Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

FACT CHECK: Health insurer profits (not that facts matter to the liberals)

who's talking here?

freshhell 2
randyjet 7
planemom 3
AuthorMan 4
Zionist NightOwl 1
david 1
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 1
Perfection 16
RiteWingKing 1
Ogre1 1
curtis 8
james osterberg 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

It's all about the FACTS WASHINGTON (AP) - Quick quiz: What do these enterprises have in common? Farm and construction machinery, Tupperware, the railroads, Hershey sweets, Yum food brands and Yahoo? Answer: They're all more profitable than the health insurance industry. In the health care debate, Democrats and their allies have gone after insurance companies as rapacious profiteers making "immoral" and "obscene" returns while "the bodies pile up." Ledgers tell a different reality. Health insurance profit margins typically run about 6 percent, give or take a point or two. That's anemic compared with other forms of insurance and a broad array of industries, even some beleaguered ones. Profits barely exceeded 2 percent of revenues in the latest annual measure. This partly explains why the credit ratings of some of the largest insurers were downgraded to negative from stable heading into this year, as investors were warned of a stagnant if not shrinking market for private plans. Insurers are an expedient target for leaders who want a government-run plan in the marketplace. Such a public option would force private insurers to trim profits and restrain premiums to compete, the argument goes. This would "keep insurance companies honest," says President Barack Obama. The debate is loaded with intimations that insurers are less than straight, when they are not flatly accused of malfeasance. They may not have helped their case by commissioning a report that looked primarily at the elements of health care legislation that might drive consumer costs up while ignoring elements aimed at bringing costs down. Few in the debate seem interested in a true balance sheet. But in pillorying insurers over profits, the critics are on shaky ground. A look at some claims, and the numbers: THE CLAIMS _"I'm very pleased that (Democratic leaders) will be talking, too, about the immoral profits being made by the insurance industry and how those profits have increased in the Bush years." House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., who also welcomed the attention being drawn to insurers'"obscene profits." _"Keeping the status quo may be what the insurance industry wants their premiums have more than doubled in the last decade and their profits have skyrocketed." Maryland Rep. Chris Van Hollen, member of the Democratic leadership. _"Health insurance companies are willing to let the bodies pile up as long as their profits are safe." A MoveOn.org ad. THE NUMBERS: Health insurers posted a 2.2 percent profit margin last year, placing them 35th on the Fortune 500 list of top industries. As is typical, other health sectors did much better - drugs and medical products and services were both in the top 10. The railroads brought in a 12.6 percent profit margin. Leading the list: network and other communications equipment, at 20.4 percent. HealthSpring, the best performer in the health insurance industry, posted 5.4 percent. That's a less profitable margin than was achieved by the makers of Tupperware, Clorox bleach and Molson and Coors beers. The star among the health insurance companies did, however, nose out Jack in the Box restaurants, which only achieved a 4 percent margin. UnitedHealth Group, reporting third quarter results last week, saw fortunes improve. It managed a 5 percent profit margin on an 8 percent growth in revenue. Van Hollen is right that premiums have more than doubled in a decade, according to a Kaiser Family Foundation study that found a 131 percent increase. But were the Bush years golden ones for health insurers? Not judging by profit margins, profit growth or returns to shareholders. The industry's overall profits grew only 8.8 percent from 2003 to 2008, and its margins year to year, from 2005 forward, never cracked 8 percent. The latest annual profit margins of a selection of products, services and industries: Tupperware Brands, 7.5 percent; Yahoo, 5.9 percent; Hershey, 6.1 percent; Clorox, 8.7 percent; Molson Coors Brewing, 8.1 percent; construction and farm machinery, 5 percent; Yum Brands (think KFC, Pizza Hut, Taco Bell), 8.5 percent. ---  

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

UnitedHealth Group, reporting third quarter results last week, saw fortunes improve. It managed a 5 percent profit margin on an 8 percent growth in revenue. The dirty bastards, how dare they. The latest annual profit margins of a selection of products, services and industries: Tupperware Brands, 7.5 percent; Where oh where is the outcry! 

david --- 17 years ago -

The liberals cried foul when oil companies make .09 off a gallon if gas and thr govt makes more than 2 times that with no investment, you really think they care about numbers nope doesn't fit there agenda 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I agree david, and as long as they have people who refuse to think for themselves and value PARTY over individual freedoms they will continue to spew lies and hatred. 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

The funny thing is, liberals say the EXACT same thing about conservatives. Nothing gets accomplished with either tone. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

The funny thing is, liberals say the EXACT same thing about conservatives. Nothing gets accomplished with either tone. I think you're right. Dems are greedy and so are the pubs. There isn't a difference 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

So, back to the facts. Insurance companies are not the ones profiting by insurance rates. So why the lies from the liberals and democrats? Let's stick to facts. 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

LOL, alright, Chunky. :-) 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

So what IS driving the cost of medical care up, and thus the cost of health insurance premiums? Is it the cost of advanced medical technologies such as machinery, hospitals overcharging on services and supplies, doctors making "obscene" salaries, doctors having to run every single test known so they don't get sued for overlooking something, the high cost of malpractice insurance premiums? I don't have the answers; I'm asking this as an honest question. WHAT is the problem that needs to be addressed? I.e., let's get to the source of the problem, rather than trying to fix the symptom, which is high health care insurance premiums. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Zionist NightOwl, I think you are very accurate in your thoughts. Malpractice is a high cost for providers so yes, they run more tests than they may need to to keep from being sued. Tort reform however was removed from the bills. Advanced technology is expensive. Everyone wants the latest and greatest gadgets and treatments, but those come at inflated prices. Also, virtually every provider now is a "specialist" - how many true general practioners are there? So with these specialties come higher prices. There is also a labor shortage of RN's, and those that are remaining are aging - so the cost of nursing is going up. With the advanced technology comes the need for people to operate the equipment - so another specialty is created in the technician field. Americans are living longer - this places increased demands for more people using the services. We have become a convenient society - we want what we want and we want it right near us. Well that is great for us, we have urgent care clinics around the corner, surgery centers in strip malls, clinics in drug stores - well all of these increase the demand for the limited resource of people to staff them - so that raises the cost of providing the care again. Convenience comes at a price. The cost of drugs is high - this is partially because of the testing that is government mandated that while great for us - isn't required in other countries so this places us at a distinct disadvantage in that we have to pay more for the same drug that another country can sell cheaper. In my opinion, the easiest one to fix and the one that would have the best chance to decrease cost would be tort reform. If there were caps placed on medical malpractice then the cost of malpractice insurance would drop dramatically and therefore the cost the provider charged would be allowed to fall. But lawyers (most of our elected officials are lawyers) are not backing this one and it is always removed. Hopefully someday, logic will win out over emotion. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

Oh yeah. Tort reform. Texas already has this. You are totally out of luck if the doc or hospital made a bad mistake and you are quadriplegic now. No lawyer will take your case because they won't make enough to make it worth their while. Ask LTP and Traveller how they feel about tort reform. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

We need the robust public option and we need it yesterday. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

freshhell, what will a public option do to correct the issues that are driving up the cost of care? No lawyer will take your case because they won't make enough to make it worth their while. So because the attorneys want to be rich is a reason to NOT have tort reform? 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

I think freshhell has a point though. There comes a point where the right is being stripped from the patient to hold a doctor accountable for malpractice. The problem is that we don't actually know what our rights are when a doctor messes something up. My grandmother died due to malpractice at a hospital in Houston, but our lawyers said, "with this new law that's been passed, there really isn't much we can do." I do think there needs to be some modifications to frivolous lawsuits, but I don't see any evidence that suggests tort reform will solve a majority of these problems (not that anyone is really advocating that, I suppose). 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

curtis --- 36 sec ago - quote - flag comment I think freshhell has a point though. There comes a point where the right is being stripped from the patient to hold a doctor accountable for malpractice. The problem is that we don't actually know what our rights are when a doctor messes something up. My grandmother died due to malpractice at a hospital in Houston, but our lawyers said, "with this new law that's been passed, there really isn't much we can do." I do think there needs to be some modifications to frivolous lawsuits, but I don't see any evidence that suggests tort reform will solve a majority of these problems (not that anyone is really advocating that, I suppose). Maybe they really need to define malpractice - right now people think malpractice is an adverse outcome, but honestly is it? There are cases where there is true malpractice and yes, those need to somehow be punished - is the punishment putting the doctor in jail? Perhaps. Look at it this way - if someone drives irresponsibly and kills a loved one, the person is sent to prison - you don't sue them. So if a doctor performs irresponsibly and kills someone why aren't they charged? I don't have the answers, just thousands of questions just like everyone. 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

The reason a doctor isn't sent to jail (with the exception of obvious illegal activities) is because it is believed he or she is acting in the best interests of the patient and that his or her work was a direct reflection of their education and professional opinion. The drunk driver was not acting in the best interests of others. Also, I am beginning to see a benefit to the public option. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

curtis --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment The reason a doctor isn't sent to jail (with the exception of obvious illegal activities) is because it is believed he or she is acting in the best interests of the patient and that his or her work was a direct reflection of their education and professional opinion. Your answer is the reason why then that tort reform is needed. Doctors have malpractice insurance to pay for these claims - so how is the doctor punished or reprimanded? Perhaps prison is a bit harsh, but what about in severe cases more open punishment by the Medical Board? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

So curtis my question to freshhell would apply to you as well. What does a public option do to affect the root causes of the issue? 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

Remember, insurance covers the cost of a wrong suffered. It does not negate the legality of the wrong suffered. I.e., when I got into a car wreck, the person that hit me (he was at fault and admitted it with no problem) was given a ticket and his insurance covered my wrong suffered. My wrong suffered was paid for by his insurance (so that he didn't have to fork out the full expense and severely impact his social well-being), yet his wrong to society (breaking the law by running the red light) is paid for by a ticket. My assumption (and you know what happens when we assume) is that the doctor is punished internally - often times in the case of loss of license or fire. This totally destroys the career and work an individual has put in to achieve their MD. 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

In terms of the public option, I think it is important to remember that we don't have a final bill that explains what the actual costs will be so that we can debate the pros and cons. Most of what is heard is by reading bills as they are being written and debated in the subcommittees or just blatant political pandering on talk radio and television. THAT SAID... I do believe there is a case for a public option. I know many have fear over this; much of the fear is around government controlling the well-being ans medical care of its citizens. The Congressional Budget Office suggests that by 2040, due to rising costs of health care and the added burden of the baby boomers retiring, it is highly likely that every tax dollar collected will go towards funding social security, medicare and the interest on the national debt. We will also have a little left over to fund a small - but insignificant military. All funding for parks, education, grants, loans, etc will be unavailable. I think the problem with Medicare is very difficult. #1, our society has made it a point that we agree our senior citizens should be taken care of. We also believe that they should be taken care of with as little expense possible and with dignity. I agree. The problem is, Medicare has not negotiated the prices on medical supplies and care, like the Veteran Administration has. In fact, you can buy medical supplies cheaper from retail than Medicare can. The problem here is not that government will interfere or control the lives of its citizens (we already have insurance companies doing that...let's be honest here), but that the costs must be manageable. Last time I saw (and it changes daily), the Congressional Budget Office said the current senate bill would actually reduce the federal debt by 80 billion over 10 years. That sounds insignificant (and it is when you're comparing it to the 12 trillion we're inthe hole), but it is a NEGATIVE addition to the debt, meaning it is curtailing the costs to the system. The public option helps (along with the medical exchange) IF it can curtail costs. It also helps because individuals that were once relying on the emergency rooms (and thus you and I paying $35 for three tylenol's) will have access to medical care. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I don't have the answers, just thousands of questions just like everyone. That is simply NOT true at all. You KNOW that a public option is wrong. You KNOW that lawyers and frivolous lawsuits are the problem. In short, you take as good coin virtually every GOP talking point and that of the insurance companies. You forgot that Texas has taken away your right to go to court to recover from medical malpractice, AND the insurance rates are STILL the same. Yet you say that the insurance companies are NOT to blame and that they are poor as church mice compared to other companies. The fact is that the insurance companies hide much of their income or shelter it. One way which Aetna did this last quarter was to buy back over $270 million dollars of their own stock. The yield for their shareholders was about 12% of the price of the stock. Not too bad and a lot better than any bank. The Harvard study found that insurance companies can spend as much as 31% of your premium dollar on "administrative" costs. That is not a model of efficiency at all. It sure leaves a LOT of dollars lying around for the taking in bonuses for execs and others. Not to mention the ad money that they place. I can hardly see any benefit to our health care system by running ads and sponoring golf tours,etc.. Then there is the billions that they are spending to defeat legislation that they don't like. I think the problem is the insurance companies who rig the system to benefit themselves, rather than the public good. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Maybe they really need to define malpractice - right now people think malpractice is an adverse outcome, but honestly is it? That has NEVER been the standard for malpractice suits. It has always been a major divergence from standard medical practices, NOT the outcome. Just because you have an operation and die, your family cannot sue the doctors. There HAS to be some major error PROVEN, such a leaving an instrument inside a patient, or cutting off the wrong leg, etc.. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Doctors have malpractice insurance to pay for these claims - so how is the doctor punished or reprimanded? It is up to the medical board of doctors themselves to decide the penalties. It is like the pilots union deciding how to punish pilots for their mistakes rather than the FAA. The docs have a great system in which they "police" themselves, if you can call it that. The only way that they really get punished is by the lawsuits, but Texas has taken that one away. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

The Harvard study found that insurance companies can spend as much as 31% of your premium dollar on "administrative" costs. Do you really think the government will be more efficient? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Do you really think the government will be more efficient? Why not? The Railroad Retirement Board's admin costs amount to 2-4%. Even the VA's admin costs are much lower than 31%. (about 18%) 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Remember, insurance covers the cost of a wrong suffered. Very true curtis, but why then do the awards need to be so large? Why do the plantiff attorneys take so much of the award or in the case that freshhell mentioned, they won't take they case because they can't make money. If the malpractice insurance was allowed to pay the family directly - just as in the auto settlement you mentioned then perhaps things could be different. Unfortunately everyone's first option now is to sue. You even hear on interviews people say they are suing to try to punish the doctor. randyjet, I know you are passionate about what you believe and what you think. Good, you should be. But please look at the facts. I know of OB docs from some states who also maintain clinics in other states and work there one or two days a month. They do this because state B does not have tort reform so the number of OB docs is way below what is needed. Physicians will not practice in areas where the cost of doing business - the price of malpractice coverage is very expensive. In Texas, one of the reasons we have so many physicians, so much research, is because we do have tort reform. Physicians feel they can make money here and don't have to pay outrageous malpractice fees. It is up to the medical board of doctors themselves to decide the penalties. It is like the pilots union deciding how to punish pilots for their mistakes rather than the FAA randyjet, the FAA is a Federal Government agency and you are saying here that the Government is NOT the best source to decide punishment over pilots, that the pilots themselves are? So given that you feel that pilots and doctors are best at deciding what is best for them, why do you feel insurance companies are not the best at deciding what is best for them? Yes, you are going to say GREED. I will then say the pilots and doctors are greedy and if you have the Federal Government overseeing one area - and they have an agency already in place to oversee the other, then they should oversee the pilots and docs. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Ogre1 --- 6 min ago - quote - flag comment Do you really think the government will be more efficient? Why not? The Railroad Retirement Board's admin costs amount to 2-4%. Even the VA's admin costs are much lower than 31%. (about 18%) Ogre1, you need to look at industry average, not the extreme on one end. Yes there are companies where admin costs are high, but there are just as many where the admin cost are low. What do you feel is a fair administrative cost and what do you think comprises that admin cost? sorry all, for full disclosure, yes I am getting my MBA in Healthcare Administration so this is a subject I have researched long and hard. 

curtis --- 17 years ago -

Chunky: Thanks for the full disclosure. Where are you getting your MBA in Healthcare Administration? I'm working on my Master's in Public Administration. You would need to ask a lawyer as to why the awards (lawsuits) are so high. From an average citizen's perspective, I would assume (once again, there's that assumin') that it is tied to perceived level of wrong suffered. It is also my understanding that a jury would decide the level of pay-out. If I am wrong, please correct me. I'm wading into territory that is rather foreign. I think you may have misunderstood Randy's sarcasm in terms of the pilots and FAA. I think he is saying that pilots will take into consideration their experience when repramanding a fellow pilot. Essentially saying that if doctors are being held accountable to other doctors, not much is going to get done. I could be wrong. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

So given that you feel that pilots and doctors are best at deciding what is best for them, I have NO idea how you got that idea. I was pointing to the absurdity of pilots regulating themselves as doctors get to do . Physicians feel they can make money here and don't have to pay outrageous malpractice fees. I am not aware that the malpractice insurance fees have gone down in Texas since so called tort reform. While you can still technically sue for malpractice, the limits on the awards make it not very cost effective for lawyers except in the worst cases, such as a doctor being drunk while operating. Lawsuits are very expensive especially so in malpractice cases which require a large amount of very expensive experts and testimony and lots of time. By limiting awards those expenses are non recoverable. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

You would need to ask a lawyer as to why the awards (lawsuits) are so high. One of the major reasons for high awards in medical malpractice cases is the FACT that the injured patient will have to have lifetime health care as a result. The awards will have to provide lifetime medical treatments if the patient survives. THAT is VERY expensive. Also, patients tend to be those in their peak earning years in the main, so that the loss of income is very substantial over a lifetime. One of the benefits of a single payer plan is that such awards will NO LONGER be necessary with such a system. Thus insurance rates can be lowered. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

One of the benefits of a single payer plan is that such awards will NO LONGER be necessary with such a system. Thus insurance rates can be lowered. randyjet, explain that please. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Lawsuits are very expensive especially so in malpractice cases which require a large amount of very expensive experts and testimony and lots of time. By limiting awards those expenses are non recoverable. randyjet, you are right, lawsuits are very expensive because of the time it takes to research and delve in to every thing that was done as well as everything that wasn't. That's one of the reasons that providing care is so expensive, doctors have to do things solely to protect from a retroactively performed research in to what was done, so to protect themselves from something that MAY go wrong, they have to test and document everything even if it at the time, has no impact in care. These steps that they have to take to protect against these future lawsuits take time and take resources which drives up cost. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

The fact is that the insurance companies hide much of their income or shelter it. One way which Aetna did this last quarter was to buy back over $270 million dollars of their own stock. And just when did the tax code change to make stock repurchases a deductible expense? 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

Find an accountant and ask them to define profit. Profit is easily manipulated when you set up reserves for future outlays,pay huge salaries, run advertising/lobbying departments.The most profitable part is the divisions set up to deny coverage. If you don't understand how a couple of bookkeeping entries can set up liabilities(reserves) and lower reported profit,ask anybody with an accounting degree to explain it.Wall street sees it much different,that is the first and foremost concern of the insurance denial industry. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

The most profitable part is the divisions set up to deny coverage. Your source for this please? Trust me, that is not the most profitable division. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

ChunkyHeifer --- 1 hours ago - quote - flag comment One of the benefits of a single payer plan is that such awards will NO LONGER be necessary with such a system. Thus insurance rates can be lowered. randyjet, explain that please. randyjet, I would really like to know how a single payor system will reduce malpractice insurance rates and make big malpractice awards obsolete. I am completely befuddled here trying to understand this. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

randyjet, I would really like to know how a single payor system will reduce malpractice insurance rates and make big malpractice awards obsolete. I am completely befuddled here trying to understand this. Maybe he is banking on the fact that it is difficult to sue the Federal Government. So, someone with a real valid malpractice suit will be SOL. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Maybe he is banking on the fact that it is difficult to sue the Federal Government. So, someone with a real valid malpractice suit will be SOL. Hhhmmm interesting. Logical too, I like that. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Logical too, I like that. Bernie thunk it! :-) 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Or may be since medical care won't be a financial issue awards will be smaller. They only have to cover loss of income. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground