Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: What is your definition of pro-life?

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 2
CMGs 21
Sandyr9111 2
aunt_dodo 1
Zionist NightOwl 17
BrookleighPhotography 2
Rachel 1
2girlygirls 1
Donkey Hodie 5
ghostpost 1
~sassy~ 4
Dynomite 3
I am me! 1
Perfection 1
PHSMOMOF2 2
photobug 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: What is your definition of pro-life?

This is a take from another thread. What is your definition of prolife?

abortion is wrong, no exceptions Vote
 
 43.9% (29)
abortion is wrong, unless the mother's life is in danger Vote
 
 19.7% (13)
abortion is wrong, unless the mother's life is in danger or in the case of rape or incest. Vote
 
 27.3% (18)
other, please explain Vote
 
 9.1% (6)
CMGs --- 18 years ago -

This is a take from another thread. What is your definition of prolife? 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

abortion is wrong, no exceptions 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

oops double post! 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

abortion is wrong, no exceptions so KM, would you then say that someone who considers abortion to be wrong, except in some cases, is pro-choice? 

I am me! --- 18 years ago -

For me personally it is wrong period. I although can understand if it was a rape baby. My bff has a dd from a rape and while now everything is great for them it was tough for a long time on her. I would have supported her either way she decided. I do not believe in abortions and would NEVER have one but I am not one to push my beliefs off on anyone else. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

abortion is wrong, no exceptions Nuff said! 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

For me personally it is wrong period. I although can understand if it was a rape baby. My bff has a dd from a rape and while now everything is great for them it was tough for a long time on her. I would have supported her either way she decided. I do not believe in abortions and would NEVER have one but I am not one to push my beliefs off on anyone else. so if you were to consider someone pro-life, it would be only if they believed that abortion is wrong, no exceptions? 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

would you then say that someone who considers abortion to be wrong, except in some cases, is pro-choice? isn't that a choice? if you are pro-life 'except....(whatever the exception is)', then that is a CHOICE. I think if you are pro-life that means you believe 100% abortion is wrong with no exceptions. Otherwise, any exception is a choice. (again....I'm weighing in on LOGIC here, not a political statement, not my own views, disclaimer disclaimer, lol) 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

(again....I'm weighing in on LOGIC here, not a political statement, not my own views, disclaimer disclaimer, lol) That's what this poll is, your view! :) 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

abortion is wrong, unless the mother's life is in danger The problem I have with this wording is that the "in danger" has been interpreted so broadly as to include mental anguish as posing a danger to her mental health. If a woman's physical health is in danger, then it is simply a matter of self-defense to save her life. (And self-defense isn't murder.) A doctor works to save both mother and baby if possible. If it isn't possible to continue the pregnancy because the mother's life is at stake, i.e., she will likely DIE if the pregnancy continues, then I don't think anyone would condemn the mother for making a reasonable decision to save her life. I mean, that is pro-life (for her life). 

photobug --- 18 years ago -

So a mother with other children should just die due to a pregnancy and leave her living children motherless? Just wondering why not many are asking that question? 

photobug --- 18 years ago -

So a mother with other children should just die due to a pregnancy and leave her living children motherless? Just wondering why not many are asking that question? 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

NightOwl, I don't know that I can edit it, but I did mean, only to save her life. So, then by your last statement, do you mean that your definition of pro-life, makes the exception of the mother's life? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Yes. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

So a mother with other children should just die due to a pregnancy and leave her living children motherless? Just wondering why not many are asking that question? We can discuss it, but in your opinion, does being pro-life include that scenario? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

CMandG'sMom, I know you can't edit a poll. I wasn't faulting your wording. I'm just saying that historically, that is what has happened. People have used the wording as a loophole. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

Let me clarify, yall know abortion is my big thing....but I admit that to save the life of the mother or perhaps rape, I admit there ought to be exceptions. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I wasn't faulting your wording. I'm just saying that historically, that is what has happened. People have used the wording as a loophole. Oh no, no offense taken, I completely see your reasoning. 

Dynomite --- 18 years ago -

If the Mothers life was at risk, that would be a decision between her and the doctor. The law wouldn't have a say because its between the doctor and the Mother. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

to save the life of the mother or perhaps rape so no incest then? 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

perhaps rape I know several women who have adopted children that came into this world thru a rape situation. Those babies are loved and spoiled beyond belief! 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

The law wouldn't have a say because its between the doctor and the Mother. I'm not asking about the law, I'm asking what you consider to be pro-life. 

photobug --- 18 years ago -

Look I am a labor and delivery nurse and have seen one case where the mother's life was in true danger of death and one other softer case where the mother was loosing so much blood and having multiple transfusions in the early second trimester and chose to abort. Nurses I work with who are very tenured had not seen cases like these. What I am saying is those cases are so few and far between but I do know that individuals believe no abortion in those cases. I just do not understand that. I am so against it but would want to live for my living children, though it would kill me inside. So I was just asking. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

I although can understand if it was a rape baby. My bff has a dd from a rape and while now everything is great for them it was tough for a long time on her. In that situation, I would advocate adoption. In my mind, I would feel that something good came out of something awful rather than enduring the guilt of having an innocent infant suffer the consequences. 

Dynomite --- 18 years ago -

I'm not asking about the law, I'm asking what you consider to be pro-life. I gave you my answer and it stands. What you are asking is if its ok for the law to step in and make abortion legal. NO. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

I know several women who have adopted children that came into this world thru a rape situation. I always thought rape also, until I heard a lady speak who was a successful business owner. Her birth was the result of a gang rape and was given up for adoption. She was selling her business to go out and speak about her experience and how she's not a monster and she was thankful her mother chose life. Changed my beliefs instantly. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

so no incest then? Yes, sorry 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

What you are asking is if its ok for the law to step in and make abortion legal No, I'm asking YOUR personal opinion on what pro-life is, no laws, legal, illegal, or anything. Just your personal opinion. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

I always thought rape also, until I heard a lady speak who was a successful business owner. Her birth was the result of a gang rape and was given up for adoption. She was selling her business to go out and speak about her experience and how she's not a monster and she was thankful her mother chose life. Changed my beliefs instantly. Same here but we can't always get it all...unless mcCain wins, in which case RvW could be over turned in our life time, with exceptions, ofcorse. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

sassygirl - you are entitled to your opinion and I respect that. Understand that unless you are an incest survivor you don't understand what we go through. If I had had to worry about carrying that B*****ds child too - I would have committed suicide. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

Same here but we can't always get it all...unless mcCain wins, in which case RvW could be over turned in our life time, with exceptions, ofcorse. Yes, because McCain believes that abortion is wrong with exceptions to mother's life, rape and incest. 

photobug --- 18 years ago -

My question is since a Republican, Bush, is in office now, why hasnt RvW been overturned? How will McCain be different. Bush is Pro Life. 

Dynomite --- 18 years ago -

If the situation is the Mothers life, this is between the doctor and the Mother. This is not considered abortion or the morning after sex alternative, because women like JDB said, can't keep their britches pulled up. There is no exception or excuse for this. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

why hasnt RvW been overturned? Because the Supreme Court hasn't tipped far enough right yet. 

photobug --- 18 years ago -

I think the most effective way to have an impact on abortion is to reach out to individuals at risk and educate them on what abortion is and does to a woman mentally and physically and also what it does to her unborn baby. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

If the situation is the Mothers life. . . . This is not considered abortion Exactly. It's called abortion because the pregnancy is aborted, but again, self-defense is NOT murder. 

photobug --- 18 years ago -

I am pro life, but I truly think politically it will never be overturned period in our lifetime, or our children's children's lifetime. I think the most effective way is as I stated above. I was pro choice until I became a nurse and had to participate in a pregnancy termination. Education is key. Women who have babies with anomolies are told they need to terminate, are given the worst case cenario and do not even know there is hope. I turned in a letter stating I would not take assignments as those unless the mother's life was in danger of death or if the baby had an anomoly which was incompatible with life outside the womb. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 18 years ago -

Wow, photobug. Good for you! [[[Applause]]] 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

Because the Supreme Court hasn't tipped far enough right yet And because a decent percentage of Republicans are pro-choice, I don't believe it'll ever get voted on. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

If the situation is the Mothers life, this is between the doctor and the Mother. This is not considered abortion or the morning after sex alternative, because women like JDB said, can't keep their britches pulled up. There is no exception or excuse for this. So by that same reasoning, a rape or incest victim should also be able to abort without it being called an abortion? They didn't willingly pull their britches down either... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground