Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Holding a child back in school

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Jen 1
ollie 1
mand1994 1
ms_mm 1
MissT 1
JDTTT 4
cmi 1
Fallon 1
Stephanie 2
Loni 1
I Love Horses 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

Hello, i have a question!
My son is in kindergarden and his teacher wants to hold him back a grade, because he does not know how to write story's or essay's and he needs to know this before going into 1st grade, is it me or does that seem like alot for a kindergardener or 1st grader to do, he already has 10 spelling words a week that he has to study and get tested on every friday and he has to write a in detail story about the picture for the week (and the parents are not allowed to help at all) iam just wondering if i should hold him back a grade or let him go to the 1st grade and just work on his story comprehension over the summer. Any opinions on this is appreciated. Thanks 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

Also my son was not allowed to go to pre-k because we are not in the low income bracket, so i had to rely on my sitter to teach him the basic's because i worked from 7-7 mon-sat and did not have the time to do it myself. well she sat on her lazy butt and did nothing, so now iam a stay at home mom so that the same thing does not happen to my 1 year old. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

they move so fast now a days.. I've heard of holding boys back becuase of there maturity level.. Its hard to say, you dont want him to struggle but you hate to hold him back.... The only advice I can give is its much easier on the kid to be held back early on then later when he has lots of friends and realizes hes not moving on with them....
Ask you pediatrician what she thinks sometimes they can help 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

I waited until my son was in the 2nd grade and he was just so far behind so we held him back then... My advice is to listen to the teacher and do it when they are young rather than when they get older. Boys a lot of time really do need the extra year. There's nothing wrong with it. 

mand1994 --- 20 years ago -

When is his b-day? Is he a younger kindergartener? It may be better for him to get an extra year of help in. I agree with Loni. I'd ask your pediatrician what they think. 

JDTTT --- 20 years ago -

My kindergartner was born in late July. We talked early with the teacher about holding him back. The approach we took was to step up the reading and the writing (only in fun ways, no "work" for a kindergartner). He was able to progress enough that he will not be held back and is going into the Spanish Immersion program. He does not write very well yet. He is reading pretty well, but he still writes numbers and letters backwards. His comprehension is weak too (too much imagination I think). It might sound as if my childs school is not as concerned, but I think the opposite is true. They actually watched my son very carefully and put in a lot of extra time and energy on their time (in addition to the extra effort from my wife and I) to help him get where he needs to be.

What school are you guys going to? It is such a tough call because there are pros and cons no matter what you decide. Thank goodness it is your choice to make though...you'll make the right one since no one else loves your child as much as you do, right?

Stephanie is right though...if you are likely to do it, do it early when the peer concerns aren't ripe.

Good Luck to you! 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

Nothing wrong with holding him back at this age. I've always believed it better to be the smartest one in the class than the one that struggles all year long!
He will make new friends quickly and probably not ever remember. 

Stephanie --- 20 years ago -

JDTTT - if your teachers put a lot of extra time in to your son it sounds as if they wouldn't steer you wrong. My older son was attending New Caney in Kindergarten and First grade and then we moved to the galleria area where he attended Briargrove and that's when we noticed how far behind he was. He was actually failing but the teacher and I agreed to tell my son that we were holding him back to give him more time - she even gave him an award at the end of the year for the student who tried the hardest. By 2nd grade he was already aware of passing/failing. I don't want to sway you either way - but to know that it's ok if you do it. A lot of parents do. My son was also premature and was diagnosed with ADD a couple of years ago. They think his being premature may have had something to do with his slower development although even though we tested him for every kind of learning disability we could, he always aced those tests, so go figure.... Every child is different and talking to the pediatrician might be a good avenue too. At least when you've made your decision it will be an informed one. 

cmi --- 20 years ago -

Kindergarten is the best time to do it if you are going to. Do they really write essays coming out of Kindergarten? 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

My son turned 5 in august of last year! We were in the new caney school but we moved and now he is in klein school district and they are very competative, and want to be ahead of everyone else. 

JDTTT --- 20 years ago -

Thanks Stephanie. We were very pleased with Bear Branch. My son will be going to first grade next year, but I have to tell you, nothing has torn at my heart strings like analyzing this situation and making this decision. The easy part is knowing that my son is the spitting image of myself, inside and out. He'll probably drag a little in maturity, but I think he'll be ok. What a tough thing to deal with though! 

ms_mm --- 20 years ago -

The district should have a list of benchmarks by grade level and subject posted on the Internet. Or you can look at the TEKS on the state site: http://www.tea.state.tx.us/teks/index.html (also by grade and subject).

Look at these and see what is expect of a student in each grade - this should help you decide if a child is ready for the next grade level. 

Jen --- 20 years ago -

Angela,
I understand from a friend that liveds in Klein, that the school district there, offers you a test, to determine if your child may be ready to start or not. Her son was 5 August of 1994. She was concerned he was not mature enough to start....after she performed the school districts test to see if he was ready, she found he was still to immature. She held him back and did not let him start Kindergarten til the next year. Chances are your son may have been to young to start. See if they still offer this. If so, how does he do? If needed, better to hold him back now, than we he is older. Klein ISD is a very hard driven school district. As you say, competitive. (I grew up in it, as well). Good luck! 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

Thank youguys for all your input, i think i will probably hold him back as i dont want him to feel overwellmed with the 1st grade. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Klein like Humble ISD is very competitive, so if they think he should be held back, do it now. We really felt our son was ready to start K last year but he missed the cut off. It turned out to be a great thing. He is at the top of his class this year, and is a leader. He helps other children with their work, and this has given him a lot of confidence. Reading came easy and writting has too. Now he is looking forward to 1st grade. So why not hold him back and let him breeze thru school instead of struggle. Less stress all around, but it is a hard decision. 

Carla --- 20 years ago -

Angela,

Things are definitely different now as far as expectations in kindergarten. I remember being a little stunned at the orientation after the teacher told us what they would be learning.

In my daughter's class at WHE, they've been doing journals in their "writer's workshop" since I think the first week of school. They've gradually been learning how to spell the words rather than just write the sounds and working on sentence structure.

I think that it is pretty common for boys to have struggle with writing at a young age. I've talked to moms of several little boys that my daughter went to preschool with that are doing well in other areas but have a hard time with the writing.

JDTTT,

I really wanted my daughter to go into the Spanish Immersion program, but I heard that were more applicants just from Bear Branch than they had spots for this year, so it's not happening.

If she had got in, I picked out a couple of home school English courses to do at home so that she didn't fall behind. So instead, I'm going to get a Spanish course designed for kids and we'll do our own little immersion program at home. 

JDTTT --- 20 years ago -

Carla -- one person applied that didn't get in. My understanding is that Pine Forest has plenty of openings though. If you go to Pine Forest, you have to make the five year committment to their school. In my opinion, it would be well worth it. My daughter is fluent in reading, writing and speaking and it is a tremendous advantage. She fell behind in English for a short time and her spelling still reflects some language mixture, but without a doubt it is a great program. It does take some hard work and dedication though.

Good Luck! 

ollie --- 20 years ago -

JDTT,

I guess my daughter was the one who didn't get into the spanish inmersion program at Bear Branch. Do you know by any chance who to talk to at Pine Forest so I can see if she could join the program there ? 

JDTTT --- 20 years ago -

I don't know who to talk to at Pine Forest, but Miss Thrower should be able to help you. The sad part is that the attrition rate is still pretty high. I can't remember how many exactly, but several students drop out. To me it is a shame not to expand the program. I am sorry to hear about your daughter. If it is any consolation, many of the kids getting in are allowed because we had older children in the program. We were told in the beginning that our younger siblings would be allowed in as well. Makes sense to me because I am not going to do the program if only one or two of my children can participate....all or none from us. Not like band or sports where the kids can choose at our house....good luck to you Ollie. If you can't reach Ms. Thrower or need help finding the information, I am sure that my very organized wife has all of the contact information for Pine Forest too. I can get it when I get home. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground