Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Am I too judgemental?

who's talking here?

Carla 1
GCan 1
justme 1
Lilteapot 1
mamadog53 1
rose8304 2
AuthorMan 2
Mabbers 1
Rachel 1
Jano 1
KUenforcement 1
~sassy~ 2
Perfection 9
fishlady 1
~Songbird~ 1
Meme2my5 2
ladybughomeschool 1
clockwatcher. 3
mimifromsa 4
♥kerry♥ 3
*momof5* 1
cushybum 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Am I too judgemental?

Yeah, I knew that would get you to look. LOL. Here is the thing, I have an employee who does what is expected, doesn't go above and beyond, always takes off when she wants for vacations and stuff and basically does what we ask. Well last week she told me her husband may be getting laid off (he is a high dollar engineer) and today she came in and said yes, he did infact get laid off. She then preceeded to tell me they offered a position in Tennessee but it pays $20 less per hour than he makes now and they would cover his expenses while there but he won't take it. She then proceeds to tell me they are still taking a 3 week vacation coming up that she will need time off for so they can go to Europe.... And then......... she asks if I can give her overtime so she can have some extra spending money. Now I have a lot of other employees that are single moms and dads who are struggling to make ends meet and who have never taken time off and always work any overtime I have available whereas she only works it when she wants. Well, do I give her overtime? Should I even care about her husband losing his job and maybe they may need additional income? Should I worry that my single parents could use some more money right now? HELP

Yes - regardless of why she wants it give it to her even though it will mean less OT available for someone who may need it more Vote
 
 23.9% (11)
No - give it to those who have always worked it in the past Vote
 
 76.1% (35)
Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, I knew that would get you to look. LOL. Here is the thing, I have an employee who does what is expected, doesn't go above and beyond, always takes off when she wants for vacations and stuff and basically does what we ask. Well last week she told me her husband may be getting laid off (he is a high dollar engineer) and today she came in and said yes, he did infact get laid off. She then proceeded to tell me they offered a position in Tennessee but it pays $20 less per hour than he makes now and they would cover his expenses while there but he won't take it. She then proceeds to tell me they are still taking a 3 week vacation coming up that she will need time off for so they can go to Europe.... And then......... she asks if I can give her overtime so she can have some extra spending money. Now I have a lot of other employees that are single moms and dads who are struggling to make ends meet and who have never taken time off and always work any overtime I have available whereas she only works it when she wants. Well, do I give her overtime? Should I even care about her husband losing his job and maybe they may need additional income? Should I worry that my single parents could use some more money right now? HELP 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Should I even care about her husband losing his job and maybe they may need additional income? Aw hale NO! Are you a Tard? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

~sassy~ --- 47 sec ago - quote - flag comment Should I even care about her husband losing his job and maybe they may need additional income? Aw hale NO! Are you a Tard? See that's what I am wondering, however as a boss, I am supposed to treat everyone equally as long as they do what is expected of them. I guess I just always gave the OT to the single parents trying to help them and I didn't care that she typically didn't take it because we all knew she had her husband's income. Now that's changed, so should I take away from the others to help her (even though we all know the money isn't for living expenses but rather a trip to Europe). Sometimes I hate being the boss. 

Carla --- 17 years ago -

If they are still planning a European vacation, they can't be hurting too badly. I'd give the overtime to the people who have always done it for you unless they can't and then give it to her. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I can't believe you of all people, are even asking, lol. If you are the decision maker you get to decide who you want to give the overtime. She doesn't sound too smart to me..she could have least come up with a sob story! 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Personally, given what you've described, I couldn't see myself helping her finance her vacation. Especially given that she's a mediocre employee and other employees that perhaps would benefit from the extra O/T. These single parents would likely use that money just to make things a little less tight. This employee by her own admission just wants to spend it frivolously. 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

...Well, Losing his job isn't too worrisome if they are planning a trip to Europe!! If she's not worried, neither would I be...Also, be prepared..they are going to Europe, after the trip, she's really going to try to usurp overtime potential..and not fair to everyone else..IMO- 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

See that's what I am wondering, however as a boss, I am supposed to treat everyone equally as long as they do what is expected of them. Within certain guidelines, yes that is true. But all things being equal, sometime you have use something as a tie breaker..loyalty, tenure, work ethic or output, or even need...you don't need to explain it that way, but sometimes you have no choice..it would be nice if everyone could get overtime that requested it, but sometimes that isn't the situation. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I guess I just always gave the OT to the single parents trying to help them and I didn't care that she typically And ya know I wuz just messin' with ya, right? ;D 

cushybum --- 17 years ago -

Don't let feelings and emotions get involved when it comes to business. Leave all the personal reasons out of your decision making. :) 

KUenforcement --- 17 years ago -

If you have to ask, you shouldn't be in a leadership position! 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

♥kerry♥ --- 22 sec ago - quote - flag comment I can't believe you of all people, are even asking, lol. If you are the decision maker you get to decide who you want to give the overtime. She doesn't sound too smart to me..she could have least come up with a sob story! kerry, none of us are really the decision maker, all of our employees can always file a grievance with employee relations and I can be investigated by HR (been there, done that and it wasn't fun the first few times LOL). My job is to make sure things get done and to do so as efficiently and least expensively as possible. What we have to do will cost some OT, it is my choice to either give a good amount of hours to a few people (and reward them for long term good work behavior) or spread it out equally to everyone regardless of past performance but it is equal. I want to use the OT as a reward for past performance, but I know that if I do that she will report me to HR again and I will have to spend weeks undergoing an investigation of all of my documentation of every communication with my staff to validate my decision. Trust me, that is not a fun time but it is their right to request it for any reason they want. Heck, I was once investigated because one employee was mad at me because I bought lunch for everyone. Now I chose a day when it was convenient (typically Fridays) and sent them all a notice I would buy lunch for them - but she had a doctors appointment and was off that day and felt I was discriminating against her for that reason. HR came back with the recommendation for me to not buy lunch for them again, but I can't do that. They are are the reason I earn what I earn and I appreciate all they do so I like to show them that in any way I can. It may get me in trouble, but it is the right thing to do. 

cushybum --- 17 years ago -

If you have to ask, you shouldn't be in a leadership position! I agree with that remark 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

So I am being judgemental if I look at her reason for wanting the OT as well as looking at the reasons that others want the OT right? I am putting a value on one person's needs based upon my own value system. hmmmm 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

KUenforcement --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment If you have to ask, you shouldn't be in a leadership position! So what would you do KUenforcement? 

~Songbird~ --- 17 years ago -

if you have been using the OT as a reward in the past for good work, then continue with it. if she is not performing as well as others who are requesting it, then you give it to those who have earned it with their performance. what they use the money for doesn't matter. look at her performance. does it earn reward? 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

If you have to ask, you shouldn't be in a leadership position! Chunky, consider the source...The best leaders ask for input for the betterment of companies...it's the know-it-alls like KUE who will always be a follower and NEVER a leader... 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Chunky, consider the source...The best leaders ask for input for the betterment of companies...it's the know-it-alls like KUE who will always be a follower and NEVER a leader... Thanks clockwatcher, I value input from all sources regardless of their motivation. KUenforcement and cushybum raise a great point, that in their eyes the leader makes the decision solely based on the needs of the business and uses the tools (human capital) to the best efficiency. Songbird makes a great point too, if it historically has been used as a reward for past performance or as a motivator for future performance, then I should continue to do so and not worry about how the OT is spent. I already decided to do it as I always had, which could mean that one employee is negatively impacted (her) while the others are not impacted in any way (since there is no change to them from what was going to happen anyway). I just wondered how others on here would see it. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

If you have to ask, you shouldn't be in a leadership position! This from Mr or Mrs Judgemental themself. Chunky listen to your heart !! 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

KUenforcement --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment If you have to ask, you shouldn't be in a leadership position! So what would you do KUenforcement? You are asking a 15 year old? lol Must be 15, based on the immaturity. You have no control over someone else's circumstances. If the people were making an honest attempt to do the right thing and take measures to adjust to the current situation, I would be inclined to do what I could for them. If they feel the need to plow right into old plans, so be it. They will regret it either way. She sounds immature and selfish to me. 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

Yes, and beware of being a "bean counter" and evaluate the ones that are your hardest and most loyal employees. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

I think you made the right decision. As the supervisor or whatever, your employees personal lives are not your business. If you need to give overtime, it should not be based on what you believe the employees will do with the money. That's not your concern. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

As the supervisor or whatever, your employees personal lives are not your business. If you need to give overtime, it should not be based on what you believe the employees will do with the money. That's not your concern. absolutely agree. Overtime is usually based on job performance. Using job performance as your guide leaves all personal judgements out of it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

So let me change this up some.......... The person who requested the OT is a single parent who typically does just what is asked and nothing more while the other employees are married with working spouses and they typically do extra stuff for me/the company. In this case, should I give the single mom preferential treatment for OT knowing that she has extra bills that the others may not have by being single without someone else helping her on the bills or should I continue to base it on performance? My ethical dilemna 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I think you made the right decision. As the supervisor or whatever, your employees personal lives are not your business. If you need to give overtime, it should not be based on what you believe the employees will do with the money. That's not your concern. I think this is a very good way to look at it and would solve your dilemma. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

My ethical dilemna Who gets paid more on a professional sports team? The producers. I always wanted people under me who were capable of doing my job. Made my job easier. 

Lilteapot --- 17 years ago -

If you are in a leadership role at work, you should be required to treat all employees equally and within the guidelines of the company. JMO 

mimifromsa --- 17 years ago -

I'm sorry, but if he lost his job they have no right to be going to Europe on a three week vacation and expecting you to fund it with over time. They should just give up the vacation and use that money to live on until he finds another job. Jeez. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

mimifromsa - are you saying that if someone is facing financial tough times they shouldn't be allowed to have some fun and enjoy a preplanned vacation? 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

AM is right. I think the person who does the best work for the company, the one that produces the most, that does what is asked of them and more is the one that is more deserving of the OT. What would be the incinitive to do your best if that's not the criteria for the OT. 

Jano --- 17 years ago -

I think it would depend on how much overtime you have to offer and then to be fair have a meeting to discuss how it should be divided up with all the employees. That way, they can all feel they have a say and can hopefully come to solution that everyone would be satisfied with. That way she'll be able to plead her case to the single parents, that she thinks she deserves to have the OT to have extra spending money on her vacation, instead of them being able to make ends meet. Or maybe she will just realize that that's not fair and just drop the subject. This way it will take a little weight off your shoulders and put some on hers. You can just be the mediator. Or you could just divide the OT up evenly. 

mimifromsa --- 17 years ago -

Well, Chunky I'm saying that perhaps the money would be better spent on actually paying the mortgage and feeding themselves than traipsing around through Europe. 

mimifromsa --- 17 years ago -

Seems to me that if I had lost my job a trip to Europe would not be uppermost in my mind. I'd be thinking about how I was going to pay my bills and make ends meet. Just a thought. Not my decision if they want to go on a vacation. I would be thinking about the tough financial times you mentioned. 

justme --- 17 years ago -

At the company I work for (35,000+ employees) each work group assigns OT differently. However, none of them assign it based on performance. Personally, I've never heard of that..But maybe I need to get out more..lol..Most base it on seniority, rate of pay, or whoever signs up for it first.. I like the way my father's company assigns OT. At some point, they created a list of all employees who want OT. When OT is available, they call the next person on the list. If that person turns it down, that employee goes to the bottom of the list. Then the next person is called, etc, until someone accepts it. Of course, the person who finally accepts it will go to the bottom of the list, too..This way, everyone gets a chance and no one person keeps getting the OT unless he wants it and no one else does. I think the "reason" any employee needs/wants OT is irrelevant. And performance issues are best left for evaluation when it comes to raises or promotions. JMHO :) 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Justme, that is a great way your dad's co. decides on the OT. That seems to be a very fair way of doing it. 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

Don't let feelings and emotions get involved when it comes to business. Leave all the personal reasons out of your decision making. :) I know but sometimes it is hard when you trust someone but then it really hurts when you find out they have been stealing from you........someone you trusted, can't prove it with facts but 99% sure I have two employees that have been helping themselves to my money out of my drawer......I hate being the bad guy! I hate having to make tough decisions.........lol I don't like being boss! I would give the others a chance for overtime, she is taking a 3 week vacation? That must be some severence package he is getting......lol As far as him not taking the job, my husband while he was job searching STUFFED ENVELOPES IN A WAREHOUSE from 10pm-6am for 7.00 an hour for us to pay our bills, he also worked for temp agencies and took whatever job they gave him. He was an engineer and had a degree but took whatever job was available.....family came first before pride 

mamadog53 --- 17 years ago -

Consider this - maybe their trip is already paid for and to cancel it would mean losing money. Or maybe they're using accumulated airline miles to finance the trip. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

exactly mamadog53, they always take 3-4 weeks of vacation 2 or 3 times a year. As noted above he was very well paid, they have no mortgage and their cars are paid off. Her money that she earns is their vacation fund and that's it. It will be an interesting day at work today when I have their staff meeting. 

mimifromsa --- 17 years ago -

Whatever. Europe is expensive. The money they will be spending there would be better spent living and paying expenses while he's out of a job. I couldn't enjoy the trip knowing when I got back I might not be able to pay my living expenses. 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

I didn't read the responses but what about giving ALL employees the opportunity to work the OT at equal share? That seems to be the fair and equitable thing to do. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground