Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Pelosi wants to allow Democrats to vote for the health care bill without really voting for it

who's talking here?

Carla 1
randyjet 9
My 3 and Me 1
MonzaRacer 1
lizandmike 6
AuthorMan 2
Joybell 5
R.E.B. 9
Donkey Hodie 2
david 1
justforfun 17
~sassy~ 34
ExLady In Blue 2
Perfection 7
Betty 1
Meme2my5 1
Allimama 10
Hiro Protagonist 2
JusticeForAll 2
JohnLynch 4
evolved 6
james osterberg 9
JeffSpicoli 1
Dr Aborto 9
A Simple Equation 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

This is nuts. "I like it, because people don't have to vote on the Senate bill," Pelosi said. I bet she does. Does she realize just how unconstitutional and wrong that sounds? The fact she proudly says such a thing shows how crazy she is. Basically the Democrats can vote for it, but not officially vote for it. So when it hits the fan, in the next election, these senators can officially say they did not vote for the bill. Pelosi and Rep. Louise Slaughter, D-N.Y., chairwoman of the House Rules Committee, are cooking up a plan to pass the original health bill from the Senate side without forcing rank-and-file Democrats to technically go on record in support of it. Democratic leaders are considering the option because many House Democrats don't want to cast a vote in favor of the Senate bill, which they oppose for numerous reasons. Problem is, the House must pass the Senate bill in order to move on to the package of changes intended to correct all the things about the Senate bill that House members don't like. Enter the Pelosi tactic, known as a "self-executing rule." Under this tactic, the House could simultaneously approve the Senate version of the bill while voting on the package of changes. This would "deem" the Senate bill passed, though not directly show members voting in favor of passage. ***** We will remember come the next election. You won't BS your way out of this one, Pelosi and friends. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Have you ever seen such a corrupt government before? I don't care who you are this should make everyone mad. 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

All I have to say is . . . "Only" 1041 days until freedom. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Heard that today. Either way, the Dems are done. 

My 3 and Me --- 16 years ago -

Of course she wants to do that! So much for govt by the people!! 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

Enter the Pelosi tactic, known as a "self-executing rule." You forget to mention that "self-executing rule" (Slaughter Rule) was formulated and made possible by the Republicans. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Oh and reform without Public Option is what? Nothing. People better watch what they wish for. Now those without insurance are gonna be fined for not carrying it. lol And adding 30 million to the system without an increase in health care workers.......what a joke that will be. 

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

You forget to mention that "self-executing rule" (Slaughter Rule) was formulated and made possible by the Republicans. I don't care if Santa Clause formulated the rule. The Republicans are not the ones using it to pass a Trillion plus dollar government program, nor have they ever. (If they ever did, I would call on them to be thrown out on their tails.) BTW, the Republicans are not in charge, so I am not worried about them right now. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

BTW, the Republicans are not in charge, so I am not worried about them right now. Most are very worried because the dems are in charge. 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

I don't care if Santa Clause formulated the rule. Best quote of the day!!! :-) 

Carla --- 16 years ago -

You won't BS your way out of this one, Pelosi and friends. Sure they will. People have short memories and are too busy watching American Idol to pay attention to what politicians are doing. Media Matters will pump out a load of spin, Obama will go on TV and will paint this alternate version of reality, and they will buy it hook, line and sinker. Just like the '08 election. Facts don't matter. It's all about who has more money to blanket the media and can spin the best. Our Republican primary for district 127 is proof of that. Curling is still clinging to her lies. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Just heard old lady Pelosi say make no mistake about it, we will do whatever necessary to pass this bill. Yep, they're DEEMING it into law. Okedokey....out ya go dems. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

I just can't believe what they are doing. How could this be anything but political suicide? 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

I'm shocked,shocked to see they are using the same thing as the republicans. passing reconciliation when you have a majority in both chambers. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

So is our answer to everything that is wrong in Washington "Wahhh! The Republicans did it first!"? That is ALL I hear. Egads, we are screwed. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

So is our answer to everything that is wrong in Washington "Wahhh! The Republicans did it first!"? If they've already done it before, how can they complain if someone else does it? Just sayin. 

JeffSpicoli --- 16 years ago -

The Republicans are now shamelessly screaming for up-or-down votes on healthcare, after all this time dedicating themselves to preventing exactly that.   LMAO! Your implication -- that the House will approve health reform without voting on it – is completely false. There will be a vote on health care reform, and nobody is suggesting otherwise. The final vote in the House won't be a simple vote on the Senate health care bill. Instead, it will be a vote on a resolution which effectively passes and amends the Senate health care bill at the same time. It’s simple: The House is working to structure its final vote to ensure that the Senate bill does not become law without being amended.    In so doing, the House is trying to do the responsible thing, --- eliminating any chance of the Senate bill passing without reconciliation fixes, thereby making sure that the country ends up with the best possible policy.   

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

Alli ignoring the cold facts? we are screwed. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

If it's wrong, it's wrong period. Every time. It doesn't matter "who started it". I think that a lot of pubs are waking up to this fact, hence the tea parties, and the exodus to the libertarian party, but dems need to figure this out as well. I know that you guys dealt with 8 years of a guy you hated, but this one is pulling BIGGER crap than Bush did, and you suddenly think it is fine? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

I know that you guys dealt with 8 years of a guy you hated, but this one is pulling BIGGER crap than Bush did, and you suddenly think it is fine? I don't really like it. The partisan politics have been dirty as hell for a long time now, I just don't see how one group can complain about the other pulling the same dirty tricks they've already done. By the way, I don't even really like the bill. As far as I'm concerned I wish they'd take healthcare completely out of employers hands. You could increase their taxes and the businesses would still be saving a ton in comparison to what they pay now in employee benefits. You'd think pro-business minded people would be for this, but alas I'm one of the lonely few and it will never happen. 

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

Your implication -- that the House will approve health reform without voting on it – is completely false You better tell Pelosi then. She thinks she can. I hope you are right. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

If a few foot prints in Iraq turns out to be,well,you know, then whatever this turns out to be,pass it. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

I like the idea of taking healthcare out of the employer's hands, because technically, none of us really get to "choose". You are bound by your field and the job you can get. But I definitely don't thinkthe govt can fix it. 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

I know that you guys dealt with 8 years of a guy you hated, but this one is pulling BIGGER crap than Bush did, and you suddenly think it is fine? I don't really like it. The partisan politics have been dirty as hell for a long time now, I just don't see how one group can complain about the other pulling the same dirty tricks they've already done. More than that, if you didn't complain when the Republicans did it, then you're just being partisan if you complain about it now. There's nothing wrong with being partisan, if that's how you want to roll, but don't try and masquerade your partisan outrage as "principled" outrage now, if you didn't complain back when your guys did it. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

You forget to mention that "self-executing rule" (Slaughter Rule) was formulated and made possible by the Republicans. it was probably not mentioned because it wasn't formulated nor made possible by the Republicans. just another lib attempt to rewrite history. From Karen Tumulty's piece on the self-executing rule: "Self-executing rules began innocently enough in the 1970s as a way of making technical corrections to bills. But, as the House became more partisan in the 1980s, the majority leadership was empowered by its caucus to take all necessary steps to pass the party's bills. This included a Rules Committee that was used more creatively to devise procedures to all but guarantee policy success. The self-executing rule was one such device to make substantive changes in legislation while ensuring majority passage. When Republicans were in the minority, they railed against self-executing rules as being anti-deliberative because they undermined and perverted the work of committees and also prevented the House from having a separate debate and vote on the majority's preferred changes. From the 95th to 98th Congresses (1977-84), there were only eight self-executing rules making up just 1 percent of the 857 total rules granted. However, in Speaker Tip O'Neill's (D-Mass.) final term in the 99th Congress, there were 20 self-executing rules (12 percent). In Rep. Jim Wright's (D-Texas) only full term as Speaker, in the 100th Congress, there were 18 self-executing rules (17 percent). They reached a high point of 30 under Speaker Tom Foley (D-Wash.) during the final Democratic Congress, the 103rd, for 22 percent of all rules. When Republicans took power in 1995, they soon lost their aversion to self-executing rules and proceeded to set new records under Speaker Newt Gingrich (R-Ga.). There were 38 and 52 self-executing rules in the 104th and 105th Congresses (1995-1998), making up 25 percent and 35 percent of all rules, respectively. Under Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.) there were 40, 42 and 30 self-executing rules in the 106th, 107th and 108th Congresses (22 percent, 37 percent and 22 percent, respectively). Thus far in the 109th Congress, self-executing rules make up about 16 percent of all rules." 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

For days on end the republicans have been standing there saying: Knock this stick off my shoulder,and if you do,your gonna be in big trouble. If you don't,your history. it's part of history 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

If they've already done it before, how can they complain if someone else does it? Just sayin. Hitler killed Jews so we should do that again too? Two wrongs don't make a right. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

Excellent Glenn,er a, Chunky. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Two wrongs don't make a right. But YOU never said it was WRONG when the GOP did it MORE than the Democrats! It is only when YOUR side get gored that YOU object! THAT is called being a hypocrite. 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

The only time that I know that this tactic was used was when they banned smoking from all flights. . . was anyone, besides chainsmokers perhaps, that were outraged about that? This bill is 1/6 of the economy and drastically affects every American's life (and perhaps death). The people don't want it, but they are finding loopholes to push it through. Slightly different scenario, don't ya think? 

MonzaRacer --- 16 years ago -

Pelosi, Reid, Obama and a few others want this passed sooo bad, and yet will never be a user. Makes ya wonder, Why? Just what the DamnHell are "they" gonna get from this.... 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

The only time that I know that this tactic was used was when they banned smoking from all flights. . I see that you don't read much. You might try reading JL's post. It lays out the number of times it was used in past Congresses. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

It’s simple: The House is working to structure its final vote to ensure that the Senate bill does not become law without being amended. In so doing, the House is trying to do the responsible thing, --- eliminating any chance of the Senate bill passing without reconciliation fixes, thereby making sure that the country ends up with the best possible policy. THAT is the best explanation of the facts I have seen. Thanks! 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

THAT is the best explanation of the facts I have seen. Thanks! it doesn't surprise me that you think so since that "explanation" was copied directly from the Daily Kos 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

randyjet --- 23 min ago - quote - flag comment Two wrongs don't make a right. But YOU never said it was WRONG when the GOP did it MORE than the Democrats! It is only when YOUR side get gored that YOU object! THAT is called being a hypocrite. randyjet, perhaps it is because we are now a more aware electorate, perhaps it is because now we see what is the result of power gone wrong, perhaps it is because we want what is best for the Country and not a select few who wish to benefit off the work of others. But for whatever my and others reasons, we feel this way. Are you stating that simply because it was done before is justification to do this now when over 50% of the population does not want it done? 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

THAT is called being a hypocrite. And this is the ONLY wrong according to relativism. You can screw the people all you want as long as you aren't hypocritical about it. This is the mindset running our country today, and apparently voting. And Randy, are you aware of any of the situations that used the Slaughter Rule? The only situation I'm aware of was banning smoking. John Lynch only posted numbers, not scenarios. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

The only situation I'm aware of was banning smoking. Well that was only one out of as many as 52 for the GOP which was the high water mark for this. I guess they banned smoking 52 times? 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

Again, what scenarios randy? Were they regarding 1/6 of the economy? Did they affect EVERY SINGLE AMERICAN? My guess is that some research would show that these were usually used to fix little problem areas in bills without going through the red tape. Not to fundamentally change the economy of what was once the most powerful nation on earth. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Now Allimama you know randyjet can't give you any scenarios, the Daily Kos didn't print them because it was not positive for their point. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

excerpt from: Democrats aren't suicidal. They're self-executing By: Byron York Chief Political Correspondent March 15, 2010 "Nothing of this magnitude has ever been done with a self-executing rule," says Dreier, who served as chairman of the Rules Committee when Republicans held the majority. Dreier is correct; there has never been an occasion when a bill of such national importance and scope has been slipped through the House with such a maneuver. But bills have been passed using self-executing rules. In the past, such rules were used to pass small, technical changes in legislation. But the 2006 Congressional Research Service report says self-executing rules have also been used in cases of more substantive bills. From the report: * On August 2, 1989, the House adopted a rule (H.Res. 221) that automatically incorporated into the text of the bill made in order for consideration a provision that prohibited smoking on domestic airline flights of two hours or less duration. * On March 19, 1996, the House adopted a rule (H.Res. 384) that incorporated a voluntary employee verification program — addressing the employment of illegal immigrants — into a committee substitute made in order as original text. * H.Res. 239, agreed to on September 24, 1997, automatically incorporated into the base bill a provision to block the use of statistical sampling for the 2000 census until federal courts had an opportunity to rule on its constitutionality. * A closed rule (H.Res. 303) on an IRS reform bill provided for automatic adoption of four amendments to the committee substitute made in order as original text. The rule was adopted on November 5, 1997, with bipartisan support. * On May 7, 1998, an intelligence authorization bill was made in order by H.Res. 420. This self-executing rule dropped a section from the intelligence measure that would have permitted the CIA to offer their employees an early-out retirement program. * On February 20, 2005, the House adopted H.Res. 75, which provided that a manager’s amendment dealing with immigration issues shall be considered as adopted in the House and in the Committee of the Whole and the bill (H.R. 418), as amended, shall be considered as the original bill for purposes of amendment. So self-executing rules have been used in the past. But would any of those examples strike a fair-minded observer as precedent for using a self-executing rule to pass Obamacare? The bottom line is, Republicans are on solid ground when they say Democrats are considering an unprecedented maneuver to pass their health care bill. And for what purpose? Do Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority Leader Steny Hoyer believe voters won't figure out who voted for Obamacare and who didn't? That Republicans will ease their opposition because the final vote was for a rule, and not the specific bill itself? Do they think that anyone won't get the message? Republicans have often remarked that Democrats seem suicidal in their drive to pass a bill that most Americans oppose. Passing it with a self-executing rule will likely just make things worse. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground