Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: *Man Faces Jail for Giving Illegal Immigrants Water

who's talking here?

planemom 1
wayward1 3
funmom 1
Going off air 1
Clown Vomit 1
d:-] 1
Fin and Feather 2
~sassy~ 5
rEVOLution 8
Perfection 1
POTUS 2
JusticeForAll 4
Ogre1 1
racefan 1
james osterberg 1
novastar 3
kwtraveler 1
Puppydoglover 5
Momw/2kidsincollege 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: *Man Faces Jail for Giving Illegal Immigrants Water

Man Faces Jail for Giving Illegal Immigrants Water (AP) A judge has threatened to sentence a Tucson man to 25 days in prison for leaving jugs of water in the desert for illegal immigrants. A federal jury in June convicted Walt Staton of littering in the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge. In August, a judge ordered Staton to pick up trash for 300 hours and also sentenced him to a year of unsupervised probation and banned him from the refuge for a year. Staton is a member of the group No More Deaths, which supports humanitarian aid along the border. He was scheduled to be re-sentenced Friday after he told the U.S. magistrate last month that he objected to the court's punishment on moral and legal grounds. But Magistrate Jennifer Guerin denied Staton's motion to modify or suspend his sentence pending appeal and threatened to double his community service hours to 600 hours or give him 25 days in prison. Guerin has scheduled a probation violation hearing for Dec. 21.

Should this guy be punished for Aiding and Abetting illegal immigration? Vote
 
 21.4% (6)
Should all charges be dropped because it's not illegal to render aid to illegal immigrants. Vote
 
 25.0% (7)
He should be forced to clean up litter and Cease and desist his actions. Vote
 
 21.4% (6)
He should be allowed to continue giving water to the illegal aliens. Vote
 
 32.1% (9)
rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Man Faces Jail for Giving Illegal Immigrants Water (AP) A judge has threatened to sentence a Tucson man to 25 days in prison for leaving jugs of water in the desert for illegal immigrants. A federal jury in June convicted Walt Staton of littering in the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge. In August, a judge ordered Staton to pick up trash for 300 hours and also sentenced him to a year of unsupervised probation and banned him from the refuge for a year. Staton is a member of the group No More Deaths, which supports humanitarian aid along the border. He was scheduled to be re-sentenced Friday after he told the U.S. magistrate last month that he objected to the court's punishment on moral and legal grounds. But Magistrate Jennifer Guerin denied Staton's motion to modify or suspend his sentence pending appeal and threatened to double his community service hours to 600 hours or give him 25 days in prison. Guerin has scheduled a probation violation hearing for Dec. 21.  

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

Leaving water for someone is not a crime in this country. Geez, what is this world coming to? I highly doubt that the people crossing know what's waiting for them on this side of the border and I doubt that is persuading them to cross. It just keeps them from dying of dehydration for God's sake. Ridiculous to have these kinds of cases tying up courts when there are so many REAL crimes being committed. Stupid IMO. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

Magistrate Jennifer Guerin probably looking to be a GOP scotus nominee someday. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

How is aiding and abeting one illegal activity any different than aiding and abeting another? Would you answer differently if he were aiding the gentleman who recently was arrested only a couple of miles from here who escaped from prison? 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

Leaving water out is not helping them get across.. they're already across the border. They're not aiding anything except sustaining their life IMO. 

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

Crossing the border isn't much of a crime. It's the taking of a job w/o authorization in a foreign country that is a crime for all of us. So, giving people who are walking in the sun water isn't really aiding and abetting criminals. At this point, they are looking at less of a fine than those of us who speed. Letting souls die for trespassing doesn't seem like justice to me. If he were to offer them undocumented employment - then he would be committing a crime and making this whole affair really illegal. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Forget the illegals. He is leaving items in the middle of nowhere. It's called littering. If it's okay to leave water jugs, why not clothes? I think he should be charged for littering but drop the aiding and abetting charge. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I guess giving them water is no more encouraging them to come here than all of the companies who hire them for their cheap labor right? I agree, it's not a crime to provide water for them although some see this as him rendering aid in illegal immigration. It's a touchy subject but certainly one that should be addressed. I do not think this guy should be punished for doing this but I do think that the laws must be strictly defined and exercised. We have got to stop making it appealing for them to come here illegally. The problem is that it is less appealing if they come here legally because then they are held to the same laws as everyone else. Like carrying car insurance, paying taxes, and so on. 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

He is leaving items in the middle of nowhere. It's called littering. It's his property so it's hardly littering. He can do with it as he pleases I'm sure. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

This is what some of our border areas look like now because of illegal aliens crossing the borders. I know it's no different that trash and litter that's already here but it's just an added frustration and inconvenience and safety issue for these land owners. In Arizona  

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Letting souls die for trespassing doesn't seem like justice to me. I'm not sure, but I don't think souls can die, right? That is a strange thought. It's almost like double-think or something. I thought the whole concept of a 'soul' was based on it being a level of existence that transcended life & death or whatever. Anyway, this guy leaving the water jugs is breaking the law, but if he's really doing it because water is legitimately needed, I can't see how someone could stand to gain from charging him. I'm sure they'll drop this now. They should, if only for the fact that arguing about plastic bottles full of water in the desert is totally beneath grown adults in official positions. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Letting souls die for trespassing doesn't seem like justice to me. The problem is that it's not just the Trespassing that is the problem. It's all the other free rides they will receive from the backs of hard working American taxpayers. Their children get free school, they get free health care, a lot of them do not carry car insurance so when they crash into like they have to me three different times, my premiums go up, not theirs. The worst that happens to them is they get a free ride back to where they came from. They lower the standard pay for low paying jobs, they earn tax free American dollars which they send a lot of back to Mexico. In 2007 about $23.9 billion was sent back to Mexico by legal and illegal immigrants here in the U.S. This was release a few years ago by a CNN reporter CHRISTINE ROMANS, CNN CORRESPONDENT: "Wells Fargo is opening 700 new accounts every day for illegal aliens. Since November 2001, it's helped more than half a million people to, as it says, come out from the shadows." 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Again I say if Uncle Sam simply cuts off their reason for coming, which by and large is our social services, THEY WON'T COME. No way they could afford to live here otherwise. Plus we now have e-verify. A great tool for weeding out illegals. If you can't prove citizenship - buh-bye. lastly, if you come to the USA to have your babies birthed here for the purpose of citizenship - baby stays but YOU go. That loophole's been taken advantage of long enough. Naturally mum and dad will take baby back where they all belong so they can then apply for citizenship the LAWFUL way. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Again I say if Uncle Sam simply cuts off their reason for coming, which by and large is our social services, THEY WON'T COME. No way they could afford to live here otherwise. Plus we now have e-verify. A great tool for weeding out illegals. If you can't prove citizenship - buh-bye. lastly, if you come to the USA to have your babies birthed here for the purpose of citizenship - baby stays but YOU go. That loophole's been taken advantage of long enough. Naturally mum and dad will take baby back where they all belong so they can then apply for citizenship the LAWFUL way. 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

The problem is that it's not just the Trespassing that is the problem. It's all the other free rides they will receive from the backs of hard working American taxpayers. So the answer is LET THEM DIE in the desert of dehydration? I just cannot agree with that. 

funmom --- 16 years ago -

i am torn on this yes it is not illegal to provide water to another human being but i have a friend that works border and customs in brownsville and i know how hard and dangerous his job is so i cringe when i think of the people crossing the boarder since he has told me stories.. 

Puppydoglover --- 16 years ago -

Revolution, you forgot to post pics of the dead bodies lying in the desert from dehydration. That's what this is about. It's not about littering. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Puppydoglover FTW lol 

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

I don’t like illegal immigration the way it is here, but there is big reason why it exits. The bottom line is that is makes people TONS of money. Whatever figure anyone gives on its costs is peanuts to what people make from it. It’s the ugly truth and why it exists. We jumped on terrorism hard and fast b/c is was a threat. The business and govt. world views foreign labor as a necessity so they sit on their hands. The border patrol is for drugs, not workers. Every country has immigrant labor, but most everywhere else has organized guest worker programs. We need to make it organized and use it more to our advantage. We’ve always just had this wild-west border so that’s the way it has developed. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Screwem. Youse rolls the dice youse takes your chances. 

Fin and Feather --- 16 years ago -

Give a illegal a job and it supports the economy, give them water and go to jail.. What a cheap kick in the nutz 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

So the answer is LET THEM DIE in the desert of dehydration? I just cannot agree with that. I understand your thinking, I really do but the problem is something that America should have figured out a long time ago is that you can't protect people from their own fate. If I choose to trespass on someones land, I know that I am risking my life to do so and therefore accept the consequences. The U.S. passed that law in Florida that if you can make it from Cuba to the U.S. without assistance, you can stay. Now Florida has a large problem with Cuban immigration. Not to mention all the tax dollars spent on supporting those people. For some reason American lawmakers have decided that the governments job is to protect people from themselves and that's not their job. If you really want to protect illegal immigrants, stop making it so appealing to come here illegally, instead of making it safer for them to come here illegally. I can understand the mans desire to give these folks water, it's the humane thing to do but it's no different than if you live on one side of an interstate highway and there's stray kittens on the other side and you put food and water out daily for them. So the kittens risk life and limb to get to your side of the highway knowing the riches they will find once they cross. If you really want to help them, don't give them a reason to risk life and limb to cross the highway. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I'm not saying that this man giving them water is why they are coming here. There are far more better reasons to come here but I am saying that he is taking away one of the elements that would deter them from crossing in that region. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

too controversial no comment 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

no comment Too late, LOL ;-) 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Revolution, you forgot to post pics of the dead bodies lying in the desert from dehydration. They are fully aware of the risks. While I would never deny a dying man water if I happened upon one, they can blame no one but themselves for chancing their lives to sneak into our country illegally. If they sought citizenship legally, they would bypass the risk of possible death from dehydration. 

d:-] --- 16 years ago -

Give them Water - no. Give them Jobs and Free healthcare- yes. /sarcasm FWIW - Littering is a crime. That is what the man was charged with. Read, people. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Give them Water - no. Give them Jobs and Free healthcare- yes. /sarcasm FWIW - Littering is a crime. That is what the man was charged with. Read, people. Pretty much sums it up. 

Clown Vomit --- 16 years ago -

Some of those pix look like the day labor camps on 494. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Maybe he should put garbage cans out there...empty them as they fill when he's taking the water out...problem solved. I think it's admirable to care enough about others to leave water for them, illegal or not. 

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

If they sought citizenship legally, they would bypass the risk of possible death from dehydration. I'm not entirely sure that they or we want them to become legal, permanent citizens. Many come to work and then leave with their money after a while. 

Fin and Feather --- 16 years ago -

From the way it looks from those pics the gov is staking out the wrong areas.. FAIL 

kwtraveler --- 16 years ago -

Personally I admire the guy leaving water for the illegals that are willing to risk thier lives to better thier own situation. why judge a person who is willing to die for thier family? its true most come over and send the money back to support thier family back home.. I cant fault a man or woman willing to do anything to support loved ones. They are willing to do the lowest of low jobs for less them nothing why? because it is more than where they come from Poor here is nothing like poor in 3rd world countries and I fully support anyone willing to get out of that situation! Illegal or not I do not care if my tax dollars helps pays for a baby born I rather it go there then for some congressman new gold plated tolet for his office 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I'm not entirely sure that they or we want them to become legal, permanent citizens. Many come to work and then leave with their money after a while. True but I think most, and admittedly I might off here, come to milk the system for as long as they can. They can't get life time social services in their country like you can in America. Can we say Generational welfare? 

novastar --- 16 years ago -

It's the taking of a job w/o authorization in a foreign country that is a crime for all of us HELLO!!!!!!lastly, if you come to the USA to have your babies birthed here for the purpose of citizenship - baby stays but YOU go. 

racefan --- 16 years ago -

what about local officials that give "sanctuary" by not enforcing the laws. oh yeah thats right he'll be running for governor of this great state. anyone's guess as to how the illegal immagration platform will be bypassed during his campaign and possible term as governor. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

lastly, if you come to the USA to have your babies birthed here for the purpose of citizenship - baby stays but YOU go how can anyone really feel that way? Who should raise the baby? Do you know how that baby is supported once the parent is shipped off? Ripping apart a family is righting a wrong? 

novastar --- 16 years ago -

but I don't think souls can die, right? POTUS I don't believe souls ever die. The spirit can be broken but the soul lives on. 

Momw/2kidsincollege --- 16 years ago -

They are people too. 

Momw/2kidsincollege --- 16 years ago -

This judge may have to look at the laws a little closer....it is always a necessity to be humane. The immigrants are going to be there anyhow why not help them. I would, they are human beings. Their immigration status is their business. Rendering any kind of aid is just doing the right thing. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground