Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Was a 135-point victory in a high school basketball game bad sportsmanship?

who's talking here?

planemom 2
needrnr 2
*Annie* 1
AuthorMan 1
Joybell 2
KWPlanner 1
ShookUpRamen 4
Mom's Taxi Service 1
Mabbers 1
hummer 1
~sassy~ 2
rEVOLution 1
Ersatz 2
Hiro Protagonist 1
PHSMOMOF2 2
ladyjane 2
Mark 2
evolved 5
novastar 1
atexpart 1
allday 1
textualchocolate 5
Dr Aborto 1
LadyGolfer 11

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Was a 135-point victory in a high school basketball game bad sportsmanship?

-The 4A defending state champion Yates Lions are averaging 115 points a game this season. They're ranked No. 5 in the nation by ESPN. They've scored more than 130 points five times in 14 games as they chased the state record of 166 set by Hardin-Jefferson in 1992.The Lions were even hoping to hit 200 points against Lee on Tuesday night. -Yates did set a new state record in a 170-35 win, but not everyone was happy about it. "We talked on the way to the game on the bus about getting 200 and setting that record," said one Lions player. -By halftime, the Lions were half way there, outscoring Lee 100-12. At the start of the second half, Yates left its starters in the game and continued its frantic full-court press despite the lopsided score. But the friction on the floor was high. A hard foul was thrown by a Lee player and a fight ensued. Lee's coach threatened to forfeit the game. - Then the referees and coaches made the decision to each leave only five players on their team to finish the game. "They got a little frustrated from the score and they went and fouled our guy on purpose. We talked to our guys about not reacting to that, so I'm a little disappointed that we reacted to them doing something," said Greg Wise, Yates basketball coach. Wise said he did not just play his starting five, but all of his players got in the game. The teams tip off against each other in what should be an interesting rematch on Friday, January 29 at the Barnett Complex. -Source: KTRK-TV

Yes, bad sportsmanship Vote
 
 40.4% (19)
No, not bad sportsmanship Vote
 
 59.6% (28)
Ersatz --- 16 years ago -

 

textualchocolate --- 16 years ago -

All of Yates players played. It's not poor sportsmanship. It's not like it's YMCA or church league. It's high school. The other team should get better. Yates baseball team lost 38-0 to a team from Austin. Not a whisper about sportsmanship then. I wonder what drives the complaints. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

Absolutely, is the answer to that question. No question Yates is an outstanding team. Such huge scoring differences have nothing to do with sportsmanship. 

textualchocolate --- 16 years ago -

I should also note there was NOT a fight at the game. If Lee players can't check Yates 3rd string players, tough! I think it is more disrespect to lay down for a teams feelings than play. Those boys and their coach need to learn you don't always win but you do compete. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, a fight would have made a bad situation 10 times worse. Winning is one thing, but 135 points is a joke... Sportsmanship..."Conduct and attitude considered as befitting participants in sports, especially fair play, courtesy, striving spirit, and grace in losing." I don't believe that statement can be applied to this game. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

Well check this out, before christmas break my son played a team and they won 100-16 sorry but if you are going to play you are playing to win. Those boys are out there play their butts off, if you can not play then dont play. They are not their to stroke their egos, you are on a team and you know whatyou are up against. Take your loss and move on, the better team won. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

Believing a high score this is bad sportsmanship is the same attitude that believes EVERYONE should get a trophy and NO ONE should win. Skill and dedication should be rewarded. Bad sportsmanship is if EITHER team was playing dirty (i.e. throwing "hard fouls", fighting, etc.), and not a function of the score. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

So far, both of you have determined that Yates won. And that Yates was the better team. Both of those statements are a simple fact...BUT refer back to the question in the heading! One can win and be a loser, with the lack of sportsmanship displayed. One can be a loser and still show more grace than the winner. SPORTSMANSHIP people...a dying concept in today's competitive sports. Don't get me wrong, I love winning and that is why sports are played. But show come CLASS along the way. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Was it poor sportmanship back in '92? If it was they should have added in a sportmanship rule back then so records wouldn't be set or chanced to be broken. Doesn't the ref have the ability to call the game? It does make you feel bad to see it plastered every where and being the whipped puppy, but you usually know before going into the game what your chances are. Heck they did score off of them, it wasn't a complete loss. I am sure the losing team learned something from game if momma would stop coddling them. 

textualchocolate --- 16 years ago -

Poor sportsmanship when Tiger won the Masters by almost 20 strokes which was unheard of at the time. The losers showed poor sportsmanship lead by their coach. 

KWPlanner --- 16 years ago -

My only question after watching the highlights last night was 'why the need to do a full-court press the entire game?' Once you're up by 50, go back to playing the zone. If the other team can't make a basket and you're able to get the rebound, take it down and score then I have no problem with the outcome of last night's game. But to deliberately perform a press the entire game makes me question the sportsmanship. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

Why should the winning team slow down to because the other team cant not stand up to their level of play? that makes no sense. The best team won, you take your loss and learn from it Bottom line. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

It's only bad sportsmanship if they were gloating about it. Otherwise, they won fare and square. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

Hey Textual, now you're in MY arena. Very poor analogy at best, lack of knowledge at worst...to bring Tiger into the mix. Golf is an individual sport and cannot be compared to team sport competition--especially since there is no coach calling the shots. A golfer is responsible for his or her own actions on the course. Now, SNEEZING in someone's backswing is poor sportsmanship. Again, winning is one thing. Showing lack of class (the absence of sportsmanship) is another. And I can guarantee you that the losers in this situation came away learning more from that loss than the winners. Was Yates the winning team, YES. Did they accomplish this win with sportsmanship in mind, NO. If you want to read a great article about sportsmanship.... http://blog.oregonlive.com/breakingnews/2008/04/the_best_tale_of_sportsmanship.html 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

My only question after watching the highlights last night was 'why the need to do a full-court press the entire game?' Because that's how you become the best - by doing your best at all times regardless of whether you are winning or losing. If you as a coach teach your team to slack off while you are ahead, you instill the value that mediocrity is okay. The next time, when your team is behind, that mediocre spirit kicks in and you never come from behind to win. It's a mindset thing. 

textualchocolate --- 16 years ago -

Ladygolfer, I was being facetious about Tiger. Of course it wasn't poor sportsmanship yet he didn't take his foot off the accelerator. Neither did Yates. Same difference, why special dispensation for so called gentlemens sports? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Ladygolfer, I was being facetious about Tiger. Of course it wasn't poor sportsmanship yet he didn't take his foot off the accelerator. You aren't saying he should have played less than his best are you? 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I never thought good sportsmanship was about taking it easy on someone else. I thought that would make them madder than beating them by 100. But text has skin in this deal. Text, when Brandon is on the other side of the coin hopefully he can accept the losing aspect as easily as the winning because as you know in college sports it changes drastically unless he ends up at KU, UT, Duke, etc. Curious Ladygolfer, why team sports are different in your mind than individual?? Would Usain Bolt pull up in the sprint to not humiliate his opponents, would Serena Williams not win 6-0, 6-0. I'm trying to digest the inconsistency but can't. 

textualchocolate --- 16 years ago -

Of course not sassy...you completely missed my point. Nobody questions Tiger or golf yet these high school ballplayers are called out. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

Oh yes, by all means, let's put our foot on the accelerator and run up the score as much as we can, because winning is the ONLY thing. By golly, they should have gone for the 200-point win! Because that obviously shows the world that they're the "better" team. Since when has running up the score been a sign of "good sportsmanship?" What you've taught those kids is that sportsmanship has no role in winning. I am one of the most competitive individuals that I know of, I play to win. I teach my kids to shoot for the best. Being an athlete with great talent is a God-given blessing, or to you athieists out there, a sign of great individual achievement. Use that talent in the spirit it was meant to be used--to the HONOR of your sport and to honor yourself as an individual athlete. Be a champion, do it with humility, respect, grace and compassion. That is sportsmanship folks. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Oh yes, by all means, let's put our foot on the accelerator and run up the score as much as we can, because winning is the ONLY thing. Tiger ran up the score. That's the whole point, he didn't slow down to not humiliate his weaker opponents. He wants to as he should want to, humiliate them so next time they are fearful. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

to the HONOR of your sport and to honor yourself as an individual athlete. Be a champion, do it with humility, respect, grace and compassion. That is sportsmanship folks. You have a point. I don't like the spirit of "rubbing your nose in it" but text has a point also, though I hate to admit it ;0 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Everybody should play to win, and I'm all for teams setting lofty goals (Ex. 200 points) but at the same time, I have never been on a team that would still be playing a press if the game was decided. That only seems like you're trying to show the other team up. This one isn't a wussification of America thing either, if this happened 20 or 30 years ago, plenty of people would've said that it was too much then, too. Hell, I can honestly say that if another team was pressing like that when my H.S. team was playing, the game would've ended in a brawl for sure. It reminds me of a H.S. baseball game I played in where the guy on the other team tried to steal home when we were down by 10 runs, the benches cleared. Sh#t like that is weak! 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

As long as records can be set records will be broken, and someone will always be on the bottom of the dog pile. No it is not fun. Gentlemens sport or not. What did the poll state the losing team's player through a hard foul because the full court press was making them play harder than what they were use to. The losing team let the mind game get the best of them. Their coach threatened forfeit.. what is that suppose to do for their record for the year or to remembered as? The team to have taken 35 points off the golden boys in a defeat, or the team to get their lunch handed to them, but got cried and said "I'm not playing with you anymore, and I'm taking my ball home too." 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I hear ya completely Marcellus. Would you believe me if I told you that Yates has never practiced a zone? Can't play it and coach doesn't want to screw with their heads. Their 3rd team guys were in the game getting their chance to play. I personally wouldn't do it--HAHA but they are going for National #1. Mack Brown does it in football, how many longhorns say anything? You have to in college football for BCS rankings, similar to HS mythical National CHampionship. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

Hey all, this has been fun. Thanks for all your opinions and thoughts.... Curious Ladygolfer, why team sports are different in your mind than individual?? You can't compare football, baseball, tennis, soccer, etc. to individual sports such as golf, running, speed skating, cycling, etc. because there is no "direct influence" on an athlete's performance from his opponent. An individual athlete playing his own sport is not influenced by the play of the other team, since there is none. The Usain Bolt analogy was weak. Runners are judged based on time. And individual performance. And evolved, the only thing that strikes fear in me about Tiger is when another one of his mistresses pops out of the woodwork. Running up the score on an opponent only shows that you are the winner, not the one who displays sportsmanship. And as Forest Gump would say....that's all I've got to say about that. 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

Yates showed us all we need to know when they began fouling intentionally the other night so they could get the ball back - just so they could reach 100 points...which they failed to do. Wise knows it, and we all know it. You don't get any better by pressing a team that you're 135 points better than. Rather than going for 200 points, it would have been a perfect time to work on something that could actually benefit the team. I would have implemented a 4 pass rule on all possessions. Arizona's string of NCAA tourney appearances will likely end this season. Wonder how the Wise family has prepared for losing? 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Westbury Christian, Second Baptist are the 2 best TAPPS (private schools) in Houston and routinely beat opponents by 60, 70 points. Last night an opponent was held to 6 points by one of the good Christian schools (they also recruit.) Where's the crying over that? As I've stated, get better or don't play. No teams other than Lee's coach has had a problem with Yates and that goes to the dislike between the coaches. Also, I wouldn't personally let a score like that happen but if it happened to my team, I'd be more embarassed than angry at the opposition. 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

Yates showed us all we need to know when they began fouling intentionally the other night so they could get the ball back - just so they could reach 100 points...which they failed to do. There's right and there's wrong, and 99% of the time it ain't that hard to know the difference...even today, with folks being so "evolved." 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

with folks being so "evolved." Just some. Others still stare at shiny things. 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

When a basketball team is that far ahead, stuff like leaving the starters in after the win is assured is low class. Doing things to intentionally humiliate the losing team, like showing off by high-fiving or making hot dog moves such as dunking, is also low class and show extremely poor sportsmanship. There's also an unwritten rule that the fans of the winning team stop screaming at some point and even, depending on the ages of the kids playing, start cheering politely for especially good shots of the opposing team. Neither the team members nor their fans do anything obnoxious to rub salt in the wounds of the ones who are experiencing an extreme whipping (the "rules" relax considerably in a closer contest, lol). Some of you who are commenting don't seem to be in the "basketball culture," but this is how it's done. 

LadyGolfer --- 16 years ago -

You're right, I'm not in the basketball culture, but do understand that running a full-court press the entire game was uncalled for. Good sportsmanship in any sports is easily spotted and identified. 

atexpart --- 16 years ago -

If you have coached, you know that it is common to rest your starters after the win is secured. You often do not take a chance of injury to a important part of the team. Kids understand this concept and reserve players get valuable minutes to improve their skills. If you were at the game, you would have seen that the Yates coach chose to keep his starters in long after the game obviously was not in doubt(into the second half). He is the coach, and he has that right, but no one has to agree with his decision. Also his style of play after the game was decided leaves something to be desired in my opinion. Luckily, we can all have our own opinions about high school sports, and choose whether or not it is something we think was handled correctly. As a coach and a player in the past, I can tell you that the whole situation is difficult at best when things get out of hand like they did. Yates can play in that district, and hand out the punishment, but if they were on the receiving end, I think they might speak differently. This year they might not lose at all. They are college level talent. Hoep these kids are getting good grades and studying so that they can take the college scholarship and achieve o nthat level too... 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

NOPE! The winning team should have slowed their pace about half time so that the other team could catch up. If by the near ending of the game they were still winning by an outrageous margin they should have adopted the other teams players on to their team to help level out the playing field. There is no excuse for one team to that much more successful than another team. It's not fair and it hurts peoples feelings. Actually what might have helped the most to put an end to this kind of point spread would be to redistribute the Winning coaches paycheck to all the other coaches in the league to help make things more fare. Or maybe spread out the winning teams players onto the other teams to help spread the wealth that way. I can't believe the arrogance and greed of that winning team to insult and humiliate all the other teams by beating them that badly. How unfair to all the boys on the other teams who worked so hard. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Maybe, if a team is ahead 100-12 at halftime, they should play the second half with blindfolds on. Or, maybe the losing team should be blindfolded- can't be much worse. Better yet- have them just play HORSE. That way, one team would never win by more than 5 points. Or, you could place an 'excess accumulation' tax of 90 points on the better team with more points, so the playing field would be level. Or, you could give 'earned points bonuses' to the disadvantaged team to make it fair, say 10 points a basket. 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

I'm really not being sarcastic, but as LadyGolfer and others have pointed out, there's a different etiquette that goes along with a team sport. No, you don't just hand someone the game - that would be insulting - but you don't press the whole time, you give your team's hardworking, dedicated second-string players a chance to play which, incidentally, evens the playing field a bit, and you don't intentionally humiliate another team. It's sportmanship ala TEAM sports - not the same as individual sports. And, by the way, that's very good strategy. If only the A-team is used to playing with big, screaming crowds, what happens in those games where the starter-guys get fouled out and you have to pull in the second string? You've never utilized the other guys and they don't know what to do or how to handle the pressure. So it's good sportsmanship and good strategy. 

novastar --- 16 years ago -

I would say a bit over matched but then again hell yes go for it. I love the hoops.Sorry ku but I know it's sad but then again ?never thought good sportsmanship was about taking it easy on someone else. I thought that would make them madder than beating them by 100.  

hummer --- 16 years ago -

Yes, initially I'd say no. But, I read more and saw that they were going to try to score 200 points. I think considering the age of kids this is poor decision for any adult to obliterate the opposing team. Yates, should let all their players play and if they score 200 then okay. But, just to run the score to 200 that is poor sportsmanship. These are just kids. I'd also think if a 4A team is outscoring their opponents by 100 points then I'd have to consider maybe they should be playing 5A teams. I'd also investigate how this Yates coach is recruiting his players... 

*Annie* --- 16 years ago -

What is "running a press" in basketball? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

It was poor planning on the schools part not poor sportsmanship. Why did they have the two teams play against each other? In my youth, I was on the team that got their butt kicked and on the team that kicked butt. Both situations provided me an opportunity to learn. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground