Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

A discussion for the democrats

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 8
smartypants 4
randyjet 1
planemom 3
Sandyr9111 1
MonzaRacer 1
donottreadonme 1
Spartacus 3
~sassy~ 7
EarlyBird 1
Forecaster 1
CoralReef 2
Perfection 8
brian* 8
MxMike 1
Lord Cheezus 20
Ogre1 14
genxer 3
Mark 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Forecaster --- 17 years ago -

Obama wants to give tax cuts to the bottom 95% of families who file tax returns. Of that 95% only about 40% actually pay income tax. So in essence he's taking away money from the ones making 250,000 a year and giving to the very people that break even every year and don't pay a dime to the IRS. How is that even logical? My question wasn't addressed on another thread but I think this needs addressed. O has a huge spending infrastructure plan as well which includes things such as insulated schools and government buildings and making golf courses more efficient. I have to ask how, given the current economy that even O says is of historic proportion, this helps the economy. Do you know what happens when business' are taxed at higher rates? They cut workers which cuts production which causes inflation with no jobs. I hope he turns his radical thinking around for the greater good of the USA but his ideas are flawed. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

How is that even logical? Obama's plan was for a reduction in taxes paid by most people. So they would have less money taken out of their paychecks. given the current economy that even O says is of historic proportion, this helps the economy. The creation of jobs in the field of energy efficiency helps the economy and cannot be outsourced. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

90% of the tax code is about redistribution of wealth. Up until now, the redistribution has been at the upper end of the scale. Ask me about Capital Gains... after I'm done cursing, I'll tell you that the CG tax is custom made for those who make OVER 250k a year. NOT for you and me (assuming you don't make 250k a year) AND, I still don't get why people think that businesses are going to be taxed at a higher rate than individuals. There are so many deductions for businesses, so many exemptions, that speaking of business taxes and individual taxes in the same line simply indicates a person's ignorance of the tax code. And the $250,000.00 number, that's NOT gross receipts. That's TAXABLE INCOME which is a completely different animal all together. For a business, that's profit after all expenses for making that profit are deducted, after all the payroll is deducted, after a thousand other things are deducted and exempted. The media has done a lousy job of explaining how this works. And Most people haven't read the IRC (I unfortunately had to for Fed. Income Tax class last semester) According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, NOT A SINGLE SMALL BUSINESS CATEGORY REPORTED AN AVERAGE GROSS TAXABLE INCOME of $250,000.00 in 2007. Doctors, lawyers, engineers, and sales managers show an average in range of $100,000-$150,000, but not near $250,000. Feel free to read the report linked to, I feel for you if you do, it's painful. So all this whining about Obama's tax plan just comes about from a lack of knowledge about how things really work with the tax code. So get past it and let's see what happens. Can't possibly be worse than the past eight years! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Now let's look at the Second Assumption. Will giving tax breaks to people making over $250,000 a year encourage them to create more jobs? This assumption assumes these individuals are making their money in fields that would in fact lead to job creation. According to U.S. Census reports 1,324,000 reported incomes above $250,000. So who are these 1,324,000 people? Again, it's hard to narrow it down. Most of the statistical charts deal in median income, which means it throws out the top and bottom wages to calculate the average. So perhaps we have to go with our collective knowledge. What groups can we identify, off the top of our heads, that earn $250,000 a year? Entertainers and Athletes. These guys are pulling down millions (OK, not the D-list actors, but you know what I mean). Does giving them a tax break generate more jobs? Does reducing their tax bill by, on average, $15,000 a year, create a new job? Or does it buy another Rolex? Or, on the other side, does increases their taxes by, on average, $23,000, destroy an existing job? They might have to fire their housekeeper or gardener...no, that would mean they would clean their own houses or mow their own yards. Besides, most of the Hollywood types are supporting Obama anyway, so obviously they aren't concerned about the $23,000. Corporate CEOs. Not the guy who incorporates his business and gives himself the title to sound important. We're talking about the big boys from the big corporations. These are the guys running those big banks, mortgage lenders, investment firms, and such that the taxpayers are currently bailing out to the tune of billions of dollars. These are the guys that make the decisions to move jobs overseas, close plants, and fight giving employees a living wage. Will putting an extra $15,000 on average in their pockets suddenly inspire them to move jobs out of China and back to the U.S.? Or will increasing their taxes on average $23,000 help offset some of the economic problems their lack of forethought caused? Health Care professionals and attorneys. While the median doctor income is around $150,000, some earn hundreds of thousands of dollars. Now don't get me wrong, I respect the work these folks do and believe they earn that money. But will giving them a $15,000 tax break create a new job? Marketing/Sales professionals. Though the median income for these folks is around $90,000, those that work for the major firms can pull down MILLIONS! Of course, their income depends on the average American being able to afford to buy the stuff they are marketing. When the economy bottoms out, these guys stand to lose a lot. So will giving them a $15,000 tax credit save their jobs? Or would increasing their tax by $23,000 in order to provide a tax credit to the middle class actually help them make MORE money, because the average American would have more disposable income to spend on Xboxes, clothes, and cars? Investment Brokers and Speculators. Have you seen the chaos on Wall Street lately? Would giving them a $15,000 tax credit fix the problem? Enough said. The Wealthy. The folks who come from "Old Money." Those that inherited money from their families. The select few like Bill Gates that pulled themselves up and launched their own empires. Will giving any of them a tax credit inspire them to do anything they aren't already doing? The wealthy that already give back to the community will continue to do so. The wealthy that do not will continue not to. A tax break is not going to change the behavior of either group. Neither is a tax increase. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Viva la discussion! 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Very interesting Ogre1 when ya look at it like that. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Obama wants to give tax cuts to the bottom 95% of families who file tax returns. Of that 95% only about 40% actually pay income tax. So in essence he's taking away money from the ones making 250,000 a year and giving to the very people that break even every year and don't pay a dime to the IRS. I would still like to see a logical discussion on this point. How is it a tax cut, if you don't pay taxes yet are receiving additional monies back. That isn't a cut, it is redistribution. 

donottreadonme --- 17 years ago -

A discussion for the democrats Aghhhhh not all Democrats voted for Obama. I hope he turns his radical thinking around for the greater good of the USA but his ideas are flawed. It didn't work for Bush, why Obama. Extremist don't make good or great presidents, but 51% of we the people never figure that out every 4 years in November. As for Obama, I am going to give the same advice I was given when Bush got elected. Give him a chance to see if it works. Will Obama be the next Roosevelt :) or the next Carter/Reagan :( 

Empty Nest --- 17 years ago -

90% of the tax code is about redistribution of wealth. Up until now, the redistribution has been at the upper end of the scale. I don't understand this statement. Unless you believe that everything belongs to the government and people should only be allowed to keep the portion the government decides they deserve, then how is income being redistributed from those who pay little or no tax to those who pay the majority of the taxes? By the way, my husband is a corporate tax accountant, so I have some knowledge of how this all works. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

it is redistribution. What did I say above about the tax code, Chunky??? THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT TAXES ARE ABOUT!!! Good Grief. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Unless you believe that everything belongs to the government Well, as the statement doesn't involve EVERYTHING, I think your logic is flawed. The statement involves only the tax code, which deals only with the collection of taxes. I.E. money, in particular, Taxable Income. So, does the government own everything? No. You own your personal property. But you'd be surprised about how much that you THINK you own is only yours by fiat of the government. Take property. DO YOU OWN your real property? Not really. What you have is a right to possessorship with an additional right to survivorship (in most circumstances). What this means is that you can occupy real property, and by doing so you assume all the rights and responsibilities of a property owner and you have the right to pass that property down to your heirs. BUT all real property is technically owned by the government. THUS, imminent domain works. Thus, adverse possession works. Mineral Rights, which is a property right, work pretty much the same way. In fact, the United States is just about the only country where an individual even has a right to the minerals under their land. The only other country is Canada, and theirs is really weird. How about your right to vote? I challenge you to find it in the original Constitution. It's not there. At least not until 1870 when the 15th amendment was ratified. But even it doesn't give people the right to vote, it simply prohibits racial discrimination in voting. It's not until the 17th amendment, ratified in 1913 that people are given, in the Constitution, the right to vote for their Senators!!! Before then, that right, was by FIAT of the government. These are just a few examples of things that people think they "own" that in fact are simply given to them by the government. 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT TAXES ARE ABOUT!!! No, that's not what taxes are about. Taxes are for maintenance and operation of the nation's governmental operations and infrastructure. Increasing the tax load on one segment of society so that a section of society that pays no net income tax can receive a larger refund than what they have already paid in through withholding is redistribution of wealth, and is completely against traditional American values. Sorry that you don't like that reality, Ogre; perhaps you would be happier in some other country... 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

What did I say above about the tax code, Chunky??? THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT TAXES ARE ABOUT!!! Good Grief. How is it redistributing when it is given back to the person who EARNED IT in the first place? Redistribution is when you take from someone and give it to someone else. That is why President-elect Obama's plan is redistribution and the current tax code is not. Do you feel the Government should employ EVERYONE and give us income based upon our value to society? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Taxes are for maintenance and operation of the nation's governmental operations and infrastructure. NO, that's what taxes are USED for. (Ideally...but not always) The tax codes primary purpose is to take money from one source (You and me) and give it to another source (the federal government) which then uses it as it sees fit (REDISTRUBTION). 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

How is it redistributing when it is given back to the person who EARNED IT in the first place? I think you're assuming that all the money taken from you is taxes. It's not. What your taxes come from is not your income, but your TAXABLE income. And usually those two things are not the same. with TI being lower, thus taxes being lower. When you get a refund, you're not getting TAXES back. You're simply getting overpayment back. What is redistribution is when someone takes something from someone else and does something with it, in this case, gives it to a third party...say... Wall Street or Auto Makers. THAT is what the Tax Code is for. It allows the government to redistribute YOUR wealth. As to the other... never thought about that. Not sure it would work. But the benefits would be nice. WHAT I would like is if the government would employ a few people with I.Q.'s over 78 so when you tried to get something done it would actually get done. 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

The tax codes primary purpose is to take money from one source (You and me) and give it to another source (the federal government) which then uses it as it sees fit (REDISTRUBTION). Nice try at twisting the meaning of words to fit your agenda, but you and I both know that that is not the definition of "redistribution of wealth" in this context. I'm not really sure what "redistrubtion" means... 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

THAT is what the Tax Code is for. It allows the government to redistribute YOUR wealth. I do not want the Government to redistribute my wealth. It is mine to determine what to do with. 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

Increasing the tax load on one segment of society so that a section of society that pays no net income tax can receive a larger refund than what they have already paid in through withholding is redistribution of wealth, and is completely against traditional American values. I notice that you conveniently ignored this part of my post... 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

As to the other... never thought about that. Not sure it would work. But the benefits would be nice. WHAT I would like is if the government would employ a few people with I.Q.'s over 78 so when you tried to get something done it would actually get done. So you are saying that current Government employees have IQs below 78 and are non-productive? Hmm, so why would I want to invest more in them? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Well, first, I don't have an "agenda", I just like to fight. And actually, it's the pubs who are twisting the meaning of words to fit their agenda. That's part of the problem with this whole discussion, is that the terminology is wrong. Historically: "Redistribution of wealth" is specific to when assets are seized from one entity and redistributed to another entity in a process to cause economic equality. I.E., you have two cows, the government takes one and gives it to me. THAT is Redistribution of Wealth. It's a hot button phrase used to describe what Communists and Socialists do with money. BUT, up until this election it wasn't used to refer to taxes and what is done with them. Prior to this election, the phrase used was "transferring of wealth." This was used specifically for taxes on unrealized future income. I.E., I earn $10, you earn $8 and the government taxes me $1 and gives it to you. All political and economic systems facilitate the "transferring of wealth" including capitalism, communism and socialism; however the favored method of redistribution varies from system to system. And that's really what people are arguing about, they've just tried to change the term to this hot button term that people associate with commies. As to redistribution, I'd rather my tax money be given to individuals, who may accidentally use it wisely, than to Wall Street or the Auto Makers who haven't shown any penchant for doing so. 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

This was used specifically for taxes on unrealized future income. I.E., I earn $10, you earn $8 and the government taxes me $1 and gives it to you. So explain how that is not what Obama's plan intends to do with this... however the favored method of redistribution varies from system to system. And explain how Obama's plan fits in with the capitalist system and not the socialist one... 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Hmm, so why would I want to invest more in them? Didn't see where we were talking about that, Chunky. I thought we were talking about Redistribution of Wealth. But since you bring it up, I do think you gets what yous pays for. And if you pay someone $8 an hour, you'll get $8 an hour service (meaning bad). But if you pay someone $10 an hour you'll get $10 an hour service. Which, if you haven't ever noticed, is remarkably better. It's the same problem with teachers. I don't know how people become teachers after college... I currently have about $80,000.00 in debt from student loans... I couldn't even begin to pay on those with a teacher's salary! The better you pay someone the better quality of person you get. Up to a point. I think there's an UPPER limit on that as well, but I'm not sure where it is. Thus you wind up with CEO's who SUCK and yet make $10 million a year. Further research is needed. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Ogre1, please check the facts. With benefits, the average U.S. worker makes $24.00 an hour. With benefits, the average U.S. government employee makes $38.00. So you are saying we need to pay our government workers more? They are already making MORE than our private sector employees and producing less. Where is the economic benefit there? Where is the logic in your argument now? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

So explain how that is not what Obama's plan intends to do with this... Never said it wasn't. My argument is simply that people are talking out their butts about how many people this is going to affect. The pubs are coming off with the whole doom and gloom of businesses going under (like they aren't doing so now) when in fact, according to the governments own statistics, on average, NO SMALL BUSINESS earns $250k a year in TAXABLE INCOME. (See above) And in fact, Obama has been talking not about business taxes, but about PERSONAL taxes. And that there are less than 1.5 million people who make more than $250 k in this country. That's about 1/3rd of 1% of the population. And actually, I kind of question that stat... seems like an awful lot of REALLY big homes around here for there to be so few people making that kind of money...but it's a stat from the same government that's bringing you the whining. So who knows. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Chunky, you're getting into an argument that I wasn't making and don't really care about. When did we start talking about raising government employee salaries???? We were talking about redistribution of wealth. And yes, Government bennies rock! Just out of curiosity, where did you get your stats from. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Economic data supplied by the Department of Labor. Simple tables to sort though to do lots of comparisons. A great source for job related data. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Links, Chunky, I want links! And I think the reason for the disparity is the government jobs are top heavy. Have you looked at www.usajobs.com recently? I have, there are more $60,000.00 plus jobs open than there are low end jobs. Government doesn't hire a lot of yard workers, those people are contractors. But the government DOES hire a lot of doctors and lawyers at 70-140k a year. Can't say that for sure, it's just an assumption. 

Empty Nest --- 17 years ago -

As to redistribution, I'd rather my tax money be given to individuals, who may accidentally use it wisely, than to Wall Street or the Auto Makers who haven't shown any penchant for doing so. I fully agree with you here, and also the post in response to my question about not owning property. I get very annoyed when people don't seem to realize that we don't own property as long as someone has the right to tax it or seize it. However, you didn't answer my question. When my husband works and earns good money and pays huge tax bills, how are we getting redistribution from people who don't pay nearly as much tax as we do? 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

Never said it wasn't. My argument is simply that people are talking out their butts about how many people this is going to affect. The pubs are coming off with the whole doom and gloom of businesses going under (like they aren't doing so now) when in fact, according to the governments own statistics, on average, NO SMALL BUSINESS earns $250k a year in TAXABLE INCOME. (See above) And in fact, Obama has been talking not about business taxes, but about PERSONAL taxes. And that there are less than 1.5 million people who make more than $250 k in this country. That's about 1/3rd of 1% of the population. And actually, I kind of question that stat... seems like an awful lot of REALLY big homes around here for there to be so few people making that kind of money...but it's a stat from the same government that's bringing you the whining. So who knows. Nice try at dodging my question to you. Seems like you're the one talking out of its butt... 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

% only about 40% actually pay income tax. So in essence he's taking away money from the ones making 250,000 a year and giving to the very people that break even every year and don't pay a dime to the IRS. Yup U got it! The nut! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

how are we getting redistribution from people who don't pay nearly as much tax as we do? We're not. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Nice try at dodging my question to you. Seems like you're the one talking out of its butt... Not dodging your question. The answer was, Never said it wasn't.  

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Gotta run... hit me with a few more questions if you like, It will be this evening before I get back. Lunch with friends then Geocaching today. You guys have fun. 

Empty Nest --- 17 years ago -

90% of the tax code is about redistribution of wealth. Up until now, the redistribution has been at the upper end of the scale. Ask me about Capital Gains... after I'm done cursing, I'll tell you that the CG tax is custom made for those who make OVER 250k a year. NOT for you and me (assuming you don't make 250k a year) how are we getting redistribution from people who don't pay nearly as much tax as we do? We're not. Ok, so are you retracting those first statements? 

Empty Nest --- 17 years ago -

Lunch with friends then Geocaching today. Sounds like fun! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Ask me about Capital Gains... after I'm done cursing, I'll tell you that the CG tax is custom made for those who make OVER 250k a year. NOT for you and me (assuming you don't make 250k a year) That CG affects me and while I don't mind paying my fair share - never have - U can bet UR bottom dollar I mind supporting lazy, generational welfare recepients who haven't worked a day in their lazy lives, and illegal aliens who are not lawfully entitled to a portion of my sweat in the first place! And I will ALWAYS mind the Gov't believeing they are entitled to half my freakin' income! I WORK FOR THAT MONEY - NOT THE GOV'T! Grrrrrrrr!!!!!! Ahhhh now I feel better 'D 

Empty Nest --- 17 years ago -

And I will ALWAYS mind the Gov't believeing they are entitled to half my freakin' income! I WORK FOR THAT MONEY - NOT THE GOV'T! Grrrrrrrr!!!!!! I hear ya Sassy. I mind ANYONE thinking that they are ENTITLED to anything that's mine. I am generous to those I choose to be with the half the government allows me to keep. 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

Not dodging your question. The answer was, Never said it wasn't. Nope, you're just trying to evade a defense of your position. That's the same as dodging... 

Lord Cheezus --- 17 years ago -

hit me with a few more questions if you like, Why bother? You'll just dance around those as well. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

I hear ya Sassy. I mind ANYONE thinking that they are ENTITLED to anything that's mine. I am generous to those I choose to be with the half the government allows me to keep. And I hear U scoutman...and lol @ being generous with the half the Gov't allows U to keep! I think it's insane to heap more tax upon the heads of those earning above 250,000.00 because these are the one's who hire those that the Gov't seeks to give all the breaks to....don't they understand that if U tax business, especially BIG business, they hire less? The Gov't should give INCENTIVES to big bidnez...do that and watch the hiring frenzy. They don't HAVE to keep their business in the USA to begin with. Look at Nike, but for one example. Me and my dh are not business owners, just lucky enough to have acheived the American Dream and then some - but nobody gave us jack crap.....we worked out tails off, lived below our means, saved more than we spent....and now look....Ten years from retirement and there's threat of taxing our portfolio....and don't even get me started on our 401k.....Grrrrrrrrrr! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground