Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should we bring prayer back to our schools?

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 7
love4bdd 1
DrowningFish 1
randyjet 1
planemom 3
Texas Girl 1
lLackCreativity 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
Deltadawn 1
Mygirl01 4
Cicero 9
Rachel 1
ghostpost 3
recycled teenager 3
~sassy~ 7
rEVOLution 1
traveller! 1
Wilstar77 1
ladybughomeschool 1
believer 9
KUTEX 2
hopscotch 1
Abigail 1
♥kerry♥ 3
MomofTwins* 1
Polly Ester 6
james osterberg 2
TexasOma 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should we bring prayer back to our schools?

Should we bring prayer back to our schools? Has it gone to far? Should kids/teachers be expelled for praying with a friend or teacher in private?

We should not ever pray at school because doing so may infringe on the rights of a few. Vote
 
 32.3% (20)
We should allow prayer at school because not allowing prayer infringes on the rights of the majority. Vote
 
 67.7% (42)
Texas Girl --- 17 years ago -

Should we bring prayer back to our schools? Has it gone to far? Should kids/teachers be expelled/fired for praying with a friend or teacher in private? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it should be mandatory. I think all the children should be allowed equal time to pray to whom ever they pray to without prejudice. 

lLackCreativity --- 17 years ago -

If my family can say our prayers, then your family can say your prayers. But if you think my prayers offend you but I'm not supposed to be offended by your prayers....well that is where the problem comes in. Don't force feed me your religion and I won't feed you mine. That is what bothers me about prayer in school as a school activity, not as an activity that is optional for the kids. What religion are they going to pick? Or will there be time allowed for all the religions? What about people like me who don't teach their kids one religion, but teach them of ALL religions? Prayer should always be an option because it is a very important part of life. 

Abigail --- 17 years ago -

As required by Texas law, all schools must have a moment of silence everyday. The students can pray, meditate or just sit/stand quietly. We do this right after our pledges on our morning announcements everyday so in a way it is allowed, but it is a true moment of silence so they are not able pray with others. I don't keep up with it much, have there been cases where students have been suspended for praying with others? 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

no one can stop you from praying.......you can close your eyes and say a prayer. done. if you are saying that school should have group prayers? um, i'm gonna say NO way to that one. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

This poll doesn't make sense to me. Children in Texas schools have the opportunity to pray privately everyday by the required moment of silence. Why does it need to be more than that? That is respecting everyone's rights and is a state law that each school have it. I don't see moment of silence as an option, so I didn't vote. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Children are allowed to pray in school. Prayer cannot be initiated by a teacher or other authority but a student may pray. We absolutely pray before our school time and I think that is the only way we make it through some days. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

This poll doesn't make sense to me i totally agree. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

Poll is a little misleading so I didn't vote. I don't mind prayer but it shouldn't be required. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

This poll doesn't make sense to me i totally agree. ditto. If you are asking if a student should be expelled for praying with a teacher..no, I don't agree with that, because the teacher is an authority figure and the student would not be at fault. However, I do not believe a teacher should pray with a student. That is not their role and IMO not a professional act. There is no reason prayer needs to be public in the school setting. Children can be taught that their faith can be practiced throughout the day, just as many do within the workplace (Isn't that the point of school..to prepare our children for their future?) without distracting or infringing on others by making it a public spectacle or requirement. I did not vote because the poll did not have the option for the existing moment of silence, which I think is fair and appropriate for the school setting. 

TexasOma --- 17 years ago -

I don't mind prayer but it shouldn't be required. Same here. There is nothing wrong with a "moment of silence" to allow kids to either pray or not pray - just a time of reflection. If a child is going to pray, they do not need time set aside and telling a child they must pray can turn the child against prayer. Schools just need to have a moment of silence. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Required prayer should not be allowed. Should students get in trouble for praying on their own? No way! If a student asks a teacher to pray with them it should be allowed as long as it's not during class. Also, if a school has a place set aside for students to pray it should be open to all religions. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

That is a very poor question and loaded to one side. The correct question should be, Should mandatory, public, school sponsored Christian prayer be allowed in schools? When I was growing up in a predominately Protestant community, we had prayer, Bible readings from the Protestant Bible, and told the Catholics and Jews, TOUGH! If you don't like it go somewhere else. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

If a student asks a teacher to pray with them it should be allowed as long as it's not during class. What if the teacher isn't of that faith? What if a child of a non-christian faith also wants the teacher to observe his/her rituals? What if the child's parents do not want their child practicing religion with the teacher? That is opening a whole legal and ethical can of worms IMO. I do not think a teacher should be put in this position or be involved in praying with a student unless it is at a private religious school. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I didn't say the teacher was required to pray if asked only that is should be allowed. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

First off,the question is improperly worded. what assumptions do you make as to who are the feww and who are the majority? If you want prayer in school,get someone to be a volenteer 20 min before class time. dont cut into an already inefficient school day with some peoples faith needs and wants. 

love4bdd --- 17 years ago -

Prayer? In what way? A standard set prayer for all kids to say, or just set aside prayer time for each to "say" silently their own in their heads? I'm Jewish, so it could be a problem in my eyes depending on what way / how you were referring to it being "done".... 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

I didn't say the teacher was required to pray if asked only that is should be allowed. I understand that. But what if I don't want a teacher to pray with my child? What if my Muslim child asks the teacher to pray with him because she prayed with Susie..and she doesn't want to practice my child's faith with him? Do you understand what point I'm trying to make? A teacher should treat all children the same regardless of their faith..and practicing the faith of some and not the others that she teaches is not her place. It also may be that a child asks a teacher to pray but mom would prefer the teacher did not. Apparently, I am making the point badly, so I'll quit, lol..but I do not believe a teacher should pray with a student in their role as a teacher. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

ghostpost I understand your point, as for planemom,not so much. I urge you not to quit. 

traveller! --- 17 years ago -

If your attending a public school, a moment of silence, reflection, etc.. is fine. There is no need to pray out loud as there might be several denominations in the class. 

DrowningFish --- 17 years ago -

When I was in high school, they had "meet at the flag" prayer meetings at least once a week. They were well attended, and never once did the school try to stop it. I'm all for activities like that. But as for making prayer mandatory in the classroom...I don't agree with it. If they WERE to make it mandatory, then it should include ALL religions. The Christians have their prayer rituals, the Muslims have theirs, the Jewish faith, etc etc etc. They should make time for all faiths to express their prayers in accordance to their religion. I kind of rambled, did that make sense? lol. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

This is what I call an irrelevant poll. It's basically asking whether we should do something that goes against our constitution... 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

If a student asks a teacher to pray with them it should be allowed as long as it's not during class. Let me clarify. Not during class means before or after school but on campus. Not a big production in front of the class. I also said if the student asks. This would not be teacher led and the teacher would have every right to say no. In most cases I would guess the teacher would say no for the reasons you stated. Mostly, I'm just hesitant to put any more restrictions on what teachers can and cannot do. It seems the more restrictions placed on the teachers the worse our school system becomes. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I also said if the student asks. This would not be teacher led and the teacher would have every right to say no. I am a teacher (substitute) and a Christian. I do not want to pray with children during school hours or on campus. I want to be their educator and I have no problem being a role model by how I conduct myself and treat the children in my care. But I do not want to share my religion in the classroom or at the schoolhouse. I want to remain neutral while I am entrusted with the care of children that represent a diverse population. That doesn't mean I don't pray for my students every day. I also pray that I be an educator worthy of their instruction. I do not believe children should pray aloud during the instructional day. That is intrusive and unnecessary. If that happened in my classroom, I would quietly tell the child they need to do that silently. I would not embarrass them, but they are capable of learning to pray silently. Its a great life skill. I do teach Sunday school and in that capacity have prayed with children that I also have had in the classroom. They don't seem to have any problem with the distinction of my roles, even very young children. Like so many other things, I think it is adults that tend to make very simple things complicated. Children have the opportunity at school to pray everyday or not pray. Why does it need to be any different than that? 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

I am a teacher (substitute) and a Christian. I do not want to pray with children during school hours on campus. I want to be their educator and I have no problem being a role model by how I conduct myself and treat the children in my care. But I do not want to share my religion in the classroom. I want t remain neutral while I am entrusted with the care of children that represent a diverse population. YAY FOR KERRY!!!!! your entire post makes sense to me and makes me say YAY! 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I edited my post to say that I do not want to pray in the classroom or the schoolhouse. It may be hard for those that have not been in the classroom to understand that the teacher needs to be someone looked up to by all of her/his students. Not just the ones that practice my faith. It isn't my students business what my religion is and its none of my business what theirs is. I have my hands full as it is. It isn't any different than keeping my political views or morality views to myself and private. Teachers have great influence over your children. It is important that we know how to keep our personal views and beliefs private. That doesn't mean we are stifled and can not lead our students. Unfortunately, just like in every profession..there are some teachers that need the boundaries. Without them, there would be teachers crossing the line into religious teachings and political lecturing that would be inappropriate. I am sure it happens anyway, but it shouldn't be. 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

YES.... 

Polly Ester --- 17 years ago -

NO.... 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

YES! 

MomofTwins* --- 17 years ago -

I wish my kids' teachers would make them observe the moment of silence, instead o letting them sit there and write in their journals, fool around in their desks, etc while not talking. Whether people pray or not during that time is their choice, but I do think it should be a more peaceful time (no movement) rather than just an oversight. 

Polly Ester --- 17 years ago -

YES! Yippee! I am packing little Bashir's prayer rug in his backpack right now! I will include a tape of the call to prayer with it for the teacher to use five times daily as well. My little one is so excited to practice his faith with his beloved teacher! God is most great! 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

if you want a prayer that the entire class participates in, then go to a private religious school. IMO, a public school isn't the place to "force" religion upon people of different belief's. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

the opportunity to pray if you wish is there. close your eyes and pray. prayer is about what is in your mind and heart, not what comes out of your mouth. if the prayer HAS to be out loud, that seems it is more about 'who will hear me' rather than 'what i am doing'. 

KUTEX --- 17 years ago -

Absolutely we should. Most definitely. Liberal whiners that wish to say otherwise should just shut the f up and stand silently while others do the right thing. You have your right NOT to pray, but it does NOT allow you to tell others not to. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

IMO, a public school isn't the place to "force" religion upon people of different belief's. Uh, Christian nation....where's the tolerance? Oh wait! There isn't any. You equate 30 seconds of silence with 'forcing' religion on anyone? How so? 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

You equate 30 seconds of silence with 'forcing' religion on anyone? How so? i know this wasn't to me, but can i chime in? the moment of silence is fine, imo. actually, i remember really liking it as a kid.....gave me a minute (literally) to take a breath and prepare for the day. i think the opposition is more towards prayer that is out loud. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

i think the opposition is more towards prayer that is out loud. Oh I beg to differ. I think if the opposition could find a way to legally take away the moment of silence, they would in a heart beat. i know this wasn't to me, but can i chime in? I love it when you chime in! ;D 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

Oh I beg to differ. I think if the opposition could find a way to legally take away the moment of silence, they would in a heart beat. ok, since you wanted me to chime in, i'll rephrase ;) MY opposition to prayer in schools would be to prayer that is out loud. the moment of silence is a great thing, imo! 

Polly Ester --- 17 years ago -

Liberal whiners that wish to say otherwise should just shut the f up I'll pray for you.. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

Liberal whiners that wish to say otherwise should just shut the f up I'll pray for you.. silently or aloud? ROFL! j/k....i'm just trying to lighten this up! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground