Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I KNOW I will regret asking...

who's talking here?

Poquita 1
lindagail 1
JDB2 5
Lilteapot 1
crazyfun2baround 3
FishinKim 1
♥be as you are♥ 1
*Annie* 1
MoveIt 2
crrc 2
gumbeauxgirl 7
m•t•v 4
Mabbers 3
Rachel 1
Sue 1
Tootsieboo 1
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 7
ExLady In Blue 5
Unichic™ 1
MomTimesFive 23
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
TheBatsMeow 1
Hope 15
Allimama 7
Vladimpaler 4
PHSMOMOF2 7
Big Ben 1
KUTEX 1
clockwatcher. 5
♥kerry♥ 1
Polly Ester 2
Shenanigans 2
mommie21g1b 2
Stella111 1
goatlady 2
jamie 4
amy 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

but, how do you feel about zero tolerance vs discretion. I had to go to the middle school today to pick up my dd's cell phone and pay a $15 fine. At first I was upset with her and I was going to make her pay the fine. But, the more I thought about it I became angry with the policy. She normally would NEVER use her cell phone at school. I have tried on a few occasions to reach her (BEFORE school) while she was walking to school and also AFTER school on rainy days to let her know I would pick her up. I always get her voicemail because she has it turned off because of school policy. Wednesday she called me during her lunch period from the girl's bathroom because she felt sick. She wanted me to pick her up. So I went to check her out. She was asked what phone she called me from and when she told the attendance person he took her phone. This is a child who has been called to the office exactly once. She was called in with a few of her friends because of how nicely they had treated another girl who had low self esteem. Evidently it had a huge effect on the other girl. They were rewarded by the principal with pizza for lunch. BTW, although she did enjoy the pizza she felt they shouldn't have been rewarded for treating someone the way they deserve to be treated in the first place. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

 

Big Ben --- 17 years ago -

My Honest Opinion, Zero Tolerance is Bullsh*t. They go way overboard on stuff. Im glad Im not is school these days. 

TheBatsMeow --- 17 years ago -

I don't quite understand but I think the cell phone policy is utterly dumb. It shouldn't matter in my opinion how your daughter contacted you, but the fact she felt sick, and could make others ill if she didn't leave the school. It seems to be a bunch of politics back and forth among parents and school teachers. I'm HATE it. But what can you really do? 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

You would think they would be worried about the drug use and sex in the bathrooms and not...... gasp a girl calling her mom on the cell phone in the bathroom. I would raise HELL. She is your child and she has a right to contact YOU whenever she needs to. The government should not be allowed to take that right away from you as a parent. 

Polly Ester --- 17 years ago -

Why didn't she go to the school nurse? 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

If you aren't vomiting or running a 101.4 fever they don't let you call home. At least that is how it was when I was in school. Even with an ongoing medical concern, the nurse would not let me call home. Neither would the principal's secretary. I had to sneak to the pay phone or use the phone in one of the few teacher's who sympathized with my situation in order to call home and ask for my mom or neighbor to come get me. Then when they checked me out they could not say I called them they had to just say I had an appointment. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

Intitially I asked why she didn't ask her teacher and she said she was afraid they wouldn't believe her. I am not happy with this answer at all. I asked if it was a specific teacher or teachers in general. She said teachers in general. She said she has seen it happen with other kids. She is also extremely shy and does not like to call attention to herself in any way. Even just asking to call home. I told her in the future to ask her teacher and if they don't allow her to call then we will handle it. I also asked her about the school nurse. She said all the nurse ever does is give you an ice pack no matter what the problem is. lol She did say she would probably have her lie down for a bit. I knew she wasn't feeling well that morning before school, and I thought about keeping her home. However, dd said that she had a big test review and didn't want to miss anymore days. She was really sick earlier this year and missed about a week. Anyway, she didn't have any fever or other symptoms besides her tummy so I let her go. She has had two very big projects over the last few weeks and has been under a lot of stress. So much so, that it has made her cry on a few occassions which is very unlike her. 

amy --- 17 years ago -

The policy in the schools is clear. There are no exceptions for use of cell phones. If the school allows this to slide, they will have to allow others as well. Which in turn causes more problems. Don't blame the school. They followed their policy, which everyone is aware of when entering the school year. Turn this into a learning experience for your daughter. Even the nicest children make mistakes. 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

they have to have zero tolerance because the ones that really abuse policy won't tolerate someone saying their kid did wrong and your's didn't....in other words, the misusers can't understand discretion. Zero-tolerance solves that concern and therefore avoids legal action on more serious offenses and encourages kids to stay within the guideline. Fortunately, I get to decide whether to be upset with my DD or not. She knows the rules, I know the rules. If she or I decide to break the rules, we know the consequences. It becomes simply a matter of making a decision that way. I hope your DD is feeling better. 

KUTEX --- 17 years ago -

ZT IS BS  

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

We were told by our principal that the only reason kids were allowed to have their cell phones is because of 9/11 and Columbine. In an emergency of that kind, every parent wants to communicate with their child, and we support that. Any other use of the phone during school hours is a disruption of learning or policy. 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

I do think that in this case, paying the fine and then letting the matter drop is the best way to go. My daughter got a d-hall because she was late for club last year. I thought it was ridiculous but she knows that I expect her to follow the rules. So she went to d-hall and the matter was dropped. I told her that where I thought d-hall was extreme for that she still needed to respect the authority of the school administration and left it at that. Of course she is in high school. I used to tell my kids to put their cell phones in their lockers until school got out but there are so many random shootings and such going on if they keep their phone in their backpack thereby giving them access to it in case of an emergency they may stand a chance. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Gumbeaugirl...I think that policy sucks! I would have not paid and neither would my son. I would have gave them a piece of my mind but not my money. What school is this? 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Rachel are you serious...wow some of the schools are taking these EXTRACURRICULARS to a whole new level! What the heck! 

lindagail --- 17 years ago -

I have to agree with some of the others and say you should treat this as a learning lesson. ALWAYS follow the school policies. You sound like you have a wonderful daughter and should be proud. Shy or not, she should have gone to the nurse. Just let her know you understand WHY she wanted to call you but the school policy states NO CELL PHONE USE. And, for what it is worth, my son would have probably done the exact same thing as your daughter did! :) 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

We were told by our principal that the only reason kids were allowed to have their cell phones is because of 9/11 and Columbine. In an emergency of that kind, every parent wants to communicate with their child, and we support that. Any other use of the phone during school hours is a disruption of learning or policy I disagree the child was in the bathroom and on a lunch break. Although, we had a pay phone at my high school, we weren't on lock down. I doubt that any learning was being done in the bathroom that day. I would talk to the highest pricipal....not pay the fine and tell them why. It's not that awful since she was in the bathroom and feeling ill. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

? 

Lilteapot --- 17 years ago -

I read on here recently, ( a post by randyjet), something which has stuck with me and is a great way to go. He said the founder of Continental airlines said the manual and handbooks are good to go by, however, common sense always overrules. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

This is another reason I'm glad I homeschool. I found that when my older kids were in school, the lack of common sense was so bad that I was constantly having to call the office or talk to a teacher. It's so nice not to have to put up with all their garbage anymore. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Good post JDB. I once went through the same thing with my dd's cell phone, and it sucked. But rules are rules. Sometimes though it makes me wonder the common sense of the 'rule maker' lol I'm curious, Does anyone know why this infraction carries a fine and others do not? 

crazyfun2baround --- 17 years ago -

She was asked what phone she called me from and when she told the attendance person he took her phone So, for being honest, feeling sick and using her phone in the bathroom during lunch, she gets penalized?? That is crap! (excuse my expression!) HOWEVER..knowing the way the schools are and not wanting to have dd have any issues from here on out, myself, I would probably pay the fine, get the phone, and move on. JMO! Fortunately, I get to decide whether to be upset with my DD or not. She knows the rules, I know the rules. If she or I decide to break the rules, we know the consequences. It becomes simply a matter of making a decision that way. Have to agree with jdb here. I truly do hope your dd is feeling better. 

Allimama --- 17 years ago -

The rule is that you cannot use your phone during school hours, period. The reason for the rule is because kids cause all sorts of hell with their phones. Taking pictures of tests, texting during tests (and they do this underneath their desk while looking right at you and talking, they are sneaky little devils), taking pics of kids in the bathroom, taking pics of kids in the locker room. I had grandmothers calling their grandkids in the middle of class "just to chat"! We have to have a fine so that the madness would stop. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

We have to have a fine so that the madness would stop. Yeah, I suppose there are all sorts of mischeviousness that can come from those lil phones. It's a good thing the school realizes they would have a mass uprising on their hands if they decided to ban them altogether, so in THAT sense, they're using their sense lol! 

crazyfun2baround --- 17 years ago -

Does anyone know why this infraction carries a fine and others do not? I would think it is to discourage the students and parents from allowing them to bring them to school. The only thing they can hold "ransom", kind of idea. 

MoveIt --- 17 years ago -

I would not punish her this time- but tell her the policy is in place for a reason. If she felt sick, she should have asked to use the office phone. My son calls me from there when he has forgotten something, missed the bus, etc. (and he has his cell) 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

So, for being honest, feeling sick and using her phone in the bathroom during lunch, she gets penalized?? Yes. I think the fine is new. The letter I received about the policy was dated last week. Maybe I am more of a rebel than I thought. lol What if you were the little attendance nazi... uh I mean man? No one knew she had used her phone except for dd and myself. She was not disrupting class or anything like that. If she had used the phone in an inappropriate manner I would have a new phone for myself. I think he took a perverse pleasure in catching her and taking her phone. 

crazyfun2baround --- 17 years ago -

I think the fine is new. Not if you are in Humble ISD. That has been in effect for at least 3 years. That is about as far back as I can remember! lol 

m•t•v --- 17 years ago -

Cell phones are supposed to be turned OFF, not just silenced, all throughout the school day. If she had gone to the nurse, they would have let her call. Like others said, the rules are clearly stated. If she chose to turn on her cell phone and use it, it's a clear violation of policy. She didn't get penalized for being honest, she got penalized for violating the policy. And obviously, she didn't HAVE to tell the guy, but do you want your child to learn the lesson that just cause you don't admit it makes it okay? Would you expect her to not be penalized for breaking other policies, such as those that have to do with cheating, even if she admitted it? I'm playing devil's advocate here to prove a point, such pls don't jump down my throat about it, but it's just something to think about.. 

Stella111 --- 17 years ago -

I don't agree with the policy. If enough people voice their opinion, maybe they will change it. 

MoveIt --- 17 years ago -

I don't understand what there is about the policy to disagree with. If they are allowed to keep their phones on- they WILL be distracted, they WILL text, etc. The office has a phone they can use. Kids/phones/and class do not mix. 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

I have told her that in the future she needs to go to her teacher or the nurse first. If she is not allowed to call me then by all means I give her permission to use her cell. 

m•t•v --- 17 years ago -

I don't understand what there is about the policy to disagree with. If they are allowed to keep their phones on- they WILL be distracted, they WILL text, etc. The office has a phone they can use. Kids/phones/and class do not mix.  DITTO 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

Some kids do have their cells on at school and try to be sneaky texting, etc. My dd has seen it herself. She only turned hers on in the bathroom at lunch to call me and then turned it back off. I would never advocate using it in class. I just don't agree with zero tolerance. I think a little common sense can go a long way. 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

I just don't agree with zero tolerance. I think a little common sense can go a long way I would have to agree... 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

If she is not allowed to call me then by all means I give her permission to use her cell. I'm sorry...I should be able to decide if my child needs to go home...as a parent, I want to know if my child is not feeling well at school...that would take my right away as a parent. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Not if you are in Humble ISD. That has been in effect for at least 3 years. That is about as far back as I can remember! lol My daughter is in college, and she was fined in middle school, so it goes back a little way. I was NOT happy having to drive to the Humble police station. Is that meant to piss off and to inconvenience? Well it worked lol! 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

AND I would ensure that the nurse understood that as well. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I don't agree with the policy. If enough people voice their opinion, maybe they will change it. The only thing I might truly disagree with is the fine. 15 bucks a pop...who gets this money? Not sure I want the school proffiting off bad behavior from the age group where bad behavior is almost a sure thing, generally speaking. If I saw the other side of the coin I might see that differently. 

m•t•v --- 17 years ago -

I'm sorry...I should be able to decide if my child needs to go home...as a parent, I want to know if my child is not feeling well at school...that would take my right away as a parent.  Not if your child goes to the nurse! Come on, quit making excuses for your kids to break rules. If your kid was really sick AND went to the nurse, AND laid down for a while and they STILL didn't let her call and made her go back to class, then I could see you getting upset.. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground