Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Marcusa!

who's talking here?

JDTTT 1
Fallon 2
marcusa 7
bbjones 7
Anderson 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JDTTT --- 20 years ago -

Marcusa -- Where does the U.S. get its oil? What percentage of our usage do we get from whom? How much do we produce domestically? I know we are all aware of the constraints facing US refineries and exploration.

Do you know what would happen if every single SUV in America was exchanged for a hybrid?

Do you know how much oil there is in America, excluding Alaska? How much is under Colorado?

Do you know how poorly the Palestinians are doing now without Western aid?

I appreciate your passion, but you are simply being fed the liberal line. You seem to have taken it a little further as well. Why did you come to this county if you so despise our actions? Why is it that you think I should be concerned whatsoever with what OBL says? His actions speak louder, wouldn't you agree? Sadaam wasn't a threat? No WMD's? Not even the liberal politicians believe that there were none or that there aren't. Not many of them are willing to say (with conviction) that they never existed and that they won't be found in Iraq.

Your world sounds great theoretically...unfortunately, there is no basis in reality. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

JDTTT, "Do you know how poorly the Palestinians are doing now without Western aid? "

I was just reading today that they are doing pretty badly....and yet they have the nerve to act like we're "stealing" money from them!! PLEASE.....it's our money! 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

JDTTT

In order:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Imported_Crude_Oil_as_a_Percent_of_ US_Consumption_1950-2003.jpg

We can't exchange all vehicles overnight. And even though it would reduce usage, it realistically wouldn't even cut it by more than half, assuming hybrid technology improves. Hybrids are nice, and some are really fuel efficient (Prius, Escape/Mariner, Civic) but they aren't the solution.

The oil in Colorado is trapped in shale. I learned in geology that shale holds water but does not let go of it. Same goes for oil. And even if we could efficiently extract it, the amount of oil in shale around the world is equivalent to current reserves, and thus also very much subject to depletion.

They're doing horrible, we will soon have a humanitarian crisis there. If we don't start helping they'll start killing more.


"Why did you come to this county if you so despise our actions?" well, I did like Williamson county in Austin better...

"Why is it that you think I should be concerned whatsoever with what OBL says?" He talked a lot before he acted. He also told us his plans, unfortunately nobody was really listening. OBL is some self-appointed protector of his peoples nut. But there's also some truth to what he says. Otherwise, nobody would listen to him. Hitler and Mussolini rose to power because the French and British got greedy after WWI and broke the Germans and ignored their allies in Italy. If we would've realized the truth to some of what Hitler said before he was anywhere close to being in power and having half his country saluting him we would have not had an issue. Then we could've fixed the major problems and when everyone was happy taken out the nut if need be. History has shown, as long as everyone is happy nothing happens. During the boom in the late 20's in Germany people ignored him because times were good, but when it all crashed he came back full force and got into power.

I think if WMD's exited SH would have used them against the U.S. army. He probably had some chemical stuff (to gas those pesky Kurds) but I doubt he had nuclear or biological, or any quantity of chemical weapons that posed any risk in the open air. After all, if you want to make chemical weapons, all it takes is a trip to Wal-Mart, problem is you'll need to deploy it in a building or other enclosed space.


The U.S. Constitution and Enlightened ideals sounded great theoretically, and although they aren't flawless they work pretty darn good. I believe the average person anywhere rarely ever wants a war, only their leaders do. keep in mind, there's some family not much unlike yours sitting in Iran who voted for the other guy and who doesn't want their house, work and schools bombed. Plus it kind of sucks when you know you're going to lose. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

Not all of the oil in Colorado is shale oil.

The US Office of Naval Petroleum and Oil Shale Reserves estimates that there are approximately 1.6 trillion barrels of oil contained in oil shales around the world, with 60–70% of the reserves (1.0–1.2 trillion barrels) in the United States. We have had the ability to effectively extract the oil from shale since the early 1960's although it is not economically feasible for companies unless crude oil prices are at $40 per barrel or above. Estonia, Russia, Brazil, and China currently mine oil shale.

You wrote "I think if WMD's exited (sp? existed) SH would have used them against the U.S. army. He probably had some chemical stuff (to gas those pesky Kurds) but I doubt he had nuclear or biological, or any quantity of chemical weapons that posed any risk in the open air."

Sadaam had WMD's during the first Gulf War (everything but nuclear) in large quantities and DID NOT use them. Here is a news article explaining why we have not found large stockpiles of WMD's this time.

"06 January, 2004

AFP

Nizar Nayuf (Nayyouf-Nayyuf), a Syrian journalist who recently defected from Syria to Western Europe and is known for bravely challenging the Syrian regime, said in a letter Monday, January 5, to Dutch newspaper “De Telegraaf,” that he knows the three sites where Iraq's Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD) are kept. The storage places are:

1- Tunnels dug under the town of al-Baida near the city of Hama in northern Syria. These tunnels are an integral part of an underground factory, built by the North Koreans, for producing Syrian Scud missiles. Iraqi chemical weapons and long-range missiles are stored in these tunnels.

2- The village of Tal Snan, north of the town of Salamija, where there is a big Syrian air force camp. Vital parts of Iraq's WMD are stored there.

3-. The city of Sjinsjar on the Syrian border with the Lebanon, south of Homs city.

Nayouf writes that the transfer of Iraqi WMD to Syria was organized by the commanders of Saddam Hussein's Special Republican Guard, including General Shalish, with the help of Assif Shoakat , Bashar Assad's cousin. Shoakat is the CEO of Bhaha, an import/export company owned by the Assad family."

Why doesn't the liberal media make this page one news?

You wrote "I believe the average person anywhere rarely ever wants a war, only their leaders do."

Another back handed slap at President Bush? What makes you think that President Bush likes going to war? What is your proof? He gave Sadaam every opportunity to avoid war or did you forget that?

You wrote "keep in mind, there's some family not much unlike yours sitting in Iran who voted for the other guy and who doesn't want their house, work and schools bombed." Iran does not have a republic or democratic type of country that allows them to vote. If they truly believe that their leaders are wrong, then they could revolt. Since they do not, then they are in effect passively agreeing with their leaders.

I just can not understand why the liberals in this country want to destroy it? 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

So you want to tell me the administration knew about WMD's during the war (and yet renamed the war several times and stopped mentioning WMD's) knew where they were moving (not that all our intelligence and spy satellites wouldn't have picked up such a movement) and yet failed to act on it, allowing it all to be moved to an equally dangerous country? Then it said nothing more? How is this fighting the war on terror? Nobody is stopping the Republicans at this point, they have majority control of all 3 branches of government!


"I believe the average person anywhere rarely ever wants a war, only their leaders do" was not aimed at any politician in particular but as a whole. Can you think of any war (besides to some extent WWII, which was really a continuation of WWI) where the people were urging rather than the other way around? It's much easier to be for it if it's far away and neither you nor anyone close is going. I come from a family with distinct military service, which is also a family of pacifists.

As far as "He gave Sadaam every opportunity to avoid war or did you forget that?" I ask one thing. Why didn't he accept the duel? worst case scenario there would be only one US casualty and we wouldn't get Iraq. And face it, the odds were for him. He's younger, in much better shape, and with quicker refelxes, not to mention he'd have a lot more people cheering for him. Was he "too good" to die? Was he not willing to risk his life? I think this is how all future wars should be. Either that or put an equal and well-matched number of leaders + cabinet members, etc into a sort of war game, last ones standing alive win. Or just play some massive capture the flag. Why do people have to be killed and cities leveled at a cost of millions?

Read "All Quiet on the Western Front" and specifically for Iran watch the movie "Children of Heaven" Maybe that'll stir up some compassion.

Also, Iranians do vote, and their election if I remember correctly was overseen by the UN, something Bush would not allow. I wonder why. Don't believe me, read up on it at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran#Politics

They don't want to destroy it. They disagree with the leader. Nothing could be more patriotic than to question one's government, I'm sure you questioned every last thing Clinton did. And that doesn't explain the unbalance between Democrats who served and Republicans who served, or the fact that out of 12 Iraq/Afghanistan veterans running 10 are Democrats. They must be from the same America hating breed as all those Generals who are criticizing the administration, since the administration is more infallible then the Pope himself apparently. And let's not forget, this country was founded by liberals and follows the tradition of western liberalism. If it were up to conservatives we'd be celebrating the Queen's 80th. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

Your ramblings are worthless because your facts are skewed.

The WMD's were moved before the war.

Saddam did not challange President Bush to a duel, he challanged him to a debate. Probably in an attempt to buy more time to move his WMD's.

You wrote "Also, Iranians do vote, and their election if I remember correctly was overseen by the UN, something Bush would not allow. I wonder why. Don't believe me, read up on it at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran#Politics "

Quoted from your own reference

"The political system of the Islamic Republic is based on the 1979 Constitution called the "Qanun-e Asasi" ("Fundamental Law"). The system comprises several intricately connected governing bodies, most of which are appointed."

MOST OF WHICH ARE APPOINTED!

You wrote "Nothing could be more patriotic than to question one's government".

That is a false definition of patriotic adopted by liberals who despise everything this country stands for. To be patriotic is to be loyal to your country.

This country was founded by conservatives not liberals. The country was founded based on morals which liberals have a problem with and have been trying to destroy for many years. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

If this country was founded by liberals, there would not be the mention of God as prevalent as it is. Obviously you need to read a book or two on the founding fathers, they were not even close to a liberal. The founding fathers had facinating lives go to the library and check out a few books, you will be truly astounded as to what these men believed, and how brave they were. George Washington, truly believed God was on his side, he thought it was ordained by a higher power that the US win against Great Britian. 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

bbjones

He did challenge him to a duel. http://archives.cnn.com/2002/WORLD/meast/10/03/iraq.bush.duel/

Do you want me to find an article on it from FOX News as well?


It doesn't matter that most of their government is appointed, they still vote. Senators were appointed up until recently in the U.S.

If "To be patriotic is to be loyal to your country" then the Founding Fathers were extremely unpatriotic, much like "liberals who despise everything this country stands for" How dare they question King George?

You want to know what conservatives and the British did to the 56 men who signed the Declaration of Independence? Five signers were captured by the British as traitors, and tortured before they died. Twelve had their homes ransacked and burned. Two lost their sons serving in the Revolutionary Army; another had two sons captured. Nine of the 56 fought and died from wounds or hardships of the Revolutionary War. They signed and they pledged their lives, their fortunes, and their sacred honor.

And look how radical those that stand against the current George look:

"Any people that would give up liberty for a little temporary safety deserves neither liberty nor safety." Benjamin Franklin

"The citizens of the U.S. are responsible for the greatest trust ever confided to a political society"

"We base all our experiments on the capacity of mankind for self-government." James Madison

"Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God." Thomas Jefferson

"Government is not reason; it is not eloquence. It is force. And force, like fire, is a dangerous servant and a fearful master." George Washington

Look at what Madison said, YOU are responsible. That means YOU have to hold government accountable and YOU are accountable for government. 

Fallon --- 20 years ago -

Thanks marcusa, you just made our argument for us!

By the way, the democratic party was against the civil rights movement, and it was the republican party, the party of Lincoln, that ended slavery! 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

Fallon

"Obviously you need to read a book or two on the founding fathers, they were not even close to a liberal."

Oh really. Let's walk through this.

1) Let's look at the etymology of the word. Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin liberalis suitable for a freeman, generous, from liber free; perhaps akin to Old English lEodan to grow, Greek eleutheros free

So to be liberal is to be free.


2) The U.S. government is based upon Enlightened Ideals. More specifically John Locke. he argued "government could only be legitimate if it received the consent of the governed and protected the natural rights of life, liberty, and estate. (where have I heard something similar to this?)If such consent was not given, argued Locke, citizens had a right of rebellion"

"He is widely regarded as one of the most influential Enlightenment thinkers and contributors to liberal theory. His writings, along with those of the writings of many Scottish Enlightenment thinkers, influenced the American revolutionaries as reflected in the American Declaration of Independence."

3) The Enlightened Age "led to the rise of capitalism and the birth of socialism, liberalism and fascism."

"The intellectual leaders of this movement...regarded their purpose as leading the world toward progress and out of a long period of doubtful tradition, full of irrationality, superstition, and tyranny. This movement also provided a framework for the American and French Revolution..."

4) And finally, let's extensively define liberalism:

"Liberalism is an ideology, philosophy, and political tradition which holds liberty as the primary political value...liberalism seeks a society characterized by freedom of thought for individuals, limitations on power, especially of government and religion, the rule of law, the free exchange of ideas, a market economy that supports private enterprise, and a transparent system of government...Fundamental human rights that all liberals support include the right to life, liberty, and property...Liberalism has it roots in the Western Enlightenment"

Fallon, it looks like it is you that need to read up on the fascinating lives of the Founding Fathers instead of listening to Rush Limbaugh, Michael Savage, Bill O'Reilly, or the current (or any) administration's version of it. The Library of Congress online has several original letters, documents, etc you can view on your computer.

Note: Definitions are from the Webster dictionary and quotes are from Wikipedia, and none came from disputed articles. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

If you read your own reference, the duel statement was made by "Iraqi Vice President Taha Yassin Ramadan in an interview with Abu Dhabi television that was also broadcast by CNN." Saddam never had the guts to say that himself.

Only some men vote. "The Supreme Leader is elected by the Assembly of Experts (86 men), on the basis of his qualifications and the high popular esteem in which they are held"

Go back and study history. The USA was not part of Britain. It was only property that was claimed by Britain. The people living in the colonies had no voting rights. Many were exiled (meaning no longer accepted as British citizens) to the colonies and were like indentured servants. They were not unpatriotic to Britain because they were not considered part of Britain. Also, under Biblical standards, Kingdoms were not a conservative standard. God (Father of conservatism) never wanted man to be ruled by kings.

Your definition of liberal and liberalism is skewed. Liberal is defined as "Not limited to or by established, traditional, orthodox, or authoritarian attitudes, views, or dogmas". In other words, to go against the established morals.

Based on what is considered "far right wing conservative" today, those who call Bush and republicans "right wing extremists" would have to call the founding fathers Nazis.

Why? Because the founding fathers were so incredibly far right by today's political standards, that they would be shunned as outcasts and freaks. Look at the Constitution that they themselves created, which has been interpreted to mean hardly anything by activist judges.

Using George Mason's "Virginia Rights of Man" as part of their basis, they came up with the Declaration of Independence that said "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. --That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,"

Right in that text they said "Governments are instituted among men, "deriving their powers from the consent of the governed"

Then right in the tenth amendment they say "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

Nowadays, it is the other way around. We go to government to ask their permission to see if we can do something. The Federal government holds states at their mercy by witholding federal funds if they don't comply with that they say is right. Federal judges overstep their jurisdiction and remove an elected judge from the bench in Alabama because of what they thought was right. That would be like me coming into your house and spanking your kid because he didn't eat his peas the way I thought was right. I have no power to do that, and neither does the federal judiciary, yet they regulary ignore the Constitution that governs our political system.

Basically, what the founding fathers designed has been shot to pieces and is pretty much ignored nowadays, save a few select amendments (like the first, etc..) that is convenient for people. Nowadays liberals say that the First Amendment has virtually no limitations on it (child pornography is protected, etc...) yet the second amendment limits you to only "approved" arms that they think is ok. Washington, Jefferson, and the other designers of our nation would be appaled, as are the "right wing extremists" speaking up today. So I guess there's your answer, they'd be "right wing extremists" (although they'd be CORRECT... that should tell us something, that maybe these "right wing extremists" are really just people who believe in what the country was founded on).


From the establishment of our Nation onwards, conservatives are those that wish to preserve (or slowly change) the ideals and principles put forth by the Founders and embodied by the Charter of this great country. Liberals are those that wish to significantly change that which has been established, to varying degrees. 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

"the duel statement was made by "

I'm sure the vice-president would be willing to make such a statement under Saddam's rule. What could Saddam do? Face it, I'm sure if you overstepped under Saddam you were taken out back and shot. Just another example of nitpicking. Not that it matters, bush said no. Do you think he would've said yes had Saddam asked himself? No, he considers himself much too precious to risk his own life.


"Only some men vote"

If you would have read you would see the President and Supreme Leader are not the same in Iranian government. And lots of western countries still have leaders appointed by elected officials.


"The USA was not part of Britain. It was only property that was claimed by Britain"

It was...A British Colony? Occupied by the British, paying taxes to the British, subject to whatever King George said, and fought over long and hard by the British? Plus you're nitpicking into facts that do not change the meaning of the message, the Founding Fathers rebelled against the establishment.

"God (Father of conservatism)"

God is above politics. I know the GOP wants you to think otherwise but if you read the Bible you'll know that His Kingdom is not of this earth as well as "to give Caesar what is Caesar's" Jesus did not politic like humans do, that's why He was killed, He told it just like it was.




"Your definition of liberal and liberalism is skewed"

Take it up with Mr. Webster and Dispute the Wikipedia article. That is not my definition.

"Look at the Constitution that they themselves created"

Read what I wrote to Fallon. The self-evident truths are based on Locke/Enlightenment, which in turn is the origin of liberalism. Or are you going to ignore historical fact? Seriously, I hope you posted that without reading what I wrote, otherwise your mind is so warped you refuse to see the facts in front of you.

"Using George Mason's "Virginia Rights of Man" as part of their basis"

Other then naming it wrong (it's Virginia Declaration of Rights) and assigning the wrong author (Jefferson) you just decided it was convenient once again to leave John Locke out of it. Furthermore you confused the Bill of Rights (what George Mason is considered the father of) with the Declaration of Independence, whose draft was written by Jefferson with minor changes by Franklin and Adams. Jefferson was in turn very Enlightened and the phrasing is almost a carbon copy of what Locke says. Once again read what I wrote to Fallon for more details.

"deriving their powers from the consent of the governed"

So since we're the ones giving government their powers, should we not question their every action and doesn't that make us accountable? Given Bush's ratings, the consent of the governed right now is pretty low.


"Federal judges overstep their jurisdiction and remove an elected judge from the bench in Alabama"

In a majority Conservative Court. The exact same Court that overruled what Florida said and stopped the recount, appointing the president. I don't care who wins what, every last vote should count, otherwise you've completely undermined democracy.

Respond once you have solid facts that address te issue, not minor inconsequential points. Seriously, if this was a term paper you'd fail, no matter what political leaning the professor (not that it matters). It's mostly opinion, cites no sources, and is in direct contradiciton to known and proven facts. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

Again your facts are skewed. President Bush did not say no, he did not respond to the ridiculous statement.

If you would read your own article you would see that "The political system of the Islamic Republic is based on the 1979 Constitution called the "Qanun-e Asasi" ("Fundamental Law"). The system comprises several intricately connected governing bodies, MOST of which are appointed."

Also,

"The Supreme Leader of Iran is responsible for the delineation and supervision of "the general policies of the Islamic Republic of Iran". The Supreme Leader is Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces and controls the military intelligence and security operations; he alone can declare war. He has the power to appoint and dismiss the heads of the judiciary, the state radio and television networks, and the commanders of the police and military forces. He also appoints six of the twelve members of the Council of Guardians."

He is the person that we would have to be concerned with. The President is basically a figurehead like the Queen of England.

You wrote "It was...A British Colony? Occupied by the British, paying taxes to the British, subject to whatever King George said, and fought over long and hard by the British? Plus you're nitpicking into facts that do not change the meaning of the message, the Founding Fathers rebelled against the establishment."

I was not nitpicking, and I stand by what I wrote. A definition (Webster's) of loyal is "faithful in allegiance to one's lawful sovereign or government". The founding father's did not recognize the King as their lawful government.

What I wrote as a definition of liberal is directly from Webster's "Not limited to or by established, traditional, orthodox, or authoritarian attitudes, views, or dogmas". Another definition of liberal from Webster's is "Free to excess; regardless of law or moral restraint; licentious."

Licentious is defined as (Webster's):

"1. lacking legal or moral restraints; especially : disregarding sexual restraints
2 : marked by disregard for strict rules of correctness"


Again you can not comprehend the English language. Conservatism is defined as "a political or theological orientation advocating the preservation of the best in society and opposing radical changes". Conservatism began with God because He gave us the initial laws to live by.

I did not confuse anything. I did not see your post to Fallon, because I was composing my post to you. However, to say that the "phrasing is almost a carbon copy of what Locke says" is a stretch of the truth because only one phrase was similar.


From Wikipedia (which you like to quote) :

"The Virginia Declaration of Rights was a document proclaiming that individual natural rights are inherent, and calling for American independence from Britain. It was adopted unanimously by the Virginia Convention of Delegates (Jefferson was a member) on June 12, 1776, and influenced a number of later documents, including the United States Declaration of Independence (1776), the United States Bill of Rights (1789), and the French Revolution's Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789).

It was initially drafted by George Mason ca. May 20-26, 1776, and later amended by Thomas Ludwell Lee and the Convention."

John Locke was dead when the U.S. government was formed. Locke may have had some influence on some of the writers, but Mason's actual document, adopted unanimously by the Virginia Convention of Delegates on June 12, 1776, was actually used as a basis.


You wrote "So since we're the ones giving government their powers, should we not question their every action and doesn't that make us accountable? Given Bush's ratings, the consent of the governed right now is pretty low."

To base a statement on polls (which is of course how Clinton based his decisions) is indeed silly. Polls can be skewed so that the answers fit the poller's agenda. They do this by wording the question to get the response that they want. THE CONSENT OF THE GOVERNED IS DERIVED FROM THE RESULTS OF ELECTIONS - NOT POLLS.

I believe that it is you who do not have the facts. You wrote "The exact same Court that overruled what Florida said and stopped the recount, appointing the president."

The Supreme Court did not even hear (they declined) the case of the judge in Alabama. So how could it be the exact same court.

You wrote "I don't care who wins what, every last vote should count, otherwise you've completely undermined democracy."

Following the election, recounts conducted by various United States news media organizations indicated that Bush would have won the probable recount method favored by Gore (in his argument before the Supreme court) at the time of the Supreme Court decision. Of course you forgot to mention the illegal votes cast for Gore thru multiple votes by one person, votes from dead people, votes from felons, etc. in your undermining of democracy statement.

My facts are solid. You use more opinion and take more things out of context. What known and proven facts have you cited? Some rantings of liberal professors? I was not writing a term paper so I did not feel it necessary to footnote dictionary definitions designated by quotation marks. However, in all of my years of schooling (two college degrees), I never once received a grade lower than an A in my English classes which included the writing of many term papers. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

I believe that you need to read and understand the Bible. I do not know why you wrote "to give Caesar what is Caesar's" as a reason to show that God was not the maker of conservative values. Also, Jesus was not killed because he did not like politics. Again, you do not understand what the Bible is saying.

During his life Jesus told people they should expect him to be put to death . It was God's plan. Jesus told his followers that he had come on a rescue mission. A mission to liberate men women and children from the terrible dilemma of wrongdoing, of sin.

Yes the Romans, the mob, and the Jewish leaders were treacherous, but the most alarming fact is that our own treachery put Him on the cross.


You quoted from Luke 20:19-26 "to give Caesar what is Caesar's" which is Jesus' response to a very political question.

The goal of the Pharisees is to get Jesus tried under the jurisdiction (Greek arche) and authority (Greek exousia) of the Roman governor, Pontius Pilate, the only ruler in Jerusalem who has the authority to exercise the death penalty. They want him arrested, but need a provocation because the people as a whole support Jesus.

Therefore the trick question:

"Is it right for us to pay taxes to Caesar or not?" (Luke 20:22)

If Jesus agrees that Roman taxation is right, then perhaps they can turn public opinion against Jesus with the same vehemence with which tax collectors are hated. But if, as they suspect, Jesus secretly despises the Romans' right to occupy Israel and place burdensome taxes on its citizens, perhaps they can get him to say something that can be construed as rebellion against Rome. Perhaps they can paint Jesus as a Zealot, one who fights to free Israel from Roman domination. It is a trick question, all right!

Notice how Jesus answers their trick question with a question?

"He saw through their duplicity and said to them, 'Show me a denarius. Whose portrait and inscription are on it?'
'Caesar's,' they replied.
He said to them, 'Then give to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's.' " (Luke 20:23-25)

The head tax must be paid with a denarius, the very coin Jesus asks his opponents to show him. That they have the coin indicates that they should have already known the answer. That they would even be holding such a coin was ironic, since it bore an inscription that the Jews considered blasphemous: "Tiberius Caesar, son of the deified Augustus, Augustus" and on the obverse an image of the emperor's mother Livia as an incarnation of the goddess Pax (peace), with the words "High Priest."

Jesus is saying: If the coinage bears Caesar's image, then it indicates that Caesar is the ruler who should be submitted to in paying taxes. But Jesus continues, "And [give] to God what is God's." There is the implied question to the Pharisees, whose image do you bear? The image of God, all Jews would acknowledge (Genesis 1:27). Then, Jesus is saying, with your bodies, minds, and spirits, you yourselves, you owe allegiance to God himself.

2000 years ago Rome and Caesar laid claim to everything. Every person and horse and dollar in the entire Roman world belonged to Caesar. So, when Jesus said "Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s" the really important point is that he was saying there are some things Caesar does not own! (In effect, God's owns everything because He created everything and He can destroy everything)

Also, the Jews were an occupied people. (Similar to the colonists) They were allowed to keep some of their customs and traditions, but Rome laid claim to owning Israel and Jerusalem and the Temple. So, when Jesus said "Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s" the really important point is that he was saying that the Romans may occupy our city, but they can never own our hearts." 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

I always took it to also mean that, although our leaders should rule by God's Rule and our laws should reflect His, that any leader that claims to be running on the side of God and Jesus is blaspheming, because you're saying that something imperfect and of this earth and all bad actions to be what He would do. It's hard to put into words but let's put it this way:

Firstly, your faith is to be kept for yourself, not dislayed blatantly out in public.

Secondly, you're human and will sin, you cannot claim to be on God's side or you blaspheme. Even if you don't realize and genuinly try to run the best governmnet, you're just human.

And lastly, if God is blatantly put into the political cycle, we ca end up extremist just like during the middle ages or what we see in Iran right now, because the people don't think they can be wrong.

10 Commandments in court: OK. Judge judging by the Bible: Not OK. Leaders who ensure our laws are moral (i.e. Banning Abortion): OK. Rulers who "act" and display prominently their faith ("we must save God's children"): not OK. Keep it to yourself or it does not count. I think the "Christian" leader should be identifiable by his actions in government, not his words.


BTW, did you read up on the Enlightenment and Liberalism? 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

What you just wrote makes no sense.

You wrote "Firstly, your faith is to be kept for yourself, not dislayed blatantly out in public." Who says that. Not God!

And he said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature. (Mark 16:15)


You wrote "Secondly, you're human and will sin, you cannot claim to be on God's side or you blaspheme."

Blasphemy is defined as "1 a : the act of insulting or showing contempt or lack of reverence for God b : the act of claiming the attributes of deity" For a leader to say that they are using God's Word as a means for making their decisions is a) showing reverence for God's Word (NOT blasphemy) and b) not saying that any "bad" action is what God would do. The Bible tells people what God would do!

Not accepting God's son Jesus as our Lord and Savior IS blasphemy because you are showing contempt for God by not believing Him through His Word.

You wrote "And lastly, if God is blatantly put into the political cycle, we ca end up extremist just like during the middle ages or what we see in Iran right now, because the people don't think they can be wrong."

That is ridiculous. Man can not put God into the political cycle. Man has no power over God. If you mean that God's ideals and morals should not be interjected into the political fray because it makes him an extremist, I would have to say that it is the lack of those morals that makes men extremists. If mankind would follow God's Word as written without interjection of their own interpretations and opinions, then there would be no extremists.

Your last paragraph makes no sense. Who said it was not OK for a judge to "judge by the Bible". Who said " Rulers who "act" and display prominently their faith ("we must save God's children"): not OK." WHAT ARE YOU TRYING TO SAY? Who says someone must keep it to themselves? A Christian leader should be identifiable by both his words and actions - not one or the other.

Yes, I did "read up on the Enlightenment and Liberalism" and that liberalism is not the same as is being displayed today. 

marcusa --- 20 years ago -

Arguing points of faith is rather moot, we each have a different interpretation of the Bible. I'm just going to say one more thing on that, it says to spread the Gospel but it tells us to pray in a locked room. I think political leaders who use God are not trying to spread the Gospel, but they do say about how they Pray and are good people. It's missing a certain degree of humbleness, it's like the rich man and poor widow, if you make a display of it that's all the reward you'll get.

I said two things, one that the country was founded by liberals (true) and secondly that it is patriotic to question government, the very foundation that our Enlightened Constitution.


I never said anything about it being the same today. Thomas Jefferson is the founder of what is now the Democratic Party, but on the same note it was Republicans (Lincoln) who believed in the fact that all are equal and abolished slavery, something Jefferson tried to put in from the beginning. When it comes to the Judicial and Constitution, I'm a firm believer in "Original Intent" and NOT "Living Document." The Constitution is not a law book and the Judicial is not here to legislate. The Constitution is a document that describes the human condition and seeks to create a government that is legitimate and protects natural rights. That means I'm against Roe vs. Wade just as much as I'm against an Ammendment prohibiting gay marriage (although I'm firmly pro-family). Neither belong there. I also think direct election of Senators was in some ways a mistake and that the line out veto, provided it works just like any other veto, should be there. On the same hand I think natural rights should extend to things such as socialized health care and better social security. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

marcusa

I think a big difference between us is stated in what you wrote - "we each have a different interpretation of the Bible"

You interpret the Bible and I follow the literal meaning. I do not believe that God needs us to interpret what He wrote - He knows what He meant and He has told us very plainly what that is - if we will read and pay attention.

The problem with using one liners from Scripture, as you have done when you wrote "it says to spread the Gospel but it tells us to pray in a locked room" is that many times the message gets distorted.

The Gospel teaches us that Christ's coming freed worship from traditions which restricted it to special places where people were obliged to come at appointed times. Christ said to the Samaritan woman, "Woman, believe me, a time is coming when you will worship the Father neither on this mountain, nor in Jerusalem." (John 4:21) He told this woman, who had asked him where they should worship, that it was neither on Mount Nablus nor on the Mount Jerusalem. He desired to make her understand that God fills all of space so that we can worship him wherever we are.

Christ DID also stress the importance of INDIVIDUAL prayer in private. He said, "But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you." (Matthew 6:6)

The purpose of this privacy is to provide the us with a quiet place where we can be alone with our Heavenly Father. However, that does not mean that we can not pray in public as long as it is for the wrong reason. He did not want us to be like the hypocrites who loved to stand and pray in the synagogues and at the street corners to be seen by men (Matthew 6:5). They desired to have the praise of men rather than of God.

The Bible needs to be taken as a whole when discussing a topic. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground