Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Landscaping: Mulch vs Rocks?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 5
Lilteapot 1
Fallon 1
Sarah75 1
gumbeauxgirl 6
ladybeachbum 1
Clown Vomit 2
Mabbers 1
I Kissed Frogs 1
JerryKat 11
momof5 6
Perfection 2
*maryc 2
horns32 1
♥kerry♥ 1
jtcitrus 3
sadiesmom 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Which do you have, which do you like better? Which is easier to maintain? Cheapest place to get them? thanks for any info : ) 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

I have rocks. I like them b/c they don't blow away, turn colors, need to be replaced or bring in pests. I don't like them b/c they are a pain. They are constantly getting into the yard and have to be picked up before mowing. Moving them isn't an easy job if you want to change you landscaping layout and you can't kneel comfortably in the garden to weed or tend the flowers. 

horns32 --- 17 years ago -

Weeds grow between rocks which can be a pain to maintain. Weeds still grow in mulch, but it's alot easier to maintain. Eventually mulch fades & has a chance to wash away. I have mulch. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

Weeds still grow in mulch even if you put that paper down first? How long does the paper last? Moving them isn't an easy job if you want to change you landscaping layout and you can't kneel comfortably in the garden to weed or tend the flowers. That never even occurred to me! thanks! I have three flower beds that I have to find a solution for, they've had mulch before, (previous owners) but I thought rocks might be easier... thanks for the info. 

Lilteapot --- 17 years ago -

I have both (in different area's of my yard). Mulch can be messy when it's windy and it blows away. Rocks, depending on the size are more costly. I have a small pebble walkway in my back, I hate it. The pebbles constantly get everywhere, It's hard to push the lawnmower through the path, and I am constantly weeding it. Cement...thats the best, cheap and low maintenance! 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

My plan was to put rocks in, then buy big planters so I'm not really maintaining anything but them, and I can change them out easily. A couple Shepherds hooks here and there and done! I haven't even priced this out yet...lol. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

I use pine needles for mulch. I tried the pine bark chips or nuggets and they float away, turn white and rot. I tried rocks and they sink into the ground and get covered with dirt, then again I have no mulch. With the pine needles, they are free, and I have an endless supply. All you have to do is place them where you want them and water them down and they keep most all weeds from growing through. They do rot, but I just have to rake my yard and add on top. In the past, if I run short, have even stopped and picked up other peoples pine needles when I see them bagged and thrown out. I like the idea of them being free, not going to the landfill and they are natural! 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

ok momof5 take it from me mulch might be a little more work but in the long run it is better than rock.and don't put down plain newspaper. Go to lowes and get the landscaping plastic to put down...... Cedar mulch also has less weeds come up.... If you have anymore landscaping questions I will be happy to answer them. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

what about rubber mulch? 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Moving them isn't an easy job if you want to change you landscaping layout and you can't kneel comfortably in the garden to weed or tend the flowers. So true! When I moved here there were these UGLY red volcanic rocks in one of the beds. I had to dig them all up but I still keep finding them in the yard and everywhere and it has been 5 years! 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

See whatcha the bad thing about pine needles is you will not be able to grow some things because how much acid is in the pine needles.... 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

even if you put that paper down first? How long does the paper last? I haven't used it but my neighbors swear by old, wet newspapers. They get them from the local hotels that provide a daily paper to guests, lay them down to a depth of several inches, wet them well and then mulch on top. The newspaper prevents anything from growing up through the mulch. I tried rocks and they sink into the ground and get covered with dirt This is so true. The bottom layer will sink and if you ever want to move them, you have to dig out the ones imbedded in the ground. 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

Rubber mulch is great but it ain't cheap either 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

I have had to move rock out of gardens and pathways and it stinks digging them all up. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

My plan was to put rocks in, then buy big planters so I'm not really maintaining anything but them, and I can change them out easily I like this idea! Maybe you should try flatter larger rocks so that they do not sink into the dirt, like the smaller, gravel does. You could use small flagstone. 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

They will still sink befor it is over..just because of their weight when we get a gully washer, which we get from time to time. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

and don't put down plain newspaper My neighbors were just trying to convince me that was the way to go this summer and I was leaning towards the landscape fabric. Why shouldn't you use newspaper? I'll have to go down and let them know. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

I don't like the look of rocks. We have mulch. Landscape fabric does prevent weeds from growing up from the ground, but weed seeds can germinate and grow above the landscape fabric. I do find that weeds are easier to remove from mulch vs rocks. Mulch will also need to be replenished somewhat each year depending on how thick you apply it and how much it weathers. If you have a truck or can borrow one you can get a yard of mulch for about $30. That is much cheaper than buying the bags. We usually get ours from Kingwood Mulch. If you have a 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

See whatcha the bad thing about pine needles is you will not be able to grow some things because how much acid is in the pine needles Yes, but my Hydrangeas love them and I have yet to have anything react badly to them. I'm not sure why but I was worried about that too, but no problems so far. 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

its just that plain newspaper starts to decompose quicker and it is a mess if you have to redo the garden for some reason. now for the pine needles there are plants out there that don't like the acid levels at all but if it works for you hey... 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

I know azelas(sp) love it and blueberry plants and holly also. 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

Both. Cobble rocks for drainage, mulch for plants. I have some of the larger boulders for decoration/balance. The thought process is to get the water away from areas you don't want it (around foundations and walkways) and retain it in places you do want it (plant roots). 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

Pine needles can be very effective and of course free. Hydrangeas do love them. So will any acid loving plants...azaleas, camellias, magnolias, ferns etc. I still prefer the overall look of mulch. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

wow! so many different ways to go about it! Thanks guys! Those volcanic rocks are ugly!!! I was thinking more the round pebbles. I've never even heard of the wet newspaper idea...interesting. I was just going to put down that black fabric stuff, depending on the price...lol. I never thought about the planters sinking into the ground....Maybe a few smallers ones? 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

I have seen alot of flower gardens in my day. 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

landscape fabric I used that 2 yrs ago, and have mixed feelings. It does work for about 1 season, then as someone mentioned, weed seeds will grow on top of it. The other negative side is if you want to add some other plants, you first have to pierce the fabric to get to the underlying dirt. It's not hard, just annoying. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

I have used newspapers before as well. They worked fine. I'm sure they do decompose more quickly than the lanscape fabric. Your planters should be fine. I have pots placed in some of my beds. :) 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

It does work for about 1 season, then as someone mentioned, weed seeds will grow on top of it. The other negative side is if you want to add some other plants, you first have to pierce the fabric to get to the underlying dirt. It's not hard, just annoying. That's why I wanted to just cover the areas with rocks or mulch and have the self contained planters on top of them, so I'm not really "weeding" too much, you know? with 5 kids, I don't have the time or energy to work on the yard a lot, so I was hoping to find a low maintanence way to do this, and I thought the planters would be fun for the kids, they could help pick out the plants and water them, etc etc. 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

are all your plants going to be in planters or are you going to have plants in the ground also? 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

We generally only use landscape fabric or newspapers if we are putting in a new bed and don't want to bother taking out all the grass. Bill is right. It is a pain to try to dig through it if you want to plant something. Nothing will prevent weeds 100%. A good layer of mulch will help though. 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

if they are all in planters then you could just spray everything down first with that once a season round up and then set your planters down and move them when it came time to do it again. 

momof5 --- 17 years ago -

are all your plants going to be in planters or are you going to have plants in the ground also? no ground plants...lol. That was the idea. I weeded out the entire area a few weekends ago and it's bare bones now, so, this would be the perfect time to do this. there are a few plants in there, but nothing much. So, I have to either plant new ones in the ground, or now that it's cleared, lay down the mulch or rocks and get the planters. I have a bed around a tree as well, I was going to do the same thing with it, and put in a shepherds hook. The other bed has (according to my neighbor) gardenia bushes...they don't really flower, so I have no clue what they are. So I was gonna leave them, and just put in the mulch or rocks. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

Any plants that are in planters will need to be watered alot more. Especially in the heat of summer they will need it everyday. 

JerryKat --- 17 years ago -

the gardenia should flower they will be white and they smell good.... we have them here at the house and the wife loves to clip the flowers and bring them into the house. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

You might think about eventually putting in a few perennials. They come back every year and require very little to no work to maintain. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I put down the landscape fabric and really like it. I put down some flowering large plants first and then put the landscaping fabric around them. This was last summer and the beds stayed pretty weed free to this spring as well. My beds are raised and filled with mulch and have landscape rocks around the borders. If you prepare your beds right the first time then the maintance goes down in the long run. Raised beds with good borders look best IMO and the mulch doesn't wash away as much and are less maintenance. We hired someone to do our beds initially after a couple of years of always trying to keep our beds looking nice and wondering what we were doing wrong. We drove around our neighborhood and looked at yaeds we liked and relized that our beds were not raised high enough and needed the large landscape rocks to define them and keep them from washing out. I really think some large and easy plants (like lantana if its sunny, impatients if its shady) would be less maintance than potted plants..and will spread and reseed themselves each year. Mulch definitely over any other filler for the beds. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

No matter what you choose, the weeds will come through. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Rocks: Sink into the ground and eventually, even with regular use of a blower get covered over by pine-needles dust dirt, and other things (I've found so many landscaping rocks under the topsoil in this neighborhood its ridiculous) Weeding is a pain, and you wind up relying on Round-Up - which should be avoided when possible. Mulch: - Shredded Native Hard Wood Mulch OR Aged Pine is Best. It's effective, attractive and adds organic material to the soil over time. (don't get colored mulch though, you lose points for that) - Rubber Mulch is Stupid. unless you're creating a Running Path or a Dog Run Don't use it (even then for the $$ decomposed granite walkways look better and are easier to maintain). It contributes nothing to the soil but Toxins that leach out of it slowly over time. - News Paper under Mulch: GOOD! Just don't use any of the shiny stuff that contain heavy metals. Use old fashioned b/w print 8-12 pages thick, It lasts a month, but if you Mulch at the correct time of year, it effectively stops a generation from germinating. - Pine Needles: Excellent! NOTE: the rule about pine needles only being good for acid loving plants because the make the soil too acidic is a MYTH! It would take 100 years for pine needles to move the soil PH too low for any plant that grows here... assuming we have no rain. (also the nonsense about not mulch-mowing oak leaves because of the tannins is false too. Grass will grow if you give it light water and topsoil... if you want grass that is.) - Landscape Fabric under mulch: good, but eventually weeds find their way through anyway and makes pulling them out from the root more difficult. This is Houston, not Minneapolis... weeds will find a way. - Potted Plants: Great addition to the garden, but be advised: potted plants take a lot more care and maintenance than plants in the ground. anyway, 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Lantana is beautiful, but the berry is dangerous.....perhaps a trailing verbena would serve the same purpose in a sunny area and safer around the children. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

- Pine Needles: Excellent! NOTE: the rule about pine needles only being good for acid loving plants because the make the soil too acidic is a MYTH! It would take 100 years for pine needles to move the soil PH too low for any plant that grows here... assuming we have no rain. (also the nonsense about not mulch-mowing oak leaves because of the tannins is false too. Grass will grow if you give it light water and topsoil... if you want grass that is.) I guess that explains why I have had such good luck with pine needles. They do look a little messy when you first but them down, but after a few waterings the compact and flatten out. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground