for peace for those that are suffering. I pray that if something is God's will that maybe a miracle will happen and that will change.

I don't have a good answer for you though..because of my own questions and struggles. I do know that prayer brings me comfort and when I turn my worries over to prayer I feel a great release.

But I feel that when my prayers are not answered it is because God had a greater plan and purpose that I may not understand at this moment or maybe never..and in these times I just have to (try to) trust. 

racefan --- 16 years ago -

that which does not kill us, can only make us stronger...through our faith 

Polly Ester --- 16 years ago -

Faith in what? Yourself? My faith remains in God the Almighty. He knows what is best for me and my family. Sorry you don't get it.

That sounds condescending. If you have a personal relationship with God then it stands to reason to me that it might not match up with someone elses relationship..hence, why it is personal. JMABS may have a different relationship than you but it doesn't make it less real or less faithful. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Polly, maybe she'll understand me better if I use metaphors. Bringit, your faith is your sword and shield. Your faith is God's armor you've been given to deal with life on earth. Are ya feelin' that one? 

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

Zombie Slayer! --- 49 min ago - quote - flag comment

bad

like being hurt-kidnapped, raped, murdered, dismembered, that kind of stuff.


I have asked this question before and maybe it did not sink in. If laws, morality, rules offend you then there is only one conclusion you you are corrupt aka sin, missed the mark. Follow. To blame God for bad things is like blaming a innocent child for murder. Follow. All those things you indicated are a product of sin. Then you say God is playing game with his creation so I am mad at him. NO NO. Immediately after man sinned God promised a savior Jesus and he will deliver all who believe in him in a world he will rule and reign. This world will pass but the world to come is eternal. Just because you are a atheist does not mean anything you believe in nothing try Jesus in a prayer to him 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

God says He will never leave or forsake us. He is always with us. God does not "let" bad things happen. Free will lets bad things happen. When bad things do happen, he is there to give us strength to get through those things.

That's pretty much what my answer was going to be as well.

It was put to me like this when I asked.

If you consider God as a physical father and you are his child walking down the street one day. You are side by side and as the child you stumble, fall, and scratch yourself up really bad. God did not let this happen, it just happened and as a child you learn to be more careful. But God is there to pick you up, wipe the blood and tears away, and help heal the wounds. 

allday --- 16 years ago -

I find the religious fascinating in an odd way. Free will in particular has always seemed odd in that Xhrisitans spout the concept but disallow as sinful so many things so as to remain in control of the flock.

The big irony to me has been regarding what I think is a disservice to children. The tension between a sacred point such as the inviolable right to life of the unborn. The same fanatical adherents seem to guarantee that the child LOSES all of it's rights to not be indoctrinated, brainwashed, or psychologically abused by those parents.

Regarding the question posed. If we have a blind spot about religion (god) and it's impotence or non existence by virtue of logic then we continue to do our society a disservice. Every topic is subject to evidence EXCEPT ONE. 

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

Regarding the question posed. If we have a blind spot about religion (god) and it's impotence or non existence by virtue of logic then we continue to do our society a disservice. Every topic is subject to evidence EXCEPT ONE.
And the fool in his heart has said, There is no God. Evil exists on this planet for one reason If you believe the natural state of man isnt sin then you are fool. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

moronkiller, you are free to disagree with our beliefs as much as you would like and to call us parents that brainwash our children.

I truly hope the day will come for you, and everyone on KU that doesn't believe, when God will reveal Himself to you in a way that you cannot deny.

It always saddens me to read the garbage that non believers post on KU and the way they trash the Bible, but I cannot make their beliefs change. The Holy Spirit can cause change. I pray He makes those life changes in each of you. 

RedMulch --- 16 years ago -

I have often wondered that myself.......as dedicated as i am......as truly religious as i am...and i wonder why as bad as there is in the world, why has it never happened to me? and why does it happen to other people? So much unexplained..........It's called faith.......Let me ask you this............Was Saddam Husssien sic not a Child of God? it's deep, I know.......but something on my mind with this question. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

To blame God for bad things is like blaming a innocent child for murder.

i did not blame god...i said he ignored the prayers to keep them safe. he just did not step in and he could have.

then the prayers are sent up to heal what could have been prevented had god listened to the original prayer to keep their family safe.

its a legitimate question. 

Bob Ross --- 16 years ago -

moronkiller, you are free to disagree with our beliefs as much as you would like

Pretty sure he/she didn't need a reminder of his/her personal freedoms. 

Polly Ester --- 16 years ago -

.i said he ignored the prayers to keep them safe. he just did not step in and he could have.

I don't think of the prayers as ignored as much as requested not granted, I guess.

its a legitimate question.

Yes, it is. It is truly something that tests faith and yet, I know people that will say that they came to later understand why prayers were not answered and to even sometimes be grateful that they weren't..that there was a greater plan ahead for them. I've even heard people say that a tragic event made them a greater person or a painful situation made them stronger.

But it is a very hard concept to wrap my head around..especially when it involves children suffering. 

allday --- 16 years ago -

I expressed my legitimate feelings. It's the feelings of millions of others. It's not trashing anyone. But mine and other's feelings are called garbage by someone like you. Why are the religious allowed to call others feelings garbage?

I can tell you this. Christian children are the only ones with nightmares of hell and demons.

Because they believe a book we don't. Silly.
Perhaps it should be kept private as Jesus urged, or is that another topic up for debate among the religious? 

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

God does keep the chilren safe

Jesus said, "Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these.

God does listen to prayer do you pray to him?

If I walk into the supermarket lot and get killed my world is not this world. You miss the big picture he does keep you safe and save you.


Its amazing so many of you atheist like abortion yet you blame God when bad things happen to children. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Its amazing so many of you atheist like abortion yet you blame God when bad things happen to children.

You're insane. LOL. No wait, no LOL. Just insane. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

Its amazing so many of you atheist like abortion yet you blame God when bad things happen to children.


Atheists don't blame god...I'm afraid your misinformed. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

why do some of you have to gum it up with abortion on EVERY THREAD?

im not an atheist, im agnostic. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground